Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 255 comments are related to the topic:
Premium charge dispute - any lawyers out there?

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 7 of 7  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 255
By:
turtleshead
When: 29 Aug 10 14:37
"Traders" (whoever they are?) aren't asking for an across the board change to a 5% flat bet fee, just pointing out that it would be far fairer than the indiscriminate pc which just hits people at random!

We can all put up examples to prove a point. How is it fair that I can win 50K on Saturday, lose the lot on Sunday, and not pay a penny of pc, whereas if somone else wins 50K on Sunday, and loses the lot on Monday, they will get clobbered for around 10K in pc Confused
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 29 Aug 10 14:55
Only the dafties are calling for a flat 5% as most of the pc payers recognise that it would be suicide for betfair to adopt such a scheme. Even if it wasn't, it's like convicted murderers requesting a maximum sentence of 3 months so that the odd innocent party doesn't suffer too much.
By:
MIB34
When: 29 Aug 10 22:50
Strange,  you all seem to think  the whole  PC  charge  is just to do  with comission.
and Taxing winners.


Its not!

- I realised straght away.

The PC carge  is entirely about  volume of trading.,


Think if it from BF  point of view.


Customer 1,

10,000 x    £2  bets   over a year to make    £250   profit.

or
Customer 2,

1 x   £20,000  bet     to make  £250  profit.



**  which would they rather have ?

The difference  is not the profit.
The difference  is  cost  of running the exchange !

All those small bets  add up.  Thus  giving BF  a huge running cost.
By:
catfleppo
When: 30 Aug 10 00:04
turtles,
as a gambler you should have a better understanding of 'random' ;)
By:
Charkitz
When: 04 Sep 10 11:05
Turtles: "We can all put up examples to prove a point. How is it fair that I can win 50K on Saturday, lose the lot on Sunday, and not pay a penny of pc, whereas if somone else wins 50K on Sunday, and loses the lot on Monday, they will get clobbered for around 10K in pc"

Exactly, hit the nail on the head. This is the bit I find frustrating. This particular aspect of the pc is blatantly unfair. Its undefendable.
By:
turtleshead
When: 04 Sep 10 13:41
MIB34, so explain my example then?
By:
.Marksman.
When: 04 Sep 10 14:57
Even an income tax on annual profits would be preferable to this.  At least with income tax, when it is calculated over the year, there would be one annual deduction which would leave you with the bulk of your earnings. Because the PC is charged on every winning week, you could have a losing year and still have to pay the PC.
By:
askari1
When: 05 Sep 10 17:01
Marksman, yes, if you are a lifetime winner.

I remember asking well before the pc even came in what percentage of their yearly profits people (meaning mostly traders) wd be prepared to pay for ZERO commission.

No one answered me. But I can't suppose that the very many sophisticated winners on the site have no idea of a threshold or breakeven point. It's just that it wd seem astonishingly high to recreational punters, who wd get the idea that the odds were stacking against them when they went up against these players.
By:
MasterTS
When: 23 Jun 21 11:42
Hi all, if we all take them to court over premium charges, hoards of us all chip in and turn up, the power of the people is what betfairs all about, we have to do it altogether and fight them all together, the court would not let this company take that much profit whilst calling it self betfair! because that's a con
once we all sign somthing and send it into betfair with our intentions of taking them all the way, they might get squeaky bums and drop it or at lest 12.5% of it.
By:
dave1357
When: 26 Jun 21 16:27
no chance whatsoever.
By:
.Marksman.
When: 04 Jul 21 19:40
MasterTS
I'm afraid that that ship sailed 11 years ago.
Even if we were claiming a refund of historical PC,
I doubt whether it is now worth the effort.
I haven't paid PC for 8 years and, before then, Betfair had taken £1,514.20 in PC.
It would be nice to get it back, but it is too late now.
The only way that it will be scrapped is if it appears to Betfair that they are no longer a viable profit making company with it.
However it is nice to see this old thread resurfacing.  I was banned from here for 9 years and this is exactly the sort of lively discussion that I remembered.
By:
The Knight
When: 05 Jul 21 22:23
Interesting that this has come to light again. But a huge misconception about IP addresses early on in the thread which still applies.

Unless you have a static IP address, and very, very few have, you will be given a different IP address every time you log on to the internet. If it did not work like this, there would never be enough IP addresses to go around because every time someone logged on anywhere that IP address would be used up.

So, IP addresses cannot be used to trace if someone is acting for someone else. BUT, 'cookies'  today are very sophisticated and they could be used to match up the same type of user behaviour on different computers.

As for the premium charge, I am sure I read somewhere - perhaps on here - that the PC is sued to partly fund the lay side of the machine because without it there would not be a strong enough 'laying' market.

Anyone know if the latter is actually true?
By:
dave1357
When: 06 Jul 21 10:37
a) it is a bumped thread from a decade ago

b) I don't think that is true

One point (that doesn't matter now with 2% commission), is that BF's method of calculating commission for premium charges was clearly unfair (the use of the "[actual commission + 3% of losses]divided by 2" method). I'm not a PC player but still see the portal when I drop under 50% charges and there is a substantial discrepancy between the commission I have paid and the amount BF say I have paid.  As I said, with 2% it now favours the customer, but I'm surprised no one made an issue of it in the past.
By:
viva el presidente!
When: 06 Jul 21 19:08
People talked about it a lot at the time, but there wasn't really anything they could do about it.
By:
PeteTheBloke
When: 29 Jul 21 19:46
If you got a decent contact in the support team for paying PC, it would _almost_ be worth it.
By:
HallGreenSpy
When: 05 Aug 21 11:24
I do wonder how many players they have lost because of PC. Obviously not enough.
Page 7 of 7  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com