Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 120 comments are related to the topic:
Betfair the exodus has begun!

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 4  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 120
By:
catflmasppo
When: 25 Sep 11 09:40
I don't think they are going to hit the deck. My profits are up since the implementation of pc2, why should I be concerned?
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 09:43
How do you tell a good egg from a bad egg?

Well its very hard to tell as they both look the same, but if you wait long enough one will start emitting bad smells and one will hatch into something much better.
By:
catflmasppo
When: 25 Sep 11 09:46
Ah, I see. I should be concerned about my breakfast?  I'm about to make it actually, I'll report back here is there are any problems.

[;)]
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 09:47
so cat your full of glee too, lets call that profit related denial , betfair shares your feeling and your profits ,

but betfair wont make itself efficient, something all good pro- punters have to do every day and thats where in my view the real problem lies.
By:
weatherman2004
When: 25 Sep 11 09:50
I don't think we're really talking about that much profit, though, are we?

Incentivising losing customers to leave should concern you.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 09:56
If observation and comment is not allowed then the
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 09:57
truth is hidden
By:
Beat The OverRound
When: 25 Sep 11 10:30
Again, you miss the point.

I have made a living on here. Enough to not have to do anything else.

But I've made it at 3.5%.

Either your comments are aimed at me, in which case they are inaccurate, or they are aimed at those under 250k profits, and 19% of them appear to have left.


Well I'm struggling to make sense of what you've written.
Either you are leaving something out, or you're just giving up.
I haven't missed any point given what you've written.

I had 2 years losing on here, but stuck at it thinking one day it would work and I would make back all I'd lost. Imposing a £250k limit destroys that.

Clearly you don't understand how premium charge is implemented.
How is it destroyed if you've already lost for two years and want to get your money back?
And even if you do get some tier of premium charge, what's stopping you reducing your commission rate to compensate?

So imposing a 350k limit destroys that, yet I have made a living on here. Enough to not have to do anything else.

So clearly it hasn't stopped you or anyone else getting money back they already lost!

But I've made it at 3.5%.

So?

If you have to pay a PC, then push your commission down to 3.25%
I don't see what the problem is.

I don't agree with Premium Charges, but your argument lacks substance.
By:
catflmasppo
When: 25 Sep 11 10:39
Nope, i agreed with the pc right from the outset.  My upswing maybe as a result of statistical fluctuations or it maybe that pc2 has changed the market dynamics.  Whatever, I am delighted to say that I may have to pay some soon.

I don't see how it is any incentive for losing customers to leave.  How do you figure that?
By:
catflmasppo
When: 25 Sep 11 10:42
The eggs were fine btw, bff.
By:
Beat The OverRound
When: 25 Sep 11 11:01
Looking at it from another perspective...

I was in business importing stuff and selling it in Australia.
Then they brought in GST (similar to your VAT).
I can't sell it for 10% more, I can't claim GST on imports so I have to sacrifice 10% of my profits.

I can...

a) bitch and moan
b) give up
c) move to another country
d) double my turnover
e) look for other ways to supplement income
f) Be really smart and sell to charities and other organisations that don't pay GST.
g) sell only to overseas countries.

One has to be able to adapt.

So I started doing Betfair seriously, sold to charities and other GST exempt organisations and sold overseas.

Since then, Betfair has taken over, but the point remains the same.
By:
weatherman2004
When: 25 Sep 11 11:36
You still miss the point.

I am not talking about me. 19% fall in active accounts has nothing to do with PC payers leaving. I am explaining why they have left. How it impacts those starting out looking at the upside/downside risk.

I am saying if I was starting out now the risk/reward profile would encourage me to do something else.

I cannot negate the premium charge now - my lifetime profits are too high. Any low margin, high commission strategy (or other such "statements of the bleeding obvious") would take years to have the desired effect - the site isn't liquid enough.
By:
Do wah Diddy
When: 25 Sep 11 11:38
SUCCESS IS ONLY TEMPORARY
By:
Do wah Diddy
When: 25 Sep 11 11:40
YOU ASK KAUTO SKY
By:
Coachbuster
When: 25 Sep 11 11:41
that's Form - Do Wah
By:
Coachbuster
When: 25 Sep 11 11:41
mind you,mine is always temporary
By:
Do wah Diddy
When: 25 Sep 11 11:43
KAUTO STAR YOUVE EVEN FORGOT ITS NAME
By:
weatherman2004
When: 25 Sep 11 11:45
Whatever, I am delighted to say that I may have to pay some soon.

As I suspected. Posters font size should be proportional to their P&L.


I don't see how it is any incentive for losing customers to leave.  How do you figure that?

I've already explained. But another way to reply would be "why are they leaving then?"
By:
catflmasppo
When: 25 Sep 11 12:16
You are jumping to conclusions in both cases.  The most likely reason for losers to leave is that they don't want to or can't afford to keep losing.
By:
weatherman2004
When: 25 Sep 11 12:21
Nope.

If that were the case the stats would have shown them leaving previously.
By:
Beat The OverRound
When: 25 Sep 11 12:25
I cannot negate the premium charge now - my lifetime profits are too high.

Then you just haven't cottoned on, and I'm not prepared to explain further because I'll just end up going around in circles.

Any low margin, high commission strategy (or other such "statements of the bleeding obvious") would take years to have the desired effect - the site isn't liquid enough.

Sorry, that's pure rubbish.
By:
weatherman2004
When: 25 Sep 11 12:36
Nah.

Don't buy it.

I reckon the best you could think of would be dutching the correct score markets against match odds.

Won't work fast enough.
By:
catflmasppo
When: 25 Sep 11 12:43
what is your source of the stats?
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 25 Sep 11 12:48
It seems obvious and logical to me, to find something that is breakeven after commission and turnover as much money as you can

Hilarious stuff BTO.
By:
cpfc4me
When: 25 Sep 11 18:43
Beat The OverRound: If you are over or close to the £250k mark, after several years on here with a low Commission Generated to Gross Profit ratio, as Weatherman says, it is impractical to negate your Premium Charge. And if you were able to churn enough to negate the charge, what's to stop Betfair from moving the goal posts again anyway?
By:
Beat The OverRound
When: 25 Sep 11 20:00
There is nothing to stop Betfair from moving the goalposts, they have done this many times.
It's how you deal with it.
You adapt where you can or move on.
I don't agree with any of these charges, but my post was about what to do if you want to stay here.

a low Commission Generated to Gross Profit ratio

a key sentence!

Why on earth would you blindly continue on attracting more and more charges when you can continue on negating the charges using a two fold attack.

It is only impractical if you are so blinkered that you can only see doing what you've always done.

The answer is to increase the commission generated to gross profit ratio while retaining the original income stream.

If you think it's not possible, then you just can't get your head around it and it's probably best to look elsewhere.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 20:09
There is a certain exchange that has implemented the perfect commission level system, when betfair designed theres they made a fatal error, to make the site look more appealing then they assumed that by offering reduced commission charges the more you turn over that this was good to attract more gamblers but the new site does things the over way, the better you get then the more commission you pay up to 5%, this is quite correct as it gives beginners and recreational players a better deal and the sharks and wise-folk pay more commission at higher rates.

This would of made the perfect launch board for the ethos of increased charges for the best to pay
but by betfair allowing the big players to bet at 2% comms for so long they lost acres in profit and lumped a 20% PC later, also the recent hike seems to be so severe that it can only signify that betfairs problems are deeper than its staffing, directorship and investment problems(flotation).

Perhaps the founders realize now the error of there ways and having gone will at some point
recreate a new site with a different, self financing operation.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 20:19
One thing is for sure, creating any new business idea is very complicated and surely betfair could not see into the future being a pioneer so lets all consider the enormity of the task they have achieved all be it controversially lately.
By:
Beat The OverRound
When: 25 Sep 11 20:37
Nah bff, that's one reason why I'd never go to betduck.
The mistake they made was calculating commission on profit only.
They should implement a flat reduced commission on turnover.

This would address many problems [;)]
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 20:51
Hi BTO just letting you know it wasn't betdak I was pointing to , it was another new site[;)]
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 20:52
The social exchange thing site
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 20:54
They don't have greyhounds, in fact only betfair does good fair markets on greyhounds so I have to accept that for me betfair is the only site at the moment i could use.
By:
cpfc4me
When: 25 Sep 11 20:57
And why wouldn't you use Betfair when you are a new member and nowhere near to the £250k mark?
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 20:58
If some bright spark knocked a deal up to make a social betting site that could do deals worldwide to show races and events, not all but enough, had advertising on the site to support the model and was levy friendly somehow, it would be mega successful, but it would have to accept winners without contradiction.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 20:58
We can  only dreamSad
By:
Eddie Batt
When: 25 Sep 11 21:03
Very good thread- I would consider myself a middle of the road betfair user -last year I peaked at 40000 commission points,for the last 6 months 18000 has been my average.
Anyway having spent the last few years clocking up an incredible amount of time on the laptop betting on almost every horserace in Europe and America on the weekends I have reverted to my old strategy of having fewer bets for cash.
The site regularly being out of action on s Saturday afternoon,the Ryanair type customer services approach and the high commission rates have all contributed to my decision to take my business elsewhere.
I didn't realise it for the last few years but there is plenty of punting action away from here.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 21:03
I will use betfair as for me its the only one good enough.
By:
Eddie Batt
When: 25 Sep 11 21:13
What did you do before you joined in July.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 21:14
Interesting post Eddie Batt, you must be one of the 19% that has moved elsewhere, what for you was the pivotal reason for your departure from the ryanair exchange company.
By:
bf_fananatic
When: 25 Sep 11 21:19
Well I joined a couple of years ago but have been busy running a security business, been interested in greyhound racing for many years so decided to soon pitch my wares here before there are no tracks left thanks to the bags system and before there is no betfair because of the charging system, and I thought it would be easy.Cry
Page 2 of 4  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com