Forums

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 108 comments are related to the topic:
HOW MUCH WORSE CAN IT GET

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 3 of 3  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 108
By:
callataxi
When: 09 Sep 13 22:19
yeh if u fancy discussing ideas at all coachbuster or on possible other avenues to explore betting wise

then let me know on here and will give u my contact details.
By:
CONER
When: 09 Sep 13 23:45
NO way to beat the tax,no matter what you come up with,unless you lose overall with betfair.
NOW its great to have peace of mind and lay off on here.
But at the end of the day when you look at the p-l it just gives you the HUMP.
Think of all the on course bookies that lay off.They all lose. FACT.
By:
Coachbuster
When: 10 Sep 13 13:05
Callataxi ,  i'm none too optomistic ...mainly because this site has already gone to the dogs !

Looking at the football fixtures on the opening page i note England's game is hidden away . I can only assume this is a deliberate attempt to sabotage the exchange .
The new lay out is obviously worse still (for us) .This time  2 years ago i got off to a similarly dreadful start ,but put that down to my own failings and folk out enjoying the hot weather .

This time round i feel different .... by October /Novemeber  it could be just a shark tank ,which means it may still be able to make a profit but not a healthy living ....and a lot of folk will be questioning the investment of their time .Maybe this is the grand plan ! 

I am keeping a close watch and will let you know how each week goes .  Other than that i have no new ideas i'm afraid that will bear too much fruit  ...we can only hope that the Purple get things together .

P.M me  via the loft Taxi ,occasionally i go up there to read messages  .... will be interested to hear your thoughts . Happy
By:
Coachbuster
When: 10 Sep 13 13:07
optimistic *
By:
cdog
When: 10 Sep 13 15:27
Coachbuster I just went onto the main page to have a look, and the Ukraine v England game was the main "featured" match in the football section, the Davis Cup winner was the main tennis market. Or were you on about the "new" site, as I am still on the "old" site.
By:
Coachbuster
When: 10 Sep 13 16:49
cdog - the old site ,and under the Football subheading .

They have listed the games in chrono' order rather than in order of importance i note

can't imagine too many folk rushing to get bets on the Denmark game though Confused
By:
Just Checking
When: 10 Sep 13 18:01
"Coachbuster I just went onto the main page to have a look, and the Ukraine v England game was the main "featured" match in the football section,"
Isn't for me, it's down the list of chronoligically listed matches (old site). Top game is currently Lithuania v Liechtenstein, that's always a server crashing big money draw so fair play to BF :)

"This time round i feel different .... by October /Novemeber  it could be just a shark tank "
That's a fear I've voiced before, in different words. I like that analogy.
By:
YOMOMMA
When: 10 Sep 13 18:15
I just had a quick flick through all the different sub markets in the Ukraine v England match and not all that much has been matched 1 1/2 hours before kick off and it's World Cup qualifier.

Betfair pricing structure is all wrong. I turned down bets yesterday because I didn't want to win to try and stay clear of the PC.
By:
Darlo Bantam
When: 10 Sep 13 19:41
Ukraine - England match is the main featured match on my sports section, in-play section and football section.
By:
Templeton Peck
When: 10 Sep 13 21:48
"I just had a quick flick through all the different sub markets in the Ukraine v England match and not all that much has been matched 1 1/2 hours before kick off and it's World Cup qualifier."

Few better examples of 'mugs' leaving and only sharks left behind. Surely mugs bet as much on England v Ukraine  on ITV as they do on an EPL match? Sharks tend to rely on facts/stats/etc to take a position/trade and much more difficult with international football.
By:
Coachbuster
When: 10 Sep 13 21:52
Just Checking -  yeah,all gets confusing knowing which pages to hunt down for the best . Cry

I would check out the new site for info ,but i left the ray-bans in the pub Grin
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 12 Sep 13 13:05
I'm on my worst ever run which started the day Murray won Wimbledon, so 9-10 weeks ago 

I've took time off, some for a holiday and some just faffing around, so it actually only equates to 6-7 weeks, but still I've had holidays and faffing around periods before and it's not been noticeable.  I feel I've been particularly unlucky (but then again maybe I haven't) and also made some uncharacteristic mistakes, some lazy and some because of pressure from dealing with the perceived bad breaks.  The most laughable was when I was watching TV once when I'd live paused the tv and hadn't realised I was about 5 minutes behind and the event had gone in play.  Lots of my betting and profit is not on here and that is the way it's always been for me, except for a period of around a year in 2007 when it was almost exclusively on here.  Having a big individual loss is easier to take, my biggest was in 2004 when I stupidly chose to chase a loss where I'd bet the wrong thing by mistake and went on tilt.  I was over it the next day.  It's when you have bad runs that and can't find good bets you question yourself.  It isn't the first time I've had a bad run and questioned things and myself.  I had one in February to April 2006
and one in 2011 when PC3 came into force, which really affected my motivation for a couple of months.  It's not just Betfair that gets more difficult, it's everywhere.  It just doesn't happen simultaneously and is dependent on what sport/events you bet on and in bigger sports what markets you bet on.  I had a big win last year off one bookmaker.  They made a mistake

Something tells me this time it is different too.  I noticed the abysmal turnover on the Ukraine v England game.  Markets where I thought I might find value I didn't.  It wasn't that the prices being offered were poor, the opposite was true, so I don't buy this people aren't betting because the prices are carp.  I think it's more that people aren't betting because the liquidity is poor rather than the value and it's an ever decreasing circle, because it's very risky to offer good liquidity in a market where there isn't much interest, as if you end up making a mistake the lot will get matched, whereas if you don't the chances are only a little will get matched, so you offer liquidity in a fashion whereby if you make a mistake it can be covered by the bets matched when you don't make a mistake.  One falls, the other falls and so on.  When there is less uniformed and casual money as a proportion the inevitable end result is falling liquidity.  Out of everything, the England/Ukraine market made me feel more pessimistic than anything else.  This was England in a HUGELY important WC QF match and interest was almost non existent.  OK, maybe in the eyes of the public faith in the England team is at an all time low, but still.
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 12 Sep 13 13:18
Didn't finish a sentence there what I meant to say was.....I had a big win last year off one bookmaker.  They made a mistake, but the win was big enough and the mistake was obvious enough that they won't make the same mistake again so what worked once will almost inevitably fail to work in the future at some point
By:
Gin
When: 12 Sep 13 13:46
CLYDEBANK29
12 Sep 13 13:05
Joined:
10 Jan 02
| Topic/replies: 3,750 | Blogger: CLYDEBANK29's blog
The most laughable was when I was watching TV once when I'd live paused the tv and hadn't realised I was about 5 minutes behind and the event had gone in play.



A few years ago a similar thing happened to me during an IPL match. I had rewound the tv to look at a wicket being taken and then walked out the room.

Towards the end of the game it was getting very close and I was surprised at the prices when I checked them so started betting accordingly, thinking that I was getting massive value.

At times the odds were moving the opposite direction to what I was watching on screen. Thinking that a bot had gone on "tilt" I carried on trading in and out and taking profits until out of the corner of my eye I saw the green circle of the Sky+ box spinning (indicating that the tv was behind real-time). I greened out immediately to show a profit of £400 and when I checked, I had been watching the TV with a 4 minute delay!

I was a lucky boy that day although there has been times since (when going through a bad patch) that I have though about rewinding the TV by four minutes and trying it again!!LaughLaughLaughLaughLaugh

Seriously though Clydebank, its tough when you go through those periods and you have done the right thing by taking time off and coming back to the market fresh. Also, I normally try to go back to basics and try to take volatility out of my returns until my confidence returns and then build back up again.
By:
charlatan
When: 15 Sep 13 12:09
i had a great period between 2004 and 2009 and
was basically printing money but then the pc kicked in at 20 then 40% and most of the markets i played on
literally dried up and its been a struggle for the past 2 years.


i guess i'm lucky in that i was at around £200k lifetime profit when they brought in the super premium charge. having seen the effect of the initial premium charge on liquidity in the smaller markets i used to do well in (and way back before that the effect of betfair hiking the commission rate on baseball from 2% to 5%) as well as what i take to be the effect of smartphones at venues where we went from the occasional market with someone miles ahead to pretty much every market on something like darts, i figured i would struggle to mkae a decent living at 60% pc (which is what i would be on if i made it that). since then i've essentially gone part-time and i'm taking an ou degree with a view to getting a job at the end of it. i'm actually slowing down so much as i'm getting into the studying (and spending more time looking after the kids) and fewer and fewer markets become worthwhile anyway, that i'm unsure if i'll ever make it to £250k. certainly not before i finish the degree at this rate. as i get older i find myself less intimidated, nope, that's the wrong word, appalled by the prospect of working in an office. eight hours just doesn't seem as long at 37 as it did at 21.

many of us find ourselves in the ironic position that we would probably be better off if betfair did kill the exchange off completely because maybe then the purple or red or whatever they are now would be better placed to launch a promotional blitz and make a decent fist of it. until then the liquidity keeps us here or so it seems. we're in a massive prisoners' dilemma situation.
By:
CONER
When: 17 Sep 13 00:01
BETFAIR Are killing the great exchange they had,its just a joke to what it was.
IS IT PURE GREED,STUPIDITY,OR A MORE SINISTER AGENDA.
By:
pmbets
When: 17 Sep 13 00:16
And we the people on here created the exchange.We have given gazillions of or free time to build up Betfair since it's inception.
And this is what they do to us.
By:
CONER
When: 19 Sep 13 00:07
CORRECT
By:
Just Checking
When: 19 Sep 13 17:42
Just reviewing the sizes of matched bets I get unless Mr Joe Punter esq. and all his buddies are now big money players, soooo much of the activity on the exchange now is surely bookies, bots, bookies bots, manipulators, insiders, (f1xers..?) etc.

It's not like you get mostly £4 bet, £5, £10, a sequence of recreational sized bets from your average Joe, that you'd get in a "healthy" exchange like it used to be. It's thump, bang, big wad, spike.

It's the death of it.
By:
YOMOMMA
When: 19 Sep 13 21:15
Same here just checking, it's bots arbing the exchange and the pro books, they are rife.
By:
Just Checking
When: 19 Sep 13 22:36
I can't see it improving and only getting worse I'm afraid. I think it's time to start winding down, maybe just do big premier games that still have actual people on them. BF created this mess in lesser markets, they can lie in it, not sure it's worth it any more.
By:
YOMOMMA
When: 19 Sep 13 22:59
Keep a close eye on what the odds are with Pinnacle, IBCbet/12bet (they have the same odds), so you don't get arbed. Don't put too much money up in one go so if the odds move against you, you can red out without that much damage. Sometimes the odds can move sharply and you end up getting eaten, hate it when that happens.
By:
CONER
When: 26 Sep 13 00:16
WELL IS IT GETTING BETTER
By:
CONER
When: 02 Oct 13 00:43
After all the cobblers about the rugby and pc tax ,it has just got more pitiful,what the hell is betunfair playing at.
By:
Latalomne
When: 03 Oct 13 08:52

Aug 31, 2013 -- 8:58PM, Just Checking wrote:


Liquidity disappearing is the death of trading as you risk being matched one side and unable to be matched other side (or only at very bad red odds).So traders also leave the market.It's a death spiral.


Bang on.  As someone who has provided more liquidity in tennis and rugby HC markets than most in recent years, certainly the former, is now not worth bothering with unless one of the really big names is playing, and even then it's marginal.  It is physically impossible to trade because there are no backers.  If there are no backers, there's no ability to trade and if there's no ability to trade, margins are only going to increase, thus making it even less appealing for backers. 

As I said when I was asked if the rugby 'change' would affect my betting activity, that rather depends if there's any more backers' money in the market.  I'm always willing to pump more money in if there's an ability to trade.

I think a few things have helped us get to the stage we're now at.  1) PC  2) HUGE time advantages for those prepared to pay for the privilege - who wants to get picked off on markets where the prices are changing before the events have unfolded on the TV? 3) An ever-increasing lack of loyalty to BF (I think that's under playing it)  4) A half-arsed attitude towards Live Video, which, if they could be bothered, could go some way towards addressing the issues created by #2  5) The sportsbook  6) A complete lack of understanding of how the exchange functions from successive management teams

As has been said in Frog's thread, the fact that they were looking to do something to increase liquidity on the rugby markets - however flawed that plan may have been - is the first real indication we've had that someone at BF Towers is starting to wake up and smell the coffee....  Is it too late?  For me, the sad thing that remains in all of this is that despite everything, a REAL alternative is still to emerge....

By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 03 Oct 13 11:29
A very good post Latolomne.  The rugby promotion only addressed point 1.  That on it's own won't work, fundamentally because of points 3, 5 and 6.  Point 4 I feel is a cherry on the top once you get the fundamentals right, whereas point 2 I feel is something without a good solution and is an inherent weakness in the exchange model.

I would also like to add point 7, and that is the level of shrewdness and the relative level of shrewdness. 

The market grew very quickly in the early days because you didn't have to be that clever to make money or extremely knowledgeable to offer prices, because there weren't anywhere near as many pros.  As the level of shrewdness increases, liquidity/offers decrease as you become more respectful of the opposition.  It's an inherent weakness in the exchange system and something that can't be tackled. 

Much more important is the relative level of shrewdness.  As the level of shrewdness went up over the years, the relative level of shrewdness didn't go up by anywhere near the same amount, as the exchange was growing, new blood was entering, there was a feel good factor that everyone was working together etc etc.  Now what is happening is that as the exchange is contracting, the relative level of shrewdness is increasing by more than the level of shrewdness.  It's part of the reason why competitors can't get off the ground.

Death spiral in itself probably doesn't do it justice, it's an accelerating death spiral.
By:
Templeton Peck
When: 03 Oct 13 15:43
Yep, good post, Latalomne.  I concur with the handicap betting on tennis.  3 or 4 years ago it was one of my major sources of income, now I've pretty much given up on it it as people like myself and many small backers have also left. Like you're saying, it's a death spiral.
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 03 Oct 13 16:28
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w7RIgs3eygo
By:
CONER
When: 07 Oct 13 22:34
LOVE THE VID, RINGS TRUE.
Page 3 of 3  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com