We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
All being well runs AT LEAST four and I'd probably buy at 4 tbh.
|
|
By:
yes headmaster but i'm afraid he did the hanging himself as is his want...i have to say he looked a far more tractable horse off a dawdle pace at york and maybe he is just learning, i like the horse headmaster don't get me wrong he has a very good chance in another weak addition of the race
|
|
By:
Wouldn't include Ulysses as he was a horse still developing and wasn't serious Gp1 material until the age of 4.
|
|
By:
Lots of shifting goalposts in this game!
|
|
By:
Didn't the much maligned Mordin once do some analysis showing that many horses hang as they quicken? Certainly seems to be the case with RL rather than him hanging 'cos he's shagged out.
|
|
By:
the horses compromised were elarqam and masar both of whom had shown previously a liking for being on the speed/up in the van
masar, elarqam, they all seem like loser horses to me. didn't elarqam get hammered on saturday when connections were saying he'd win before the race? horses with an electric turn of foot like roaring lion don't come along that often. when they do they should not be missed, so as to get on some slowboats that might "outstay him" ![]() |
|
By:
I mean proved themselves top class over 10f afterwards. Preferably in the same year, as I know some horses gain stamina with age.
Goalposts haven't budged here. |
|
By:
Cracksman then Figgis.
|
|
By:
Howellsy, you think he didn't stay 12f? Don't you think the horse was just a much improved runner later in the year. He was by my reckoning and Gosden said he was twice the horse, obviously an exaggeration but you know what he means.
|
|
By:
Saxon Warrior’s second dam is closely related to Dancing Rain and his third dam is a three-parts-sister to Dr Devious out of Rose Of Jericho (by Alleged), a full-sister to top-class three-miler chaser Legal Right, she produced the 1991 Greenlands Stakes winner Archway along with Royal Court (Sadler's Wells) who was placed in the Great Voltigeur Stakes and won the Ormonde Stakes as a four-year-old and a useful Danehill colt Hill Country who won and was Listed placed over 12f.
Roaring Lion was impressive in the Dante and his time for the final last 3f was good but the overall time was nothing special. I think he has to find improvement over the longer trip and can't for the life of me see him getting any closer to Saxon Warrior over 12f. As I’ve mentioned before Roaring Lion is a grey/roan and no grey of any sort has won since Airborne in 1946- you can put line through the lion! |
|
By:
The thing is, Figgis, you are arguing from a sort of self-guaranteeing position here. Cracksman turned out to be a top class 10f horse as a 3yo yet failed to beat inferior horses in b
|
|
By:
... (oops) both Derbies. You asked for a horse that proved top class over 10f later on as a 3yo and this one had won over the trip beforehand and was in with a strong shout at the furlong pole at Epsom ... but he didn't quite see it out!
|
|
By:
madhu and kinscem i see you are both looking into pedigrees answer me how many all american pedigrees have tried in the race ie roaring lion's and how have they fared? i can't recall many hence the question if you have the info of course?
|
|
By:
Howellsy, the case with Saxon Warrior is totally different. Cracksman was a work in progress. From thinking he was just a horse with potential before the Derby, nothing special after the race, I became a believer in him being a Gp1 horse after the much improved rating he put up over 12f in the Voltigeur. This time we're talking about a Guineas winner. Maybe some people are saying that Saxon Warrior isn't all that, fair enough, however I'm arguing against those saying yes he is top class but only as far as 10f not 12f.
|
|
By:
It might be that he's a miler - and he wouldn't need to be a special one to have won the early miling triple crown. He'd be long odds-on for the St J.P. IT'll be ironic if he truly doesn't stay in a year where he'd have been champion miler and when they've got nothing good over 12 unless one of their squad improves for a strongly run 12f which they surely won't orchestrate this year due to SW's speed. I guess the worst case scenario for Ballydoyle would be Roaring Lion just edging SW in a slow run race with something like Delano running on late into a close third. Not that I can see RL beating SW in any circumstances.
|
|
By:
It might be that he's a miler
Entirely possible, but think you're the first person I've read/heard that from. Can you think of any horses from the past who put up a performance similar to SW's in last year's RPT who trained on but didn't get further? I mean ran in a fast run mile as a 2yo, putting up a decent time figure in the process, amenable to restraint and showing battling qualities at the finish. |
|
By:
Can't see Ballydoyle doing anything else than trying to set up a fast run race, not that they've always succeeded, sometimes the pacemakers have gone off at a brainless tempo. If you've got a Guineas winner who has always been fancied to excel over further it has to be the way to go. They did it with Camelot and Australia (Guineas placed) and I'd do exactly the same. They think he'll stay and I think he'll stay. I just think it's a case of if he runs his race he's highly likely to win, rather than a question of if he stays.
|
|
By:
American Post travelled very nicely behind Motivator but failed to stay, having won the RP trophy and then the French Guineas - not saying he quite meets all your criteria but an interesting one. I have very little doubt SW will prove top class at 10 and that he will win the Derby. But I am also sure he could have been champion 3yo miler in this ordinary looking year. I would have just one pacemaker and have SW track it at an even pace.
|
|
By:
Dawn Approach won the 2000 Gns like a miler, not like a middle distance horse. His sectionals showed that he was slowing down at the end, the race was run in a fast time. On top of that, his breeding indicated that he would be better over distances short of 12f despite being by New Approach.Yet he went off 5/4 fav for the Derby at which price he was a massive lay.So much for the market being the best guide.
SW runs like a horse who will most definitely get further than 8f, he will get 10f for sure.Why? Because he was strong at the end of the 2000 gns yet he didn't run the race in a very fast time nor did he show a blistering turn of foot. This horse looks like a 12f horse, runs like a 12f horse and almost certainly is a 12f horse.Doubts about his breeding are a red herring this time as all the evidence is that DI gets plenty of top class 10f horse and also gets 12f horses. His dam sire is Galileo who has the best record currently for imparting stamina and producing classic winning descendants. If SW gets beaten I'm confident that it won't be for reasons of lack of stamina. I will put my money where my mouth is and back him to win on the day. Can RL reverse form or are ther others who may also put it up to him. Possibly because horses can improve tremendously at this time especially when trying new trips. It is a horse race and the best horse doesn't always win. Someone recalled the case of El Gran Senor, Then there was an even better example with Dancing Brave. It is one race and it won't define my season at these prices. However, I hope to see a talented winner, one who will go on to run in the Arc.Whoever wins. |
|
By:
i don't think they have got a serious speed horse to use as pacemaker howellsy looks like nelson won't run i suppose rostropovich may go but the others look slow...masar and knight to behold will go i'd say, they have no choice otherwise they have no chance as will pull there chances away. agree with figgis i think they will want a decent pace for saxon warrior
|
|
By:
Was Bald Eagle American bred ?
|
|
By:
What price for AOB getting a 1st, 2nd and 3rd similar to 2016 Arc? 100/1? I'll have some, if so.
|
|
By:
Roberto might have been American bred and a good horse he was too . I am sure Onlooker could find an American bred winner . The colour of the horse makes no difference if they are good enough .
|
|
By:
agree with howellsy. cracksman may have got the trip later but didn't stay at epsom after looking the winner in the straight
|
|
By:
as for those like sandown saying that they are bullish that saxon warrior will get the trip, imo we just won't know until the day and odds on hardly screams value to me.
|
|
By:
Harry, I don’t think you can really state Roaring Lion has an all Americain pedigree, Kitten's Joy’s was by El Prado (Sadler's Wells) and his dam's sire is Lear Fan who was sired by Roberto.
I’d guess as anovice at pedigress that Secreto had the nearest to what might be considered an all-American pedigree but then again his damsire was by Secretariat whose damsire was Princequillo, and it came as a surprise just now to find that Princequillo is considered as having an unfamiliar European pedigree! |
|
By:
well if he hasn't got an american turf pedigree i don't anymore madhu
|
|
By:
all american pedigrees/an american turf pedigree?
|
|
By:
Delano looking weak this evening.
|
|
By:
Richard Kingscote relishing Knight To Behold Derby ride
“The Derby is a massive, iconic race and I’m delighted I’ve got an opportunity to ride in it, Knight To Behold has done everything right so far and full deserves to take his chance – it’s not like he’s a maiden who is 200-1. I’m sure his improvement hasn’t finished and I’d hope he’d run a big race. Whether it was a good ride or not, I think the horse would have won. He was well on top at the line, Adam (Kirby, on Wax And Wane) got to the front early on and, like most in that position, wanted to slow it down. My lad was in daylight and wanted to race, they were going too slow for him to be in his comfort zone. I thought there was no point us fighting and I had free rein from Mr Dunlop to do my job, so I did. Once in front he pricked his ears and enjoyed himself. It worked out well and that high cruising speed he showed will stand him in good stead at Epsom. We were always comfortable and I think he had more left in tank. He was still a bit green and looked up at the big screen. I’d ridden him probably six weeks before and he did a very good piece of work, so I believed in his ability and was pleased he was able to stretch away once he got balanced in straight. He looked good, travelled good, picked up good and he stayed to the line. He couldn’t have done any more and it has to be a positive that he’s gone the [Derby] distance already. He was extremely immature. The first time he got beat through greenness and second time he almost got beat because he just didn’t know what to do off the bridle – he showed he was up for a fight but just didn’t know how to knuckle down and put the race to bed. When I rode him in his piece of work [before Lingfield] I was pleased because he went away from his lead horse without that hesitation. And at Lingfield he was happy to make his own running and he stretched away without wandering too much or waiting for the other horses. They say the Derby is the ultimate test and because those in it are relatively young and inexperienced horses that is a big part of it. Derby day is only time I’ve ever noticed the crowd – when you turn in you really are aware of them. So it is a big deal but Harry and his team done a great job at home minding him. He was very well behaved at Lingfield, so I can’t see it being a big problem.” http://britishchampionsseries.com/2018/05/27/richard-kingscote-relishing-knight-behold-deby-ride/ |
|
By:
harry callaghan
madhu and kinscem i see you are both looking into pedigrees answer me how many all american pedigrees have tried in the race ie roaring lion's and how have they fared? i can't recall many hence the question if you have the info of course? Good question. I have the foaling location of 656,887 horses on file. One of the problems is you must separate USA horses into turf and dirt, and I have only partly done that. It is one of my future projects. A while back I counted (with a program) the countries of the 126 ancestors in the six generation pedigree of horses, splitting each pedigree into the major countries. It would take me some time to find the work (and I won't) look). I did not do an analysis of any one group of winners/race, just about 300k horses at one go. As far as I know (without looking it up) Roaring Lion's sire, Kitten's Joy, was a turf runner. A good place to find this info is in pedigreequery.com A typical USA opedigree is Air Force Blue, almost all USA (some CAN) That often means precocity (i.e. a dominating 2yo) and not so good afterwards. Best thing to do is look at your Derby and Oaks picks in pedigreequery.com You will very quickly see where most of the pedigree originated. |
|
By:
Looks like strong chance of heavy showers Tuesday and Wednesday. How well can SW go on good to soft?
|
|
By:
He goes much faster on heavy.
![]() |
|
By:
Plenty of people thought Cliffs of Moher was top class this time last year (he started favourite for the Derby I believe). Plenty thought the same of US Army Ranger and Carlton House at this moment in their 3YO careers. Ulysses, like Dubai Millennium, was a crack 10 furlong horse who didn't stay at Epsom. Spectrum and Rodrigo de Triano are other good examples posted on here, and I'm sure anyone who can be bothered to look will find a few more. So yes, there are plenty of examples of 10f horses considered top class at this stage in their careers failing to stay at Epsom. None of them means Saxon Warrior won't stay, though I'd say the breeding on his dam's side raises a doubt, especially at odds of 4-5.
|
|
By:
I think only connections especially AOB thought Cliffs Of Moher and US Army Ranger were top class or could be top class...the rest thought they were "pigs" given the dismal performances in Derby trials. And they have proven so with time despite their excellent parents.
I think Saxon Warrior will stay 12f - connections are more than just hopeful - thus will win the Derby this saturday doing an Australia who did not win the 2000G. |
|
By:
lewisham ranger
as for those like sandown saying that they are bullish that saxon warrior will get the trip, imo we just won't know until the day and odds on hardly screams value to me. Kincem's previous post is worth restating i]It has not been made public the Equiniome classification of Galileo, but in my data I have guessed he is a T.T (stamina), and my other guess is Sumora, the other parent of maybe is a C.C (sprinter) so Maybe must be a C.T as she gets one from each parent. If Deep Impact is a T.T then Saxon Warrior could be a T.T (stayer) or a C.T (middle distance). But in my data (guesses) I have the parents of Deep Impact, Sunday Silence as a C.T, and also have Wind In Her Hair as a C.T, so it is likely Deep Impact is a C.T. If Deep Impace is a C.T and Maybe is a C.T then it is 25% likely Saxon Warrior is a C.C (sprinter), 50% a C.T (middle), 25% a T.T.[/i] This makes it highly unlikely that SW will be ineffective at middle distances which combined with analysis of his pace figures gives me confidence that if beaten it will not be for reasons of stamina. As to value, I have to agree that his current price is not especially tempting but his record of 2 G1's and 4 from 4 puts him clearly into the bracket of clear form choice. The weather forecast indicates rain over the next few days so it is very unlikely that we will see fastish ground and possibly even soft ground as thunderstorms are possible. There is no problem with that for SW but can that be said for all the rest? It may be that evens becomes a reasonable price after all on the day, if still available. |
|
By:
Plenty of people thought Cliffs of Moher was top class this time last year (he started favourite for the Derby I believe). Plenty thought the same of US Army Ranger and Carlton House at this moment in their 3YO careers.
Surely then the conclusion to draw is that none of those horses were top class, so anyone who thought so was wrong on that score alone, stamina is irrelevant. |
|
By:
Think I'll stop banging my head against a brick wall for now and find something constructive to do instead.
|
|
By:
I do not wish to see the rides given by Moore to Minding and US Army Ranger ever again at Epsom.
As for US Army Ranger he came from a different county (last 3, 16th straight) to be 2nd whereas the winner was never out of the 1st 8 throughout. I think only connections especially AOB thought Cliffs Of Moher and US Army Ranger were top class or could be top class...the rest thought they were "pigs" given the dismal performances in Derby trials. Strange then that Moore should be criticised for getting a "pig" to go so close in a Derby. |
|
By:
If anyone is arguing SW might not be as good as people think, fair enough. If they're arguing he's a top class miler who will probably just about last 10f, fair enough (although that view would seem in a very small minority). My point is there have been very few horses already considered top class (won two Gp 1s) where 10f is considered almost a formality that have failed through stamina unless beaten by a very smart runner. I'd say it's extremely unlikely SW is going to be beaten purely through lack of stamina by anything outside the next two in the betting.
|