|
By:
...well...I can see both sides.....
Maradonna was a great...no doubt....and the mental strength he had to show to lead the sides he was part of to wins and trophies with all the expectation he had to carry was amazing...as well as do that and keep up his own form.....and as you say he didn't have Iniesta..Xavi...etc.. Messi is also a great...no doubt...and has also had to show mental strength while being the talisman for a team... ..but for me...what trumps winning or losing matches and trophies is redefining the limits of how a particular sport can be played in a positive way... (I guess the other example would be Puskas and Hungary in the 1950's especially when they put us to the sword) ...and as I stated for me he was crucial in raising it to an art form when Barcelona were at their height.... ..and I cherish that over winning or losing or even just taking part any day. |
|
By:
Messi for me over Maradonna. the pass for Neymar the reason why, not mentioned on this thread but fantastic vision and weight of pass.
He slotted 3 and made the first,too. Brilliant ! |
|
By:
Without messi that barca team would struggle to get in champs league imo, certainly wudnt b challanging for the league, the lad is a fu cking magician, set up the first, played neymar twice 1 he should have burried and the other won a pen and scored a hatrick,
|
|
By:
hes teh greatest club player ever by a country mile...............if he could score 5 or 6 goals and guide argie to victory his GOAT status is sealed
|
|
By:
the greatest player ever.
|
|
By:
There is one reason why neither Maradona or Messi can be considered the best - Pele
|
|
By:
there is no player in history who would do what messi has been doing for past 5 years at barca...................no way
|
|
By:
consistency since he stepped onto the nou camp pitch
|
|
By:
quite stageering indeed, his form did drop a bit after the injury but hes only humn, altho ronaldo did deserve bal on dor last year
|
|
By:
well done mess good thinkig
funny how mugs on telly was saying 4 days ago how crissy is 2 streets ahead of anyone including messi ,nothing like footy experts pundits![]() |
|
By:
|
|
By:
please do not mention the word robinho in same breath as others.............he is the epitome of the modern day overrated parasite.............making a fortune while doing nothing............he was a disgrace at man city and at AC milan he is a joke.
|
|
By:
yes he is drastic example of usual brazilian mentality of superstar, he was blessed by pele as his successor when young had promising spells in real but mainly at the beginning and the pattern copied in following clubs, great at start then reality hit him and probably had no desire to work hard,epitaph of what i said about brazil mega talents.atm hes barely 30 mind you,so should be at peak but typical mentality didnt let him cope with some normal for most sportsmen setbacks. fine example. also included neymar he is sort of beginning his european tour but u can see already he will need to work hard and maintain it to became as successful as his brazil reputation,hopefully he will be exemption of usual case and reality will only make him better |
|
By:
maybe i went to harsh on ronaldo da lima but in later stages of his career which included some major injuries tbf, got feeling he dedicated himself much more to perform on national team level than in clubs,he was still very effective
but played limited number of matches and could easily grab best all time player nomination with bit of more dedication and effort imo |
|
By:
and overweight and much slower while still 30
|
|
By:
How many people here have actually seen Pele play? I doubt back in the day, t he 50's, 60's and 70's that UK TV showed any Santos games, the only club he played for, so t he the only time you would have seen him would have been at the World Cups? I don't know how a player can be called the GOAT based on about 20 matches,
Maradona, before my time as well but I remember Linekar saying once he saw him pre match kicking the ball into the air as high as he possibly could and never moved more that 5 yards from the spot, it came back down and he kicked it straight back up - 20 times, try doing that more than twice over the park, you wont be able to. Bot Messi and Maradona have the advantage over Ronaldo because of their diminutive stature, having a low centre of gravity enables you to stay more balanced when dribbling at speed, and dribbling at speed through a defence and scoring at the end is what blows people away, whereas Ronaldo appears more of flat track bully, but anyone that watches him knows he gives much more than that. 'Ibra' could only dream to be of that class. |
|
By:
mes, r u going to tell us who is the best?
|
|
By:
I regard Pele as the best admittedly from limited knowledge and viewings and observations from those who played with and against him but my opinion is somewhat reinforced by someone who considers Wilshere is World Class - he is about as far away from being a footballer in terms of comparable ability to Pele as it is possible to be
|
|
By:
Pele was pretty good in escape to victory...better than john wark ans russell osman anyway.
|
|
By:
What a game of football. I'm watching it again on Sky right now.
Barca for the CL now! ![]() |
|
By:
Barca r to dodgy at the back to win chmps lge
|
|
By:
Bhoys
In my lifetime, Henry Bergkamp Ronaldinho Messi Scholes Raul Both Ronaldo's Zola Gerrard Pires Figo Vieria And Hagi deserves a mention, looked a class apart every time I saw him play, but not often enough, Wilshere will be in this bracket by the time his career is finished. |
|
By:
The Boys "Barca r to dodgy at the back to win chmps lge"
Then they'll just have to score more goals than the opposition ![]() I like the new Barca. This new style of play is far better than Gladiola's choking the opposition in their own box. Which unfortunately I am starting to see at Bayern now. Can't stand that style of football. |
|
By:
Quite a list mes, i actually like that style of play, it amazing how they keep the ball, and its effective tho i must say bayern were better last year imo
|
|
By:
Exactly highlander, glad you recognise what boring football the myth 'Pep' gets his teams to play. Biggest myth in football.
|
|
By:
I'm not a fan of the Pep footballing style at all. He does have nice suits though.
Plays the game in the opposition's box. It's percentage football really. If you play a large chunk of the game in your opponents box, with the football pinging around in there like a giant game of pinball, the chances of it ending up in the net are pretty high. Either that or it goes out for a corner or a goal kick. It's quite clever but is begging to be Catenaccio'd. Like Chelsea did for example. Not my idea of the beautiful game that's for sure. |
|
By:
maradonnas greatness is based on two games.....................q final v england and semi v belgium..............wonderland perfromances...........he had a very good career at napoli also, but nowhere near anything messi has done at barcelona...............its not even close
|
|
By:
Messi is the best player ive ever witnessed and ronaldhino is 2nd but ive never seen maradona or pele
|
|
By:
Didn't Maradonna win the league title twice with a small club(at the time) in Napoli when AC milan were ruling the roost at home and Europe ?
|
|
By:
Mesmerised,
For goodness sake, wake up! Apart from you considering Wilshere as England's best, both now and in the future, you list a group of best ever players that contains a stack of Arsenal players. Let's try and be realistic and unbiased here. |
|
By:
In terms of pure natural talent, Wilshere IS England best current player when fully fit and in form, unfortunately he has been hampered by a succession of injuries which has naturally held him back, you will see what I mean when he gets comes back and stays free from these niggles and injuries for any sustained period of time. He is pure class.
Also, where did I "best ever" you must of missed the part where I actually said "in my lifetime" I am in my twenties hence the the players listed being from the last 15 years. And they are the best I have seen, name me better players than those 13 in the last 15 years or so? It's subjective anyway, obviously I've seen more of Arsenal players than any other player from any other club so I am a better judge of them, but most would not have the likes of Henry or Bergkamp or Pires out of there top 20 in recent years, if they do they are clueless, those three were world beaters in their day. |
|
By:
Well,
I stand partly corrected on the best ever front. You are a relatively young guy but I thought you nay have found your way to place a certain Uruguayan striker somewhere in your team. Your obsession with Wilshere is ill judged. |
|
By:
Liverpool fan are with Meadow
![]() I had Gerrard in there, and every player bar 3 long term established players listed has now retired, that's the best way too judge them in a any best of category, Suarez is on his way into everybody's list but he has too do it in the Champions League before he is ranked alongside these greats. |
|
By:
I am not a Liverpool fan. I am not biased either.
|
|
By:
I don,t know why people are still looking to downplay Messi ffs his level of consistency at the highest level is unbelievable,his 2 passes to Iniesta/Neymar were terrific especially the one to Neymar.
|
|
By:
Your obsession with Wilshere is ill judged.
Not an obsession, everybody is quick to put him down because they don't like his character, and if he got lippy to me outside of a club I wouldn't think twice about putting him in his place, but as a player - top drawer. |
|
By:
Mesmerised,
Top class players are judged on the highest stage. As far as Wilshere is concerned, his best chance in the forseeable future is in the World Cup. Roy has to decide on his final squad. He will almost certainly take players that are presumably fully fit, consistent and will run all day,working together as a team until they drop. Wilshere does not come into this category. He may make the squad, but the fact that you are singing his praises as a great on a World level is complete nonsense. |
|
By:
Roy has to decide on his final squad. He will almost certainly take players that are presumably
-fully fit, -consistent -will run all day, -working together as a team until they drop. -Wilshere does not come into this category. He picked Ashley Cole as a started against Denmark and he's hardly had a kick all season, Roy will pick his favourites, the way all England managers do. Wilshere will be back 2nd week of April, 2 whole months before the first World Cup game, and will be fresher than any other player in the squad bar Cole, but he doesn't have youth on his side, I doubt any England player will be running all day in the Amazon heat and he always plays players in rather than try and be greedy. |
|
By:
messi scored 73 goals in one season...............................73 guys.............maradonna scored 115 in his 8 years at napoli.
|
|
By:
Brain dead jockeys spot on here. Messi is simply World class.
For someone to think that Wilshere can compete against players of the level of Messi is completely bizarre. |