Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 255 comments are related to the topic:
Premium charge dispute - any lawyers out there?

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 3 of 7  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 255
By:
Avocado
When: 07 Aug 10 02:47
How did you make that calculation Trev?
By:
.Marksman.
When: 07 Aug 10 09:57
Avocado     07 Aug 10 01:03 
If I'm placing bets pre kick off and letting them run without trading out, will I still have to pay PC if I'm making regular profit and paying less than 20% commission?


That is correct.  And if, due to only making fairly small bets, your commission is still 5%, Betfair will assume that you are on typical commission of 3%. So, if you have one bet in a week, and it wins, you will pay total charges of 22% on your winnings.  This will carry on week after week, until you have lost enough to no longer qualify for the charge. After this you will be OK, unless you have a good winning run.
By:
Avocado
When: 07 Aug 10 10:00
Fvcking thieving cvnts aren't they.
By:
.Marksman.
When: 07 Aug 10 10:09
Suppose you were going along nicely, breaking even before commission. Or even breaking even after commission. You have been doing this for years, had hundreds of bets and plenty of fun, near misses etc.  Then one day you see that Binocular is 1000 for the Champion Hurdle and, through a google news alert, that he is now an intended runner. You may be tempted to have another fun bet at these odds. It wins. Then, a few months later, you see that Snow Fairy, that impressive Goodwood winner, is 1000 for the Oaks. She just needs to be supplemented. You think to yourself, why not have a flutter, as my account is still cash rich from Cheltenham. And it wins, too. Next week you get your first Premium Charge statement, and if you have your usual Saturday bet each week, you will be charged at 22%, if it wins.  This will probably go on for years...
By:
Avocado
When: 07 Aug 10 10:23
If I ever get PC I will use DAQ as much as possible.
By:
The Calculator
When: 07 Aug 10 12:09
turtlehead,

Maybe you should read a little more carefully before ranting. I didn't say
people can cheat quite legally. I put "quite legally" after "traders" because I knew if I didn't then some idiot would think I was accusing traders of cheating. I didn't factor in other kinds of idiots, for example ones who can't read.

I also didnt say that cheats, fast picture merchants and traders were the only people who can incur the tax. I never said that, so going off in a seething rage about how other kinds of user can be charged just means you haven't comprehended what I wrote. My point was that those three categories of users are going to be the main beneficiaries of removing the premium charge and adopting a flat 5% commission. That was all.

oh, and lmao at the idea that cheats would be put off and everyone would benefit by them paying 20%+ of their profits instead of 5%+, with the rest going to betfair

You're right, that would be a stupid idea. Lucky I made no mention of cheats being put off, nor of everyone else benefiting. Laughing your arze off at an idea that on one has ever suggested and that only exists in your head sounds like the symptoms of mental illness IMO.
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 07 Aug 10 12:10
Suppose they deducted 22.5% of your lifetime profit as a running total making deductions / rebates after each market was settled and then each Wednesday they calculated what you would've paid under the old system and, if they was less than you'd already paid, docked the difference from your account. Then

1) Everyone would pay more or less what they do now

2) The Ferengi wouldn't have a Wednesday payment

3) Almost all gamblers would have a Wednesday payment

4) Gamblers would be up in arms at having to subsidise the mainly worthless Ferengi.

5) The only people who wouldn't be whinging would be the Ferengi

Sharp minds my fkng @rse.
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 07 Aug 10 12:11
*if this was less than you'd already paid
By:
turtleshead
When: 07 Aug 10 12:57
The Calculator, you are just an imbecile.

"I put "quite legally" after "traders" because I knew if I didn't then some idiot would think I was accusing traders of cheating."

No, you deliberately lumped them in together to make out that someone who "trades" (wtf does that mean anyway - if I place more than one bet on a game at different points do I qualify?) is somehow acting unfairly like the other two categories.

"My point was that those three categories of users are going to be the main beneficiaries of removing the premium charge and adopting a flat 5% commission. That was all"

You just invented that off the top of your head without a shred of evidence to back it up, and then went into a rant yourself. The people who are affected are ones who have high strike rates. Which are all the other categories I mentioned, and many others. You are simply prejudiced against people who make money in a different way to you. And people who cheat should be banned, not just have a bit extra deducted. People who use faster pictures - wtf is wrong with that? Should no-one on here bet unless they have exactly the same means of viewing an event? Traders (again, what would you define as a trader?) If it wasn't for them providing the vast majority of the liquidity, betfair would effectively cease to exist. Why do you think that so many of the smaller markets have so little money in them now? Pretty obvious really, it's because very few who might have an edge and specialize in them have an incentive to put up prices to try and beat the 20%+ PC. If everyone on here only bet on Man United v Liverpool and Arsenal v Chelsea, how much do you think Betfair would make in PC? That's correct, the square root of feck all!

"You're right, that would be a stupid idea. Lucky I made no mention of cheats being put off, nor of everyone else benefiting. Laughing your arze off at an idea that on one has ever suggested and that only exists in your head sounds like the symptoms of mental illness IMO"

Looks like you are the one who needs to go back to school and have some reading lessons. It was a general point made at the end and nowhere did I say you, or anyone else on this particular thread had claimed this. But it's one I've seen repeated frequently on other PC threads, along with the "betfair need the money to attract more customers" cobblers. Hope this helps your understanding.
By:
Blessington
When: 07 Aug 10 14:01
If you hadn't got TRADERS you wouldn't have any IN-PLAY markets.Shocked

Who would put up prices in Soccer games for 90 minutes changing after every attack?Confused

Likewise Rugby, Golf, Tennis, American Football you name it.

Do some people really think £20 million has changed hands on a Tennis game or likewise a Champions League game.

Sorry guys thats the same money been retraded over and over again giving guys like me a chance to place a bet inbetween when we switch on to a game.

Likewise if you hadn't the on course bookmakers betting back into Betfair you would just wonder what liquilty would be in the Racing Markets.

So I don't know why anybody has problems with traders more than any other type of Betfair punter......Cheers
By:
Avocado
When: 07 Aug 10 14:20
What's so good about in play betting?
By:
ilMule
When: 07 Aug 10 14:35
I agree, Blessington, without traders noone shold place consistent bets in the markets at a good price. Markets would be dominated by big bets at unfair prices
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 07 Aug 10 15:05
Traders (again, what would you define as a trader?) If it wasn't for them providing the vast majority of the liquidity, betfair would effectively cease to exist.

LaughLaughLaugh
If that's true why are they all here paying up to five times more than they would on the purple? When the pc was first introduced betfair stated they weren't in the least worried about losing them. The traders organised a mass migration to the purple site and no one noticed a blind bit of difference and that included the purple site. The fact is they contribute zilch in real liquidity. All they do is act as needless middlemen between true layers and backers apart from in the ir markets where they can place endless ping-pong bets on trader favourable commissiuon terms and take advantage of built-in cheats. In their absence layers and backers are just matched directly at better odds. Your average traders no more supplies liquidity than a ticket tout generates extra seats at sell out events.


Why do you think that so many of the smaller markets have so little money in them now? Pretty obvious really, it's because very few who might have an edge and specialize in them have an incentive to put up prices to try and beat the 20%+ PC.

Why do they have to beat the 20% PC? It's 20% of long term profit. What's to beat FFS. If you don't show a profit, you don't pay it. If you do you get to keep around 80% of it.

I'm afraid you're the imbecile turtleshead. Why don't you give us all a laugh and try addressing my 12:10 post?
By:
Avocado
When: 07 Aug 10 15:17
Hi Feck. I think you're right, you seem to know what you're talking about. Do you mainly punt on horses or do you do football too?
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 07 Aug 10 15:37
Horses Avocado. The very odd football bet for an interest.
By:
Escapee
When: 07 Aug 10 16:04
But you don't bet in any meaningful ammounts ( i.e. enough to generate 100 betfair points ) do you Feck ?

otherwise you wouldn't have created a thread on here bemoaning the fact that you need a 100 betfair points to access the betfair historcal data would you ?

But congratulations on fooling Avaocado into thinking you know what you're talking about.


talk the talk but you can't walk the walk eh Feck ?


troll away
By:
Avocado
When: 07 Aug 10 16:07
I've only been betting on here regularly for a year but I think the PC is a fecking con.
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 07 Aug 10 16:29
Escapee, I'd be astonished if your lifetime profits were anywhere near my lifetime commission paid. The reason I didn't have 100 points was because I refused to bet until they based the pc on lifetime profit. Isn't it strange, there was me walking the walk while all you whinging cnuts were on here talking the talk and trading away.
By:
.Marksman.
When: 07 Aug 10 16:48
Feck, so you boycotted Betfair, at great cost to yourself, to get the Premium Charge rules changed for the good of the company.  At the same time, you stuck to your principals and never succumbed to trading yourself. And your one man campaign was a success and has benefitted the majority of Betfair's users. This is in addition to your succesful campaign to alert mug punters about the dangerous self matching, clock beating thing. And the market maker advantage.  Do you ever tire of doing these good deeds?  I have a feeling, despite being new here, that at some stage, I will become greedy and may not have such high moral standards.
By:
BobSievier
When: 07 Aug 10 17:06
No one seethes about traders like Feck....different class.
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 07 Aug 10 18:30
I stopped betting because I was going to be charged the pc because of result sequences. I felt this was unjust as I had already paid over 22.5% of my lifetime profits and, as I had already been subsidising traders and cheats for 8 years, I didn't see why I should pay more because their plan to get the aforementioned to pay their fair share was flawed. As for the rest, I think it's more about a dislike of delusional p1ss takers than philanthropy. Bob sums it up well.
By:
baconONtoast
When: 07 Aug 10 18:46
Purple place didn't attract any custom away because betfair essentially has a monopoly on in-play trading. Other exchanges can't grow because they have no liquidity. No liquidity will go there till they grow.

No way out of that until the market expands, which will only happen if the US legalises online gambling and some big player over there starts their own exchange.
By:
Avocado
When: 07 Aug 10 18:52
USA will be legalising it I think, so hopefully that might produce some more competitive prices. Yank mugs will start trying to back and lay Premiership matches and we can take their money.
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 07 Aug 10 18:54
It didn't get any custom because only the traders walked out and they need gamblers to feed off. The gamblers on here didn't even know they were gone though. I think the delusional walkers actually thought the purple place was going to roll out the red carpet for them and employ new operators to run whatever markets the walkers wanted. Truth was, who in the fk wants a division of middlemen ponces that think they are doing the exchange a big favour giving them 5% of whatever they manage to remove from the churn?
By:
.Marksman.
When: 07 Aug 10 19:02
Feck, it all makes sense to me now:  You suddenly got hit by the PC yourself and, in a state of total annoyance, you stopped betting (hoping that you could get the annual amount of markets that you had played in down to less than 250.  But, later, you had the idea that if the PC was charged over a lifetime on here, you might be OK. But you didn't know for sure, so you tried to look up your historical data on Betfair. But now you had less than 100 points and couldn't access it. But you found out, from Betfair, anyway, that you had paid over 20% during your lifetime, so it was in your interest to go ahead with your protest to get the charge shifted onto some other poor soul.  Why didn't you say all this in the first place?
By:
Rocket to the FACE
When: 07 Aug 10 19:12
The historical data relates to viewing markets once they have closed i.e lowest price match, time stamps etc
By:
.Marksman.
When: 07 Aug 10 19:33
Rocket to the FACE, thanks for that, I think my imagination must have been running away with itself there!
By:
baldloaf
When: 08 Aug 10 01:06
baldloaf Joined: 22 Apr 05
Replies: 66 06 Aug 10 18:30 
Catflappo, if someone wins 500 a week on betfair and pays premium charge (and is not a fast pic, insider, etc) and someone who wins 1000 a week doesn't pay the charge, is this logical and sensible?


catfloppo Joined: 16 Nov 06
Replies: 470 06 Aug 10 18:56 
Yes.  The person winning 1000 will still be paying at least twice as much commission.



Quite right. However, the person winning 1000 has taken a 1000 out the system, whereas the other person has only taken 500 out the system. Yet 500man is charged because betfair say that he is taking a disproportionate amount out of the system? Logical and sensible still aren't quite applicable. 500man pays a minimum of 105 to betfair and in this scenario is left with 420. 1000man pays a minimum of 200 (and possibly much more) to betfair and in this scenario is left with.....1000. The person taking the most out the system gets to keep it all.....Hang on, what about this 'disproportionate' excuse? Lets pretend that 500man wins 1000 one week. Why should he be left with less than 1000man on payday? Still not seeing any logic or sense in this....
Lets not forget that betfair will be taking a minimum of 300 in charges from all this, (someone check that?). Quite possibly, they will receive charges exceeding the 1500 that was won by both persons put together, depending on the sequence of bets and commission rate for each person. Suddenly we have a third entity here who is taking a disproportionate amount out the system. Are you still feeling sorry for betfair catflappo? Do you not feel frustrated that you can't have more than one bet in each market without being discriminated against?
Ive read back through your posts and i just can't work out why the great need to defend betfair over this. You say you have done well out of betfair. Betfair have done much much better out of you. They don't care about you. In fact, its people like you that enable big organisations and governments to run riot and make the rules up for themselves as they go along. I put it to you that you either have not done very well out of betfair (else you would be paying the charge), or that you lose only slightly less than you win, meaning that you pay enough commission to not qualify for the charge. The latter places you in a strange category of people who think they are justified in not paying the charge, even if they take more out the system overall. Think about it. Betfair want the money to be churned. Thus eventually taking 99.9% out of the system. People who arn't churning are lessening betfairs ability to reduce EVERY customer's bankrolls steadily. Betfair would like everyone to be an outright bettor, having at most, one bet on each market. This is the fastest way for the money in the system to find its way to betfair. I can see it now.... 'How dare these people back the other outcome when they think that play might turn. Whaaaaat!!! All green? Doesn't that mean less money for us? TAKE the money from them!'
Don't be a lemming churner catflappo, start working for yourself and not betfair.

If you don't want to address any points in this post, just answer two related questions.
Why did betfair implement the charge?
What do YOU think the charge is addressing?
Im not looking to make an enemy here, so careful how you process all this.
By:
Feck N. Eejit
When: 08 Aug 10 09:46
WALOFS baldloaf. The guy that won 1,000 might've paid 99,000 in normal commission for all you know. Why don't you address this post

Suppose they deducted 22.5% of your lifetime profit as a running total making deductions / rebates after each market was settled and then each Wednesday they calculated what you would've paid under the old system and, if that was less than you'd already paid, docked the difference from your account. Then

1) Everyone would pay more or less what they do now

2) The Ferengi wouldn't have a Wednesday payment

3) Almost all gamblers would have a Wednesday payment

4) Gamblers would be up in arms at having to subsidise the mainly worthless Ferengi.

5) The only people who wouldn't be whinging would be the Ferengi.


and tell us why the Wednesday people should have more money deducted.
By:
baldloaf
When: 08 Aug 10 15:41
It doesn't really matter how much commission has been paid by 1000man. That money has gone straight to betfair, not back into the pool. Don't kid yourself into thinking that you are putting more money back into the system. Your ideas that traders provide no liquidity is a joke. All gamblers do is turnover. A high percentage of this turnover goes to betfair. Gamblers are pushing liquidity into the hands of betfair, not back into the pool. Traders however, are not earning betfair as much due to a technicality in the system which means that if most of their bets are in the same market, they are treated differently.

By your post, i take it you mean that everyone who is in profit, will give or receive back charges such that overall, they will have paid 22.5% of lifetime profit (not including 5% on winning markets), until they return to a neutral situation, in which case they would have been rebated all the charges back?
This means everyone pays the same charges on their profit at the end of each week right? 500man pays 22.5% of 500, 1000man pays 22.5% of 1000. It sounds a lot better when you put it like that.

Im not sure about this bit....
and then each Wednesday they calculated what you would've paid under the old system and, if that was less than you'd already paid, docked the difference from your account.

Whatever profit has been made each week, will have already had 22.5% taken from it. Therefore no need for that statement. Everyone pays a flat rate tax of 22.5% on running profit no matter what their sequence of bets. So if you arn't in a lifetime profit, you wont have paid any charge right? So each week you have to beat the 5% commission rate and whatever profit you have left over, you pay 22.5% to betfair. Each losing market gets you 22.5% of that loss (as long as you are still in lifetime profit) put back into your account. Therefore the 22.5% running total is upheld.
This means that if you are constantly level, you simply pay 2.5% of turnover in commission. Under this system, traders, gamblers and whoever else pay the same amount on turnover, pay the same amount on profit and their sequence of winning losing trades/bets have no bearing on their overall charge.
- If you win and lose 100, you end up with -5. Just like the current system.
- If you win 5 (profit = 5), you end up with 3.7
- If you win 100 and only lose 90 (profit = 5), you end up with 3.9. Made up of 5% commission on winning markets and 22.5% charge on overall profit.
If you lose 90 and then win 100 (profit = 5) you end up with 3.9 again. The sequence does not matter.
If you win 20,000 and lose 18995 (still a 5 pound profit) you end up with 3.9.

Only problem i can see is that anyone who doesn't have a single losing market one week will pay very slightly more. Im sure a solution could be worked out for this though.
There must be flaws in this idea so if anyone wants to hit it with some data then let me know whats been overlooked. What do you think of this tweaked version feck?

The current system is akin to the situation where someone who consistently goes to work each week, for a small wage, pays a charge on their earnings. Whereas the bloke across the road, who squanders most of what he earns, but still ends up with a higher wage doesn't receive a charge.
By:
baldloaf
When: 08 Aug 10 15:52
feck wrote
In their absence layers and backers are just matched directly at better odds.

The absence of traders means that you are more likely to be matched at worse value. You seem an intelligent chap, what am I overlooking here?
By:
Ghetto Joe
When: 08 Aug 10 18:00
You're overlooking the fact it doesn't suit Fecks style of betting badloaf. Feck's no different to any other punter on here and just looking after his own interests which is fair enough. Traders fill gaps in the market which feck would prefer weren't there so his poor value odds would have a better chance of being taken, apparently even though they stick up offers for punters to take they aren't providing liquidity or taking risks
By:
VennOttery1981
When: 08 Aug 10 19:50
'Hopefully the othr betting exchange (DAQ) will become more of a rival'

traders/IR punters have to use this place, us pre race gamblers are fine over at daq, still can't help but think daq have not made the most of this PC, maybe they are happy plodding along? thats my only moan, before it was early door markets the but its like a ghost town on here now anyway looking at horse racing markets the night before compaired to yesteryear.
By:
I've got to...didcot, yately
When: 08 Aug 10 21:41
baldloaf Joined: 22 Apr 05
Replies: 69 08 Aug 10 15:52 
feck wrote
In their absence layers and backers are just matched directly at better odds.

The absence of traders means that you are more likely to be matched at worse value. You seem an intelligent chap, what am I overlooking here?


baldoaf. if you can pick holes in feck's sound argument please do so. you can't, so therefore you wont.
By:
turtleshead
When: 08 Aug 10 22:15
The reason why very few people bother to argue or respond to feck is quite simple, every single post he makes on the pc can be summed up by "not paying fair share moan city boy types whinge ferengi grumble/fast pictures complain/unfair cheats whine
bots/hoovers not fair/trapers/ponces gripe" and many others.

Probably has them stored on his computer so he doesn't forget any when a thread comes up.
By:
.Marksman.
When: 08 Aug 10 22:37
Anyway, I've put the tennis on to see why there is so much traded on this sport. I have never watched it before, but I did play it during PE lessons, about 40 years ago, so I can remember how the scoring goes.  It does seem the ideal sport to bet on in play, because, as someone has already said, nothing significant happens off screen.  I quite like it so far. There is always something happing, The score keeps moving on and there aren't any boring bits where nothing is happening.
By:
.Marksman.
When: 08 Aug 10 22:42
Svetlana Kuznetsova:  What a fine athletic woman she is.
By:
.Marksman.
When: 08 Aug 10 22:47
I meant to post these comments on the thread about the self matching clock that beats the loop hole on the tennis markets. I realize that they have no relevance to this discussion.
By:
baldloaf
When: 08 Aug 10 22:53
didcot, feeble contribution to the thread there mate. Although i liked the 'hole' reference.

If there are no traders, there will most likely be a big 'hole' in the market between the best back and lay prices, let alone a hole in fecks arguement. Why do you think the arguement is sound?

Without traders, one person gets great odds, another gets bad odds. With traders, both parties get as close to the perceived current price that the liquidity will allow.

You can be sure that a trader will want to offload some or all of his bet at a future point in a match/game. Thus providing more liquidity to the market at a future point in the match/game.

You may think your the big I am with a single bet for x amount in the market. Truth is, most traders will have bets bigger than yours many many times over in a market. What kind of liquidity does your ONE bet provide?

Gamblers generally take prices. No traders, less prices on offer for the gambler.

The arguement resembles swiss cheese. Rotten swiss cheese. Either add your own ideas or suggestions to the thread or keep out the way. All you have shown so far is that you hold no opinion of your own.

Feck, ive just thought, if the traders are putting the dampers on you getting big bets on without having to drip feed them in, why haven't you figured a way how to make money out of their behaviour? Your incessant drive to push traders out the way so you can get juicy prices kinda makes you look a little like a member of the ferengi race yourself don't you think?
By:
turtleshead
When: 09 Aug 10 00:00
Many people have nailed the essence of Feck's complaints, he wants his rubbish value high margin bets to be taken by mugs, and if it wasn't for those evil nasty mean rotten traders offering better prices (but still not liquidity - LaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaughLaugh) he'd be able to clean up!
Page 3 of 7  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com