Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 205 comments are related to the topic:
Premium Charge- Help

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 4 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 205
By:
jimmy69
When: 28 Dec 10 00:38
Maybe Betfair thought it would look good to prospective shareholders.
By:
Rs1
When: 28 Dec 10 00:39
heynoodles
28 Dec 10 00:32 Joined: 18 Jan 05 | Topic/replies: 15,626 | Blogger: heynoodles's blog
1. In running horseracing (the most exciting form of betting full stop, imo)
2. In running betting all sports
3. Pre-race trading
4. Greening up at short odds after backing much higher (especially if it then loses)
5. Better odds for outsiders
6. A democratic forum
7. The opportunity to reduce your losses when you know you've got it wrong
8. Being able to lay @1.01 etc in the hope of a big win for small stake
9. Paul Nicholls column
10. Winning accounts not closed


As you can see a truly great company.



HE MUST BE WORKING FOR BETFAIR
By:
Rs1
When: 28 Dec 10 00:39
heynoodles
28 Dec 10 00:32 Joined: 18 Jan 05 | Topic/replies: 15,626 | Blogger: heynoodles's blog
1. In running horseracing (the most exciting form of betting full stop, imo)
2. In running betting all sports
3. Pre-race trading
4. Greening up at short odds after backing much higher (especially if it then loses)
5. Better odds for outsiders
6. A democratic forum
7. The opportunity to reduce your losses when you know you've got it wrong
8. Being able to lay @1.01 etc in the hope of a big win for small stake
9. Paul Nicholls column
10. Winning accounts not closed


As you can see a truly great company.



HE MUST BE WORKING FOR BETFAIR
By:
turtleshead
When: 28 Dec 10 00:40
noodles, why don't you sod off?

No-one is forcing you to contribute to this thread full of whingers, are they? Why don't you spend some of your time on making your fortunes from horse racing that you keep going on about?
By:
heynoodles
When: 28 Dec 10 00:43
There's other ways to make a living rs1?
By:
Rs1
When: 28 Dec 10 00:44
THIS AINT MY LIVING DIK HED
By:
FINE AS FROG HAIR
When: 28 Dec 10 00:45
turtle
As I've said repeatedly I do sympatise with the essence of your complaint.
That is, in catching the big fish BF has done considerable cllateral damage to a minority of the smaller fish.
Is there an obvious, workable solution satisfactory to all ?. Note scrapping it would presumably leave BF short of well needed income to maintain the site and give a satisfactory return to s/holders..
By:
Rs1
When: 28 Dec 10 00:48
i give up good night all

i cant believe there are so many idiots on here thinking never to post again
By:
FINE AS FROG HAIR
When: 28 Dec 10 00:50
Promises, promises.
By:
heynoodles
When: 28 Dec 10 00:55
The majority of pc payers imo are people with a time advantage. ie track players winning huge amounts and paying feck all commission in relation. Unfortunately, this may result in a higher pc in future or perhaps horseracing bettors having to pay levy. Again in  defence of BF they are the ones fighting hard to stop this happening (solicitors fees etc).
By:
turtleshead
When: 28 Dec 10 00:57
"The majority of pc payers imo are people with a time advantage. ie track players winning huge amounts and paying feck all commission in relation"

Any evidence for this? And if it was just as simple as that, why wouldn't loads more do it?
By:
FINE AS FROG HAIR
When: 28 Dec 10 00:58
Oh come on noodles.
I might not think the PC is the monster it's made out to be by some, but to portray BF as the white knight in all this is stretching it a bit, isn't it ?
By:
turtleshead
When: 28 Dec 10 00:59
"Unfortunately, this may result in a higher pc in future or perhaps horseracing bettors having to pay levy. Again in  defence of BF they are the ones fighting hard to stop this happening (solicitors fees etc)"

ShockedShockedShockedShockedShocked

Good god some people are naive and gullible, if they honestly think this ShockedShockedShocked
By:
FINE AS FROG HAIR
When: 28 Dec 10 01:05
If I thought that PC charges wrre going up in solicitor fees, then that would put me well in the turtle camp.
By:
five leaves left
When: 28 Dec 10 01:09
Apart from slipping noodles and jimmy a tenner each for defending the PC, what are they doing with the money?
By:
FINE AS FROG HAIR
When: 28 Dec 10 01:13
Improving the services of the company?
Or perhaps they are just gratuitously raising extra income to abuse their monopoly position?
I reckon, if I had to guess, you're in the 2nd camp.
By:
FINE AS FROG HAIR
When: 28 Dec 10 01:14
Move over Rs1, I'm coming to bed.
Good night all.
By:
five leaves left
When: 28 Dec 10 01:16
As for the OP. Unfortunately after over 100 replies, it seems no one can help.
But froggy and his mates think it's fair you pay, so I hope you feel a little better now.
By:
turtleshead
When: 28 Dec 10 01:19
"Move over Rs1, I'm coming to bed"

Very brave of you to say that on the betfair forum Shocked























































Any room for a third Love

Devil
By:
five leaves left
When: 28 Dec 10 01:20
Well i've had fewer markets to bet on this year, compared with last.
So they've not improved my service.
By:
rink rat
When: 28 Dec 10 06:29
I do see this. Lots of us have made good coin on Betfair. We all will jump sites for a better price when gambling recreationaly. Betfair wants our allegiance even if they are not competitive in things like pre-match wagering.
By:
heynoodles
When: 28 Dec 10 08:34
* solictors fees = levy consultation not pc.

Betfair gets the blame in horseracing circles for taking too much out of the sport, when in fact it is the winners on here that do that not Betfair themselves, imo.
By:
jt45
When: 28 Dec 10 10:55
FINE AS FROG HAIR     28 Dec 10 00:16 
Marksman
Suppose for easy example I could bet on even chnces at 5% commission with a success strike rate of 55%.
Thus in a 100 bets, I would win 55 points, pay commission on my winnings of 2.75 points, and so make a net profit of 52.25 points and thus have a net income of 7.75 points, being 52.25-45.
My total charges would be (2.75+ ( 3% * 45))/2 = 4.1 points = 51.6 % of net income of 7.75 points.
That is, well over the PC 20% threshhold, and yet I'm in profit.
Am I right ?


No. You appear to have misunderstood how the premium charge is calculated. The premium charge is the lesser of:

The difference between 20% of the previous week’s gross profits and the total charges generated during the week; and The difference between 20% of gross profits and the total charges generated during the lifetime of the account.

The terminology that you used in your example is inaccurate. For simplicity I will use similar terminology to that used by betfair in their 'charges' section.

Winnings: 55 points
Losses: 45 points
Gross Profit: 10 points
Commission Paid (assuming 5% commission rate): 0.05*55 = 2.75 points
Commission Generated: (2.75+(0.03*45))/2 = 2.05 points
Other Charges = 0 points
Net Profit (excluding any applicable premium charge): 7.25 points
Total Charges Generated/Gross Profit = 2.05/10 = 20.5%

Note that the net profit (which you described as net income) is irrelevant in calculating the premium charge.

As your total charges exceed 20% of your gross profit in the given week you would not be subject to any premium charge.
By:
FINE AS FROG HAIR
When: 28 Dec 10 11:43
jt45
I did correct one error in a later post, but I did miss the gross profit mistake.
But the example still serves its purpose, which was to prove to Marksman that you can be a long term winner even if your actual and implied charges are above the 20% PC threshhold. In this artificial example they're at 20.5 %.
By:
jt45
When: 28 Dec 10 11:51
Ok, I agree that a significant proportion of long-term winners may never be subject to the premium charge.
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 28 Dec 10 12:23
pc calimeros still at it then?
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 28 Dec 10 12:25
"We are being charged less than everyone else instead of only a quarter of that. It is an injustice it is."
By:
five leaves left
When: 28 Dec 10 12:27
Back more losers appears to be the only piece of advice for the OP.

There are plenty on this thread who should be able to help you with this.
By:
allinadayswork
When: 28 Dec 10 14:06
As I said before if staying here, research a break-even method and run it alongside the winning method, hopefully that will water down your profit vs turnover so you are within the allowed threshold, though you will have to do with Maths as it would be different for each person according to the way he bets!
By:
allinadayswork
When: 28 Dec 10 14:08
do the Maths* I meant
By:
.Marksman.
When: 28 Dec 10 17:13
Froggie, how does your example help me, if I only bet on one market in a particular week?
By:
VennOttery1981
When: 28 Dec 10 20:06
marksman, I use the daq, outright positions no trading just on uk/ire racing, can get on at betfair prices no problem normally, harder in the morning but this place is dead now early doors, gone are the days finding real value the night before at this place.  I do mostly lays and was alarmed when looking at the portal on here showing most of my allowance used up, guessing its from the 100% weeks when managing to be ultra selective, hardly making rapid profits but account in profit, pre race gamblers have an alternative, IR punters don't.  I did email Betfair asking if they could kindly explain when and what weeks the allowance was taken, all they sent is a copy what I could see on the portal o_O
By:
VennOttery1981
When: 28 Dec 10 20:09
from the way I see it, if your account is in profit you will have to pay pc on that 1 bet, very fair
By:
allinadayswork
When: 29 Dec 10 00:28
I dont ever see myself betting inplay anyhow, your brain has to work ten times as fast surely so much safer to give every bet alot of thought and do it the traditional way if you can make that work, thats my take on it anyhow.
By:
allinadayswork
When: 29 Dec 10 00:30
Then again I know there are a few tried and trusted methods, they tell me if a front runner leads early on its price automatically drops.
I do find this rather odd as surely if its a front runner its going to front run aint it, so hardly any surprise so to me the price should remain unchanged at least in the early stages, fair enough if it gets an easy lead off a slow pace I can see the attraction.
But will stick to what I know best!
By:
pxb
When: 29 Dec 10 03:18
A lot of misconceptions here.

Firstly, sports bet markets is an absurdly profitable business. The gross margin with capital investment appropriately discounted will be over 50%. No other business by a publicly traded company comes remotely close.

Secondly, BF like many initially succesful companies is spending (squandering IMO) its profits by expanding into markets where its likely to fail, poker etc.

Thirdly, monopolies in law only need to be defacto. There are government agencies that exist to control the behaviour of monopolies and someone from the UK should report BF and let the appropriate government agency decide. (I'm not a UK resident).

Fourthly, words like 'fair' and 'reasonable' don't mean anything, and are irrelevant to the discussion.
By:
viva el presidente!
When: 30 Dec 10 00:53
the monopoly question is interesting.

plainly BF isn't strictly a monopoly (there are other exchanges, and they're doing nothing to stop anyone starting new ones).

but I'd argue it's a de facto monopoly, and the question is, how did they get that way? I'd argue that they couldn't have got to their position of market dominance if they'd instituted the PC from day one, or told people they intended to.

in that sense, whilst they were obviously within their legal rights  to introduce it, I've always thought it was an act of bad faith. I also think even some of the PC's defenders would accept that it's been transformative in terms of the way BF is seen by a large part of its customer base.
By:
FINE AS FROG HAIR
When: 30 Dec 10 01:26
Viva
Surely nobody, even you, thought that the BF site wasn't going to evolve in all sorts of different ways over time.
You don't really think that they could have introduced a whole new betting concept and got everything right from day one, including pricing structures.
Clearly a group of clever punters has found a way to rort the BF platform for immense gain, and BF is trying to combat this.
There has been some collateral damage to a minority of innocents, but that's life I'm sfraid to say.
By:
pxb
When: 30 Dec 10 01:36
Clearly a group of clever punters has found a way to rort the BF platform for immense gain, and BF is trying to combat this.

LOL

Exactly how are these claimed 'rorts' occuring?

Note that BF is an exchange provider and as such should have no interest in how its exchange is used, other than complying with the law.

BTW Froggie, you sound more and more like a paid BF shill.
By:
viva el presidente!
When: 30 Dec 10 01:39
they encouraged people to develop trading based strategies in their publicity, then once they'd established a monopoly position increased charges on people using those strategies by 500% with very little notice. at a time when they were already very profitable.

imo, that constitutes bad faith.
Page 4 of 6  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com