Forums
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 188 comments are related to the topic:
Emily Maitlis

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 5 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 188
By:
1st time poster
When: 29 May 20 13:43
was reading this  morning as some people in the country didn't agree with her ,she broke the rules

so i,m assuming those on the right guido fawkes nut jobs would want maitlis to be impartial about a terrorist attack if some people in the country agreed with it,
its known as the law of unintended  consequence,s,or law of the sod
By:
nineteen points
When: 29 May 20 14:02
i didnt go anywhere. i have a life.also have an opinion,a sense of right and wrong and enough life experience to know when someone is telling me lies and taking the p1ss out of me. its nothing to do with hating tories.i just hate liars.
By:
Cider
When: 29 May 20 15:20

May 29, 2020 -- 1:43PM, 1st time poster wrote:


was reading this  morning as some people in the country didn't agree with her ,she broke the rulesso i,m assuming those on the right guido fawkes nut jobs would want maitlis to be impartial about a terrorist attack if some people in the country agreed with it,its known as the law of unintended  consequence,s,or law of the sod


That's right, she was found guilty of breaking the rules. Almost as delicious as election night last December Laugh

By:
Baphornet
When: 29 May 20 15:25
i vaguely remember seeing  Maitlis's legs buckle; when the opinion poll surfaced
By:
nineteen points
When: 29 May 20 17:17
so you condone liars by your lack of response to my question?
By:
BARROWBOY
When: 29 May 20 19:46
Maitless still in denial about brexit,hates Cummings & no one at the bbc had the ***** to reign her in.
By:
nineteen points
When: 29 May 20 20:32
thats fair enough its your opinion.are people not allowed to say they think the whole affair stinks and they have all lied and took the british public for fools.
By:
BARROWBOY
When: 29 May 20 20:43
There are plenty of other news feeds that have got an axe to grind .me ,I’d prefer the bbc just to report the news rather than to try to influence public opinion.
By:
1st time poster
When: 29 May 20 20:45
well watch the news at 10,clus in the name
By:
BARROWBOY
When: 29 May 20 20:48
It’s called balance,a premise you probably don’t understand.
By:
1st time poster
When: 29 May 20 20:50
heard the sky presenter this afternoon
1st interview the lady sage behavouril scientist who,s interviewed on tv nearly everyday, pointing out before she spoke she was a longstanding labour supporter
then interviewed a bloke about schools returning and pointed out he worked for a left wing thinking think tank

fair enough but never heard them introduce them like that before

and they don't introduce grimes,harwood,moffatt etc as right wing nut jobs LaughLaugh
By:
nineteen points
When: 29 May 20 21:44
good point.
By:
1st time poster
When: 29 May 20 21:52
just read torygraph online and besides fanboy tom banging on about doris putting the fear of god in EU by keeping cummings,the rest could be on front paywall or guardian or mirror
By:
Cider
When: 30 May 20 07:10

May 29, 2020 -- 8:50PM, 1st time poster wrote:


heard the sky presenter this afternoon1st interview the lady sage behavouril scientist who,s interviewed on tv nearly everyday, pointing out before she spoke she was a longstanding labour supporterthen interviewed a bloke about schools returning and pointed out he worked for a left wing thinking think tankfair enough but never heard them introduce them like that beforeand they don't introduce grimes,harwood,moffatt etc as right wing nut jobs


It's about time left wing elitists and labour activists masquerading as neutral experts are identified.

By:
1st time poster
When: 30 May 20 10:00
agreed as long as the knucklegraggers are pointed out as well
By:
Cider
When: 30 May 20 11:13
The broadcast media doesn't surreptitiously use activists in the guise of neutral contributors that have right leanings though does it. Only left wing elitists get those gigs.
By:
Baphornet
When: 30 May 20 11:20
Carol Malone is feisty though
By:
Cider
When: 30 May 20 11:30
On BBC’s flagship documentary programme, Panorama, recently, one of the main interviewees was Professor John Ashton. His left-wing political affiliations were not mentioned. This is curious because the programme was broadcast on 27 April. Two weeks before, Guido Fawkes, on Twitter, ran a clip from Sky News in which the presenter introduced Ashton as “the former president of the faculty of public health, Professor John Ashton; we should also say he’s been a member of the Labour Party at various points.” Ashton shouted back: “Where did that stuff come from about the Labour Party? I am not a member of the Labour Party… I have not been in the Labour Party for over a year… Please don’t politicise this.”

As Guido Fawkes pointed out on 13 March, when Professor Ashton appeared on BBC 1’s Question Time, where he vigorously attacked the government’s Covid policy, he had been introduced as a “former regional director of Public Health England for the North West.” What viewers were not told was that two years ago he described himself as a “broad left, radical, non trot, baby boomer, green, gender inclusive, feminist labour Party member for 53 years.” Panorama had somehow missed all this or chose to ignore it.

Another regular media pundit is Professor Susan Michie. When she appeared on Radio 4’s Broadcasting House on Sunday, 24 May, she was introduced as a member of a sub-group of SAGE, and went on to attack Cummings. When the Conservative MP, Sir Peter Bottomley was introduced, he pointed out that Professor Michie “has been a member of a far left party for decades [The British Communist Party], donated more to the Labour Party under Corbyn than I’ve given to the Tory party in forty years, was the wife of a former Labour Party special adviser and mother of Labour’s head of complaints. That might have been better than just saying she’s a member of SAGE.” The presenter, Paddy O’Connell, criticised Bottomley for his “ad hominem attack”, rather than acknowledging his and the programme’s shocking omissions.

All three BBC programmes misled the viewers/listeners by presenting a speaker with well-known left-wing, anti-government affiliations as simply a medical scientist.

How do we do journalism?
When Andrew Marr interviewed Pippa Crerar, Political editor of the Mirror, on Sunday 24 May he asked her how she broke the Cummings story that weekend. She said, “We have just done old-fashioned traditional journalism.” No follow-up question from Marr. Nothing like, “Come off it! You just managed to track down the two people in the whole of Durham who happened to have allegedly spotted Cummings? Are you sure they didn’t contact the two main left-wing newspapers in the country and hand you the story?” Even if this wasn’t the case, surely the question was worth asking. Not on the BBC.

Balance on the BBC
Much of Radio 4’s Today programme on 25 May was taken up with the Cummings story. I only heard one defender of Cummings, the Education Secretary. Opposed to him were a Labour shadow minister and numerous other critics of Cummings.

In addition, the news bulletins during the programme quoted various bishops who had criticised Cummings. Apparently, not a single bishop supported Cummings.

Who are these people?
On Tuesday 26 May The World at One quoted a Conservative MP, Harriett Baldwin, who had criticised Cummings and therefore, implicitly, Boris Johnson. The BBC forgot to mention that Johnson had fired Baldwin and that she had then supported Jeremy Hunt in the leadership campaign. On the same day, James Vincent, BBC Yorkshire’s Political Editor, quoted a Tory MP who had criticised Cummings and Johnson, but omitted to mention that the MP was anti-Brexit. Might this have coloured his view of them?

Running orders
On Tuesday’s World at One the BBC led with the Cummings story. There were no big new revelations. A Scottish Tory MP I had never heard of had resigned as a Junior Minister and a few Tory MPs I had never heard of had criticised Cummings and the PM. That was it. No new revelations. In the meantime, mortality figures had fallen dramatically, small shops were to be opened, US deaths were due to pass 100,000 that day. None of these stories were considered as important as this obscure Scottish Tory.

We always assume media bias is obvious. Sometimes it isn’t. It often takes subtle forms. What’s missed out as much as what’s said. The follow-up question that’s never asked. How guests are introduced. But there are also spectacular examples of clear bias like the preachy introduction to last night’s Newsnight by Emily Maitlis, which has created a firestorm on social media. The journalist Stephen Pollard, no fan of Cummings, tweeted, “there can be a place for editorialising on TV, but not in the intro to a flagship BBC analysis programme.” The Daily Mail, also no supporter of Cummings, wrote, “BBC is blasted for ‘bare-faced bias’ after Emily Maitlis states as fact that Dominic Cummings ‘broke the rules’.”

The programmes I have mentioned are not trivial. These are the best-known news programmes on the BBC. They are all guilty of bias on some of the biggest British news stories in years.
By:
1st time poster
When: 30 May 20 11:38
words reached me that Emily enjoyed ian hislop on HIGNFY last night, Laugh,wwith about 20  times more viewer,s  than newsnight,trending on twitter,been  shown all around the  world on social media. LaughLaughLaugh
By:
Cider
When: 30 May 20 11:42
You carry on thinking twatter is representative if it makes you feel better Laugh

It only serves to make the reverses twatter experiences all the more satisfying.
By:
Cider
When: 30 May 20 11:47

May 30, 2020 -- 11:20AM, Baphornet wrote:


Carol Malone is feisty though


She has a nice kitchen Grin

By:
1st time poster
When: 30 May 20 11:50
trump credit,s it with getting him elected, I suppose you like trump would censor the bits you don't like
By:
Cider
When: 30 May 20 11:55
I favour free speech, however not on the BBC, paid for by the tx tax.
By:
Baphornet
When: 30 May 20 11:55
ironic post 1st TP
By:
moonaxed
When: 30 May 20 12:16
Cider...Carole Malones kitchen is indeed nice,at least 30 grands worth without the labour, i would like a bit of 6/4 she rarely cooks though. Peace.
By:
1st time poster
When: 30 May 20 13:10
I,d like 6 to 4,she rarely doesn't eat, Wink
By:
moonaxed
When: 30 May 20 13:36
I d take 1/16 on that.Free money that is
By:
differentdrum
When: 02 Jun 20 10:36
How is it that Victoria Derbyshire can pass personal opinion on the George Floyd situation?

I look forward to the reprimand.
By:
nineteen points
When: 04 Jun 20 10:53
go on emily.well done girl.free speech is alive and well as long as some still have heart.unlike the fridge finder general.
Page 5 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com