Forums

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
jamesp
27 Jul 09 11:11
Joined:
Date Joined: 05 Jan 02
| Topic/replies: 2,750 | Blogger: jamesp's blog
I have referred to this two-year-old filly on a couple of other threads and mentioned it as one to look out for in yesterday's Prix Robert Papin at Maisons-Laffitte. Just for the record here's the earlier post (in response to one from ben10):

"I had already noted the two French fillies [Sorciere and Dolled Up]. I haven't seen a recording of the Prix Yacowlef (I don't think it was covered by either ATR or RUK) but apparently the winner took the lead early on and was never really challenged. Runner-up Special Duty was a bit slowly away and ran a bit green. I'm impressed by the fact that Sorciere managed to beat Special Duty, as I had been expecting a big run from the latter, who seems to be well regarded by Criquette Head-Maarek. Criquette has used this race as the launch pad for several of her best fillies in recent years, including Group 1 winners Gold Splash, Pas De Reponse and African Rose. Special Duty is by Hennessy out of Quest To Peak (an unraced full-sister to the brilliant Sightseek, who won seven Grade 1 races up to 9f, and half-sister to 10f Grade 1 winner Tates Creek). On breeding she's sure to get a mile, so she must be a very useful filly to have run so well over 5f on debut in what looks to have been quite a hot Listed race. The winner Sorciere must also be rated a top prospect and, as you rightly point out, she should get 7f or a mile, being by Orpen out of the miler Serandine (a half-sister to Shaka, who won the 11f Prix Hocquart and was third in the French Derby). Sorciere has been given a Racing Post Rating of 99, which is superb for a debutante, and Special Duty is rated 94. I'll be very surprised if they're not both up to winning Group races. Sorciere would have to be reckoned a prospective Guineas filly if she weren't trained by Carlos Lerner (a trainer not noted for his cross-channel raids). She may now be aimed at the Prix Morny, according to the race report on www.frogsracing.com. The trainer says that Sorciere is not very big, but she has a big engine. Special Duty is the one that appeals to me as a potential Guineas filly and I'll be following her progress with great interest."

Special Duty surpassed my expectations in beating the highly touted favourite in yesterday's Prix Robert Papin (the unbeaten colt Siyouni, who had previously won the Listed Prix la Fleche in a canter), at the surprisingly generous odds of 15/2. Criquette Head-Maarek has trained many top class fillies in her time and says that this one is most progressive and will now head for the Prix Morny (and a potentially mouth-watering clash with Canford Cliffs). Considering her breeding, it is highly encouraging that she has managed to win a competitive Group 2 over an inadequate trip on only her second start. As on her debut in the Prix Yacowlef she ran a bit green, having to race on the outside, hung left, changed her legs, and even jumped a shadow on her way, but nevertheless went away when the favourite Siyouni came on her inside a furlong out and scored comfortably by 1½ lengths.

The form has a very solid look to it - in addition to Siyouni she beat Dolled Up (winner of the Group 3 Prix du Bois) and the previously unbeaten Italian Group 3 winner Orpen Shadow. She has been given a provisional Racing Post Rating of 109, which puts her second only to Queen Mary winner Jealous Again in the juvenile fillies rankings. The winning time was nothing special (the race was run on g/soft ground) and was more than a second slower than Natagora's winning time two years ago, but was still quicker than Divine Proportions' winning time in this race five years ago and was one of the fastest in recent years.

One slight concern is the fact that she is a daughter of Hennessy, whose only Group 1 winner in Europe to date was the brilliant juvenile (and now sire) Johannesburg. Hennessy himself was lightly raced and his best performance was a close second to Unbridled's Song in the Gr.1 Breeders Cup Juvenile over 8½f. His son Johannesburg cleaned up in the top 6f juvenile races (including the Phoenix Stakes, Prix Morny and Middle Park Stakes) before going one better than his sire by winning the Gr.1 Breeders Cup Juvenile. Hennessy's best progeny to date have raced in America, Australia and (to a lesser extent) Japan. His best performers in Europe (apart from Johannesburg) have been: Mousse Au Chocolat (second in Gr.3 Prix d'Aumale and winner of Listed 8f race at two, very useful miler at three); Short Dance (12 length winner of Listed 8f race at three); Perigee Moon (winner of Gr.3 Killavullan Stakes over 7f at two); Wiseman's Ferry (second to Joahnnesburg in Gr.3 Anglesey Stakes at two, later winner of Gr.3 in US over 9f); Reve Lunaire (winner of 9½f Listed race at Deauville); Set Alight (winner of Gr.3 Prix Thomas Bryon over 8f at two). He has also produced a number of Gr.1 winners around the world, mostly over 8f+. Hennessy's relative lack of success with his runners in Europe is a slight worry, but this is more than outweighed by the immense promise Special Duty has shown in her two races.

Special Duty looks sure to progress with racing and although she possesses plenty of speed she should stay a mile. She is a top class prospect and whatever she manages to achieve against Canford Cliffs in the Prix Morny she will surely take some beating in the Cheveley Park Stakes (a race Criquette favours as a preparation for the 1000 Guineas). She is now my top long-term fancy for next year's Guineas: I have backed her at 50s (prior to yesterday's race) and at 33s (after the race).

Anyone else got any thoughts about this filly (form, breeding etc)?

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 1 of 13  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 13 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 513
By:
platinni
When: 27 Jul 09 11:12
eh think youve covered the bases there james. good post
By:
thornton reed
When: 27 Jul 09 11:20
Brilliant post. Where did you get a price for the 1000?
By:
thornton reed
When: 27 Jul 09 11:22
It's ok found her on here. No money waiting to be backed though.
By:
jamesp
When: 27 Jul 09 11:28
re: prices, you'll need to ring around and ask for prices, as firms have not included her in their published lists - several firms were only offering 20s yesterday
By:
thornton reed
When: 27 Jul 09 11:46
Thanks. I'll probably wait for a while then. Do you think she'll come over here next year or stay at home for the french guineas. She could trade bigger in the winter if she's rumoured to go stay at home a la natagora.
By:
Mystic Wind
When: 27 Jul 09 11:52
Hi jamesp. She looked very speedy yesterday, quickly away and always up with pace. She looked more of a sprinter than miler to my eyes, although I take your point regarding her breeding.
By:
ben10
When: 27 Jul 09 12:11
Nice one James, I think she won really well and looks to have a good chance of progressing. She was quite free in the Papin and will need to learn to settle more when tried over longer trips. The form of the Papin looks really good and she must be the leading juvenile in France beating Dolled Up and Siyouni. What I like about her pedigree is it's all quick ground milers, Hennessy gets fast ground horses and the grand dam Viviana looked best on fast ground, she won on soft but the form of that race looks suspect to me. She has produced firm/fast ground horses in Sightseek and Tates Creek that have won at the highest level. Special Duty's action also appears to be suited to quick ground and if the Guineas was run next year under similar conditions to this year she'd have to go close. I wonder if they'll consider one of the Breeders Cup races for her this year?
By:
jamesp
When: 29 Jul 09 16:12
Nice to see Mata Keranjang run so well in the Vintage Stakes today - he had finished third to Sorciere and Special Duty on debut and is clearly a smart colt. A good boost for the Yacowlef form.
By:
jamesp
When: 29 Jul 09 16:26
Ben, I agree that Special Duty will need to settle better. I hadn't looked right back to Viviana in the pedigree, but I agree that she was probably best on good or faster ground (although she did also manage to win a Listed race on soft, as you rightly point out). Special Duty should be fine on anything except really soft ground. I hope they don't send her to America for the Breeders Cup, as that might signal an intention to transfer her to one of Khalid Abdullah's trainers over there - but surely they wouldn't do that to Criquette?! Special Duty has so much speed that I suspect they will keep her to 6f this year, so after the Prix Morny the Cheveley Park Stakes may be on the agenda.
By:
ben10
When: 29 Jul 09 16:36
Corporal Maddox also ran well and could have finsihed closer in the Vintage with a clear run, he was 3rd to Dolled Up who was 3rd to Special Duty, so it's all tying in nicely.
By:
jamesp
When: 29 Jul 09 21:08
It has to be conceded, though, that Canford Cliffs looks a class apart at present. If he can reproduce his Coventry Stakes form (boosted today by the Vintage Stakes win of Xtension) he will be very hard to beat in the Prix Morny. I'll be delighted if Special Duty can finish runner-up to him.
By:
Mystic Wind
When: 29 Jul 09 21:59
She'll do well to finish ahead of Arcano, let alone Canford Cliffs imo.
By:
Teddy Sheringham
When: 29 Jul 09 22:04
whats her foaling date?
By:
jamesp
When: 30 Jul 09 08:23
Racing Post Ratings (RPR) are usually a pretty accurate guide to past performances. They put Arcano on 111 and Special Duty on 109, each after just two starts. With the 1.5kg (3.3lbs) sex allowance they're quite evenly matched on those ratings. Canford Cliffs (119), however, is well clear of both.

Foaling dates are important to some contributers to this forum, as we know, and of little or no importance to others (I fall into the latter category). Special Duty was foaled on 12 February (which makes her an Aquarius, if I'm not mistaken).
By:
jamesp
When: 30 Jul 09 09:28
We're down to just five possible runners for Sunday's Group 3 Prix de Cabourg at Deauville (a traditional warm-up for the Prix Morny), but they include Special Duty's conqueror Sorciere and also Wonderfilly, who finished 5th in the Prix Robert Papin. Full list:
1 ZANZIBARI (A. FABRE)
2 BOLTCITY (JC. ROUGET)
3 LIXIROVA (D. SMAGA)
4 WONDERFILLY (P. DEMERCASTEL)
5 SORCIERE (C. LERNER)

Rouget's colt Boltcity beat Zanzibari by a head in the Prix Irish River over course and distance last time, form which was boosted when the third Head Of Steam came out and won at Chantilly this week by six lengths. But this looks a good opportunity for Sorciere.
By:
push
When: 30 Jul 09 17:30
Lucky Like runs in tomorrows Richmond Stakes, he was not beaten far by Special Duty, yet he is available at 70-1. Although he does have a bad draw.
By:
jamesp
When: 30 Jul 09 17:44
Lucky Like was slightly disappointing last time in a Chantilly maiden, just losing out in a photo finish. Looks up against it in the Richmond Stakes and would be better off in maiden company, but they obviously think quite a bit of him.
By:
Hawk_Wings_Lockinge
When: 02 Aug 09 14:16
Sorciere finished 2nd in the Cabourg, beaten by Zanzibari.
By:
jamesp
When: 02 Aug 09 18:56
Unfortunately I didn't see the Prix de Cabourg (what happened to ATR's coverage?!), but it sounds as though Sorciere was travelling well with a furlong to run before her stride shortened inside the final furlong, which suggests to me that she didn't quite get home over the extra furlong today. But what do I know - the RP report suggests that the trainer may look at the Prix du Calvados over 7f for Sorciere's next race. The winner seems to be a smart colt, so it was probably no disgrace to finish second to him. Wonderfilly finished a couple of lengths closer to the winner than she had in the Prix Robert Papin (behind Special Duty). I'm confident that Special Duty would reverse form with Sorciere if they ever meet again.
By:
ben10
When: 02 Aug 09 22:41
James you can view French group races here

http://world-horse-racing.blogspot.com/
By:
pedrobob
When: 03 Aug 09 11:01
have been watching some of these horses with interest since you highlighted them, jamesp.
But don't think any of them, including Siyouni, Sorciere etc , are within 6-7 lengths of Canford Cliffs .... and 3-4 lengths of Arcano
By:
jamesp
When: 03 Aug 09 16:22
I'd agree that Canford Cliffs, on his Coventry Stakes form, is several lengths ahead of anything else over 6 furlongs. However I'd dispute whether Arcano is clear second best. In the absence of official ratings for these horses, the Racing Post Ratings are as good a guide as anything else to the respective merits of these horses (in terms of what they have actually achieved on the racecourse, leaving aside speed ratings etc). After the sex allowance is taken into account, the filly Special Duty comes out just ahead of Arcano, with Siyouni (runner-up to Special Duty in the Prix Robert Papin) 4lbs below Arcano (which equates to just over a length). I'm very hopeful that with further improvement to come Special Duty can finish ahead of Arcano in the Prix Morny and prove that she's a genuine classic contender for next season.
By:
Leo Bovary
When: 05 Aug 09 18:54
James,

Nick Mordin is also a fan of this horse:

SPECIAL DUTY had run second in fast time to the smart Sorciere in the Listed Prix Yacowlef at Deauville on her racecourse debut. She apparently got knocked coming out of the stalls in that race and trainer Criquette Head feels she would have won but for that. This certainly seems credible following Special Duty's win in fast time in the Prix Robert Papin.

I had thought that the Italian raider Orpen Shadow would outpace everything in the big race as he'd showed tremendous pace to win the Group 3 Premio Primi Passi on his latest start, which was his fourth win in four outings. But Special Duty ranged alongside him right from the start and forced him to go a step faster than he found comfortable. The result was that the Italian horse tired late into fourth while Special Duty kept moving well all the way to the line to win in fast time.

This was a Group 1 class performance from Special Duty and marks her out as an even more serious threat to Canford Cliffs than Sorciere in the upcoming Prix Morny. Indeed I'm now wondering whether Canford Cliffs will have the pace to go with Special Duty in the Morny over six furlongs having seen what she did to Orpen Shadow here.

In the longer term I now have my eye on Special Duty as a live candidate for the 1000 Guineas. Her sire stayed beyond a mile and gets plenty of horses which do the same. And her dam is a half sister to two US Grade 1 winners over nine furlongs.

Special Duty is a decent size for a two year old filly and I can very well see her staying a mile later on. The big clue about whether she'll go to Newmarket for the Guineas will be if she takes up her entry in the Cheveley Park. Criquette Head, like Andre Fabre and other French trainers, believe that it's best to give a horse experience of Newmarket at two before tackling the Guineas.

Two of Criquette Head's three 1000 Guineas winners won the Cheveley Parks Stakes at two. And three of the last four French-trained winners of the Cheveley Park went on to win the fillies' Classic.

Give her physique, pedigree and the form she showed here together with the record of her trainer, it's surprising the bookies haven't marked up Special Duty for the 1000 Guineas. I'd be very tempted by 25-1 or more at this stage.
By:
jamesp
When: 06 Aug 09 11:22
Leo, thanks for posting Nick Mordin's comments (which I hadn't seen). Clearly Nick has been reading this thread! ;)
By:
jamesp
When: 23 Aug 09 15:03
Well, Special Duty couldn't quite repel Arcano, who's clearly a very smart colt, but she still ran a great race in the Prix Morny today. She has clearly improved another few pounds from her Papin win (as the trainer expected) and is now rated just 4lbs below Arcano, which probably makes her the best juvenile filly we've seen so far this season (just ahead of Jealous Again). She still showed a few signs of greenness and was a bit too keen for my liking, but even allowing for that I thought Badblokes quote of 33/1 for the 1000 Guineas straight after the race was amazing value (WH offer 12s, VC 16s). Clearly they think she won't stay a mile, but she wasn't stopping at the end of 6 furlongs today and on breeding should get the mile OK. I hope that her dismissive Guineas price will have to be radically revised after the Cheveley Park Stakes (her next intended race). Usually whenever Criquette brings a filly over the Cheveley Park, it's as a prep for the 1000 Guineas.
By:
jamesp
When: 25 Aug 09 12:37
Dismayed to hear Lord Grimthorpe say on 'Get On' (on ATR) this morning that Special Duty could even be aimed at the Abbaye over 5f as an alternative to the Cheveley Park Stakes. Obviously if she runs in the Abbaye she has no chance of being aimed at the 1000 Guineas. If she runs in the Cheveley Park at least it will give them a chance to try different tactics and see whether she can be ridden with a touch more restraint (provided she agrees to settle). If she's ridden from just off the pace in the Cheveley Park and comes through to win decisively they must surely think about bringing her back next year in the Prix Imprudence over 7f as a possible prep for the Guineas.
By:
ben10
When: 25 Aug 09 12:53
If she runs in the Abbaye you'll be able to win you Guineas money back :)
Think that race would be ideal for her the way she ran in the Morny.
By:
ben10
When: 25 Aug 09 12:56
Did Grimthorpe mention if the ground might be important to her, out of interest?
By:
jamesp
When: 25 Aug 09 13:24
No mention was made of her ground preferences. But the way she ran in the Morny it's clear she acts well on fast ground (like most of her family).
By:
ben10
When: 25 Aug 09 13:26
Yes I just wondered if that would influence their decision.
By:
jamesp
When: 25 Aug 09 16:38
I doubt if she'd want soft ground, so with the Cheveley Park and Abbaye only two days apart I guess they'll keep their options open until they have to make the declaration. My money's on the Cheveley Park, provided the ground is good or faster - it's their best chance of winning a Group 1 with her this year. Main dangers will be Jealous Again (if she gets the extra furlong) and Lady Of The Desert.
By:
ben10
When: 25 Aug 09 16:44
It might be costly but I could not back Jealous Again, think she was ridiculously forward and has had her big day. Others will at the very least have caught her up and like you say there's doubts about the extra furlong.
By:
ben10
When: 17 Sep 09 13:31
Some good news for you James, looks like she'll be heading to Newmarket.

Special Duty on course for Cheveley Park Stakes
By Desmond Stoneham12.25PM 17 SEP 2009

FRANCE: Criquette Head-Maarek will bid to win her fourth Cheveley Park Stakes at Newmarket on October 2 with Special Duty.

The trainer has already taken the Group 1 event with Ma Biche (1982) and Ravinella (1988), who both went on to win the 1,000 Guineas the following year. Her most recent winner of the race was Pas De Reponse in 1996.

Special Duty landed the Group 2 Prix Robert Papin and was then narrowly beaten by Arcano in the Darley Prix Morny after bravely trying to make all the running.

Head-Maarek said: "The Cheveley Park is the target and the filly is very well. She pleased in her work on Wednesday with Stephane Pasquier in the saddle."
By:
jamesp
When: 17 Sep 09 19:09
Good news indeed. They'd have been mad to go for the Abbaye.
By:
jamesp
When: 02 Oct 09 13:41
Good filly, isn't she?
By:
TD_Gunner
When: 02 Oct 09 13:42
50's and 33's :0 , well done mate
By:
Stake & Chips
When: 02 Oct 09 13:43
Great work jamesp.
By:
malheureusement
When: 02 Oct 09 13:43
Great shout Jamesp with Special Duty a number of months ago - fair play your posts have been very informative (especially though not exclusively about aspects of French form). With the Fillies Mile shout as well you've got this years 2 year old fillies down to a tea!
By:
nibbledat
When: 02 Oct 09 13:43
wd james
gl :D
Page 1 of 13  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 13 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com