Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 205 comments are related to the topic:
Premium Charge- Help

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 5 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 205
By:
FINE AS FROG HAIR
When: 30 Dec 10 01:51
pxb
How are these rorts happening ?
I wish I knew.
Maybe rort is the wrong word, but clearly some group of pros has found a way to benefit materially from the BF site, whilst not contributing their fair share in commission.
That's nothing to do with BF having an interest in how the echange is used per se, except to the extent that they financed the set up of the site and want and need a satisfactory return from all its users.
Basic good business practice I would have thought, isn't it ?
By:
pxb
When: 30 Dec 10 03:09
This is just weaseling around the real issue, which is that BF are grabbing a share of winners profits.

If some people are using methods that are 'unfair' then appropriate controls and/or charges should be put on those activities. As BF does already with some activities, such as high refresh rates.

Anyway, I think both I and BF will follow the current case concerning 'unfair' conditions on sporting bets, due to go to the Australian Federal Court shortly.

FYI, sports bets are legal contracts in Australia.
By:
heynoodles
When: 30 Dec 10 08:57
Some people's accounts are not profitable for Betfair so they charge them an extra commission. It doesnt seem that outrageous a concept to me. The only users I would have sympathy for would be the eddie the eagle type, who paid a lot of pc and has since hit a losing run (from what I read).

If your currently paying pc your overwhelming issue shd be to keep winning, imo.
By:
five leaves left
When: 30 Dec 10 09:35
Utter bullcrap noodles.

I bet I've paid more commission than you have or the vast majority of non PC payers do.
I also seed many of the specials markets driving business betfairs way which would otherwise have gone to the HS.

I suspect that makes my account more profitable to betfair than the vast majority of non PC payers.

Wacking the PC on top is just taking the p1ss and people like yourself Jimmy and froggie defending it under the guise of fairness is just taking the p1ss further.
By:
heynoodles
When: 30 Dec 10 09:44
fll, obviously I dont know your betting style so I couldnt comment. But I have worked in an exchange shop for 3 years and seen how many in running players bet. Some of them have near 100% strike rates (except now they go to the course). So they may win hundreds of pounds a day while paying derisory amounts of commission.

eg win £1k and pay £50 in commission. Does that sound like a good deal for BF or a good deal for the winner?

Obviously if there is "collateral damage" from the PC - ie someone like yourself - then its unfortunate and maybe it will evolve over the years.
By:
five leaves left
When: 30 Dec 10 10:08
I know about a dozen people who pay PC now and none of them bet on horses ir or otherwise.

They're just people who are willing to put in the time and effort needed to make an honest profit.

I suspect the vast majority of other PC payers are the same.

The myth spread by you and others that we're all cheats and doing our best to avoid paying our fair share really gets my goat....as you may have realised ;)
By:
heynoodles
When: 30 Dec 10 10:48
The vast majority have a time edge (nap)[;)]
By:
five leaves left
When: 30 Dec 10 11:01
Absolutely cr@p.

The only time edge the vast majority of winners have is the time they're willing to put in to studying and researching the markets they bet on.

I'd just like some honesty.
Betfair are a PLC and as such are out to maximise their profits.
One of the ways they're doing that is by putting a surcharge on winners.

The vast majority paying the surcharge are not cheating the system or unprofitable to betfair and have no advantage over any other punter on here.
By:
heynoodles
When: 30 Dec 10 11:21
Dont think anyone's denying it was a business decision. Betfair were slow to emphasise that when they introduced it I agree.

2 years later... move on.
By:
five leaves left
When: 30 Dec 10 12:00
I'm not moving on anywhere. Not til Dancing on Ice starts anyway :)

I'll continue to post when you or others pedal the myth that the PC is all about fairness.
By:
.Marksman.
When: 30 Dec 10 13:26
FINE AS FROG HAIR: Clearly a group of clever punters has found a way to rort the BF platform for immense gain

The only way that you can possibly know this for a fact, is if you to be working for Betfair.
By:
jimmy69
When: 30 Dec 10 14:30
Life is tough five leaves...you should know that. If you are so successful then you would find a way around paying the PC. It's not terribly difficult to do.

PS  I'd complain like nobody's business if I ever had to pay the PC but unless I change my betting patterns or BF change the rules it's never going to happen.
By:
frames
When: 30 Dec 10 14:33
If it's easy to do could you please post how for a thicko.
By:
jimmy69
When: 30 Dec 10 15:07
Just bet lots and make sure you win...lol
By:
marky sparky
When: 30 Dec 10 15:16
heynoodles
Date Joined:     18 Jan 05
Add contact | Send message
30 Dec 10 10:48
The vast majority have a time edge (nap)


Noodles you are completely wrong.  Some do for sure but the majority will be honest players who are caught in the net.
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 30 Dec 10 15:29
The majority of those who don't have a time edge, aren't utilising the built in market maker cheat and who aren't trapping or using inside information will be honest as the days long (would be) city boys leaching information from the rest. It's certainly very very sad that they are expected to pay a lower percentage of their profits in commission than everyone else (including those they're leaching from) when they used to be allowed to leach practically free of charge.

IT IS AN INJUSTICE IT IS. Cry
By:
marky sparky
When: 30 Dec 10 16:13
^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^
I've read that post 4 times an still can't understand it
By:
.Marksman.
When: 30 Dec 10 16:17
Feck, does it make you feel better about yourself, to believe in all this nonsense about leaches?  (I pesonally don't like words like "leaches".  I would prefer it if people used phrases like "successful  sports investors", but I suppose you can use whatever offensive words that you like, if it makes you happy).
By:
Coachbuster
When: 30 Dec 10 17:54
jimmy69     30 Dec 10 14:30 
Life is tough five leaves...you should know that. If you are so successful then you would find a way around paying the PC. It's not terribly difficult to do.
_______________
jimmy, i like to think i'm a pretty smart cookie when it comes to maths strategies  [;)] and i havent found a way to beat it yet without going round the houses and causing myself untold stress  Happy
By:
Coachbuster
When: 30 Dec 10 17:57
I think maybe we would sleep a little easier if BF were spending more of our hard earned on advertising ,more publicity regarding start up incentives or even maybe Christmas hampers for long term players who lose consistently .  Devil
By:
Rs1
When: 30 Dec 10 18:11
an better prmotions where its fecking impossible just to get a free 10quid bet!!!!

actually if i got a free 10 quid bet id still be screwing its a **** promotion  for the money needed to get there!!!!
By:
jimmy69
When: 30 Dec 10 18:28
Coach

Surely it's just down to getting your commission rate as low as possible and keeping it down?
By:
Coachbuster
When: 30 Dec 10 18:49
Possibly Jimmy , but  i won't spend any more than 40 hours a week in total  , that 40 hours for me is better spent attempting to win  ,if i spent untold hours in addition trying to defy the charge i believe it would be a waste of time on my part.

In other words i'm not smart enough to find an easy way around it . My commission rate could be lower  ,but that wouldn't suit my style of gambling .
By:
jimmy69
When: 30 Dec 10 18:53
That's fair enough Coach. The main thing is finding a style that suits yourself and sticking to it.
By:
Coachbuster
When: 30 Dec 10 19:02
Yep Jimmy, i prefer it to be a fun thing ,or as much fun as possible  Happy

Life is too short to be miserable i guess Happy
By:
viva el presidente!
When: 30 Dec 10 21:41
true coachbuster.

tbf, though, one thing that has improved is site stability. the regular saturday kick-off time crash seems to have taken a back seat of late.
By:
five leaves left
When: 31 Dec 10 16:17
I agree coachbuster. It's pointless trying to avoid it. Much better to  use your energy trying to squeeze out more profit from what you're already doing.
That's the advice I'd offer the OP.
By:
allinadayswork
When: 31 Dec 10 20:11
I think finding a way to increase your turnovers vs profit would only be a short term measure, once you have researched a way to do it the bets would be pretty much automatic without much brain power so I dont see it would be terribly time-consuming to run these extra commission-generating break-even bets alongside your usual winning ones.
I'd rather do that and be able to keep the money I had earned thats for sure.
By:
five leaves left
When: 01 Jan 11 10:19
I won in 11 of 12 main markets I bet on last year.
The same was true the year before and the year before that I won in all of them.
It would therefore take an enormous effort to get up to this arbitrary 20% figure.
Surely it makes more sense to try and win more from the markets I already do well in or look for other similar markets in which I can achive a similar success.
That's what I've been doing anyway.
By:
George Bailey
When: 01 Jan 11 10:34
Interesting thread this.  BF feels a bit like EBay in reverse. EBay started out with a customer base of genuine buyers/sellers who bought/sold their old tat or whatever.  EBay made a profit. Whole thing had a community feel and everyone happy.

EBay then got greedy. Its policy now is to specifically do everything it can to attract the multinationals. It allows them all sorts of competetive advantages e.g. a negative customer satisfaction score that would have the "little man" barred. Big commission see. Or rather big in the sense of turnover.

Bit like casinos who wine and dine the big rollers.

BF I don't understand. They seem to be doing everything they can to pisss off their big players. Whatever they win they already pay a commission so what's the problem? As has been said above BF is an EXCHANGE so unless it spots actual criminal activity it should not care who wins or loses what.

Does it cost BF any more to support an account where the bet laid is for say £50k rather than £5?
By:
George Bailey
When: 01 Jan 11 10:42
And one similarity between the two is that you can spot the "payroll posters" a mile off on both [;)]
By:
VennOttery1981
When: 01 Jan 11 11:26
the purple site is going 2.5% commission today until the end of march
By:
Fred!
When: 01 Jan 11 13:44
Looking at the T&C for that 2.5% offer...  "Offer is not available to purple API customers." 

Does that mean they are excluding our fast fingered friends from the offer?
By:
heynoodles
When: 01 Jan 11 14:29
There was no fooling you, George.[;)]
By:
George Bailey
When: 01 Jan 11 15:03
[;)]
By:
jimmy69
When: 01 Jan 11 18:02
...BF I don't understand. They seem to be doing everything they can to pisss off their big players.


I would call myself a relatively big player and I am certainly not pissed off...and neither am I on the payroll.

PS Heynoodles isLaughLaugh
By:
viva el presidente!
When: 01 Jan 11 23:16
don't agree about the big players; the PC is actually designed so that it's much easier for big players to avoid/mitigate than smaller scale traders. which is probably why liquidity hasn't been affected the was many predicted it would.

if I had a bank of £100,000 and was on 2% commission for a couple of weeks, I reckon I could build up a cushion against it that would last for years.
By:
Rocket to the FACE
When: 01 Jan 11 23:56
I think there's a bit of a difference here between 'betfair forum big players' and the big players.
By:
turtleshead
When: 02 Jan 11 01:52
"the PC is actually designed so that it's much easier for big players to avoid/mitigate than smaller scale traders"

Exactly! Yet another reason why it is so unfair!

"which is probably why liquidity hasn't been affected the was many predicted it would"

It's certainly been affected on lots of the smaller markets, where small stakes pc players specialize. No incentive to put up prices when betfair grab up to a quarter of the take, is there? Obviously in the most popular markets where millions get traded, like football and tennis, there is going to be very little pc paid as these prices are usually very accurate!
By:
viva el presidente!
When: 02 Jan 11 02:01
plus, if you have enough money and are on 2%, you can arb across the spread in related markets to mitigate it in a way that's not possible on 5%.

my guess is that the really big players pay no PC and have headroom from here till doomsday.
Page 5 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com