We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
Yeh Duffy, i did think RTR was the main Irish threat this year,but i am thinking now that the Ryanair may give him more chance of victory.
That said without the slow jumping at times he would probably have won today,and as it was it was very close. |
|
By:
Well if he jumps well,their wont be many finishing as strong as him.
|
|
By:
faster ground, slower time than the savills... surprised at the small drift in kemboy
|
|
By:
Would the Ryanair not put more pressure on RTR's jumping? He was consistently and constantly out-jumped by Bellshill in the Irish Gold Cup today. And I think those at the top of the Gold Cup market can sleep well tonight after this race; these lot are at least 7lbs inferior to the English contingent.
|
|
By:
7lbs ?
And how many lengths is that in the context of rating doctrines and divine equine inspiration please ? |
|
By:
Finally some sense from Davy Russell today regarding Percy's chance in the GC when interviewed on Sky Racing.
|
|
By:
Think yiu will find my post above
States exactly the sane thing Last september hibore Davy interviewed then by chapman At least you might get 11\4 on the day now.... |
|
By:
What did he say?
|
|
By:
He stated the sane as he said last september
Percy a few pounds short Surprised he didnt go on to say The horse isnt classy enough for the GC And the preparation is really poor ..... |
|
By:
So nothing we did not know then.
|
|
By:
He said the horse had to step up significantly from the RSA and that beating Monalee (although a good horse) wasn’t the same as taking on the horses in the Gold Cup. Percy is a very good horse but the handicapper has him quite a few pounds to find and he needs to find them and some more to be able to win. Trained by very good trainer and has a great owner and hopes to run this weekend.
Nothing amazing but some measured comments without we are about to see the second coming. Obviously wouldn’t swap the horse for the Gold Cup but more hopeful rather than ultra confident like some on here. |
|
By:
So Davy indicated what some here already knew ie beating Monalee wasn't the same as taking on the horses in the Gold Cup,...and the handicapper had him quite a few pounds to find.
I cannot agree more, and 3/1 is sheer bonkers; I'd rather back Sir Erec and Altior for a double. |
|
By:
Guardiola still thinks that United are still in the title race, he must think so as why else say it.!!!!
Did Russell state what other horse he wish he could ride..no, didn't think so ![]() |
|
By:
He’s riding Percy so why would anyone ask him that.?!?! Has anyone asked Barry who he’d ride in the Champion Hurdle.
Personally I think it’s a two horse race between Native and Percy. Not very exciting. However was interesting watch Gold Cup today on replay how Our Duke couldn’t keep up with Might Bite or Native River but travelled well when he beat Percy giving him 7lbs in last years Red Mills. |
|
By:
What the horse has to find from a handicappers point of view is pretty moot as he's unexposed and simply hasn't had the time yet to reach his full potential, yes he may not be up to it only time will tell, but I reckon that Russell thinks he is.
It would be pretty difficult for an RSA winner going into the following years GC against the defending champion and not have something to find on the official ratings. |
|
By:
Made even more difficult with having one hurdle run this season.
|
|
By:
Davy is well aware of what you do over there
Over hype a horse then when it loses Totally knock it down Nothing against anyone on here but your populist media continually creates the hero then takes pleasure in knocking it in order to sell advertising space or newspapers, or websites etc etc etc |
|
By:
the interesting thing was his immediate reply to chapman"Youre asking me to jump through a hoop for you"
|
|
By:
"What the horse has to find from a handicapper's point of view is pretty moot as he's unexposed and...."
Ya, whose fault is that? His trainer chooses to run him against non-Gold Cup contenders (persistently). And when he did run against a Gold Cup contender, for instance, last season PP was stuffed 7l in receipt of 7lbs from Our Duke a promising, but ill-fated Gold Cup participant; these are the known facts, anything else sheer conjecture. |
|
By:
Sizing John out for the season
|
|
By:
"His trainer chooses to run him against non gold cup contenders persistently"
More garbage from the impossible.... Killutagh Vic, Don Poli,monalee, elegant escape, black cotton, alboum photo .....all good cup contenders. |
|
By:
Let's hope all turn up on saturday esp Monalee. And, until post the race the jury on PP is still out, as far as I'm concerned.
|
|
By:
Saturday's race will just tell us the current well being of PP. It would be a big ask to get him to come out and beat Monalee comfortably over 2 1/2m in February. I'm assuming that's what it would take to justify his GC price to all the skeptics?
I wouldn't be getting too carried away with the race result unless he really underperforms. A battling win would be a perfect prep. :) |
|
By:
PP was beaten in this by a Irish Grand National winner last year in receipt of 7lbs. You can't have it both ways
![]() I'm not sure what this race will show to be honest. 4/5 is probably a good bet if you think he's improved 10lbs + from last year. |
|
By:
Monalee at 4/1 surely must be value given shorter trip could inconvenience PP. A bet for the Ryanair beckons if winning handsomely.
|
|
By:
PP and Waiting Patiently are both potential champions but neither has beaten any of last seasons top staying chasers but neither have they been beaten by them. That is what makes the debate so interesting-and form study so frustrating. I still see no real evidence that last seasons novice chasers are very good but PP was by far the best of them.
|
|
By:
sageform, you are more diplomatic and considered than me regards opinions of PP.
I fully understand and accept horse racing is purely about opinions and potentials gathered from the merits or achievements (hopefully) already evident. But with PP (personally) I cannot have him at the head of the Gold Cup market no matter what considering eg beating a non-stayer in Monalee; winning a 3m handicap hurdle (not Neptune/Albert Bartlett); thumped by Our Duke (another stout stayer) in the Red Mills Chase receiving 7lbs. If PP beats Monalee by 7ls this saturday then I'll upgrade my opinion of him; he's to find at least 7lbs, I believe. As such his position at the top of the Gold Cup market is wholly unjustified, and solely on the "misfortunes" of last season's Gold Cup participants. |
|
By:
Pp was laid out for the non champion hurdle race in 2017 , he won it
Pp was laid out for the non champion below standard Rsa in 2018 , he won it Hes now been laid out for what impossible will see as a below standard 2019 gold cup because "some of last years participants" have had misfortunes. It does not matter if pp gets thumped by any horse finishing the red mills, AS LONG AS HE COMES BACK SOUND .....his target since march 14th 2018 has been the gold cup on march 15th 2019. READ THE O P |
|
By:
NR has the Gold Cup last season as his main objective hence the minimum of race - unlike the season before. This time round he only ran in the Betfair Chase (£1m bonus) and King George (fact finding/place money) - he won't again for sure. And I'm glad (in a way) the timing of the equine flu predicament had meant he'd get a good break, and be fresh for the main event next month (again).
Come next month assuming all is well, NR and CDO will not be more than 6/1 either on the-day-of-the-race - antepost is very different. As for laying for profit NR and CDO offer more feasible and profitable options than PP. I'm not associated with any horse racing stable thus no sentiment or emotion attached with my selections and/or opinions, but purely on merits and known info. For instance, I'd consider Angels Breath and Battleoverdoyen extremely and unjustifiably short nevertheless, I'd back Sir Erec and Fakir D'oudairies at 6/4 and 5/1 respectively on the day had I not already done do antepost. If it's between proven form and potential, the former any time but no regrets if the latter prevails. |
|
By:
PP was favourite for the Gold Cup last April as I recall. Long before Might Bite and NR ran at Haydock or Kempton. The confidence does remind me a bit of Arkle (justified) and Beef or Salmon (not justified). When a horse is a mile ahead of the rest in Ireland they are backed accordingly regardless of what might be around in GB.
|
|
By:
"When a horse is a mile ahead of the rest in Ireland they are backed accordingly regardless of what might be around in GB"
Is that so? How have you arrived at that conclusion regards PP? He's only had 2 chases eg beaten 7l by Our Duke, and beat a non-stayer in Monalee (his only claim to fame); ran in a handicap hurdle at the Festival. He's not run against RTR; Kemboy; Gods Own; Bellshill; etc. Unlike Don Cossack (DC): ran in RSA; Ryanair; Mildmay; John Durkan; King George; etc. No More Heroes (NMH): ran in AB; Drinmore; Neville Hotel; RSA (injury). I think PP at present has not achieved a smidgeon of either DC or NMH or even Djakadam. |
|
By:
No more heroes
Ah yes this was the talking horse last year You talk absolute boleaux pal |
|
By:
I am not referring to his form but to the hype that has surrounded the horse since he won the Pertemps.
|
|
By:
What was wrong with No More Heroes? He'd much better credentials and experience than PP; he'd have won the RSA had he not sustained a fatal injury just after taking up the running 2 out; he was always given an atrocious ride by Cooper in the Albert Barlett trying to come up the rails to challenge when there was very little room - she was impeded by the 2nd both in the same ownership.
|
|
By:
I just looked up the word "substandard" in the dictionary and it gave me a link to this
1st Blaklion 11-4 Ryan Hatch N A Twiston-Davies 7 8/1 2nd ½ Shaneshill (IRE) 11-4 P Townend W P Mullins 7 16/1 3rd 8 More Of That (IRE) 11-4 B J Geraghty Jonjo O'Neill 8 6/4f 4th ¾ No More Heroes (IRE) 11-4 B J Cooper G Elliott 7 5/2 5th 1¼ Vyta Du Roc (FR) 11-4 D A Jacob N J Henderson 7 12/1 6th 10 Roi Des Francs (FR) 11-4 R Walsh W P Mullins 7 10/1 7th 12 Seeyouatmidnight 11-4 B S Hughes A M Thomson 8 9/1 8th 2 Le Mercurey (FR) 11-4 Sam Twiston-Davies P F Nicholls 6 33/1 |
|
By:
If PP'S was a substandard RSA what the fook was that, even allowing for NMH injury...what's left?
|
|
By:
To say a race is substandard, we have to know what is a standard one.
Anyone care to name me a standard one, then i can compare. |
|
By:
The benefit of hindsight provides a very good guide as I've shown above, imp was banging the substandard drum with regards to PP, then he trumpeted No More Heroes who ironically took part in what subsequent events has shown to be, well, a substandard RSA...quite funny really.
|
|
By:
Well ive got hindsight on a lot of RSA's,but i still aint sure what a standard one is!!
|
|
By:
PP beating Monalee could turn out to be very good in terms of an RSA,certainly nothing to say it was a poor one yet.
Monalee run well against the big boys over xmas till running out of steam. PP would not have run out of steam. Still think his price is too short,but the form with Monalee puts him in with a fair chance. |