Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 448 comments are related to the topic:
Prix De L'Arc De Triomphe 2017

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 12  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 12 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 448
By:
Figgis
When: 01 Sep 17 14:41
I don't want to snitch in class Headmaster, so it would be impossible to say Wink
By:
Figgis
When: 01 Sep 17 14:48
Brigust, a Gp2 or Gp3 would be my advice. Think Coolmore missed a trick not sending him for the Deauville race Eminent went for. Don't know if he'd have beaten him but he was just ahead of him in the Eclipse and could've gone close. Probably that race wouldn't mean much in the Coolmore scheme of things but it sometimes helps to get a horse back in the winning habit.
By:
brigust1
When: 01 Sep 17 14:57
That's definitely what I was thinking actually. He is not over raced son could turn up somewhere. We'll see.
By:
brigust1
When: 01 Sep 17 15:01
TH I think the truth lies somewhere around my comments made about a certain representative of a racing organisation and the fact that I do find it almost  impossible to differentiate between the two.  Wink
By:
brigust1
When: 01 Sep 17 15:08
Figgis he is entered in a Gr2 mile race next Saturday in Ireland. Bang goes my theory. We'll see.
By:
Figgis
When: 01 Sep 17 15:16
Just had a look. After the Eclipse I was thinking it could be worth stepping him back down to a mile but watching him at York he didn't look like he had bags more speed over the shorter trip. Unless he does show better form back down to a mile it won't be easy only receiving 5lbs off some of those older horses.
By:
brigust1
When: 01 Sep 17 15:54
I thought after the Eclipse and Juddmonte he lacked speed at that level so a drop back seems odd to me. He wore down Eminent at Sandown but it was pretty hard work.
By:
Figgis
When: 01 Sep 17 16:05
Unfortunately he's an 8-10f horse but just not very fast. Think some people got carried away with what he did at Leopardstown last year or misinterpreted what others said. I read somewhere that Timeform rated it the fastest maiden performance for years, or something like that. I never agreed with that. All I said was he showed enough to win a moderate Derby if he stayed. Unfortunately for me he didn't quite stay well enough. Still would've managed it if they hadn't run that pesky Wings Of Eagles but that would've still probably been his peak. Even if he'd stayed he might've gone on to also win the Irish Derby, as some other moderate Derby winners have, but wouldn't have achieved much more than that. There's a big difference between winning a moderate Derby and these all age Gp1s he's contesting, especially over shorter trips.
By:
FELTFAIR
When: 01 Sep 17 16:06
Rozel, the culprit was Imp123(Bungle) who objected to the banter on this thread and similarly the Juddmonte thread. Sadly all your information got deleted.Such a sensitive soul.
By:
A_T
When: 01 Sep 17 19:37
really odd that those threads got deleted - nothing offensive about them whatsoever
By:
twonky
When: 03 Sep 17 11:48
This is usually a race where class does out given normal conditions..I like to look at form in the class of the race wether winning or losing as a starting point..it's noticeable that in general, the winners are already proven at the highest level and have won at group 1 class by at least a couple of lengths sometime in the past and preferably earlier in that season..Enable stands out a mile on her winning distances..

Fillies and mares also have a great record recently, but do no bet a male that has already run in a previous arc...an absolute nightmare.
By:
Figgis
When: 08 Sep 17 21:16
Looking at the Niel field it's difficult to see what connections of Cracksman will gain from the run, apart from the chance of winning an easy Gp2 and a few grand in prize money of course. It doesn't look like there's going to be much pace on. So either Cracksman wins in a sprint finish or is unluckily beaten in those circumstances. Either way, I can't see how that will put them in a better position to decide to run him in the Arc or not.
By:
brigust1
When: 08 Sep 17 21:49
I disagree F. I think another run will do him the world of good. I hope he makes the running and wins comfortably. He isn't a speedy horse and if I remember they run slightly downhill into the home straight then a fairly stiff climb to the finish. The track should be ideal for his stride so I hope they let him run and use his stride. They held onto him at York until the home straight so we may not have yet seen what he can really do. He has only had four runs so another at this time of the Arc trials is fine and a well tried and tested route.
By:
Figgis
When: 08 Sep 17 21:58
I think another run will do him the world of good

Good in what way? Difficult to believe he wasn't fit enough at York given the manner of the victory and the stable confidence that was also shown in the market.

I hope they let him run and use his stride. They held onto him at York until the home straight

It's possible, but I can't see Dettori wanting to do any more to win than is necessary.

we may not have yet seen what he can really do

Wouldn't you rather he saves that for the race that really matters?
By:
brigust1
When: 08 Sep 17 22:07
With a 12f horse fitness is not always that easy to achieve. Horses don't gallop 12f at home and if he is the best in the yard finding something to extend him can also be a problem. Being a colt they can get gross and the one thing you want is 100% fitness. As you said winning may not be that difficult so blowing away the cobwebs would be ideal. None of us know how much the Voltigeur took out of him.
By saying I would like to see him make the running does not mean run him to the end of his tether. Doing what is necessary will be just fine. Waiting for a sprint finish will not be, in my opinion.
I want him to be as fit as possible on the big day. And I think another race will help toward that.
By:
Figgis
When: 08 Sep 17 22:28
But the point is that as Gosden was unconvinced about sending him to the Arc after the Voltigeur I don't see how winning this particular Niel would convince him. Maybe he's looking for something but I have no idea what that would be.
By:
brigust1
When: 08 Sep 17 22:57
My problem with that is JG may be covering his back in case something goes awry with Enable. But of course, if he performs well the pressure must be on the owner to run. This whole crazy mess is complete nonsense to me. I cannot find any horse who deliberately missed the Arc one year, other than for injury etc, then win it the following year. Rheingold was injured as a 3 year old then won it at 4. I wonder if they wish they had tun Almanzour last year?
By:
brigust1
When: 09 Sep 17 07:12
The biggest sign that Cracksman is not being seriously considered for the Arc is that they are sticking with Dettori. Had they been serious I think they would have changed the jockey this time. Who knows?
By:
A_T
When: 09 Sep 17 12:04
a run in the Niel can only be a "sighter" for the Arc surely -  can't see any other reason why it would run otherwise
By:
A_T
When: 09 Sep 17 12:08
the Foy looks the most interesting race tomorrow with the Japanese colt and what appears to be Fabre's Arc horse Cloth of Stars being given the classic French preparation for the race
By:
A_T
When: 09 Sep 17 12:12
Would not surprise me if Frankie gets off Cracksman tomorrow and the team declare him not ready this year for the Arc or something along such lines - honour preserved all round
By:
brigust1
When: 09 Sep 17 12:38
If that happened I would be gutted. No honour in that imo but at least they have been honest and up front. Unlike the AOB mob.
By:
Sandown
When: 09 Sep 17 12:39
Time to enter the Arc thread. This year we have once again a short-priced, "obvious" horse, in Enable, which dominates thinking and the market.

In the past 20 years there have been 13 such horses and 5 have won (2009 STS BF SP 2.1, 2008 Zharkava 3.2, 2001 Sakhee 3.6,2000 Sindar 3.0,1997 Peintre Celebre 2.3). The 8 losers were 2015 Treve 2.3, 203 Orfevre 3.6, 2012 Camelot 3.5, 2007 Authorized 2.5, 2006 Deep Impact 3.6, 2003 High Chaparral 3.3, 2002 High Chaparral 3.6, 1999 Montjeu 2.8.

Is Enable value to win this year is the first question to answer? She is certainly most people's most likely winner, but is she value at 2.2 best price? For me, that's an easy question to answer 3 weeks out. No, she isn't, so my first move in the market is to lay her. Not because she can't win, but that price is not a reflection of the risks involved in making the race let alone winning it. There is as much chance of her being bigger on the day as there is in her being shorter imo.
By:
brigust1
When: 09 Sep 17 14:56
I understand where you are coming from S, but with the betting 10/1 bar wouldn't it be better value to back three or four to beat her?
By:
Sandown
When: 09 Sep 17 19:55
Not yet brigust. That would carry the risk of non-runners,as well as picking the right ones,whereas laying Enable is a more limited risk. At this stage, laying is a better option until such time that we know more.
By:
Sandown
When: 10 Sep 17 13:16
Looking at those 13 shorties again, and taking the BF prices (for most) the  expected winners would be 4.5, so 5 actual winners indicates that they have won at least the right number of times, more or less. But we are 3 weeks out and those prices were SP's.
By:
brigust1
When: 10 Sep 17 14:14
Will he run? I backed him last year for the Derby at big prices and suffered mercilessly through the trial, missing the Dante on the day, just missing out on the Derby, getting mugged in the Irish Derby. Bolting up at York when we were allowed to see him run and then bolting up today. Now it's tenterhooks time as to whether they run.
By:
brigust1
When: 10 Sep 17 14:26
Doesn't sound hopeful ffs.
By:
A_T
When: 10 Sep 17 14:33
Frankie probably got off and told Oppenheimer it won't beat the filly. No vested interest of course!
By:
brigust1
When: 10 Sep 17 14:39
He might not but that's what horse racing is all about. I bet they are glad they ran Decorated Hero yesterday.
By:
Figgis
When: 10 Sep 17 15:53
Chantilly on channel 95, for anyone without RUK, Kodi, etc
By:
brigust1
When: 10 Sep 17 16:43
There is another clue for Oppenheimer. Japanese horse beaten.
By:
unclepuncle
When: 11 Sep 17 14:18
It will be a real shame if they don't let Cracksman take his chance - and I say that with no financial involvement on the race.

They keep talking about saving him for his 4 year old career but what is the aim - to win the Arc next year? He may not be fit and well next October, and even if he has a good season and makes the gig, as a 4 year old colt he will be at a massive disadvantage (only two have won this century).

The Dettori factor is something and nothing. Plenty of good jockey options out there - is Atzeni confirmed for anything yet?
By:
The Headmaster
When: 11 Sep 17 16:19
Nice letter today Laurie.  One Q...are you not worried about the horse's wind up?  You couldn't call it a 'flat spot', but at York and yesterday Dettori seems to have to get the horse's blood up from quite a long way out and it takes a while for him to hit top gear.  On softish ground that wouldn't be a problem, if he liked soft ground.

The Cracksman debate is a simple one for me.  He should have run in the Leger.  He'd have been Evens at best and won with head in chest.  That's a proper way to end your 3yo season not the bloody Niel.
By:
Figgis
When: 11 Sep 17 16:54
He should have run in the Leger.  He'd have been Evens at best and won with head in chest

Agree with that. I'd make him about 1/3 against that lot.

at York and yesterday Dettori seems to have to get the horse's blood up from quite a long way out and it takes a while for him to hit top gear

I think the visual impressions were misleading. They didn't go fast early in either of those race, Cracksman was quickening when asked but it might not have appeared so as most of the others were doing the same. A faster early pace would show him in a better light I reckon.
By:
brigust1
When: 11 Sep 17 17:50
Thanks, TH, did you spot the mile and a quarter mistake? I wrote twelve furlongs but, in their infinite wisdom, some fool at the Post changed it to a mile and a quarter. You couldn't make it up. 

I totally agree with Figgis on your main point. The pace was nothing to write home about and he quickened at the same time everything else was trying to. It was a poor race and I think he will be a lot better with a stronger pace because his stamina and stride can be used to the full.
The St Leger may have appeared a gimme but they hardly ever are and I think JG is keen on it but his winners never seem to go on to do anything afterwards. If I remember correctly.
The Dettori factor is a red herring unless the owner is mad. If Enable stays in training Frankie will ride her next year anyway on the same races targeted by Cracksman. He may miss the Coronation Cup so the only 12 furlong races left for him in this country are the King George and the Arc. And the Grand Prix de St Cloud in France. Makes absolutely no sense.
By:
brigust1
When: 11 Sep 17 19:10
Just a thought.

If they go for the Arc the possibility of going to Dubai goes out of the window. The two races in Dubai are for 4 year olds and upwards over 12f and are worth £4 million to the winner. Getting beaten in the Arc, assuming he finished 2nd is worth only a £1 million. That could be the reason. They could go for both but that would be an ask. Any betting anywhere?
By:
brigust1
When: 11 Sep 17 19:14
And JG knows all about Dubai having on the race this year with Jack Hobbs. Anyone else heard of him? Or what has happened to him?
By:
brigust1
When: 11 Sep 17 19:14
*won
By:
jedi sophie
When: 11 Sep 17 20:27
Why would Cracksman be 123 to beat Capri? Who beat him fair and square at Curragh and can be backed at 4s?
From someone who is on Cracksman for Arc and was on Antepost for Derby at 25s....
Page 2 of 12  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 12 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com