Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 448 comments are related to the topic:
Prix De L'Arc De Triomphe 2017

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 3 of 12  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 12 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 448
By:
brigust1
When: 11 Sep 17 20:33
Actually Jedi I never said he would be 1 to 3 but I think he would be slightly odds on. However, if you think he beat Cracksman fair and square in Ireland and can be backed at 4s then I would get on if I were you. Don't you think?
By:
Figgis
When: 11 Sep 17 20:45
I said I'd make him a 1/3 chance, not that the market would. The Irish Derby form is very poor, in my view.
By:
jedi sophie
When: 11 Sep 17 21:52
I backed Capri for the St Leger today,and happy to do so!Irish Derby form may not be great but to my eye it is the best form around in the context of the St Leger.G1 form.
Capri coming back at them over 1m4 also suggested to me 1m6 be within his compass,doesnt exactly quicken,just keeps going, actually a lot like Cracksman..Hence the proximity.
By:
jedi sophie
When: 11 Sep 17 22:06
Anyway chaps i meant to say,goodluck with your bets on Leger.But dont want to hijack the greatest race in the calendar thread!
By:
Figgis
When: 11 Sep 17 22:12
Yes, I just meant the Irish Derby form was poor in regards to standing up in an all age Gp1 race. I think Capri's form definitely gives him a decent chance of winning the Leger but I think the same for about half a dozen of them so it's much too difficult for me.
By:
A_T
When: 18 Sep 17 19:45
An interesting possible could be the Japanese Frankel-Stacelita filly Soul Stirring - usually ridden by Christophe Lemaire. Not raced since winning the Japanese Oaks in May.
By:
harry callaghan
When: 18 Sep 17 20:27
i thought she was staying at home...maybe next year
By:
brigust1
When: 19 Sep 17 08:36
According to recent reports, all roads suddenly lead to Chantilly, except for Cracksman of course.
By:
Sandown
When: 19 Sep 17 12:08
12 days to go to the biggest race in the European turf calendar, £3.6M in prize money up for grabs, and the picture is still far from clear. The Chantilly trials added no clues other than negative ones, and on the bare results none would get my money. Cracksman, should he run on Oct 1, didn't have a hard race and it was a perfectly satisfactory prep.His earlier form puts him in the frame. Gosden holds a strong hand but it looks as though the only way Cracksman will go to the Arc is as a sub for Enable should she not make it. The figures do not look good for anything else that ran in the trials but I wouldn't entirely give up on Satono Diamond who is an out and out stayer, not suited by a slow pace or soft ground. He could reverse form with the German horse. Cloth of Stars should improve a lot but hew needs to.

AOB is still shuffling his pack and has a strong hand with both Capri and Winter being considered along with HR and OOSG. Winter is a real wild card being totally unproven at 12f and being out of a 6f horse by Choisir doesn't look like a natural 12f horse albeit Galileo is her sire.The others are all proven at the trip.

The French have a couple that have been overlooked to some extent in Brametot and Zarak. Both have had plenty of time off, have G1 winning form and cvould improve significantly, if they run. Which is still a doubt as of today. We're waiting on news of Zarak's M-Lafitte gallop this morning.

That leaves me with the 2 at the front of the market. Ulysses looks like he will run, has G1 wins albeit over 10f. But, on faster ground (little rain forecast for Paris) and a sharper track, he could get to Enable as he travels like a dream in his races. He looks a big price at 10.0 and should shorten up  before Oct 1.

That leaves Enable, who on the face of it has clearly the bets form but at 2.2 under AP terms, is a hands off price. Wait until the day is my view. The doubts revolve around her being as good in the  Autumn as in the Spring and Summer. The York run was OK without being as good as her Ascot and Epsom victories. The Arc is replete with horses showing top class form earlier in the year and not repeating it in the Arc. She is a strong stayer, won't mind any ground, but she is no Treve or Zarkava, not possessing their turn of foot.So no gimme.

I'll continue to lay her for the time being, keep an eye on the French horses for confirmation of running plans,maybe have something on Ulysses, but generally be patient until we know the ground and draw.
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 19 Sep 17 12:37
I'm a big Order of St George fan myself, in what looks a pretty weak renewal, and have been nibbling away at the 16/1, 14/1 and 12/1 the past few weeks.

I know the form of his last two runs hasn't been top class, but I thought he was very taking both times. When you consider he was third last year on the back of being beaten by Wicklow Brave in the Irish Leger, there is no reason to think he can't run at least as well as last year... especially as he pulverised that rival in this years renewal. A reproduction of last years run may well be good enough to go close, but he looks primed to run even better this year imo.

Just praying for some ease in the ground for him as he looks a much better animal on soft.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 17 11:00
Excellent summing up Sandown. I cannot have any of the AOB runners at all. However, as a codicil, if the ground is fast (unlikely) and if Highland Reel could get an easy lead, he is classy on top of the ground if allowed to dictate but a lot will have to go wrong for that to happen. OOSG only beat Siljans Saga narrowly in this race last year so a lot will have to go wrong with others for him to win. I couldn't have Ulysses either. I don't think he will get the trip even on the suitable track with a downhill finish because this will be run at a strong pace with the Satono Diamond, Capri, OOSG and the German horse needing a strong pace. And AOB apparently never even considered running Idaho in it who nearly ran down Ulysses at Ascot.
Winter could be the fly in the ointment with top class fillies doing well in this race. On good ground and on this less demanding track she has a lot of class. The French certainly don't look good enough.
On soft ground I think Enable will win. On good or faster ground I would include Winter and keep a tentative eye on Highland Reel and Satono Diamond. I don't think Cracksman will run. Cry
By:
Jack Bauer '24'
When: 20 Sep 17 13:10
I would like to back Ulysses in a match bet against Winter if both were the same price.
By:
twonky
When: 20 Sep 17 13:58
I think that some people are sticking there head in the ground and hoping that the blindingly obvious fact will go away. That quite simply, Enable is by far the best horse in the race on the evidence we already know..12f, right handed course, will handle the ground. She's unbeaten over 12f, has already beaten the boys this season and won 4 group 1 races by a combined 20 lengths..no other horse in the field comes anywhere near that form.

Some maybe cribbed her Yorkshire Oaks win, but she still won by 5 lengths and more importantly it was her 3rd group 1 in 6 weeks and that takes some doing. Throw in the weight allowance and barring an absolute catastrophe of a ride, we're seeing an exceptional filly.
By:
Sandown
When: 20 Sep 17 16:28
Thank you for your comment brigust1. After yesterday's upbeat reports from France re Zarak and Brametot, we can reduce the column headed "what we don't know, but could" somewhat. Both horses have had very light preparations for one reason or another and whilst they obviously have to improve to be competitive, both are trained by experts and are capable of doing so.

Like you, I have my doubts over Ulysses at 12f but Stoute has made some comments to the effect that he believes the horse is competitive at the distance and clearly rates the horse being best on good ground or better. As the KG was run on soft ground, it is not entirely unreasonable to see him get closer to Enable providing the conditions are faster than at Ascot.

As to Enable's chance, being reasonably long in the tooth now, I have seen plenty of shorties with similar cases to Enable get beaten for one reason or another.I am not for one moment suggesting that there are any flaws in her form, and if one's strategy is to back the most likely winner, then she's your gal.However, I would just raise the point about the relatively poor record of horses winning the King George, peaking to do so, and not really getting back to that level of form in the Arc. Not saying that she won't but it is a consideration especially when taking a very short price, as she is at 2.2. Of course, that might also apply to Ulysses as well. Whether a horse is at ts peak on the day is one of, if not the most important, of those facts which we could know but are unlikely to find out until its too late. We rely on the expertise of the trainer but sometimes horses can go off or come to the boil just a matter of days before a big race.Being a filly, too, needs special care after a long season.

Last year, for some reason, the 3yr olds failed to perform, leaving the race to the older horses, but this year I don't think that will be the  case and expect the 3 yr olds to perform much better.


There is not enough evidence of the effect of Chantilly on the outcome of the race but the first 23 were drawn 12,11,16. Postponed, the 15/8 fav, was drawn in 7,suggesting a possible reversal of the traditional low draw bias at Longchamp.
By:
Sandown
When: 20 Sep 17 16:30
first 3 not 23!
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 17 16:56
The 3 year olds last year were dire Sandown. Harzand was the only classic winner running and the horse he beat at Epsom, US Army Ranger had been beaten in two Group 3s and he had been well beaten in Ireland.
This year there is Enable a dual classic winner, Winter a dual classic winner, Capri a dual classic winner and Brametot a dual classic winner. And with Postponed and Found, older horses with solid Gr1 form at the trip, they were well represented. This year the older horses are represented by Ulysses who hasn't solid Gr1 form at the trip.   
The writing is on the wall.
By:
Sandown
When: 20 Sep 17 17:26
I'm sure that on one of the previous years Arc threads, I raised the point about the difficulty of the winner of the KGQE  running the same year in the Arc. This isn't a complete list by any means, just a quick look, but the only horse to succeed in winning both in the same year in recent years was Dylan Thomas and he was a colt. Other colts that have tried and failed were Highland Reel in 2016, Conduit, Duke of Milan and Hurricane Run. F&M have not managed it at all as far as I can see . Dahlia failed, as did Taghrooda, Park Top and Aunt Edith.I can't find any who succeeded.  So, Enabled would be breaking new ground by doing so. Not impossible, of course, but its a hard ask imo.

Any stats wizards out there, do you know of any others?
By:
Jack Bauer '24'
When: 20 Sep 17 19:42
Lammtarra 1995.
By:
Jack Bauer '24'
When: 20 Sep 17 19:47
He was a colt obviously.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 17 19:59
Mill Reef, Dancing Brave
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 17 20:00
Nijinsky was 2nd. Ribot did it.
By:
Sandown
When: 20 Sep 17 20:40
Back in 2014 on the Arc thread, (Tagroodha was the fav that year)and it was then that I made the point about KG winners and the Arc.Briefly summarising and updating, since 1951 34 KG winners have tried and failed to do the double in the same year, 6 winning and 28 losing. Highland Reel last year was the latest running a great race behind Found.

There have been 6 F&M who have tried, all failed. I forgot to mention Pawneese 76 and Time Charter 83.

So, the question is ,can Enable become the first female KG/ARC double winner in the same year?
By:
Sandown
When: 20 Sep 17 20:49
Apologies .To be clear , 34 tried for the double  ,6 winning, 28 failing.This includes the FM's, 6 trying all losing.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 17 20:55
Were Taghrooda and Pawnese the only 3 year olds?
By:
Sandown
When: 20 Sep 17 21:04
No,brigust1. Dahlia was 3 in '73 so 3 of the 6 were aged 3. Time Charter and Aunt Edith were 4. Park Top 5.
By:
twonky
When: 20 Sep 17 21:11
I dig where sandown is coming from, but I believe 2 things....that the classic 12 f crop are simply not good enough, and have not even since Camelot and more so Australia, whom I reckon that Adelaide was sacrificed for regarding big race targets and the breed for stayers is getting weaker since the French dropped their Derby distance for the sake of breeding and money.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 17 21:13
Dahlia tried as a 3 year old as well. Finishing 16th.

Of the three Dahlia wasn't right. She had won the King George and the Prix Niel easily but slipped in the Prix Vermeille and finished lame. It severely interrupted her training schedule and she should not have run. 
Pawnese was coupled with Crow and, because of the heavy ground, Yves St Martin chose to ride Crow who finished 2nd to the 3 year old filly Ivanjica.
Taghrooda started at 11/2f was drawn badly, raced wide and was beaten into 3rd by Treve and Flintshire.

Nothing to be seen here S.
By:
brigust1
When: 20 Sep 17 21:23
I remember Time Charter she was trained by a near neighbour Henry Candy. Willie Newnes used to ride her but was injured for the King George and Joe Mercer rode her with ba lls of steel. Great ride beating Sun Princess and co. They put Newnes back on for the Foy and she easily beat All Along. In the, Arc where I thought he rode her all wrong, she was beaten just over a length in fourth with All Along the winner and Sun Princess in 2nd.
By:
Sandown
When: 20 Sep 17 21:45
"The result would have been different but for the fact that...." can be applied to anything brigust1 and is not the way to go.It results in bending the facts to suit your opinion which is  never a good thing. Fact is that 6 out of 28 colts won but 0/6 for F&M. Whether there is a reason for that or whether it is not significant depends on whether there is an underlying reason for the difference. Any thoughts?
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 17 21:46
Sandown's point regarding the King George is one I made on the deleted thread. It's a valid one I think but like all trends it's the reason behind the trend that makes it valid, not the statistic on its own. It's obviously not impossible to win the King George and Arc in the same year but it is very difficult. In my view the reason for this is the King George is usually a competitive fast run race where the winner has to run to its limit, or very close to it, to win. Fast run races take more out of a horse than races run in a slow/sprint fashion. Some horses are tougher than others. Dylan Thomas was exceptionally tough as he ran 8 times as a 4yo prior to winning the Arc, mostly in fast run races, and never ran a bad race. Sea The Stars was another who came back again after fast run races, only his Derby was slowly run. We can point to a few runners like that as positives but they are the exceptions not the norm. Even Dancing Brave had only been involved in one fast run race in his 3yo year before winning the Arc, which was the King George.

Enable has been involved in two fast run races, the Oaks and the KG. The question is will she be in the norm camp or the exceptions? Nobody can answer that confidently yet so it's all about the odds. If Gosden had skipped the KG it would be a different matter but in the current circumstances I don't think her odds represent value.
By:
Sandown
When: 20 Sep 17 22:05
I agree with your post figgis. This is a subject which we have debated before and it as you say there is no obvious way of  knowing beforehand. horses do run up light behind if they have had too much, and fillies are more likely to train off faster, but there have been plenty of masculine fillies with tough constitutions. Triptych was one like that. Cecil and Murless both were strongly of the opinion that a maximum peak is only possible once a year and were both experts with fillies and mares. I can't say that the case for or against is proven either way, but as you say the odds must be good enough to cover the doubts. On the day plenty of bookies will want to get Enable at evens or 5/4 so I think there is very little downside to laying her for now. Whether I back her back will depend on how the market goes and the competition ,but at present she is a good lay.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 17 22:20
Cecil and Murless both were strongly of the opinion that a maximum peak is only possible once a year and were both experts with fillies and mares

Well, they'd know far, far more than me about handling their charges, but as a backer and watching what horses achieve on the track I'd disagree. I think most runners when they reach a peak are able to repeat it once. I generally look out for horses that run fast and back them to repeat it, which they do more often than not. Usually I stop backing them afterwards as not only do I think they're likely to regress but their odds usually get shorter, as with Enable. I said the other week that I thought it was virtually a flip of a coin whether Enable runs to peak form in the Arc but after more consideration I'm more pessimistic than that. I'd say it's no better than 6/4 she does and that's probably being a bit generous to her chances.
By:
A_T
When: 20 Sep 17 22:22
Agree with what's been said and this what puts me off Enable. She has been on the go all year - horses campaigned this way who win the Arc are very rare and always colts: Dancing Brave, Mill Reef, STS, Golden Horn.

The French never win the race with a horse raced like this - they finish at Chantilly in June then come back later with only one race in mind.

If Enable wins the Arc it will have to be said she is exceptional.
By:
Adelaide
When: 20 Sep 17 22:23
I'd just like to comment regarding 3 year old fillies from the KG to the Arc....

Dahlia should be discounted because she was a different horse when travelling abroad...she excelled in travel and her French form was modest in comparison, and I think it's been said she maybe produced more testosterone when travelling.. something like that..

Pawneese can also be discounted because she banged her head on the stalls and ran concussed in the Arc..

Summer fillies kept on the go have a good record in the Arc, not many run in the KG but I would put forward Oh So Sharp in '85, touched off by Petoski at Ascot, and I feel pretty sure if she hadn't gone for the Leger she would have beaten Rainbow Quest and Sagace... she beat RQ in the KG..

User Friendly in '92 was hardly mollycoddled...3 Oaks including the Yorkshire and touched off by Subotica at Longchamp. Again if she had missed the Leger that might have made a difference...

Conjecture, but those fillies had it tough all season... in fact I think Enable has had an easier time than those two above, to be honest..
By:
Adelaide
When: 20 Sep 17 22:28
I should add, I'm aware Oh So Sharp didn't run in the Arc that year, just saying that if she missed the Leger and ran instead, I think she would have won it...
By:
Jack Bauer '24'
When: 20 Sep 17 22:42
Figgis, how many times did Golden Horn run fast on your figures?
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 17 22:46
Did Oh So Sharp run to her best when winning the Leger though? Opinions might differ but mine is she didn't but still won. Regarding User Friendly, she ran to a new peak when winning the Oaks but was able to win in Ireland and at York without having to match that. That year's Leger was also run at a slow early pace. Races like that wouldn't have been very taxing. I'd say the only time she had to run fast was when winning her Oaks so despite her having been on the go she was relatively fresh for the Arc.
By:
twonky
When: 20 Sep 17 22:54
If enable is to be beaten, then it's down to gosden going to York so soon after 2 group 1s. She's got the classic 5 week gap...she will not be beaten
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 17 23:01
Jack, I have him fast twice, in the Dante and Derby. In hindsight I hold my hands up to having underrated a bit him at the time. I'd already rated Jack Hobbs good enough to win a Derby and foolishly was reluctant to believe Gosden had another as good and made excuses for Jack Hobbs in the Dante instead. One of those occasions where I look back and think where on earth was my head at but it seemed to make sense at the time. However, even in hindsight he didn't run fast to win the Eclipse. He was beaten when running slower at York and didn't run fast when winning in Ireland. It was possible the pace of some of those races didn't allow him to run to his fastest but it was also possible he'd regressed a bit since the Derby. However, the Arc showed him to be as good as ever and even though the race was slowly run I thought he'd have won whatever the pace that day. It's still possible that Golden Horn was a bit below his best after the Derby which had taken the edge off him but then came back to peak form for the Arc.
By:
Figgis
When: 20 Sep 17 23:02
* him a bit
Page 3 of 12  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 12 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com