John Gosden is targeting the MBNA Chester Vase on May 5 for Nathaniel after his victory at Haydock on Saturday.
The Galileo colt had finished a half-length second to Frankel on his debut and was then beaten a short head by Picture Editor on his two starts last year.
Stepped up to mile and a half in a three-runner maiden on Merseyside, Gosden's Derby entry was not hard pressed in opening his account at the third time of asking.
"They went a good, solid gallop for a three-horse race and he's done everything fine," Gosden told Racing UK.
"He ran into Frankel first time last year and then and got chinned by Picture Editor, so we decided to come here for a maiden and it will have done him good.
"The Chester Vase would be a likely target for him. He's comfortable at a mile and a half."
John Gosden is targeting the MBNA Chester Vase on May 5 for Nathaniel after his victory at Haydock on Saturday.The Galileo colt had finished a half-length second to Frankel on his debut and was then beaten a short head by Picture Editor on his two st
True Ramruna but that was over a very inadequate mile and, as his trainer states above, he is comfortable over a mile and a half. Johnny G put him away after that defeat to Picture Editor saying he wanted to save him for this year rather than win an easy back end maiden.
He may well not be good enough but beautifully bred and at 40-1 why not a few quid for fun?
True Ramruna but that was over a very inadequate mile and, as his trainer states above, he is comfortable over a mile and a half. Johnny G put him away after that defeat to Picture Editor saying he wanted to save him for this year rather than win an
He's worth a tenner Win only at 40/1, as he has shown his well being this season and has some good form in the book, but next time you'd hope he makes a good impression at Chester.
Does anyone know any details on Gosdens modus operandi re his Derby runners ? Debussy he sent to Sandwon and then to Chester in 2009 before Epsom.
Interestingly, Gosden was at Haydock on Saturday to see Nathaniel when he could have been at Newbury to see the well touted Colombian.
He's worth a tenner Win only at 40/1, as he has shown his well being this season and has some good form in the book, but next time you'd hope he makes a good impression at Chester.Does anyone know any details on Gosdens modus operandi re his Derby ru
Nathaniel struck me as a one paced galloper last year and I seriously doubt he will be good enough even in an average year, but that is just my opinion. Did Gosden not usually favour the Sandown Classic Trial for his derby contenders?
I backed another of Goden's (Thimaar) for the Derby at decent prices during the winter after being impressed by his only run at two. The time of his race in the first division of the maiden at Newbury was comparative to Carlton House in teh second division of the maiden and as the lattare was backed into 26's I took the view that 140+ on here for Thimaar, who had a decent middle distance pedigree (family of Salsabil) was good value and he would only have to win his maiden for me to be able to trade out at a third of that price.
I was surprised to see Gosden introduce him in the conditions race last week when he could have went for a maiden which surely does suggest he is well thought of. He is also the only maiden he has entered for the Dante (he has three entries). I thought there was a lot of promise in his run last week and although he was outsprinted by the winner who received a good tactical ride, he still looked green and would also appreciate a couple fo furlongs further.
I doubt he will be good enough to win the Derby but will be interested to see where they go with him next time, I do think he is a bit more promising than Nathaniel myself.
Nathaniel struck me as a one paced galloper last year and I seriously doubt he will be good enough even in an average year, but that is just my opinion. Did Gosden not usually favour the Sandown Classic Trial for his derby contenders?I backed another
Im not sure Nathaniel is good enough either which is why you'd be hoping for something special at Chester. But it does appear he will be aimed for the race.
I thought Thimaar was given a shocking ride by Richard Hills.
Im not sure Nathaniel is good enough either which is why you'd be hoping for something special at Chester. But it does appear he will be aimed for the race.I thought Thimaar was given a shocking ride by Richard Hills.
It wasn't a great ride in hindsight although sometimes you learn more in defeat than in victory.
Travelled like the best horse in the race but didn't quicken instantly when challenged, so hopefully they won't ride him for a turn of pace in future but send him on in plenty of time. I can see him needing at least 1m 4f and staying further.
I seem to be accumulating a list of Leger types already; Thimaar, Solar Sky and Midsummer Sun
It wasn't a great ride in hindsight although sometimes you learn more in defeat than in victory. Travelled like the best horse in the race but didn't quicken instantly when challenged, so hopefully they won't ride him for a turn of pace in future but
Where is the Ballydoyle challenge likely to come from? We know about Roderic O'Connor but Recital disapppointed last week and even though I'm a Seville fan, I'm concerned that he dosen't give his all in a finish. Have they any other outside contenders and should we be concentrating on this three?
Where is the Ballydoyle challenge likely to come from? We know about Roderic O'Connor but Recital disapppointed last week and even though I'm a Seville fan, I'm concerned that he dosen't give his all in a finish. Have they any other outside contender
Recital is still their No.1 imo althoough lots of people fancy Seville.
Recital didn't look great the other day, and the run left more questions than answers, but Ryan Moore is not that experienced around Leopardstown and he probably ''got the fractions'' wrong. He was nowhere near fit either. One dodgy run from 3 starts doesn't mean he's a nop hope and his next race is reportedly the Derrinstown so he would need to win that.
Recital is still their No.1 imo althoough lots of people fancy Seville.Recital didn't look great the other day, and the run left more questions than answers, but Ryan Moore is not that experienced around Leopardstown and he probably ''got the fractio
The form has certainly worked out well, with Notable Graduate and Zanughan being easy winners since. On Debut Joseph Obrien claimed 3lb from Marksmanship and he was backed from an opening show of 7/1 into 7/2 and he won very well.
It was a similar story with Empowering when Joseph was riding, 12/1 into 11/2.
The form has certainly worked out well, with Notable Graduate and Zanughan being easy winners since. On Debut Joseph Obrien claimed 3lb from Marksmanship and he was backed from an opening show of 7/1 into 7/2 and he won very well.It was a similar sto
The Dante should hopefully go some way to establishing the Derby pecking order. I imagine Frankel, World Domination, Casamento, Seville and Carlton House would be possible runners.
The Dante should hopefully go some way to establishing the Derby pecking order. I imagine Frankel, World Domination, Casamento, Seville and Carlton House would be possible runners.
Marksmanship ran a decent race in his maiden (about the same sort of form as World Domination did in his maiden. he looks a nice sort and looks sure tio imporve. He should certainly get 12 furlongs as well.
Backing him for the Derby is sheer guesswork though. He has around 40lbs of improvement to make to win a decent Derby. Not impossible of course.
I am struggling so far to see decent Derby types.
World Domination is hugely under priced for a 91 rated maiden winner.
I don't much like Seville or Recital to be honest. Seville looks a bit too slow and may be more of a leger type. Recital is less stoutly bred and could be quicker but it was very hard to like his effort last time with his head in the air and sideways and no real speed or class evident.
Roderic looks a bit of a doubtful stayer to me on breeding - too many relatives who might have got 12 furlongs seemed not to.
Casamento is at least a group one winner, but again his relatives didn't get 12 furlongs and he may not either; at least there is a serious doubt.
Unless you start looking at the 33/1 others, and promising maidens then this leaves 2 apparent options. Frankel (sorry to mention his name on this thread) and Carlton House.
Regards Frankel he is sure to improve and will probably win the Guineas. As I believe he is bred to stay, he looks a worthy Derby favourite to me and has a very obvious chance. Given all the doubts about him running I am not sure there is a lot of value at current odds. Having said that if he wins the guineas and is annouced a definite for Epsom he will be around an evens shot, maybe shorter.
Carlton House is interesting. Quite aside from it being a godforsaken royal wedding (or royal pre divorce ritual) year and the brute is owned by the Queen. He has run twice. After a promising debut he simply shafted a half decent field of maidens on ground just on the soft side by 9, 2 and 7 lengths with the second, Yaseer, since finishing a very decent 3rd in the Craven recording a post mark of 105.
Carlton house's form is very much better than that of Marksmanship or of World Domination; and he is bred to stay the trip very well too. He looks like Michael Stoute's Derby horse; he's in the Dante and English and Irish Derby's. Only doubt about Carlton house for me is whether he is good enough (probably not if Frankel turns up!), and also his sire, Street Cry. Street cry is a brilliant European bred stallion (Machiavellian and Troy in his pedigree) but he hasn't yet had a single decent European 3yo. He did sire Zenyatta though!
So there you are, Carlton House for those who want to oppose Frankel or have a saver.
Marksmanship ran a decent race in his maiden (about the same sort of form as World Domination did in his maiden. he looks a nice sort and looks sure tio imporve. He should certainly get 12 furlongs as well. Backing him for the Derby is sheer guesswor
Frankel may well win the Derby, he looks a superstar in the making and crying out for a step up in trip imo, but it is amazingly premature to just write off the other horses.
Most of them have not been seen yet and we have no idea how they have developed over the winter.
Frankel may well win the Derby, he looks a superstar in the making and crying out for a step up in trip imo, but it is amazingly premature to just write off the other horses.Most of them have not been seen yet and we have no idea how they have develo
Carlton House is defiitely an interesting one but as COT says his breeding is a concern. At the prices I've thrown a few quid at Yaseer at 120 - bred to be much better over 10f+, and has shown he has trained on and is in good health. Hope he gives the Guineas a swerve and goes for the Dante.
Carlton House is defiitely an interesting one but as COT says his breeding is a concern. At the prices I've thrown a few quid at Yaseer at 120 - bred to be much better over 10f+, and has shown he has trained on and is in good health.Hope he gives the
ON just his second outing Slumber produced an eyecatching turn of foot to run out a wide-margin winner of Epsom's Investec Derby Trial.
The vastly more experienced Borug from the Godolphin yard finished three and a half lengths behind the winner in second. The only runner in the five-strong field with a Derby entry, the 15-8 favouriteMusawama, finished a disappointing fourth.
The 7-1 winner is owned by Khalid Abdullah, who already has the top two in the Derby market in the shape of Frankel and World Domination. He is therefore unlikely to be supplemented for the Epsom Classic.
Charlie Hills, assistant to winning trainer Barry Hills, said: "He's not in the Derby, this was only his second race and he's still a baby. He's certainly a horse for the future."
The Chester Vase is likely to be next on the agenda, with Hills adding: "He travelled well and went by them as though they were standing. We'd like to run him in the Chester Vase - but if that's too quick we could go to York."
Musawama set a steady pace over a lush green surface and under glorious blue skies. He was soon joined by Planet Waves with Jamie Spencer, bidding for a treble after taking the opening two races, sat just behind on Weapon Of Choice. Borug and Slumber travelled in the rear.
Just five lengths covered the field until the halfway mark, when at the top of the hill Spencer started to get busy on the second favourite. Still Musawama, now joined by Borug, held sway.
But Slumber was looming ominously with two and a half fulongs to race and when Michael Hills asked for his effort there was an instant response. By the two furlong pole the pair were clear and the remainder of the strung-out field were left chasing their shadow.
The winning jockey said: "The most impressive thing was the way he quickened and put the race to bed and then of course he stayed on well."
ON just his second outing Slumber produced an eyecatching turn of foot to run out a wide-margin winner of Epsom's Investec Derby Trial.The vastly more experienced Borug from the Godolphin yard finished three and a half lengths behind the winner in se
Yes I am looking for something else. Slumber looked nice but I am pretty sure the form is not great; still he stays acts on the ground and has a turn of foot. I cannot believe people ahve got World Domination cut into 13/2 for the Derby, a truly amazing mug price. He is a 91 rated winner of a maiden from 70+ rated trees and has 40 lbs of improvement to make between now and the start of June (its nearly May by the way!).
Regards French entries, who kinows. Maybe one other Irishman perhaps from Oxe will become a cony=tender. I personally feel pretty sure that the Derby market is going to get a huge sake up soon. There to many slow coaches, unproven hypw horses or noin stayers in the leading part of the betting for this to be a market that will last for long.
Yes I am looking for something else. Slumber looked nice but I am pretty sure the form is not great; still he stays acts on the ground and has a turn of foot.I cannot believe people ahve got World Domination cut into 13/2 for the Derby, a truly amazi
I will win on the race essexguy. I am the best antepost punter on here by far I dont have to resort to laying Ballydoyle non runners to make money like you, any mug could do that.
I will win on the race essexguy. I am the best antepost punter on here by far I dont have to resort to laying Ballydoyle non runners to make money like you, any mug could do that.
Any news from Stoute on Carlton House....all the hype about Cecil and the Godolphin/Ballydoyle but nothing from Stoute.
Especially if Moore rides Recital in the Derrinstown...would have thought if he can ride him AOB would get a COD to ride him if he rides him in the big race itself
Any news from Stoute on Carlton House....all the hype about Cecil and the Godolphin/Ballydoyle but nothing from Stoute.Especially if Moore rides Recital in the Derrinstown...would have thought if he can ride him AOB would get a COD to ride him if he
COT - I totally agree that World Domination is a short enough price for the Derby after one run but, with respect, I can't quite follow your logic re Carlton House. Surely CH has done only what WD has done - ie win a maiden impressively. Ok so Yaseer has come out and done well but there is a good chance that he has improved considerably since that first run. But that's Yaseer not CH.
Maiden winners, even very good ones, are rarely given ratings higher than 90 odd - mainly for the very good reason that they have only beaten fellow maidens - but I am sure that time will prove that WD's win was against decent opposition and not mid 80's handicappers.
I am sure both CH and WD will leave those last marks well behind them when they next run but my point is that if WD has to improve 40 pounds from his last run (which I would dispute) then so does CH.
COT - I totally agree that World Domination is a short enough price for the Derby after one run but, with respect, I can't quite follow your logic re Carlton House. Surely CH has done only what WD has done - ie win a maiden impressively. Ok so Yaseer
Carlton House is defiitely an interesting one but as COT says his breeding is a concern. At the prices I've thrown a few quid at Yaseer at 120 - bred to be much better over 10f+, and has shown he has trained on and is in good health. Hope he gives the Guineas a swerve and goes for the Dante.
Might this be an arb by any chance unclepuncle When: 20 Apr 11 11:03 Carlton House is defiitely an interesting one but as COT says his breeding is a concern. At the prices I've thrown a few quid at Yaseer at 120 - bred to be much better over 10f+, an
Are you all avoiding the original Derby thread re Frankel because
Graeme83 thought 'it was too early to say'
sintonian thought 'he beat nothing'
ilikewavingatbuses thought 'Frankel just another hyped horse'
Can we magically reinvent the past on this thread ... only time will tell
Are you all avoiding the original Derby thread re Frankel becauseGraeme83 thought 'it was too early to say'sintonian thought 'he beat nothing'ilikewavingatbuses thought 'Frankel just another hyped horse'Can we magically reinvent the past on this thre
jonibake thanks for starting that thread on me then fookin off after feigning a slight concern nothing like fanning the flames eh.
Who was the first person to post on his thread, having a go at people and proving his point?
You may well be good at reading horses ( sorry the best as you yourself say ) but as for relating to humans you are absolutely clueless
jonibake thanks for starting that thread on me then fookin off after feigning a slight concern nothing like fanning the flames eh. Who was the first person to post on his thread, having a go at people and proving his point?You may well be good at rea
I'm sure they were talking about an Aga Khan horse perhaps going to Epsom. It's name escapes me.
Knows his stuff this one. Graeme83 When: 20 Apr 11 22:06 "Any Frenchie contenders for Epsom?"I'm sure they were talking about an Aga Khan horse perhaps going to Epsom. It's name escapes me.
My dear little Eric. You poor little man. What happened to make you like this poppet? Who did this to you? I can picture you - I think we all can. I feel sorry for you.
My dear little Eric. You poor little man. What happened to make you like this poppet? Who did this to you? I can picture you - I think we all can. I feel sorry for you.
A_T, at least Erics posts on here concluively prove he is Mayweather now.
''I am the best''
''You clown''
''I make loads of cash''
Incase Prima Donna is looking in i'd like to let him know that Mayweather/Eric/KirkStP1zz/YsB started several threads in the build up to cheltenham claiming horses to be injured and will not run. Quel Esprit and MDH.
But nae bother, we've just got to accept him now.
A_T, at least Erics posts on here concluively prove he is Mayweather now.''I am the best''''You clown''''I make loads of cash''Incase Prima Donna is looking in i'd like to let him know that Mayweather/Eric/KirkStP1zz/YsB started several threads in th
Re Slumber ... Barry Hills has not won the Derby before, it's the only Classic he has not won, so unless Abdullah says no, I suspect Barry would like to run him after that performance today. Imo, of course.
Re Slumber ... Barry Hills has not won the Derby before, it's the only Classic he has not won, so unless Abdullah says no, I suspect Barry would like to run him after that performance today. Imo, of course.
Would suggest it needs to put in a stunning perfmance in a serious trial before Abdullah stumps up the £75k or whatever it is the supplementary stage
Sint,Would suggest it needs to put in a stunning perfmance in a serious trial before Abdullah stumps up the £75k or whatever it is the supplementary stage
Yes fairpint Roo. It is not like they are lacking contenders anyway which will probably be the main reason for him not running, if that is how it turns out.
Yes fairpint Roo. It is not like they are lacking contenders anyway which will probably be the main reason for him not running, if that is how it turns out.
eric_morris Joined: 27 Jun 10 Replies: 2899 20 Apr 11 22:02 Nothing gets past him nothing Laugh
jair1970 When: 20 Apr 11 18:18
Khalid Abdulla's got himself a Derby horse I reckon
Joke's on you Erica!
Would have thought a shrood punter like yourself might have seen that one coming![;)]
eric_morris Joined: 27 Jun 10Replies: 2899 20 Apr 11 22:02 Nothing gets past him nothing Laughjair1970When: 20 Apr 11 18:18Khalid Abdulla's got himself a Derby horse I reckonJoke's on you Erica! Would have thought a shrood punter like yourself migh
You wouldnt give us your 1000 Guineas bets on that thread (we know your main bet was Helleborine who was not good enough to make the race).
What have you got to hide you reckon you are shrewd list your bets with prices?
What are your bets in the Derby jair1970.You wouldnt give us your 1000 Guineas bets on that thread (we know your main bet was Helleborine who was not good enough to make the race).What have you got to hide you reckon you are shrewd list your bets wit
I have 25s the 5s Derby fav not as funny as your really bad bet on Helleborine the 1000 (and it took the combined 'intellect' of about 50 posters on that thread including you to come up with her ... more hands make fk all as the saying goes however you may have been the main factor in her downfall )
I have 25s the 5s Derby fav not as funny as your really bad bet on Helleborine the 1000 (and it took the combined 'intellect' of about 50 posters on that thread including you to come up with her ... more hands make fk all as the saying goes however y
Oh and of course I have 20s the 7s Derby 2nd fav tough he has much less chance. A very agreeable book so far .. unlike yours where you missed a price Frankel and World Domination. Never mind keep talking on here as though you are clued up, you know as anyone could to hide the fact they are sh1t at it.
Oh and of course I have 20s the 7s Derby 2nd fav tough he has much less chance. A very agreeable book so far .. unlike yours where you missed a price Frankel and World Domination. Never mind keep talking on here as though you are clued up, you know a
Desmond Orchard Joined: 28 Jun 04 Replies: 1427 30 Mar 11 18:02 Eric Morris on Horse Racing Ante-post/Cheltenham etc Fora, is the current incarnation of perhaps the most preposterous poster anywhere. He too is given to heroic last minute trades, directly at odds with previously strongly argued positions in order to get out in profit (often 6 figures!), despite never posting an actual bet before an event. He is utterly incapable of getting anything wrong and has, to my knowledge, never had a losing bet. Anyone who disagrees with him is a 'stalker', to whom he will attribute imaginary statements, obviously without any evidence to back them up, which he then attempts to discredit. He labours under the misapprehension that he has then 'proved you wrong' - a peculiar obsession of his that gives an indication of his overall insecurity. On the rare ocassions that he does tip up a winner (without actually admitting to having placed any actual money on the beast), he then crows from the rooftops that he is some kind of guru and all should worship at his alter, clearly oblivious to the fact that even a blind dog will pi55 up the odd lampost. He is great fun though and we would miss him over there if his Mum ever banned him for any length of time. That said, there is no shortage of contenders for Forum Idiot waiting in the wings Cry
youre famous for being a mug, wd eric (taken from the chit chat forum)
great stuff.[;)]
Desmond Orchard Joined: 28 Jun 04Replies: 1427 30 Mar 11 18:02 Eric Morris on Horse Racing Ante-post/Cheltenham etc Fora, is the current incarnation of perhaps the most preposterous poster anywhere. He too is given to heroic last minute trades, dire
Desmond Orchard Joined: 28 Jun 04 Replies: 1427 30 Mar 11 18:02 Eric Morris on Horse Racing Ante-post/Cheltenham etc Fora, is the current incarnation of perhaps the most preposterous poster anywhere. He too is given to heroic last minute trades, directly at odds with previously strongly argued positions in order to get out in profit (often 6 figures!), despite never posting an actual bet before an event. He is utterly incapable of getting anything wrong and has, to my knowledge, never had a losing bet. Anyone who disagrees with him is a 'stalker', to whom he will attribute imaginary statements, obviously without any evidence to back them up, which he then attempts to discredit. He labours under the misapprehension that he has then 'proved you wrong' - a peculiar obsession of his that gives an indication of his overall insecurity. On the rare ocassions that he does tip up a winner (without actually admitting to having placed any actual money on the beast), he then crows from the rooftops that he is some kind of guru and all should worship at his alter, clearly oblivious to the fact that even a blind dog will pi55 up the odd lampost. He is great fun though and we would miss him over there if his Mum ever banned him for any length of time. That said, there is no shortage of contenders for Forum Idiot waiting in the wings Cry
that bit slays me!! ahahahahahahahahah
Desmond Orchard Joined: 28 Jun 04Replies: 1427 30 Mar 11 18:02 Eric Morris on Horse Racing Ante-post/Cheltenham etc Fora, is the current incarnation of perhaps the most preposterous poster anywhere. He too is given to heroic last minute trades, direc
eric_morris When: 20 Apr 11 20:32 I will win on the race essexguy.
Sorry to pull you up yet again Eric my old fruit, but as you never lay any horses (not even that usleess overhyped nag St Nicholas Abbey for some reason) and clearly don't arb as thats a worse crime than rape and murder, you must have backed every single 3 year old entire colt in training, yet as there is still a supplementary stage, at which point a horse who hasn't even got a name yet could be entered and then win the Derby, you might still lose.
So please explain to us all how you will definitely 'win on the race'[;)]
eric_morrisWhen: 20 Apr 11 20:32I will win on the race essexguy.Sorry to pull you up yet again Eric my old fruit, but as you never lay any horses (not even that usleess overhyped nag St Nicholas Abbey for some reason) and clearly don't arb as thats a
Smashing post from Desmand Orchard. Got the Eric sussed to a Tee.
Dont forget Recital is covered in Eric's book at 12/1 also. So far that is 3 horses, and we are only in April.
Again, though, more evidence that contradicts his persistent ramping of Frankel winning the Derby. If your so confident on one horse winning a race, then why back several others in it ? Goes against logic.imo.
Smashing post from Desmand Orchard. Got the Eric sussed to a Tee.Dont forget Recital is covered in Eric's book at 12/1 also. So far that is 3 horses, and we are only in April. Again, though, more evidence that contradicts his persistent ramping of Fr
hes must be losing some amout of money aunty post as he seems to have every horse covered before the defection stage for potentially thousands of pounds if they win, so how much he puttin on? [;)] and what bookmaker would take these bets? u can get 20 quid e/w if youre any good and this fells is putting thousands on
rofl
hes must be losing some amout of money aunty post as he seems to have every horse covered before the defection stage for potentially thousands of pounds if they win, so how much he puttin on? and what bookmaker would take these bets? u can get 20 qu