Forums

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 96 comments are related to the topic:
Jack Hobbs 5/1 Champion Stakes

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 3  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 96
By:
harry callaghan
When: 08 Oct 15 11:58
i think you have made your point about being right about the forecast in the arc unclepunkle...

well done you were right (so were others) and if you are right here, you would be right about a 4/7 shot, so well done again in advance

you must of made fortunes on the straight forecast by the way in the arc paid a whopping 71/1 so well done for that as well
By:
Figgis
When: 08 Oct 15 11:59
Ah right, see your point about the trip rather than the ground, although his Dante form wasn't too shabby.
By:
unclepuncle
When: 08 Oct 15 12:59
Thanks HarryDevil -  though I didn't make quite as much as when I backed Sprinter Sacre antepost for the Arkle instead of Peddlers Cross.Laugh
By:
harry callaghan
When: 08 Oct 15 13:09
one hell of a strike rate punkleGrin
By:
unclepuncle
When: 08 Oct 15 13:13
They are my only two winners in the last 5 years though Harry.Cry
By:
harry callaghan
When: 08 Oct 15 13:26
hang in there - you have been patient and it is clearly turning...i wait with baited breath for your next prediction, you have always been good on weather forecasts, it is just a shame there isn't more markets, we'd all be richMischief
By:
harry callaghan
When: 08 Oct 15 13:31
does anyone know if intilaaq is over his injury?
By:
G1_Jockey_4
When: 10 Oct 15 08:19
hope so.

but it will cloud the whole race for me.

he is the one id be interested in but the fact he had a set back probably means this is a bit much of an ask .....

with a decent prep he is the one to beat imo
By:
unclepuncle
When: 10 Oct 15 08:48
O'Brien suggesting Found may run - though of course Coolmore are a total nightmare when it come to race plans.Cry

But if she runs I'd have her shorter than Jack Hobbs in my tissue so have had to take some 13/1 on here just in case. Will go in again if she is still a decent price after final decs.
By:
sintonian
When: 12 Oct 15 06:45
I hope for the sake of the race Free Eagle is a confirmed runner this weekend, if he is JH should be at least 2/1.
By:
impossible123
When: 12 Oct 15 08:11
I'd like to see Free Eagle and Found take part this weekend, if so, I think they both have a decent chance against Jack Hobbs' whose optimum distance, in my opinion, is at least 12f.
By:
unclepuncle
When: 12 Oct 15 09:30
Good to Soft going forecast so I can see Weld ducking it with Free Eagle - he has had two hard races in the last 6 weeks.

O'Brien making all the right noises about Found running but Ladbrokes have been top price over the weekend which is a bit worrying - still took some 8/1 e/w though. Bound to be a non runner now.Cry
By:
layingisthewayforward
When: 12 Oct 15 13:55
Free eagle nr, found still in.
By:
unclepuncle
When: 12 Oct 15 14:08
Excellent news.Cool
By:
johnnyrant
When: 12 Oct 15 15:52
Gosden knows which is why the Champion should never have been taken from Newmarket:

"The draw is key, we will all be hoping to be drawn between one and eight as it is very important over this trip at Ascot. He won over a mile and a quarter at Sandown in April, but he was still green and he appeared a little lost in the Dante. I feel he is happy over both 1m2f and 1m4f and he has a lot of tactical speed. It's going to ride on the slow side of good, but that won't be a problem for him."
By:
Figgis
When: 12 Oct 15 16:14
Looking at results over the last few years of races between 10f and 12f when the stalls have been positioned low results look entirely random regarding the draw.
By:
Figgis
When: 12 Oct 15 16:16
That is in fields with double figure runners.
By:
johnnyrant
When: 12 Oct 15 16:31
If there's no pace in the race & stuck wide virtually impossible to win round there. Some jockeys have been able to push forward from the start, from a wide draw, then dictate the pace. Truly run, especially a G1 at even fractions, very hard to be posted wide round the bend and go on to win.
By:
Figgis
When: 12 Oct 15 17:17
Draw  W – R      %
1     3 – 60     5
2     4 – 60     6.7
3     3 – 61     4.9
4     5 – 59     8.5
5     7 – 57     12.3
6     2 – 59     3.4
7     8 – 59     13.6
8     9 – 60     15
9     4 – 57     7
10    4 – 55     7.3
11    3 – 52     5.8
12    4 – 36     11.1
13    0 – 22     0
14    1 – 23     4.3
15    3 – 18     16.7
16    1 – 15     6.7
17    1 – 8      12.5
18    0 – 9      0
19    0 – 7      0
20    1 –6       16.7
21    2 – 7      28.6
22    0 – 7      0

Average runners 12.4
Average draw    8.1

Those are the results from 2011 when stalls were placed low for races between 10-12f featuring 10 runners or more. Prior to that the stalls were high so not really relevant.

I don't see anything too worrying there. Obviously different pace scenarios can have a varying influence on the effects of the draw but you'd think a jockey with any pace awareness and tactical nous ought to be able to overcome what may seem a less than ideal draw over this track and trip.
By:
sintonian
When: 12 Oct 15 19:38
I would guess connections of Elm Park are waiting to see what Gleneagles does before committing to QEII or Champion Stakes. Reckon it'll be the QEII
By:
johnnyrant
When: 13 Oct 15 10:58
This is a G1 over 10f Fig so I think those figures aren't entirely indicative of the draw bias. I've seen enough races there to conclude wide draw disadvantaged. Generally a jockey has a real job on his hands posted wide, if he can't drop into the rail or close to the rail off a decent gallop and get some cover and then get a clean run through, or press forward and then move across to the rail without exerting too much energy in doing so.

There is often traffic trouble, especially when the pace is poor. Even fractions, G1 horses of similar ability, one drawn 1, the other drawn 12, the one in 12 forced wider, especially round the turn, logic dictates the one on the outside is having to travel further and will be unable to make up the lost ground, unless he is a far superior racehorse - a Frankel-type.

12f gives jockeys that bit more time and scope to try and overcome the wide draw. But often in those big R.Ascot handicaps, if there isn't a decent gallop, those drawn widest have very little chance if the jockey has decided to drop in behind.
By:
lewisham ranger
When: 13 Oct 15 11:06
surely this found filly is one of the most overrated horses in training, I will probably eat my words after saturday but I just don't get what she's done to keep hyping her up like this.

I don't see the problem with the ground for Jack Hobbs. He did ok over the summer when the ground was riding quick. Now it's autumn ground on a stiff track so should be ideal.

The fact he stays further than 1 mile two is surely a bonus. The opposition doesn't look that great. If anything he should probably be odds on, not 3-1.
By:
lewisham ranger
When: 13 Oct 15 11:11
sorry I realize he's close to evens I was just responding to what uncle puncle said.
By:
Fallen Angel
When: 13 Oct 15 11:17
i was thinking you had a bookie offering you 3/1 and i was going to say fill your boots Grin
By:
ThunderRoad
When: 13 Oct 15 11:36
The two interesting outsiders from my perspective are Fascinating Rock @ 16/1 & Lightning Spear @ 33/1.

No idea if they're running, but think either could push Jack Hobbs close.
By:
unclepuncle
When: 13 Oct 15 11:40
I 'hyped up' Found at 14/1 becuase I felt it was a rick - she is now 5/1 or less so I have already been proved right win lose or draw, and I am quite happy with my position.Cool

What has she done? Other than being a much classier 2 year old than Jack Hobbs, in the Irish Champion she finished just as close to Golden Horn as Jack Hobbs has ever done, and while it's impossible to be sure I felt she would have been right in the mix for the places in the Arc with a better passage.

Jack Hobbs has two perfectly decent runs behind Golden Horn to his name (though no better than Found's) and beaten a very ordinary Irish Derby field doing all his best work at the finish and then won an egg and spoon race at Kempton. In his favour is that he has been laid out for this where as Found has run in the two highest quality races of the entire season in the last 6 weeks - though as I pointed out straight away she didn't appear have a hard race in the Arc, and comments from Moore and O'Brien suggest they feel likewise.

I'm not saying Jack Hobbs won't hack up so don't let me put you off lumping on at 11/8.
By:
Big Black Cat
When: 13 Oct 15 12:25
RIBBONS is underrated and overpriced IMHO.  Her form in Ireland with Legatissimo giving her 12lbs (WFA) on unsuitably quick ground is pretty smart, and she has ground and trip to suit here.  Frankie knows how to ride her now after the French debacle.
By:
Figgis
When: 13 Oct 15 12:35
Draw  W – R      %
1     4 – 33     12.1
2     1 – 32     3.1
3     2 – 33     6.1
4     2 – 33     6.1
5     4 – 32     6.1
6     2 – 33     6.1
7     7 – 34     20.6
8     2 – 31     9.7
9     3 – 33     9.1
10    3 – 31     9.7
11    1 – 29     3.4
12    2 – 21     9.5
13    0 - 15     0
14    0 - 13     0
15    2 - 11     18.2
16    0 - 7      0

These are the figures from 2008 till now but limited to 10f races.

Johnny, the reason I used 10-12f originally was for a larger sample size, as the amount of 10f races alone with runners above 12 was so small a sample to be meaningless. I acknowledge the point though that 12f gives a bit more time. These figures include all classes of race but are largely made up of handicap races, which are known to be more competitive than a typical Gp1 so provide a better reflection of the draw effect.

I take your point about what can happen if the pace is slow, but we don't know for sure what the pace will be. Going off past Champion Stakes races and the seemingly competitive nature of this renewal I'd expect a decent pace, but that can only be an educated guess. If there is a slow pace how do we know one of the jockeys drawn wide won't do a Dettori? A horse drawn on the inside could be dropped in and struggle to get a clear run, as happened with The Grey Gatsby over this c&d.

The upshot of all this is how does a punter incorporate any of this information into their tissue price or the price they're willing to back a runner at? Personally I don't think it's worth the effort of trying, as I believe the results will roughly be swings and roundabouts. Maybe I'm just too lazy though and good luck to anyone who has it figured Wink
By:
johnnyrant
When: 13 Oct 15 12:56
For me Fig, the unpredictable nature of that 10f at Ascot, the importance of tactics/pace in the outcome, risk of traffic trouble and the impact of that bend puts me off getting heavily involved.

I'd be a lot more confident investing in the Champion on the Rowley Mile - see it as a lot fairer, which is why for me, as a championship race with such a lengthy history associated with HQ, it shouldn't have been moved.

Time of year also means we have seen horrible slogs on bad ground at Ascot. At least this year, it looks virtually guaranteed to be only on the slow side of good, one thing to be grateful for Happy
By:
unclepuncle
When: 13 Oct 15 13:14
Other than in massive field handicaps I've always found the round course at Ascot (1m-2m) to be one of the fairest in the country - can't think of many hard luck stories in any of the major group 1's down the years.Confused

The straight course since the re-development has become a nightmare.
By:
lewisham ranger
When: 13 Oct 15 13:17
I must admit that I watched a replay of the arc and she did get an unlucky passage. If Ryan had been harder on her she surely would have finished closer.

Good luck with your bet.
By:
Figgis
When: 13 Oct 15 13:21
I agree about the bad ground problem but other than that I've liked the switch to Ascot and Champions Day as I think it's elevated the race, which was needed.

For me Fig, the unpredictable nature of that 10f at Ascot, the importance of tactics/pace in the outcome, risk of traffic trouble and the impact of that bend puts me off getting heavily involved.

Yes I think that's the most sensible approach, to take a broad view of the whole race if you view it as more unpredictable than usual, rather than try to weigh up the pros and cons individually.
By:
sageform
When: 14 Oct 15 08:25
Still think that Jack Hobbs is the most likely winner but I am still dubious about his ability over 10 furlongs when his 2 best runs have been over 12.
By:
Benjy
When: 14 Oct 15 19:52
It's a huge step up but I'm interested to see what Racing History can do. Think he'll be winning Group 1s next year.
By:
johnnyrant
When: 15 Oct 15 11:03
Jack Hobbs drawn 12. Good luck backers. How about The Grey Gatsby this year, uncle, just for starters Confused
By:
lewisham ranger
When: 15 Oct 15 13:11
I must admit that with the publication of the draw, despite all I said before, I've now switched to found. Laugh
By:
Can't Catch Me
When: 15 Oct 15 14:21
TGG was drawn in stall 1 though johnny... so whilst I agree there can be hard luck stories over this trip, I think that can happen from any draw. I dont really see JH's wide draw as a negative myself.
By:
johnnyrant
When: 15 Oct 15 14:52
Given an even pace, wider is likely to prove a harder obstacle to overcome than being on the inside. I could list many horses that ran in R.Ascot's races over 10-12f back in the summer who had hard luck stories. You see so many messy races round there; far more than clean ones.
By:
Figgis
When: 15 Oct 15 15:59
http://www.racingpost.com/news/live.sd?event_id=12529624&category=0

"One blessing is that our pacemaker Maverick Wave is drawn next door to Jack Hobbs in 13. One things for sure Jack won't get boxed in! I'll leave the tactics to William Buick."

Gosden talking about Jack Hobbs' draw, along with a few stats.
By:
Figgis
When: 15 Oct 15 16:08
Not that many Gp1s over middle distances are run at a hectic gallop from the gate these days. Most jockeys with a chance don't want to make the running, they take a pull early hoping something else will give them cover, so the chances are there will probably be nothing to stop Buick directly following his pacemaker from the start and obtaining a better position. I don't know if that's what Gosden is implying as it's a bit confusing when he goes on to say he'll leave the tactics to Buick. I would've thought if he was that concerned about the draw he'd have a plan A if the early pace allows it.
Page 2 of 3  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com