We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
It seems to me that your beef here should be more with the BHA than the Gambling Commission. Having said that the Gambling Commission is worse than useless. Its one major achievement has been to cripple small bookmakers. Wow! Brilliant. Well done f*ckwits.
|
|
By:
Magician is such a boring, sad individual
Can't make it pay himself, so tries to stitch up others with this and inrunning etc... |
|
By:
Why is it necessarily morally wrong for an owner to lay his own horse.
If you have invested a lot of money in the purchase and training of a horse then it makes sound sense to " hedge " this investment on accasion, in case it doesn't run well. The more important question is did he simply invest in the training of the horse etc to set up a sting where he would lay the horse ( knowing from inside knowledge it was eihter not in form to run well or worse was going to be deliberately held back ) for a large overall profit at some future date?. |
|
By:
Isnt this man lands on moon with Horse racing?
Everyone knows its**or am i missing something? |
|
By:
Clarky9, I'd wager my entire wealth at 1.01 that The Magician has made a lot from gambling than you have. You only make yourself look silly with your stupid comments.
|
|
By:
*a lot more
|
|
By:
FINE AS FROG HAIR 06 Apr 22:45
Why is it necessarily morally wrong for an owner to lay his own horse. If you have invested a lot of money in the purchase and training of a horse then it makes sound sense to " hedge " this investment on accasion, in case it doesn't run well. I guess you'd need to know how much was to be gained by the owner if his horse won, and therefore how much the hedge was in case it lost. If the lay was far greater than the potential gain, it would look rather suspect. |
|
By:
wtf does it take a year to complete a case?
|
|
By:
It's a victory for us horse owners and rightly so. If we didn't choose to run our horses at these shiity midweek meetings for ever worsening prize money and ever increasing costs you'd have nothing to do with your sad pathetic lives.
|
|
By:
the hills brthers
|
|
By:
keep on with trying to form a punters group magic man, when the bookies got through a % on profit instead of turnover towards the levy you know the decks stacked B-)
|
|
By:
In a perfect world insider trading or betting would not happen.
However 99% of traders or bettors, would, if the chance presented itself, take advantage of any insider knowledge. |
|
By:
(posted on other thread but this one will stay active longer)
Surely it is time for there to be an organised voice of the punters? At the very least we should start complaining to our MP's (once known!) about the totally useless drinking club known as the Gambinling commission? |
|
By:
Absolutely agree Muq.
They, like IBAS, are indefensible in their position which is constantly biased towards the laughably named "big 3". |
|
By:
Wow ! Bertrand Russell quoted on this forum. Things are looking up.Anyway nothing wrong with owners laying/backing or organising the occasional coup etc.They keep the show on the road.No I'm not an owner.
|
|
By:
Trevh 07 Apr 00:45
I guess you'd need to know how much was to be gained by the owner if his horse won, and therefore how much the hedge was in case it lost. If the lay was far greater than the potential gain, it would look rather suspect. I copied this from the RP website, it's from Dec 09: "OWNER Leighton Brookes has been found guilty of laying horses under his ownership by a British Horseracing Authority disciplinary panel. The panel found Brookes, whose horses were in trainingwith David Evans, in breach of rule 247, which imposes a prohibition on an owner laying their horse to lose, and disqualified him for a period of three years. Having considered the evidence, the panel found Brookes, who did not attend the hearing on Thursday, in breach of the rule in that he laid to lose Man Of Gwent, whom he owned, on three separate occasions. Brookes risked a liability of £3,000 to win £200 on the horse on August 23, 2008, risked £1,441 to win £149 on September 10, 2008 and risked £990 to win £55 on February 4, 2009. The owner also risked £2,562 to win £205 on Trimlestown on February 23, 2009. The panel did not accept Brookes's explanation that he shared his Betfair account with a friend and it was the friend who had placed the lay bets on Man Of Gwent and Trimlestown without his knowledge. Brookes was also found in breach of rule 241(i) in that he had failed to provide any reason for refusing to produce his telephone records. The disqualification started on Friday, December 4 and will end on December 3, 2012." |
|
By:
Tough imposition for such a trivial gain.
|
|
By:
racingguru 07 Apr 04:25
Is this the same Magician that so "honestly" with his inside info lay Carruthers off the board when he had info that it wasn't going to run in the Hennessy. Karma ........ If that's true this is a poor show indeed |
|
By:
artie 07 Apr 10:31
Wow ! Bertrand Russell quoted on this forum. Things are looking up.Anyway nothing wrong with owners laying/backing or organising the occasional coup etc.They keep the show on the road.No I'm not an owner. NO, **ing owners do NOT keep the show on the road. **ing owners are slowly destroying the game. I have come to the conclusion that you simply post contrary views for the sake of it. You think if all the **s were banned horses racing would fall to pieces? What nonesense. |
|
By:
Guess they just pass the info on now for a kickback and there is no direct link.
For 200 quid just shows you how greedy these feckers are and using his own account how stupid. |
|
By:
starfish and coffee, I remember the post refered to by the poster above. The Magician was asking if the horse was likely to run in the big race. He had noticed it had been layed at much bigger odds than would have been expected, or he might have layed as a feeler to see if there were any bites which there were not. This followed his posts stating the horse had been heavily laid (by others) in it's preceding race, and did anyone know if it was likely to be suspect (all these threads will be visible on gubbed).
|
|
By:
thanks for the clarification muqbil
|
|
By:
So Muqbil, is it only "**ing owners" that might wish to lay a horse on here.Don't " straight owners" like to back/lay as well ?
|
|
By:
Thats what i think, why shd the honest owners be descriminated against because of the cheets. Its trainers and jockeys that influence races not owners.
|
|
By:
wow, them is some life changing sums of money that '**ing' owner was making on laying his horse here......ffs, get a high horse agenda about something worth while magician
|
|
By:
You think owners should be free to lay their horses whenever it pleases them, heynoodles?
|
|
By:
The question is not the size of the **ing owner's liabilities in absolute terms but in relation to the races' prize money.
When the sums are so out of whack as they are on British racing, it presents an incentive to owners. Somewhere like Hong Kong is obviously a healthier gambling environment. |
|
By:
I've had some really bad experiences with Horse Racing ....I'm not saying you can't make it work ....but I wouldn't touch it now with a barge pole !
A close friend of mine layed two consecutive 30-1 outsiders at £100 a pop which won ! Almost £6k down ....that cured him ! |
|
By:
I think so muqbil. Id rather see the authorities looking into the reasons for a poor run or an improved run than stop owners using their opinion. If you own a horse imo you know the form of that horse better than almost everyone else because you follow it so closely. Then youre told you cant lay it (legitimately).
For example, inside information "it missed a gallop". This shd be in the public domain for everyone. Like I say I think its trainers and jockeys influencing races not owners. |
|
By:
I think the real question here is the intention behind the original post.
The poster clearly has an axe to grind. We know this from the history of the case and it is evident in the title. The GC clearly do not endourse (sic) 'corruption'. At worse, the GC could be accused of ineptitude or lack of courage, but endorse corruption they do not. So, what of the intention? Its seems to me that this could be one of two things: 1. To highlight in public that a private matter of considerable importance to the poster, has been well and truly scuppered. 2. A belief that publicising the fact in a public forum will attract support for the poster thus softening the impact, justifying the original complaint etc. Number 1 clearly achieved. Number 2 - Not (so far) So maybe the poster is now thinking that it might have been best to keep matters closer to his chest, most unlikely as that might seem to some, especially those that believe the poster is rather full of his own importance. Not that I am one of those people. |
|
By:
insider dealing is rightly illegal. Apologists for horse racing "insiders" just make their sport look even dirtier.
Poster above has it right, dont touch it with a barge pole |
|
By:
If owners were allowed to lay their own horses it would lead to total meltdown.
Scenario; Owners horses is trading 1.10 in the win market. Tells trainer to give it two good gallops and a dozen buckets of water before the race then drive round the m25 for nine hours before arriving at Kempton for the race. Owner lays his horse to win 100k for only a 10k risk that is in fact no risk. No questions asked as the owner has broken no rules. How would that be a fair rule? |
|
By:
Like I say I think its trainers and jockeys influencing races not owners.
Bizarre nonsense. The jockey is working for the owner and is paid by him. Owners often speak to the jockey in the parade ring before the race. Large owners often have their own jockey under contract whom they use overriding any trainer preference. McManus and Sheikh Hamdan for example. Large owners often have multiple trainers and employ a racing manager to place their horses for them. Obviously with small owners the balance of power is often reversed. Few trainers will try to stop the owner speaking to the jockey he has just paid for, however. |
|
By:
looking into the reasons for a poor run or an improved run
Race 1: Owner: "Finish last". Jockey: "OK guv'nor". Race 2: Owner: "Finish last". Jockey: "OK guv'nor". Race 3: Owner: "Finish last". Jockey: "OK guv'nor". A handicap mark has been obtained. Race 4: Owner: "Win". Jockey: "OK guv'nor". Journalists (chorus) "A wonderful touch has been landed by connections! Bravo!" Honest owners (chorus): "This is a mugs game. We're getting out." |
|
By:
In both the scenarios mentioned by moonlight and muqbil dishonest trainers/jockeys were required, imo. If you can explain how an owner influences a race on his own i'll concede the point.
|
|
By:
...and if a jockey deliberately finishes last that is when the authorities shd step in
|
|
By:
racingguru 07 Apr 04:25 Is this the same Magician that so "honestly" with his inside info lay Carruthers off the board when he had info that it wasn't going to run in the Hennessy. Karma ........ care to try and justify this potentially liablous remark - which you have made on two threads? |
|
By:
tobermory 07 Apr 01:07 wtf does it take a year to complete a case? excellent question? especially when the legislations only allows 6 months to void unfair bets. you can void '**ing' bets beyound the 6 month limit - but the case of **ing is presumably more difficult to prove that 'unfair' sufice to say the GC have confirmed in writing an owner laying his own horse is NOT **ing |
|
By:
Beetle
Thanks for the questions about my motivation. It is good to see people with clear questions to me about my interest past and intent, rather than people saying " corruption is great" which I hope oir assume they do not really believe. As to my intentions - I notice you have been here since 2003, But you dont post often... I remember you recent thread baout your concerns that Peple where beating the Clock in soccer betting.... If you have read many of my past threads you weill also realsie that the fairness of IR has been perhaps my biggest issue of the last 5 years. I wrote an 11 page submission to the GC on this very issue. As to my motivation..... I think racing should be fair and transparent ( strangle two of the ideals of the GC) I think when owners lay thier own horses those bets should be void because a) it is in breach of BHA rules ( that they agree to) - some would call rule breaking **ing, and b) it is more than likely they have non-transparent information about that horses chances. I have bene trying to get such unfair/corrupt or at least unpalatable bets cancelled for 5 years. I have been clokced at almost every turn by Betfair, and the BHA. more recently Betfair have become less of a barrier and more of an alie on these issues. but I thought the GC - would be an alie also. but they have been untransparent, evasive and finally dismissive, and have most disturbingly confirmed in writting it is NOT a breech of section 42 of the Gambling Act for an owner to knowlignly may his own horse ... so my motivations following this GC confirmation 1) let everyone know it is not a breech 2) promote discussion on it 3) highlight the difficultyl of voiding under the lesser charge of 'fairness' given the BHA only hope to conlcude nequiries withing 1 year - when the legislations has a 6 month limit |