Forums
Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
STUDYFORM
20 Nov 13 11:23
Joined:
Date Joined: 26 Jan 05
| Topic/replies: 20,559 | Blogger: STUDYFORM's blog
Re-Revised and now with added ‘previously missed’ names

There are so many threads on the forum on the subject of who's good or funny, and who isn't, that I've had a think about it and put most of them in order.
The names are NOT in any order within their scoring group, this list isn’t that precise. 

Of course it's MY order, and NO-ONE will agree with it, but it should make interesting enough reading.

I think most of the top funny people are in it, dead and alive. I can think of others, but this took long enough. I've given them all a rating from 1/10 up to 10/10 , the higher scores being much harder to attain, and there's a short explanation or memory jogger attached to each name. They could have been scored further, for example 1/10 effectively covers from 1/100 to about 14/100 and so on. Please allow for this.
Also the ratings try to take into consideration how they were 'in their time'.
I am expecting a few 'Grrrr' responses. Although there's really no need for any. No two people would come up with anything like the same order for this many names.

********************** THIS LOT ARE 1/10 ********************************
Dominic Holland  Gets on 50/100 greatest type shows to opine. How? Hugely unfunny.
Justin Lee-Collins Simply dreadful.
Roy Walker crap comic, even worse quiz show shouter, or should that be, host.
Cheech and Chong Lots of smoking drugs.... That's it!
Gregor Fisher can't understand a word he says
Patrick Kielty Very sad about his dad, but it didn't make him as funny as he thinks it did.
Keith Harris and Orville Fancy being upstaged by your own puppet.
Cannon and Ball If only those braces had been tighter.
Dom Joly Pranks on the unsuspecting, just annoying. Not funny.
Ricky Grover being a big, fat and aggressive ex-boxer do not a funny man make.
the Mighty Boosh BBC3. Says it all. Couldn't even smile at these people
Mike and Bernie Winters. EeeeeeeEEEEEEEeeeeeee. And a dog. Does anyone remember ANYTHING else they ever said or did? doubtful
Tony Slattery Smug, and the poorest member of whose line is it anyway.
Little and Large No explanation needed
David Baddiel Lucky man, fairly talentless, but had 2 good partners
Roland Rivron I've met him, he's the same off stage/screen as on it. Thinks holding a glass of wine makes him amusing.
Stewart Lee Must be one of the most over-rated comedians performing today.
Ellen DeGeneres One of a host of proud lesbian comics(?)
Sue Perkins See E DeGeneres
Rhona Cameron See E. DeGeneres
Helen Lederer Only famous because she looks a bit weird.
Stephen K Amos He's black and like many black comedians, he mentions it a lot.
Shappi Korshandi She’s from Iran, you know
Brendan O’Carroll Mrs Brown – A poor, less funny copy of the dated Mother Riley, Unfathomable apparent popularity

Being from Liverpool does NOT mean you're automatically a comedian, quite the opposite in my experience
Tom O'Connor From Liverpool. He refused to tell 'blue' jokes, a mistake
Stan Boardman I saw him once. I asked for my money back. From Liverpool
Jimmy Tarbuck From Liverpool. Is Golf so hilarious? I think not.
Arthur Askey I thang Yew. From Liverpool, not even funny in his day.
****************************************************
************************ THIS LOT GET 2/10 *******************************
Russell Brand Just not very funny
Bo Selecta The Masks were innovative, the rest OTT.
Lenny Henry Put on a ginger wig when he was 12 and said “Gwapple me Gwapenuts” not much since
Dennis Pennis (Paul Kaye) A bit of a coward really, wouldn't have done what he did any other way. More rude than funny and REALLY irritating in the VC ads (as is VC)
Norman Collier Just ha.ing a br.k.n mi.. phone whilst original, but kept him going for about 82 years.
Simon Amstell How can anyone not be irritated by him? though he has been slightly redeemed by Grandma’s House, but only slightly.
Jennie Eclair loud, brash, northern. Doesn’t really seem much of a basis for an act – and it isn’t.
Les Dennis was in the shadow of Dustin Gee, who sadly died. Still in it. He went from 1/10 to 2/10 on my list thanks to his appearance in Extras.
Norman Lovett[b] Made his name as the 1st Holly, in Red Dwarf
[b]Josie Lawrence
Whose line is it anyway, anything else? Has a voice that can shatter milk bottles.
Simon Pegg Writes a bit, acts a bit... Always the same sort of stuff and it's not funny.
Horne and Corden They only get 2/10 because there's 2 of them ? Horne slightly better of the 2. BBC3 again, 
Bob Hope Gets an extra point for longevity. I never laughed at anything he did
Rhod Gilbert Shouts too much, and like so many other ethnic comics, feels the need to establish his welshness
Ken Goodwin Had a few moments in 'The Comedians' but wasn't even the best in that!
Frank Carson Gets a sympathy point bringing him up to 2. That's a cracker.
Mike Yarwood Even at his prime, laughter didn't come easy to his audience. Fair mimic.
Russ Abbott I might have smiled on rare occasions, I can't remember
Max Boyce  Welsh, into Rugby. (Wrongly) Assumes everyone else is the same
Nick Frost A buddy of Simon Pegg, and just as bad, not believable in any role, oh, and not funny
Robert Llewellyn despite writing, and performing for years, only really known for playing Kryton. Which, in fairness, he did quite well
Caroline Aherne Hiding behind 'Mrs Merton' didn't work. W(h)iney.
Charlie Williams Eh oop flower. Likeable, but wouldn't have anyone rolling in the aisles.
Hope and Keen Double act of not very funny Scottish cousins, they worked with Peter Goodwright a lot, (remember him?)
Rod Hull and Emu!!! was English, not Australian as many people think, and extremely limited.
Freddie Starr Was briefly (a mere matter of days) amusing in about 1973. From Liverpool
John Bishop Almost impossible to listen to, Until he came along I thought the Scouse accent was annihilated English. He speaks annihilated Scouse.
Mel Giedroyc Quite good at voice-overs, marginally funnier than the other half of Mel and Sue
Sean Hughes Wasn't very good in 'buzzcocks' wasn't very good in his own show
Phil Jupitus Makes like he's an 'eastender' instead of being from the Isle of Wight, sometimes OK on QI, but not too often
Charlie Chaplin I never saw what was so funny, and he certainly wasn't as good as other silent stars.
Pam Ayres Having a silly accent, and sillier grin was all it took. Or maybe more was needed.
Iain Lee Doesn't make me laugh.
Chris Addison Doesn’t make me laugh – although I feel like he should
Ross Noble Lots of energy, even more bad material, becomes annoying after a while. I thought, "He's funny", then I saw him.
Graham Norton He's gay you know! Grovels and fawns over guests, treats public (who pay him) like dirt. Too camp. As annoying as the character he played in Father Ted.
Sarah Silverman Living proof that trying to be shocking all the time gets boring, and although she has the potential to be funny, she rarely shows it.
Roseanne Barr Can (rarely) be funny, awful screechy voice
Harry Worth Were it not for everyone raising an arm and a leg at shop window corners at the merest mention of his name, he'd be hard pushed to have scored 1.
Stanley Baxter A few self-indulgent production numbers in TV (both senses of TV) shows, that weren't over-imbued with hilarity
Kevin Bishop I barely smiled when I watched his show
Sandi Toksvig Quite talented, with many facets, another proud lesbian, but not overly funny. Was a part of Cambridge footlights revue with some notable others.
Mark Lamarr Too aggressive, tries to be one of the lads and it never looks natural to me, also not funny.
Duncan Norville Come on chase me....  Why?
Jack Whitehall Comes across as a privileged kid who got the breaks because he had some backing.- I don’t know if that’s the case, but he doesn’t make me laugh much
Jimmy Cricket[b] The wellies with L and R written on them get him just into 2/10 territory.
[b]Jim Bowen
Had it not been for Bullseye coupled with his ineptitude, we'd barely have heard of him. But it was a classic, so bad he's nearly OK.
.
******************************************************************
************************* THIS LOT ARE 3/10 *****************************
Lee Evans Squeaks, sweats, falls over, and repeats. If you can suffer that there may be one or two moments of humour within. The Bohemian Rhapsody mime raises his score a point
Rufus Hound not hilarious, but I wouldn't walk out
Phil Cool His face made him, but didn't keep him there. Gentle humour.
Alan Carr Really annoying voice, camp, not very funny
Abbott and Costello Whyyyyy, I oughta..... Of their time really, and even then only just.
George Formby Sang a couple of amusing ditties, and was OK on the Ukulele. His films were not funny, OK in the 30's
Jim Tavare Can raise the odd guffaw, looks a bit odd and so is memorable for that.
Jerry Sadowitz Tries to alienate everyone, and succeeds usually. Good magician
Bill Hicks I think he's held in higher regard than his humour warrants
Dennis Leary Sometimes funnyish, chain-smoker, same (incl material) as Bill Hicks
Hinge and Brackett Could be agreeable, but limited. Originally entertainers to the Gay!
Rob Newman infinitely more funny than David Baddiel, but that isn't saying much
Clive Anderson Should let other people talk more, not very funny, very occasional witticisms
Hattie Hayridge Can be amusing, known for being Holly/Hilly in Red Dwarf.
Kelly Monteith Had 6 years on the BBC in the early 80's, unusual for a US comic, (remember Gabrielle Drake?), the show wasn't bad. He never did much, if anything, else.
Jo Caulfield Average stand up, but can raise the odd titter
Michael McIntyre A bit annoying (accent and voice), can (rarely) be humourous though..
Omid Djalilli Only vaguely amusing, another 'ethnic' comic
Ken Dodd From Liverpool, and there aren't many better than him from there, gets a mark this high for being an institution and for sheer quantity.
Lee Hurst Was just about OK on 'They think its all over'. Just about OK as a stand-up, too.
Armando Ianucci Variable, more not funny than funny for me. Including his writings.
Tim Vine Like Ken Dodd, works hard, mostly plays on words. I met him, and wasn't given the impression of innate funniness
Dick Emery He was hilarious at the time, so maybe deserves more than 3, but having seen his show recently, I cannot understand what was funny, even first time around. (the 5th goon too btw)
Dustin Gee Top cabaret act, kept strange company (professionally speaking). Quite funny, and sadly, died young
Peter Serafinowicz Gets about ? in lots of Pegg/Frost things. Average. From Liverpool.
George Burns Very popular, and quite interesting, his double act with Gracie Allen had real chemistry too. Not exactly hilarious though.
Russell Howard Can amuse sporadically, not funny enough to be as regular on TV as he is.
John Sessions Puts the ‘mug’ into Smug. Bright, and quick, but up himself.
Norman Wisdom His films were OK, more amusing than hilarious, but that's it
Victoria Wood Fair pianist, fair writer (tends to give herself nice likeable roles), more appreciated by women than men.
Paul Merton OK when he goes into flights of fantasy on HIGNFY, his show was poor, not as funny as he thinks he is.
Ronnie Corbett OK in Sorry, overshadowed by Ronnie Barker, biggest ever 'Died on his arse' I've ever seen, when he was on Ben Elton's show a few years ago.
Paul O'Grady From Liverpool, passable as Lily Savage, not funny generally.
Dave Spikey Average northern comic
Harry Hill Very hit and miss for me, I wonder if he was a better doctor than he is a comic.
Roy Chubby Brown Just rude, with bits of funny. Was shocking in his early days.
Robin Williams Too manic, often can't make out what he's saying. Clever, but not non-stop funny by any means
League of Gentlemen Acquired taste. You like it or not, or in my case not much.
Rory Bremner OK, but has trouble being himself. Varies between average and not great.
Peter Kay Northern comic whose popularity I can't fathom.
Linda Smith Did loads of panel games, she could be witty, but missed the target a few times too.
Roy Hudd 'Music hall' stylings and Panto. 3/10 is kind.
John Thomson OK, been involved with loads of things, but not hilarious.
**************************************************************
************************* THIS LOT ARE 4/10 ********************************
Hale and Pace They had some moments of funny (We know a song about that don't we Billy?), but were more miss than hit.
Fred MacAuley Witty, good on panel games, not memorable.
Arabella Weir Not bad, the Posh Nosh programme which she wrote was good.
Alexei Sayle Still too radical. From Liverpool. His show in the early 90's was fair.

Jerry Seinfeld American humour, of the newer variety, OK.
Jason Manford Some good material, fair stand-up.
Tim Brooke Taylor The Goodies were unmissable when they started, averagely amusing in panel games.
Steve Coogan Good as Alan Partridge, less so as Paul Calf, Less so again as Saxondale, and even less so as himself.
Alastair McGowan Unfortunately for him, he can never look like the people he is imitating
Steve Punt Less funny than his partner, but still not bad. Does more writing
Griff Rhys Jones Used to be funny with others round him. Isn't now.
Mel Smith Like Griff, and would have been better if he'd licked his lips less. Went down several places when he brought out the Appalling 'Morons from Outer Space'.
WC Fields Some good quotes, but doesn't get me rofl.
Bill Cosby Amusing in places. Better stand-up than show.
Jim Carrey Massive over-actor, annoying facial habits, 40% of his films have funny moments, so 4/10 for him.
Chris Rock Not great, did well as the voice of Marty the Zebra in Madagascar.
Jasper Carrott Has been using the same material for over 30 years, was in just about the worst sitcom ever, but used to be funny.
Mike Reid The best one of 'The Comedians' but no versatility at all. One or 2 average jokes.
Lucy Porter Has her moments
Marx Brothers Mostly for Groucho's one-liners, and some clever slapstick they score 4/10, not much of what was left made me laugh.
David Walliams Whatever character he plays, he's just himself in different clothes.
Sean Lock Okish on panel games. Not a great stand-up.
Rik Mayall Varied stuff, can irritate, good as B'stard, overall passable.
Vic Reeves Sometimes amuses, generally only with his partner.
Angelos Epithemiou (Dan Skinner) Seems quite amusing in Shooting Stars, Was OK in his own show, but may be a bit limited.
Mark Thomas Not really all that funny, but his shows are very interesting, and some of the stuff he campaigns about and discovers is valid.
Shari Lewis (& Lamb Chop) Helped make Sunday afternoons special when I was a kid, and a very good ventriloquist to boot.
Dylan Moran A bit dull for me, good moments, but not consistent.
Nina Conti  A ventriloquist with a good line in working with the audience. I had a lol moment when watching her once.
***************************************************************
*********************** THIS LOT GET 5/10 **************************
Richard Pryor Good in his films. Not as good but acceptable, as stand-up.
Ronnie Ancona Shows talent, better in some guises than others.
Leonard Rossiter One of the best of those from Liverpool, 2 funny roles, Reggie Perrin and Rigsby (possibly ITV's best comedy) yet not hilarious.
Alan Green Average stand-up
Kevin Bloody WilsonDo you feck on 1st dates? Does your dad own a brewery?
Jim Davidson More unfashionable than unfunny, and not popular. Has definitely been funny in his time though
Mike Harding Some of his songs were amusing, and I liked his TV show in the 70's.
Tony Hawks Strikes me as a bit of a laugh, wrote some funny books, could be funny on panel games,
Peter Sellers Good at accents, good in his day, I think he wouldn't stand out so much if he was starting now. A bit over-rated. Being a 'Goon' is a plus
Tracey Ullman Most of her rating is for spawning The Simpsons, she was the funniest in the show with Copperfield and Henry (not hard that!)
Rory McGrath Clever man, says some very funny things, much of it is missed, not got a good image and not as popular as he could be.
Bob Mills In bed with me dinner was very good, (big) plus - he supports Leyton Orient.
Reginald D Hunter Sometimes funny, mumbles too much.
Barry Humphries Was better years ago, but Dame Edna was a brilliant creation, some material good, some not.
Ricky Gervais A bit smug. Always seems to play exactly the same part, even when not acting. Some funny stuff, and some of the Office and Extras were OK.
Andy Kaufman Weird, and occasionally brilliant. Best character in Taxi, which was funny at the time, but isn't now.
Charlie Drake Sort of lovable, and only 5'1”, blew millions gambling. Quite funny. (My boomerang won't come back was produced by George Martin btw)
Andy Parsons If you listen past the silly voice (which is natural, I believe) he can be very funny.
Jackie Mason Original, and was unmissable when he started out, not for long though.
Greg Davies Ex-Teacher who still plays them quite a bit, his stand-up is fair.
Miles Jupp Can be funny, posh and funny
Miranda Hart  I quite like her TV show, it’s harmless and can raise a smile. Good in Not Going Out.
Greg Proops[b/] Whose line is it regular, quite funny.
[b]Colin Mochrie
See G. Proops
Mike McShane See G Proops
Ryan Stiles see G Proops – the best of these 4.
Mark Steel Not the best delivery, but very interesting and informative TV shows, amusing too.
Chris Barrie Brittas and Rimmer, good characters, also some good voices for Spitting Image, including Reagan.
Michael Bentine Potty time was good, and a 'Goon' (not that I’ve ever laughed at the Goons), so scores well.
Charlie Higson Looks a bit meek, and like he won't be as funny as he is. Good writer.
Jethro[b/] Of the old school, tells some good jokes
[b]Sacha Baron Cohen
Funny at times, cringy too though, very hit and miss.
Jimmy Jones Same old stuff for years, but most of it funny
Matt Lucas Lots of talent, makes you think he is who he's playing, score reduced because of an awful chat show.
Sally Phillips Been in loads of things, but mostly here because I find her strangely attactive
Jo Brand Good stand-up, some good material, not pretentious
John Belushi Was a funny bloke, but not that funny.
Chevy Chase some good films, some good stand-up, some not.
Stephen Fry Mmmmmmmhhhheeeehhhh!
Sarah Millican A bit flavour of the month, can be rude, at least she’s amusing.
Nick Hancock Was good as host of Room 101, unnecessarily reactive at times.
Eddie Murphy I often can't understand what he's saying, with all the mo fo's being hurled about. Some of his films amuse though.
Hattie Jacques Carry on films, Sykes, could be funny. She utilised facial expressions well.
Larry Grayson An institution, if only for ‘Shut that door’, and names like Everard.
*********************************************************
*********************** THIS LOT ARE 6/10 ********************************

Gene Wilder Lots of memorable and funny film roles
Richard Stilgoe Some very funny songs
Catherine Tate Talented, some of her characters are amusing.
Sid James Good with Hancock. Good in 'Carry on' films, other stuff not so good.
Marcus Brigstocke Good material, makes me laugh.
Hugh Laurie Talented, and he'd get a higher score if he'd drop the very, very annoying voice he uses as 'House', Fry and Laurie's sketches never seemed to end properly to me.
Rowan Atkinson OK in Thin blue line. Excellent as Blackadder. Dire as both Mr Bean and Johnny English.
Dorothy Parker Some of the best quotes ever can be attributed to her.
Jon Richardson Quick thinking, good material, Among the best of a very large current crop.
Bob Mortimer Mortimer funnier than Reeves. Shooting stars was moderately watchable
Dave Gorman He’s original and he works hard at his gigs, Googlewhack was very good.
Jake Thackarey Should have been more famous, but was shy. Very clever, very funny songs
Eddie Izzard For someone who was never going to be on TV, he's been on it a lot, sometimes tries too hard.
Alan Davis Best in QI. Quite good stand-up..
Ben Elton Better writer than performer, very good writer.
Kenneth Williams Best in Round the Horne.
Ed Byrne Enjoyable act, smoother comic than many.
Tim Minchin Brilliant Pianist, some of his routines are a bit cerebral/hard to understand
Kathy Burke Talented, good timing, perfect as Waynetta Slob.
Les Dawson The piano playing is one of the funniest things ever, and it isn't easy. I often had trouble understanding what he said.
Dara O'Briain Good stand-up, OK on TV
Simon Evans Cynical stand-up, funny with it. Writes for others as well
Mel Brooks Made some good films, but there were often telegraphed jokes which didn't work.
Johnny Vegas Can make me laugh out loud, unusual act.
Ray Alan (& Lord Charles) ‘You silly arse’. Was the consummate vent act in the 60's/70's
Rich Hall A tiny bit too dead pan, but good enough.
Richard Digance Inventive, some good tunes too, and funny.
Tommy Cooper Just silly, I never quite understood why he was idolised quite so much.
Barry Cryer Top writer, good stand-up.
Rob Brydon Better on stage than TV. On TV too much
Joyce Grenfell Excellent in St Trinians. Was a groundbreaker for women and comedy.
Al Murray Clever, well researched stuff, very good with his audience, shouts too much.
Frank Skinner Would be better if he swore less, average chat show host. Can be funny. The ‘bluest’ stand-up routine I’ve ever seen.
Arthur Smith Good personality, and funny bloke.
Graeme Garden Best of the goodies (though possibly not at the time), laid back and quick.
Jennifer Saunders Good writer, quite funny sketch show, works well with partner.
Mae West Filthy in her day, as well as sharp
Eric Idle Writer of funny songs and a good style.
Milton Jones Silly one liners and a quite good radio show. Makes me laugh
Joan Rivers For an old lady she has lots of energy. Makes me laugh.
*******************************************************
************************ THIS LOT ARE 7/10 **************************
Clement Freud Excellent writer, one of the wittiest ever on panel games.
Eric Sykes His TV series was a classic, but did loads of other funny stuff too.
Andy Hamilton Top writer (Harry's game, Drop the dead donkey), good on QI etc, too.
Tony Hancock So many classic sketches.
Dawn French Excellent as vicar, also in Jam and Jerusalem. Good with Saunders, can be very funny.
Bernard Manning Among those with the best timing ever. Some funny stuff, if not to everyone's taste. I liked him.
Bill Bailey Brilliant musician, and when not being too 'Far out', quite funny.
Max Miller Years ahead of his time. His jokes have been nicked by 100's of comics.
Spike Milligan Funny books, the funniest 'Goon', Funny sketch shows.
Frankie Boyle Clever and quick, but tries too hard sometimes.
Harold Lloyd one of the few silent stars to succeed in talkies
Armstrong and Miller They vary a bit. The Airman, and Flanders and Swann, are funny. Both good in other things
Harry Enfield Many good characters, some not so good. Can be good.
Ardal O'Hanlon Likeable, so good in Father Ted, Funny stage act.
Paul Whitehouse Good at characterisations even if some of them are irritating. Writes well.
Peter Ustinov Brilliant man, interesting background, told stories perfectly.
Joe Pasquale Just silly, but I can't help laughing at him
Jack Dee Holds an audience well. Good quiz host too.
Frankie Howerd Unique and good with the audience.
Woody Allen V Good stand-up, made some good films, but also a few near misses.
Jimmy Carr Can be very rude, but gets away with it. Writes a good routine.
Alan Coren Some of the most amusing written stuff I've seen, was editor of Punch, excellent on the News quiz.
Phil Hammond Funny (real) Doctor. Always makes me chuckle.
Hugh Dennis Witty, very good in Outnumbered, also on panel shows.
Dudley Moore Excellent pianist, great partnership, was good in Arthur.
Bob Newhart Some classic sketches, (Driving instructor, Nutty Walt).
Robert Webb With his partner, very well thought-out comedy.
Michael Palin Not just Python, but good in other films. His travel series are humourous too.
John Cleese The most famous Basil ever?
Lee Mack Good stand-up, not bad on TV panel shows, Not Going Out one of the better recent comedies.
********************************************************
*********************** THIS LOT ARE 8/10 ************************
Peter Cook A 60's icon, deservedly an 8.
Monty Python Slightly better as the sum of its parts
Victor Borge Unbelievable Pianist, very good on stage, and the voice of Heineken ads.
Benny Hill An institution and one of the best comedy writers ever, he wrote some clever songs. Some of his TV shows were amazing at the time.
Dave Allen Clever bloke, he was master of ‘leave 'em wanting more’, hence never seeing his old shows. Timing superb.
Morecambe and Wise Naturally funny, They never failed to get a laugh, although I think it was 80% Morecambe and 20% Wise
Humphrey Littleton The funniest radio show of all time. He was responsible.
Willie Rushton Very funny, it just came without effort.
Steve Martin Funny actor, dexterous, excellent stand-up at times too
Emo Phillips Unique self-deprecation. Hilarious
David Mitchell Funny on panel games. Works well with Robert Webb – the acting is very good in their sketches and films.
Marty Feldman Looked funny, but wrote and acted funny as well. He had a very good sketch show, with some memorable sketches.
Kenny Everett From Liverpool, and a class apart from all others from there. Inventive, even funnier on radio than on TV.
Billy Connolly Surely the best stand-up ever. The mould into which most other comics have poured themselves. Material hasn’t stood the test of time.   

*****************************************************************
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * 9/10 for these 2 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Laurel and Hardy They had chemistry which has been without equal. So many belly laughs. Classic stuff (most of it) which is still funny, other old comedy mostly isn’t
Bob Monkhouse A genius. One of my heroes, he could sing, draw, write comedy, had a top stand-up routine. Shame about some of the quiz shows. Apparently a v nice bloke too.

*****************************************************************
* * * * * * * * * * * * * * * * JUST THE ONE 10/10 * * * * * * * * * * * * * * *
Ronnie Barker Probably the best comedy actor ever, he became the roles he played. He also wrote (as Gerard Wiley) and was brilliant with wordplay. Genius.
Pause Switch to Standard View The definitive list of comedians -...
Show More
Loading...
Report STUDYFORM November 20, 2013 5:21 PM GMT
McIntyre just squeezed into a 3/10 - I agree it is a bit generous.
Report Capt__F November 20, 2013 5:25 PM GMT
still on the 2s
Report Slicer November 20, 2013 5:31 PM GMT
Vlad Tepes is a serious ommission!

Where are Jack Benny, Mike Nichols and Elaine May????
Report Crisp77 November 20, 2013 5:38 PM GMT
One of the 1/10 comedians exposed 7/10 Joe Pasquale as a joke thief Plain
Report Crisp77 November 20, 2013 5:39 PM GMT

Nov 20, 2013 -- 5:38PM, Crisp77 wrote:


One of the 1/10 comedians exposed 7/10 Joe Pasquale as a joke thief


And one of the 6/10 comedians exposed him too over another joke.

Report STUDYFORM November 20, 2013 6:19 PM GMT
Not every comedian ever is in the list - I don't know much about Jack Benny and I haven't heard of the other 3, Slicer.

Which one crisp? Is it justified?
Report Navel-Gazer November 20, 2013 6:29 PM GMT
Omissions for George Carlin & Larry David? Confused
That pair should be in ANYONE'S top 10 - both are sublime Happy
Report Slicer November 20, 2013 6:36 PM GMT
Elaine May and Mike :

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x0vSLIO7m20
Report akabula November 20, 2013 6:51 PM GMT
FFS!!!!!!!!! Interesting reading? I couldn't get through the first group. Too much time on his hands.
Report morpteh mackem November 20, 2013 7:43 PM GMT
I take it phil silvers is a spinal tap 11 ?
Report rommel November 20, 2013 9:06 PM GMT
billy connolly 8?you should be in the 10/10 for that
Report brngtwt November 20, 2013 9:21 PM GMT
Stewart Lee in the same group as Keith Harris and Orv
Report Crisp77 November 20, 2013 9:25 PM GMT

Nov 20, 2013 -- 6:19PM, STUDYFORM wrote:


Not every comedian ever is in the list - I don't know much about Jack Benny and I haven't heard of the other 3, Slicer.Which one crisp? Is it justified?


http://www.chortle.co.uk/news/2010/04/04/10784/

www.youtube.com/watch?v=0YE9Kthyaco

Report STUDYFORM November 20, 2013 9:27 PM GMT
I've tended towards Brits, though there are others.
Most of the omissions seem to be Americans.
Report Crisp77 November 20, 2013 9:28 PM GMT
News on Jack Whitehall

http://www.theguardian.com/stage/2009/sep/11/stewart-lee-jack-whitehall-comedians
Report STUDYFORM November 20, 2013 9:34 PM GMT
That is a very interesting article, crisp.
Report STUDYFORM November 21, 2013 9:16 PM GMT
I have, since compiling this list noticed loads of names who aren't it.
Oh well. I'll just consider them non-runners.
Report RLKingPunter November 21, 2013 9:54 PM GMT
sarah millican, at least shes amusing........not when ive seen her she isnt.
Report doantwin2easy November 21, 2013 10:34 PM GMT
i miss Benny Hill. Chasing scantilly clad girls round impossibly high hedges is just frowned upon these days.
Report The Priest November 21, 2013 11:38 PM GMT
Can I just say Studyform that i thoroughly enjoyed reading all them and the time and effort to actually write something different for each one and not merely start to repeat yourself was amazing.

Also i did agree with most which helped and plenty of laugh out loud moments especially amongst the lower numbers.

Cheers and thanks.
Report STUDYFORM November 22, 2013 9:32 AM GMT
Yes, The Priest, you can. Thank you.
It makes it worthwhile.
Report Navel-Gazer November 22, 2013 6:02 PM GMT
SF - out of interest, just where would you put George Carlin & Larry David?
You've included plenty of relatively obscure Yanks so did you just overlook the above pair?
Report kenny mann November 22, 2013 6:11 PM GMT
Fantastic effort, certainly agree about Bob Monkhouse.
Report STUDYFORM November 22, 2013 7:09 PM GMT
I'm not overly familiar with Larry David, N-G. I wasn't as crazy as many people about Curb your Enthusiasm. He strikes me as being just a bloke you either like or don't or in my case, just think is "alright".
George Carlin was someone I'd forgotten about. Some good material, but not great delivery and a bit too much swearing. Plus, men with pony tails look silly.
Both of them are very American which, in funny terms, usually detracts a little from the laugh. That, and the reactions of American audiences.

So, 4/10 and 5/10 respectively.
Report Navel-Gazer November 22, 2013 7:23 PM GMT
I think both are hilarious but I have to agree with that pony-tail business...embarrassing.
I'm very anti-American concerning many issues (especially comedy) so for me to be such a fan (despite loathing American culture) means they're both something special if they can transcend my inherent disposition.

PS - I like plenty of those rated 1/2/3 in your list as well as those that universally appeal the the top end of your scale.
Report STUDYFORM November 22, 2013 7:30 PM GMT
I'd have been amazed if most people didn't agree with my 1/2/3 ratings. After all, they must be liked by some people to have become famous!
Report STUDYFORM November 25, 2013 12:24 AM GMT
^^^ after all the time this took, I don't want it dropping off.
Report The Leopard November 25, 2013 12:51 AM GMT
Yes, great effort SF, you could bring it out as a book for Christmas.
Report Navel-Gazer November 25, 2013 1:00 AM GMT
SF - yes squire...a fully justified 're-boot' back to the top after all that hard work Happy

BUT...what I want to know is WHY bother? Devil
Report History Maker November 25, 2013 1:31 AM GMT
Jimmy Carr live is very good. Seen one of his shows, and on QI.

Left to his own devices, most of what he says is unbroadcastable.
Report History Maker November 25, 2013 1:39 AM GMT
For what it's worth there's a world of difference between sitcom and standup, with panel show stuff somewhere in between.

Robert Webb, for example, is awful on panel shows, but very good in Peep Show/Mitchell and Webb Look/Ambassadors etc.
Report STUDYFORM November 25, 2013 4:58 PM GMT
Probably the least broadcastable I've ever seen (although it WAS on TV) was Frank Skinner.
I sort of based the list on how much humour I have personally derived from each name.

Good question N-G, it didn't start off as long a list as it ended up and I got a tad carried away.

btw, I've left out Micky Flanagan. 5/10 quite good, can make me laugh, it remains to be seen if he'll still be a top name in say, 5 years.
Report SlippyBlue November 25, 2013 6:47 PM GMT
Good to see Emo Phillips get such a high score, 8/10 is about right. I saw him years ago and he had all the audience in fits of laughter, totally unique.

I saw Micky Flanagan recently and although slightly disappointing from what I was expecting I still enjoyed the night - 6.5/10. Dara O'Briain is a different matter though, he was embarrassingly awful when I saw him in Hammersmith 1/10 for him.
Report STUDYFORM November 27, 2013 8:59 AM GMT
^^^ final bump
Report buccini November 27, 2013 9:28 AM GMT
Lenny Henry will be delighted with a 2/10. He was a 1.01 certainty to be 1/10.

Larry David, Jerry Seinfeld and Karl Pilkington are the current kings of comedy, and Ronnie Barker was superb as well.
Report Capt__F November 27, 2013 10:32 AM GMT
just made the 3s
Report STUDYFORM December 6, 2013 8:10 AM GMT
If we must bring any of my old threads to the top, at least this one deserves it a bit.
Report FOYLESWAR December 6, 2013 8:06 PM GMT
joan riverws by far the funniest female comedian  out there ,and  bernard manning love him or hate him these modern day comedians could not lace his boots imo !
Report STUDYFORM October 12, 2015 8:16 AM BST
Comedy is definitely the new 'rock n roll'.
There are loads of new comics and regularly seen panel show guests who have appeared since I did my appraisal.
Very few, if any, new comedy shows or comedy actors.

At some point I'll do a newer more updated version.
In the meantime, as there are SO many threads about comedians, here is the resurrection of some ranting ammunition.
Report The Leopard October 12, 2015 10:16 AM BST
Surely, Baking is the new Rock'n Roll ?
Report TheBetterBettor October 12, 2015 10:42 AM BST
Emo Phillips..... Hilarious Confused
Report fred October 12, 2015 10:02 PM BST
Lots of omissions at the bottom end, which is ok, but one who should be at the topend is -

Chic Murray. Sadly very little to see on line.

All I could find was

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=y82WdMot--U4

Gives a small flavour of the man.
Report Scamp the man October 12, 2015 10:13 PM BST
Bernard Manning was the funniest i seen live
Report David Fishwick Minibus Sales October 12, 2015 10:18 PM BST
stewart lee 1/10?

i'd have him much higher than that
Report rob_dylan October 14, 2015 4:32 PM BST
Jim Jefferies a good stand up I've recently discovered.  his rant about guns getting lots of airing on social media atm, which put me on to some of his other stuff well good it is.
Report David Fishwick Minibus Sales October 14, 2015 4:35 PM BST
i like him too, only discovered him in the last year or so myself

Steve Hughes also good
Report rob_dylan October 14, 2015 4:52 PM BST
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vmBIRsZSp3Q

Jim Jeffries – Fully Functional.  Complete show.
Starts off with dumb coonts and their dumb coont children and their dumb coont religions and gradually gets more offensive.  Funny as, and it makes you think and sh1t.
Report bix October 14, 2015 6:28 PM BST
Hate to say this but I saw Jimmy Cricket live some years ago and he was very very funny. Complete rubbish infantile jolks but he made everyone laugh which is what you want from a comic.
Report bix October 14, 2015 6:47 PM BST
Where's Max Wall?
Report jollyswagman October 14, 2015 6:48 PM BST
each to their own. imo peter cook is the best ever. as a child i loved tommy cooper and eric morecombe. i also really like bill hicks.

i absolutely detest jim davidson (although i pity him for what he went through). there was a time in the 80s when our family holiday was to bournemouth and we went to see davidson. he asked if there was anyone irish in the audience and i remember pleading with my dad not to put his hand up. he did anyway and jim told one of his unfunny paddy jokes. i will remember the embarassment til the day i die.

went to see ben elton in 87 and found him funny, not so funny when he was doing the same stuff years later. certainly dont find him funny now. was he ever funny? i thought harry enfield really captured the time with loadsamoney.

modern day macyntire (dont know how he spells it and dont care) is the least good by a mile. yet he makes a fortune.
Report crags February 16, 2017 1:19 AM GMT
Norman Vaughan?
Report rommel February 16, 2017 8:39 AM GMT
Billy Connolly Surely the best stand-up ever. The mould into which most other comics have poured themselves. Material hasn’t stood the test of time.
Report mememe February 16, 2017 8:48 AM GMT
Latest double act ...

Jezzer and Diane ... very funny.  Make me laugh everytime I see them.

Christ, I'm laughing now just picturing them LaughLaughLaugh

10/10
Report rommel February 16, 2017 8:49 AM GMT
go back and look at any bc vid,he never fckn says anything
Report mememe February 16, 2017 8:55 AM GMT
rommel,

he's like that Marcel Marceau guy, does funny mime.

Heading for Britain's got (no) talent contest
Report rommel February 16, 2017 8:58 AM GMT
meme was talking about b connolly,but just put jeezeer and diane into youtube,nothing came up
Report mememe February 16, 2017 9:09 AM GMT
rommel,

patience, it will after next Thursday
Report Life-Lucky February 16, 2017 9:39 AM GMT
One of the greatest posts of all-time on any Betfair forum, well done OP Studyform
Report Jack Hacksaw February 16, 2017 9:59 AM GMT
Saw Lee Nelson last week and I haven't laughed as much in years.

As a proviso, I should add that I had drunk 4 pints of 5.9% Jaipur prior and had a pint of some local 5%+ ale in the interval.

And drank another one from a plastic glass during the second half.
Report mememe February 16, 2017 11:51 AM GMT
were the women there all beautiful as well?
Report Jack Hacksaw February 16, 2017 12:16 PM GMT
Better looking than normal.

How did you know that?
Report Jack Hacksaw February 16, 2017 12:16 PM GMT
Better looking than normal.

How did you know that?
Report mememe February 16, 2017 12:26 PM GMT
Jack, they always do when you've had 8 pints.

I say, they always do when you've had 8 pints.

Does that answer both your questions?

I say does that ... oh, forget it, I'll get mi coat
Report STUDYFORM February 16, 2017 6:17 PM GMT

Feb 16, 2017 -- 9:39AM, Life-Lucky wrote:


One of the greatest posts of all-time on any Betfair forum, well done OP Studyform


Thank you,
That was one of the greatest appreciation posts of all time on any forum.
I am humbled.

I did the original of this about 9 years ago, I think.
Maybe a refreshed updated version with some of the newer names is in order.

Report TheBetterBettor February 16, 2017 7:19 PM GMT
Jerry Lewis won the Ordre national de la Légion d'honneur. in France.    Plain
Report STUDYFORM June 2, 2018 7:59 PM BST
Resurrected as it's being discussed.
It needs updating though. I'll be doing that later.

Times and tastes change, as well as new people who are not already included in the list.

Just to say, once again.
It is entirely subjective.
NO TWO PEOPLE WILL AGREE - I COMPLETELY REALISE SOME OF MYSCORES WILL BE ENTIRELY DIFFERENT TO SOME OF YOURS.
Report Injera June 2, 2018 8:01 PM BST
Decent piece of work Study!
Report STUDYFORM June 2, 2018 8:06 PM BST
Thank you, I'm going to update it soon.
Report akabula June 2, 2018 8:27 PM BST
1/10
Gregor Fisher - must be the accent - genius as Rab C.
otherwise agree and would add Jimmy Tarbuck "Is that the one?" - Can't remember ever laughing at him.
Arthur Askey - his looks got him by. I'm a little Bee. Ashamed to say I laughed at him when young, still we all grow up.
Report Ibrahima Sonko June 2, 2018 8:30 PM BST
Great work SF
Report akabula June 2, 2018 8:31 PM BST
2/10
Cant see the difference with the 1/10 ers
Apart from Rhod gilbert 5/10 and Freddie Starr probably a 3.
Report akabula June 2, 2018 8:32 PM BST
Yes have to agree with IS tis a great post.
Report akabula June 2, 2018 8:45 PM BST
3/10
Jerry Sadowitz versus the people was great viewing I thought. Seen him live loads of times at the festival. 6/10 for me.
Ken Dodds I'd also see mush higher even a 7.

Enjoying going through these lists, surprising how many chit comedians we have.
Apart from Dick Emery, Norman wisdom, Clive Anderson, Ronnie Corbett and Peter Kay the rest would be a 1 or a 2.
Report i_agree_with_nick June 2, 2018 8:51 PM BST
I like Rhod Gilbert - he's the only one of the "new breed" of comics who really make me laugh. I think he's been influenced by John Cleese.

Did Paul Merton make the list?
Report Crisp77 June 2, 2018 9:53 PM BST
I'd move The Chuckle Brothers from 2 to 3.
Report Crisp77 June 2, 2018 10:03 PM BST
No 3 to 2.
Report akabula June 2, 2018 10:10 PM BST
Laugh
Report STUDYFORM June 2, 2018 10:21 PM BST
Laugh
Report i_agree_with_nick June 2, 2018 10:35 PM BST
Fawlty Towers: I thought the bloke who played Roger in the episode where Polly pretended to be Sybil was very good.

"...all that waving, enough to tire anyone out"

I like to use variations of that line to wind up the missus.
Report Hank Hill June 2, 2018 10:50 PM BST
crisp Laugh

study - how about Dave Chapelle, Bill Maher and Bill Burr
Report STUDYFORM June 2, 2018 11:00 PM BST
There are quite a few to add Hank. Although I haven't heard of Chappelle, Maher and Burr.
I'll have to do a little research before adding some new names in.
I'll rewrite it and start a new thread in the next few days.
Report STUDYFORM June 3, 2018 12:04 AM BST
I looked those 3 names up, Hank.
There must be 100's of American comics I don't know.
I'll have to watch more and rate in the future.
Report Hank Hill June 3, 2018 12:17 AM BST
Bill Maher does a great show called Real Time study- I think you'd like the show. He still does stand up too and I saw him live years ago.
Report STUDYFORM June 3, 2018 10:18 AM BST
He's made me smile a few times in the last hour or so I've spent researching.
The new list is being done.
Report TheBetterBettor June 3, 2018 2:01 PM BST
Rodney Dangerfield

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0SVZvWaMWsA


..and norm macdonald seems to get better with age.
Report JOMO June 3, 2018 4:43 PM BST
i_agree_with_nick • June 2, 2018 10:35 PM BST
Fawlty Towers: I thought the bloke who played Roger in the episode where Polly pretended to be Sybil was very good.


He was brilliant. "A Basil Brush. Broom broom!"
Report rommel June 3, 2018 5:27 PM BST
it all turns to sh** if billy connolly gets more than zero
Report rommel June 3, 2018 5:29 PM BST

Jun 3, 2018 -- 12:17AM, Hank Hill wrote:


Bill Maher does a great show called Real Time study- I think you'd like the show. He still does stand up too and I saw him live years ago.


hank,one of the highlights of the week,wake up saturday and can watch his show,he should ditch the stand up at the start tho-bit lame,has some great guests

Report lfc1971 June 3, 2018 8:15 PM BST
Most of the news is so dire I think my sense of humour has been affected

I don’t have to read this tripe from STUDYFORM !
Report lfc1971 June 3, 2018 8:23 PM BST
Barry Humphries , might have missed him :10
Report STUDYFORM June 3, 2018 8:29 PM BST
lfc - your superior intellect will, of course render my tripe unreadable.
I'll have to resign myself to that.

However, I'll be able to console myself with your brilliant and insightful offerings ALL OVER this forum.
I hate to disappoint you but I'm about to put up a new updated version of this list.

Never mind, eh.
You might just have to force yourself to ignore it.
Report lfc1971 June 3, 2018 8:41 PM BST
no its good work study, I like your comments better than the scores..

"should have been more famous but he was shy"Laugh
Report STUDYFORM June 3, 2018 8:45 PM BST
and
Report STUDYFORM June 3, 2018 8:45 PM BST
I cannot C+P the rest Cry
Report STUDYFORM February 17, 2019 12:00 PM GMT
It needs updating, but this is also the type of thread that makes the forum better too.
Report Do wah Diddy February 17, 2019 12:51 PM GMT
Bob monkhouse had millions of jokes and could improvise and was very good at recalling jokes .but he couldn't be discribed as some one who would make you laugh or was funny as ken Dodd or Bernard Manning or Tommy cooper or laurel and hardy . They were funny he was good at what he did but you wasn't filled with a belly full of laughter like you were with those
Report Just Checking February 17, 2019 2:18 PM GMT
There is a new series on late at night on ITV4 or something called "stand up sketch show". It's mostly established second tier stand up comedians, but quite bizarrely for 2019, it's actually FUNNY and not just a pile of sh1t. I don't think it's once mentioned Trump or Brexit - it actually tires to be humourous. Very novel for British comedians these days.
Report STUDYFORM February 17, 2019 2:29 PM GMT
I'm all for things/people/comics which don't go on about politics.
Report aaronh February 17, 2019 2:38 PM GMT
Trump and Brexit are cheap laughs for that crowd in the same way bashing liberals or SJWs are for conservative comedians. plays to its base but beyond that there's not much appeal
Report HGS February 21, 2019 5:49 PM GMT
Excellent work study. Think its fair to say Mickey Flanagan still here after 5 years. Think we can all agree you have been moe than fair with Lenny Henry & Phil Jupitus!
Post Your Reply
<CTRL+Enter> to submit
Please login to post a reply.

Wonder

Instance ID: 13539
www.betfair.com