Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 513 comments are related to the topic:
Special Duty

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 6 of 13  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | ... | 13 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 513
By:
ben10
When: 08 Apr 10 21:02
He certainly could have got second if he'd tried a bit harder, he only hit her once, did you actually watch the race?
By:
Try My Best
When: 08 Apr 10 21:04
Yes Ben I watched it live.
By:
ben10
When: 08 Apr 10 21:06
and you thought he was all out on her?
By:
Try My Best
When: 08 Apr 10 21:07
She was third best on the day Ben.Simple as that.
By:
ben10
When: 08 Apr 10 21:08
Ok, good luck with following that form line.
By:
Try My Best
When: 08 Apr 10 21:09
I.m not sure what point you are trying to make Ben.
By:
RockMonkey
When: 08 Apr 10 21:11
Some amazing straw clutching in evidence here. No matter what may happen in the future it was impossible not to be disappointed by the favs run today.
By:
Cheers For Thea
When: 08 Apr 10 21:14
Graeme and a few others on here supporting her run today,

You cannot be happy with that effort. She would have been straight enough today with 3 weeks to go til race time. She would only 2-3 more pieces of work in that time. Agreed the ground was soft enough and 3 weeks might/will hopefully bring her on a bit. However the weather has been poor in N France and as a poster suggested she will have to go down south to find some sun if the current weather continues. The Guineas as we all know is very early in the year and some fillies/colts are just not ready in time, no matter how much work you manage to get into them..
We shall see and hopefully she will be a different filly in a few Sundays time but I think she will have to be..
Good luck
By:
Charlton2005
When: 08 Apr 10 21:15
You cannot be happy with that effort. She would have been straight enough today with 3 weeks to go til race time. She would only 2-3 more pieces of work in that time.

Correct. Athletes tend to taper toward big meets. No way is she miles off being fully fit.
By:
Charlton2005
When: 08 Apr 10 21:16
Agree with Rock M too.
By:
hippie
When: 08 Apr 10 21:17
Joanna beat Special Duty yet she will take on Rosanara, who beat her convincingly and connections can't honestly believe they will reverse the placings.

Hamdan has seven other entries for the 1000 gns. Presumably at least one of those is considered far superior to Joanna.
By:
enpekd
When: 08 Apr 10 21:18
sorry to interupt, i watched the race, SD had a very pleasing prep race imo, as it was to my eyes, used as exactly that, im ( nor i suspect the trainer), at all concerned , as she had stated,as there is much more improvement to come
and have backed her again, due to the ol knee-jerk reaction of people who are unable to understand G1 horse-raciong
By:
Graeme83
When: 08 Apr 10 21:19
I'm not clutching at straws. I took the 5's after the race, so i'm not being bias towards any earlier price. Many of the British fillies ain't even getting a run into them, so at least she had one. I think there was enough to like about it.
By:
Rowley Mile
When: 08 Apr 10 21:19
Try my Best.
Third best on the day you say.
Was she the best horse before the race ?
Is she the best horse to take from the race ?
As for your digs at ben10, he flagged her up as a lay(effectively) today.
Any opinion on the filly that Joanna beat in her only other g3 win ?
By:
ben10
When: 08 Apr 10 21:20
Horses, in particular fillies, can come on loads for their first run, depending on their trainer, everyone knows that (or I thought they did).
The weather will bring her on, think how nice it's been today compared last week, it changes fast and that will also help her no end. We'll see though, remember there are very few alternatives this year and as James said she's already rated good enough to win the race on her course form (on quick ground).
By:
Michrich
When: 08 Apr 10 21:22
Is there anywhere I can watch the race online?
By:
Cheers For Thea
When: 08 Apr 10 21:26
Ben the weather in N France during the last 2 weeks has not been as nice as in Blighty I assure you.
I agree she has the best form in the race from LAST season and as you point out no UK challengers have been out but I think there will be a few unexposed types that come out the woodwork. Plume is one I know has done very well and Mr Cumani knows how to train G1 winners..
By:
GRIZLY
When: 08 Apr 10 21:26
british fillies are nothing special special duty has every chance
she will be spot on now after that prep run
joanna was 100% fit and loved the ground unlike SD
By:
enpekd
When: 08 Apr 10 21:27
ps
thanks to whoever matched me @7
By:
ben10
When: 08 Apr 10 21:30
It's worth noting that that was Rouget's first winner for Hamdan, he'd be desperate to make an impression.
Plume looks a sprinter to me CFT, the dam didn't get a mile and she was dropped back herself.
By:
Cheers For Thea
When: 08 Apr 10 21:35
Two very fair comments Ben. Rouget gets them revved up early whoever the trainer and as you suggest new owner extra reason to make an impression.

Re Plume - I'm just saying she is unexposed and is working a load better than 80. 1m, Grp 1 obviously but May is one time you can get away with it.
I just am pointing out that S D might need to have improved to win and she did not show those sings today..
By:
Rowley Mile
When: 08 Apr 10 21:38
Cheers For Thea 08 Apr 20:25


. Plume is one I know has done very well and Mr Cumani knows how to train G1 winners..


Did it change trainers or are they two seperate points, genuine question and not a dig btw.
By:
ben10
When: 08 Apr 10 21:40
Fair enough re Plume, imagine she'll be of interest in one of trials and Hannon's one to rely on to get them fit ;)
By:
Cheers For Thea
When: 08 Apr 10 21:40
Apologies thought I had written Seta and Plume..
Seta is trained by L Cumani
Plume - R Hannon (only rated 80)
By:
Cheers For Thea
When: 08 Apr 10 21:41
Aye too right.
Good luck Ben. I for one am glad the Flat is back!
By:
Rowley Mile
When: 08 Apr 10 21:44
Cumani can train group 1 winners, so can MCHM.
Seta beaten in g3, special duty is a g1 winner.
MCHM training a g1 winner.
LC training a maide winner/g3 placed.
By:
Cheers For Thea
When: 08 Apr 10 21:47
and your point is RM?
If you read my threads above (what you can understand from them at least), the point I am making is that there are other unexposed horses out there trained by some very able people...
This is taking nothing away from SD and her trainer but many people are suggesting on here that there is nothing to worry about
By:
Rowley Mile
When: 08 Apr 10 21:50
Fair enough, but still no blot on the copy book imo.
This was expected by most and she should line up fav on the day imo
By:
Charlton2005
When: 08 Apr 10 21:52
Rowley Mile 08 Apr 21:50
Fair enough, but still no blot on the copy book imo.


In my experience the greatest pointer to future failure is to be beaten as a short priced fav.
By:
Try My Best
When: 08 Apr 10 21:52
RowleyMile-Can you please put up where I made a dig at Ben 10.As far as I'm concerned I have given a balanced view of SD performance today.I have conceded that she may not have been fit enough today and the quicker ground will suit at HQ.But to look at the performance and raise no negative thoughts would be absurd.The bookmakers obviously think that her performance today has detracted her chances not enhanced them.Ben 10 did say though that if she wins today she will win the Guineas.That did not happen and there must be significant doubts now about the filly that need to be discussed at the very least.
By:
Charlton2005
When: 08 Apr 10 21:53
This was expected by most and she should line up fav on the day imo

That is very clearly not true.

:)
By:
notenough
When: 08 Apr 10 21:53
The run clearly wasn't expected,

otherwise there wouldnt be a doubt about her next run.
By:
the lay preacher
When: 08 Apr 10 21:53
the biggest myth in racing bar none = good horses go on any ground.

rofl.
By:
Charlton2005
When: 08 Apr 10 21:54
absurd.

Well said
By:
Rowley Mile
When: 08 Apr 10 21:57
Rowley Mile 29 Mar 14:29


I've ignored the importance of this trial and missed natagora in 2008 having backed spacious. I notice that hatoof was beaten in 1992 in this race (2nd of 4) and still went off 5-1 for the classic. I have missed the price on this little beauty but will back her on the day or consider backing her antepost if she gets beaten in the impudence.

I'm starting to back her now.

Last point, i'm wary of anyone who only chose to post on this topic after the trial and had NO input beforehand and now know everything.
By:
notenough
When: 08 Apr 10 21:57
rowley...

you now hold the record for the most replies disagreeing to a single post
By:
Rowley Mile
When: 08 Apr 10 22:01
Thread about 9 months old and this all you have to contribute notenough.

Username says it all really ;-)
By:
notenough
When: 08 Apr 10 22:06
I hit a nerve there!
By:
Try My Best
When: 08 Apr 10 22:06
I put up my thoughts before the race Rowley on this thread.SD may well go on and win and prove me wrong but a bit more of a balanced argument would go down well.You were also wrong to suggest that I had made a dig at Ben 10.It was the other way round when he made his reply to my comments "she was third best on the day" a comment that I think is fair.
By:
Rowley Mile
When: 08 Apr 10 22:09
If i knew you i'd give you a juicy price on a match bet if they both lined up in may.

P.s; sorry for getting the wrong end of the stick but looked like you were having a dig at ben, however he's been contributing to this discussion since last year and deserves respect for his opinion cos he definitely ain't a pocket talker or a dreamer.

No hard feelings
Page 6 of 13  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | ... | 13 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com