We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
[i]Don't " straight owners" like to back/lay as well ?[/]
Since laying one's own horse is against the rules, any owner who does so, instantly ceases to be a straight owner. This much is obvious. I haven't studied the text of the Gambling Act, but I doubt that the GC are the final authority on the precise meaning of the new offence of **ing. That should be the courts. According to many on here, the GC is infested with former employees of the High St bookmakers. I agree with Muqbil that the idea of a punters representative organisation should be proceeded with if at all possible. Lobbying Parliament is the obvious way to go with these issues, esp if amendment to the Gambling Act is req'd, eg extension of the 6-month limit for voiding bets. |
|
By:
Oops. Only the first line of the above was meant to be italicised.
|
|
By:
I think that is one massive advantage the big3, the GC, the BHa and every other group within racing have is a collective voice, Moonlight. Ok maybe on most occasions the factions are at war but those who supply the levy (us) don't have a voice to be heard.
It was telling, during Paul Dixons atr 'feature' he talked extensively about how important owners were to the sport and it's ever so imprortant to keep them sweet etc. He talked about every component of those who make up racing and how they received a bad deal yet never mentioned the punters! |
|
By:
Magician. The Gambling Commmission only has the power to void within 6 months of the outcome of the bet being determined. However a bet made illegally is still void, so one could perhaps still go to court any time within 6 years?
|
|
By:
There's no shortage of things to bet on, why bother with horses at all?
|
|
By:
So it is not illegal or regarded as '**ing' for owners to lay their own horses on Betfair?
|
|
By:
It's a breach of BHA rule 247.
|
|
By:
Frog2
The gambling comission have confirmed in writing it is not '**ing' or a section 42 breech for a layer to lay his own horse on betfair. They have confirmed they will not use section 42 in such cases |
|
By:
Magician,
I admire your position and your persistence in this matter. I'm just not sure how discussion on this forum is going to help you. I also abhor corruption of any sort and would love to see the day that all sport was cleaned up. But, it is a simple fact that where money or power are concerned there will always be big players trying to dominate and small time **ers trying to rip us off. I also think that you do come across as someone with an air of importance and this acts against your aim to get full, free, honest discussion. That's just a bit of feeback which you can take or leave and it is not meant with mal intent. If you want to take this on, which I believe you should and hope you will, have you considered a private prosection under Section 2 or the Theft Act? Have you had any (good) advice? There are a number of disadantages and potential pitfalls to a private prosection which are mostly financial but the impact of a conviction would be considerable and would really raise the profile of your cause. The burden of proof in criminal law (beyond reasonable doubt) is higher than in civil cases, and without being fully conversant with the facts I cannot say whether you have a prima facie case but someone who knows this area will. The advantages to you of obtaining a criminal conviction are considerable. It would raise the profile of this matter considerably. Which is, if I read this correctly, the main reason for your persistence. More than that though, it would create a precedent and as such a big deterent to would be **ers. It would put a broom up the backside of the BHA and the GC and things would be different afterwards. If you succeeded you would put condiderable pressure on the industry, its organisation, its less honest members and you would be doing most people here a big favour for which they would thank you instead of regarding you with some suspicion. Its a tough nut and it needs a big punch to crack. So, given that you are a man who clearly has the motivation and has first hand exprience of these matters and and unresolved case, I urge you to get going. |
|
By:
I think that it might be necessary to prove that the owner conspired to stop the horse from winning to prove theft or fraud. I don't think the BHA had evidence of that IIRC.
It's not necessarily logically correct to equate **ing with theft. A plausible case can be made for the idea that sporting participants ** by placing bets forbidden by the rules of the sport. Obviously the GC don't want to bother. |
|
By:
The GC don't bother and think they can coast along like nodding dogs as they have absolutely no pressure applied from any groups. Currently they field enquiries and complaints from individuals. History has shown this to be a hopeless form of attack and well they know it.
If all those complaints were collectively mobilised, that is when change would happen, imho of course!. |
|
By:
Muqbil 08 Apr 06:08
It was telling, during Paul Dixons atr 'feature' he talked extensively about how important owners were to the sport and it's ever so imprortant to keep them sweet etc. He talked about every component of those who make up racing and how they received a bad deal yet never mentioned the punters! It's shocking that the punters always seem to be forgotten, the people who fund a significant part of the sport. In Greyhound racing an independant body has been formed called GOBATA. Greyhound Owners, Breeders, And Trainers Association. the poor old punter is forgotten again. :( Keep up the good work TM |
|
By:
top
|
|
By:
http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/business/8574637.stm
|
|
By:
strange - the other thread got deleted after being here for weeks
GC must be a little touchy about thier decision |
|
By:
The GC reminds me of the FSA a few years ago.
Imposing huger and unfair burdens on the small independent bookmakers to pay for a big bureacracy, but not really tackling the big issues. |
|
By:
Magic.. Perhaps you can indicate in the "Gambling Act" where it forbids a person betting or otherwise on anything owned or controlled by them. Thanks in advance.
|
|
By:
and more...from horse forum thread - "4 exchange layers warned off"
========Guardian Online Jockey suspected of giving information to punters who layed horses |
|
By:
Magis must be a slow reader!
|
|
By:
Yawn Magician, so so boring
|
|
By:
Well?
|
|
By:
Hazel
I will force the GC to ultimately void bets.... becasue I am morally and legally correct, new request and case is iminant. They can only protect the corrupt for so long - it is just dissapointing that they even try and protect them at all. |
|
By:
I'm still waiting!
|
|
By:
wonby10
there are two specific sections. 1) provided that bets (on the balance of proability) need to be fair - it is highly likely that the GC will ultimately decide that oweners laying is a contrivention of this (on many but not all occasions) The issue this has a 6 month time limits - and the BHA only attempt to conclude there cases in 12 months, and have been know to take 3-4 years. The BHA have decided they are not interested in trying to conclude cases within 6 months, so punters can get bets void. I dont know if this is deliberate to ensure cases dont go further, or it is just general slowness and incompitence. either way 12months to 4 years to conclude a case is a scandal 2) the section sections is to do with **ing (section 42) have you ever read the Act? I have several times |
|
By:
and whiel we are answering questions?
are you from Perth Western Australia, and what if any connection do you have to Alsistaire robertson and the WATC |
|
By:
:^0
:^0 :^0 :^0 :^0 :^0 :^0 :^0 :^0 :^0 :^0 :^0 |
|
By:
Magic... I can't see in your response where you indicate the "Act" forbids a person betting or otherwise on anything owned or controlled by them, and to save you reading it again you won't find it.
The point being that the rules of racing may forbid owners backing against their horses (something bookmakers have been doing on horses they own and having an interest in, in the normal course of their business, since Moses was a boy without any penalty) but the Gaming Act does not forbid it and to prove any **ing took place where someone has bet against a horse they own would be very difficult to prove, and that would need to be done beyond reasonable doubt not on the balance of probabilities the onus of proof of course being on any accuser. Your lack of understanding on the Law in quite a few matters and what the Gaming Commission is there to do is plain to see, and for anyone to say the Gambling Commission endourses corruption would be completly untrue not to mention slanderous. In my opinion Betfair should ban you from using the Forum all your accounts not just the one where you contravene the T & C's as previously and The Gaming Commission should issue you with a writ for Slander. In closing where I am from and what I know is totally none of your business, of course you could always apply to the Supreme Court in the correct jurisdiction to have Betfair reveal my details, but I don't like your chances. |
|
By:
Wonby10
your paragraph of FACT, is ridlled with erros.... The point being that the rules of racing may forbid owners backing against their horses (something bookmakers have been doing on horses they own and having an interest in, in the normal course of their business, since Moses was a boy without any penalty) but the Gaming Act does not forbid it and to prove any **ing took place where someone has bet against a horse they own would be very difficult to prove, and that would need to be done beyond reasonable doubt not on the balance of probabilities the onus of proof of course being on any accuser. 1) Rules of racing do NOT prohibit owners from backing the opposition. show me where? quote the rule? the BHA have confirmed to me the rules do NOT prohibit backing the opposition. 2) Bets can be void under the act without proof... there just need to be deemed 'unfair' but this lesser offence needs to be void in less than six months so two critical factual errors from you.... better go read the rules again, if you ever had read them at all |
|
By:
and I notice you dont answer my question.... about your connections?
so why are you stalking me on the Australia forum? |
|
By:
If someone called you an idiot, it would be hard to disagree.
|
|
By:
good answer when I ask you to prove something you claim...
Just cut and paste the BHA rule, that forbids an owner from backing his horses opposition? or just reference it.... I will cut and paste it |
|
By:
Yes and you cant prove the
|
|
By:
thanks wonby10
but can you post the rule that forbids owners from backing th oppositiong that you claimed was rule? I cant find it - and the BHA told me it does not exist? |
|
By:
Like I said, If someone called you an idiot it would be hard to disagree.
|
|
By:
Magician
Greetings and a sad outcome indeed The GC is the problem here - this govt appointed quango was introduced to see order in gambling when the big casino boom was about to happen - then some nutcase thought ' ah, and well get the betting operators to pay for it - then the boom didnt happen and we are left with a worthless dept that has shown its ignorance to the Gambling Act in relation to the matter you raise. Your only redress is to go thru the courts for fraud - Are you contemplating this? Even if you threaten to start this court process, the exchange sites would be very worried l |
|
By:
wonby10
you stalk me over two different chat rooms. you say my comments are incorrect and offer what you say are the FACTS instead. I point out that your FACTs are not correct and ask you to Justify your FACTS you repsonse is to say "if someone called you (me) and idiot I would no disagree" Clear argument winner - I am sorry to have wasted uor time thanks for educating me |
|
By:
wonby10
no answer to any of my questions. I hope you understand that going forward I will not waste my time answering yours. I will add you to the very long list of poeple I spent time justifying my position to, just to be criticised and not answered in return. you have lost of company, they come and go, good luck |
|
By:
You should get help!
|
|
By:
another constructive answer.
How about answering the direct questions? 1) Please tell me and the BHA ( because we both disagree with you) which BHA rule forbids an owner of one horse from backing any or all of the opposition. I guess not..... perhaps you might just call me an idiot again. LOL, and I need help. |
|
By:
You appear unable to read, your problem not mine.
|