We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
I never get tired of posting this story
![]() Betfair takes action against rogue 'bots' Ban for odds computer programs after punter bonanza Greg Wood The Guardian, Thursday 26 September 2002 20.44 BST Betfair, the internet's largest betting exchange, is expected to ban the use of automatic trading programs - known as bots - on its website, following a system crash that kept the site offline for two hours on Tuesday afternoon. The crash has highlighted a practice that has been going on for several months, much to the surprise of the vast majority of Betfair's regular clients, with one punter claiming that his computer program has made him hundreds of thousands of pounds. A bot is a computer program that can access a website and strike or lay bets, just as any human punter can. Unlike a regular punter, though, it does not need to eat, drink or sleep, and can request a web page several times a second. About a dozen Betfair clients are thought to have been using bots to scan the site for chances to bet overbroke, or otherwise gain a guaranteed edge on other users. They will now be warned to switch off their bots, or be banned from using Betfair's site. A Betfair spokesman said yesterday that Tuesday's problems were not caused directly by the use of bots on their site. However, the fact that a number of the programs were attempting to access Betfair dozens of times a second, while technicians were struggling to get it online, meant that the site was unavailable for much longer than would otherwise have been the case. The program responsible is believed to have been written by a Betfair user who regularly posts messages in the site's users' forum under the name "Gary". Although his claims are difficult to verify, he has stated that his bot has won him hundreds of thousands of pounds in recent months. He is also thought to have passed on his program to several other punters in recent weeks, increasing the strain on Betfair's servers. There are several ways in which a bot can suck the value from a robust and vibrant market such as Betfair. It is possible, for instance, to write a program that scans active markets looking for one that is momentarily "overbroke", allowing it to back every runner to return a small, but guaranteed, profit. The bot places the required bets automatically and instantly, and moves on to look for its next opportunity. Others can be programmed to notice obvious mistakes - a punter, say, who has tried to offer a horse at 2.0 in Betfair's digital odds system, and offered 2.2 instead. A bot could also be set up to back and lay consistently around a given price. Backing at 2.6 and then laying at 2.4, over and over again, would soon try the patience of most human punters, but a computer program does not get bored. "The result tends to be that there are lots and lots of very small bets going through, which are a pain for everybody concerned," Mark Davies, Betfair's spokesman, said yesterday. "And when we have a problem like we did on Tuesday, the program just keeps on trying to trade, asking the database questions which it is not in a position to answer. We're getting in touch with the account holders in question, and we would expect to make a statement on Friday morning." The bots are not merely a technical problem for Betfair. The site's image, as a place where punter meets punter in a battle of judgment and wits, is among its biggest selling points. A perception that its clients might in fact be taking on a bank of computers, or that it is pointless looking for serious value because a bot will always get there first, would be damaging. One problem for Betfair, though, is that a well-written bot will appear to be just another client logging on to the site. To be certain that no-one is using a bot, it may be necessary to study access and betting patterns over several days, or even weeks. "Depending on how well written a bot is, and if it doesn't hit the hell out of the server, it may be almost impossible to block it," said Glyn Wintle, chief technical officer of backandlay.com, an exchange which is due to launch in the next few months. "Over time, you can be pretty sure when someone's using a bot, but if someone's got a well-written program that means they can't lose, they'll probably think it's stupid not to run it. |
|
By:
Pivotal reasons-as a punter I am marginally profitable -I have been restricted by a few bookmakers-great for the ego but I realise I wlll never make a living from gambling.Look at oddschecket on Saturday morning and see the value available-it's absolutely incredible.
I also played late night American racing for fairly decent money up to a few months ago but turnover has fallen dramatically. |
|
By:
isnt the betting world just great, they advertise there great businesses, come and win with us, best odds available, winners welcome, mr x wins half a million in ladbikes, etc etc.
But the cold reality that never gets mentioned or lurks in terms and conditions of some sites is that they don't want you to win, they want all your money one ways or another |
|
By:
As long as each company can post multi-million profits, punters wanting the same are targeted, overcharged, closed down, banned, robbed etc etc etc
|
|
By:
You adapt where you can or move on.
Why on earth would you blindly continue on attracting more and more charges when you can continue on negating the charges using a two fold attack. It is only impractical if you are so blinkered that you can only see doing what you've always done. The answer is to increase the commission generated to gross profit ratio while retaining the original income stream. If you think it's not possible, then you just can't get your head around it and it's probably best to look elsewhere. BTO, have you ever thought of working in the city because it's full of clueless t1ts who talk a good game. If it was really as easy as "It seems obvious and logical to me, to find something that is breakeven after commission and turnover as much money as you can" why do betfair bother charging anyone the pc? Why don't they just do all these bets themselves and save themselves the grief of the pc? Anyway, why suggest to people they find something that breaks even after commission, why not suggest they find something that shows a profit after commission? I mean FFS, you'd think it was a case of chap on any door in Britain and there stands a man with a betfair edge that breaks even after commission. |
|
By:
Are you seriously saying you have no idea how to find anything breakeven????
Jimminy crickets!!! |
|
By:
Unfortunately at some point, you run out of hours in the day.
Spending even more time hunting around for breakeven stuff to save on PC is not the most efficient use of that time - at least for me. |
|
By:
BTO, even if you are able to find something breakeven stuff that helps you avoid PC doesn't mean that others could be saved by it.
It could be just a drop in the ocean to them and not worth bothering doing. |
|
By:
Rather than mitigating pc charges, I find that my time is better spent making money elsewhere.
On principle anyway, why would I work harder to make bf even more money? They've hardly been fair with me. |
|
By:
Are you seriously saying you have no idea how to find anything breakeven????
No, but it's got nothing to do with my point which is more about your smug, patronising attitude. If someone else had posted the p1sh you did you'd probably have replied "but surely if you can find an edge that clears commission you could adapt and refine it to be net profitable". Lori & ETE are correct. Any churning strategies will be more or less restricted to automated players. Betfair is no place for anyone who gambles, bets and wins big and isn't automated. |
|
By:
Generating more turnover on breakeven bets to cut Premium Charge is IMO bad move.
Let's say you make around 3000 euros per day trading and 21K per week. In hope cutting costs down you start betting 10K per day breakeven bets generating around 200 euros on commission and 1400 euros per week. You would still end up paying over 19K (if we assume your own trading don't generate significant amount on commission). That would make 3.65M per year on bets and only around 72K on commission, not very good ratio imo. If you could REALLY find breakeven bets you should obviously go for it, but risk those bets ending being even slightly against you will obviously cause very bad results. Overstaking on your "own value bets" which you have made your money on will obviously lead also to poorhouse. I'm happy to be proven wrong. |
|
By:
But that's what you said, so it follows that you can't.
You post like it's something that's easier said than done, so obviously it's all too hard. So you resort to insults and 12yo lol's to make it appear less embarrasing. Any churning strategies will be more or less restricted to automated players. Why? So to sum it all up, people in general are prepared to whine about Premium Charges, yet are unwilling to leave, learn anything, avail themselves of the products supplied by Betfair, or put in any kind of effort. So I'll get some smarty reply, why should he? Well, I can't see how complaining and doing nothing helps anyone at all. I give up, I've tried to help and reveal some pretty good information, but it appears lost on all but a couple of posters. One thing I do know, if you can't adapt to change, then the end is nigh. Best of luck! |
|
By:
is
betfair really going to ban the bot ? |
|
By:
Best of luck to you and thanks for your "help" and "revelations". Sorry I'm too thick to absorb it all.
|
|
By:
NO....The biggest bot user on Betfair by far is Betfair themselves!!
|
|
By:
BTO, apologies for having come on so strong earlier. We do have "form" but there was no need for me to be so heavy handed over what I consider a few ill thought remarks on your part.
|
|
By:
people in general are prepared to whine about Premium Charges, yet are unwilling to leave, learn anything, avail themselves of the products supplied by Betfair, or put in any kind of effort
no. most whine (which is bad news for betfair's reputation). some whine and fiddle a bit to alter their exposure to pc (but given the nature of the pc3 net many are too late for worthwhile mitigation). some leave. some plan to leave. some stay but reduce their effort or use of betfair relative to their use of other exchanges/bookies (implying beards and all that palaver). some apparently endeavour to be appear to be someone else (but bf are supposedly hot on that one). meanwhile everyone has learned something about betfair. the big unknown is whether betfair have killed the goose which layed the golden eggs. the dynamics have certainly changed a fair bit since some big players have disappeared from particular markets. |
|
By:
Reducing the effects of pc3 by churning would require knowledge of a sport outwith the current markets you bet in. It would be far easier to combat pc3 by increasing the risk in your current markets by providing less liquidity.
|
|
By:
would require knowledge of a sport outwith the current markets you bet in
my knowledge of the sports i already bet on isn't an issue. the particular style of market which works well for me is not the type which would be good for churning so that in itself isn't a problem but i'm never been for churning at 22.5% (have played a few markets off against each other when the margin has been big enough that i would have done so anyway (rare at my comm rate) and when bf offered a few 0% comm markets). i'm not going to start at 62.5% or whatever it is. slowing down towards the £250k barrier (i've already revamped my schedule: no more late nights) and then quitting betting when i reach it (if betfair still holds the aces) is the plan. of course they'll probably bugger things up by moving the barrier with a coupl eof weeks of notice but then i'd find i had more leisure time on my hands for a while.... |
|
By:
No problem Feck, thanks for the post.
|
|
By:
Cheers BTO.
|
|
By:
Charlatan, I was talking more from a gambler's viewpoint. Reducing risk on current sport(s) probably isn't an option for most traders.
|
|
By:
Feck,I am with you.It is only when caught up in pc3 that the difficulty in trying to reduce the charges can be appreciated.All those,including BTO,who say how easy it is to reduce it will find out if they are actually directly affected.
|
|
By:
Why churn when you can earn, perhaps your to self-consoled with your own edge/profit margin, betfair have altered theres and its not rocket science if your as good as you lot make out to change your own profit margins, be positive.
|
|
By:
Remember the first law of the jungle, becoming a specialist in just one thing can leave you in a very vulnerable position, there are many different areas of betting you could master on here far beyond the effect of a 60% deficit in profits, stop being defeatist and adapt or you may become extinct.
![]() |
|
By:
Bff, how can you possibly give us PC payers advice when you've only been here five minutes and don't pay the PC?
|
|
By:
Does a horse refuse to race because of the class of the race, does a greyhound stay in his kennel and howl because hes in the 4 box, should a pc payer give up and fold his affairs just because he has to pay for the service that delivers the massive profit he makes?
|
|
By:
I don't make massive profits and I haven't given up.
|
|
By:
god/evolution has given you a great gift which will help you overcome most obstacles in your life, an advanced brain so instead of howling on here, go and increase your knowledge and skills and stay positive.
|
|
By:
never give up my friends[;)]
|
|
By:
lets get something straight, you dont have to win massive amounts to pay the PC. for someone who has been here 10 years, they only need to win £600 per year to be caught in the net.
|
|
By:
Is bff Fine As Frog Hair? He seemed to appear not long after FAFH disappeared.
|
|
By:
I am much finer than frog hair and as course as badger hair when I am drunk, thanks for the complement.
![]() |
|
By:
It is only when caught up in pc3 that the difficulty in trying to reduce the charges can be appreciated.
And that's the problem, most people are angry and panic when it's too late. Fail to prepare, prepare to fail. One has to be prepared to take action to increase commission ratio (churn if you will) BEFORE the charge. I do have sympathy for those who had no warning or option, but I'd be looking elsewhere then. |
|
By:
Still missing the point, huh?
Perhaps a separate thread would be in order. One where you can carry on posting the same thing again and again, and not paying attention to what is actually being said. The "BTO Monologue thread" we can call it. I really think that those incapable of having more than one thought should be wary of trying to make a living on here. Intellectually you appear considerably outmatched. |
|
By:
Should current pc payers be preparing themselves for an 80% charge? or a 70% charge or a reduced 30% charge with a £500 per month subscription?
How are we (or were we) supposed to prepare for something we can't anticipate? |
|
By:
I guess you diversify by being able to earn by doing something other than betting--in Ed Miliband's terms, by moving away from financial engineering towards real engineering.
It is within bf t&c s to act as a bookie and to impose whatever level of charges on anyone they like. |
|
By:
It is the cranking of the premium charge over time that is the most worrying, it not only alarms all customers to the fear of "betfair not affording competition from its own winners" but also it says to investors and there own staff that this flavor of sporting exchange is doomed long term, on those grounds all concerned must hope the charges are not raised again.
|
|
By:
What if a new exchange appeared in the mean time, one with a system that looked better and more customer friendly than both current runners, is this possible? well it cost 1 million to set betfair up
and now the technology is getting cheaper all the time, so its well within the reach of a lot of adverture capitalists and perhaps betdak has sold a viable competitor short with its laid back and bookmaker trying to mae it as an exchange approach, only time will tell but betfair is exposing itself to any future competition by spoiling its "big lead card". |
|
By:
.
|