Forums

Cheltenham Festival

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 120 comments are related to the topic:
Cheltenham Pricewise

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 3 of 4  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 120
By:
buddeliea
When: 03 Jan 12 20:13
There will be e/w alternative,and that could well be a big priced one,and one that is run to finish in the places,as has happened often in the past.
Any horse that tries to win the race besides the 2 favs will not be placed imo.
I am presuming by the way that Grand Crus aint running,but if he does he imo makes it a 3 horse race.

There are 2 that still interest me at big odds that i have backed,trouble is they are tied in with the novices that have been running not that well - Quel Esprit and Jessies Dream,so its hopeful at best really.
By:
FOYLESWAR
When: 03 Jan 12 20:14
also are we taking into consideration that captain chris missed work and hobbs said that if the race was run a week earlier he would not have run . we should see if he stays or not in the aon denman chase if he dont then the ryanaire or champion chase are  the option but im hopefull!
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 03 Jan 12 20:18
has anyone told Kauto he's 12?
By:
buddeliea
When: 03 Jan 12 20:19
So basically the Kempton thrashing is ignored,the flawed jumping this season also ignored.
Fair enough.
By:
shockster
When: 03 Jan 12 20:24
Bud although I agree with you regarding CC.  I have to say the stats are massively against the top 2.  Quel Esprit could be anything or nothing and it's form doesn't tie in with last years novices as it fell twice, therefore it is unexposed.  Jessies Dream unfortunately ties in with a very poor generation and I could not have it.  Nicholls is training What A Friend for gold Cup as stated in todays Racing Post and as he was a nose behind Kauto last year, he'll do for me.
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 03 Jan 12 20:26
do you not think the fact that fell twice might mean he is exposed...as a bad jumper! Grin
By:
shockster
When: 03 Jan 12 20:28
Kauto has fallen more than once, is he a bad jumper?
By:
buddeliea
When: 03 Jan 12 20:30
yeh,WAF has place claims but cannot see him beating the front 2.Fair point re QE and being unexposed,and if his jumping is as good as lto that would be encouraging.
Not too bothered re the stats,Kauto seems in top form this season and Long Run winning again is quiet possible given what looks to me a worse race than last year.
By:
Colonel Sanders
When: 03 Jan 12 20:31
I said earlier he often has to tip something for the sake of it, said this could be another one. IMO it is

I took 33/1 NRNB after the King George and am happy enough with that. I don't think 20/1 is great value especially if it's ante post. There must be a 50/50 chance he won't run FFS

The idea of price wise is value betting, this IMO of course, is anything but

14/1 now ante post for christ's sake. Laughable
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 03 Jan 12 20:32
sorry shockster - only kidding.

I'm warming to the idea that Kauto and Denman might've cut each other's throat last year leaving Long Run to pick up the pieces - Kauto was out on his feet at the end last year so personally would n't read too much into proximity of WAF.

On the other hand, Long Run has that massive Cadoudal engine like Big Bucks so maybe just needs the extended Gold Cup trip to be seem to best effect.
By:
FOYLESWAR
When: 03 Jan 12 20:34
budd according to hobbs he didnt travel or jump as well as he usually does in the king george   and if he runs and jumps and travelles like he did at kempton then he will obviously struggle to make the frame in the gold cup  ,he might not even run in the gold cup if he dissapoints in his trial ,but the game is all about ifs and buts ,lets put it another way what if he jumps and travels and is 100% spot on for the gold cup , my take on it is that at the festival most  horses are going for it 100%  and primed for the big day and as a result jump better and travel better ! as they are much fitter and have been brought to thier peak for the big day  some exeptions obviously .
By:
shockster
When: 03 Jan 12 20:35
No offence taken RH, enjoy the banter.  I actually think Quel Esprit is the best handicapped horse in training, but that is a big step from Gold Cup winner.
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 03 Jan 12 20:39
Quel Esprit 5 chases 2 falls, 1 brought down completion rate 40%

Kauto Star 30 chases, 2 falls, 1 unseat, 1 pulled up ccompletion rate 87%

Bit of a difference would n't you agree?
By:
denman85
When: 03 Jan 12 20:41
shockster,  whats quel esprit handicap?? the fact that he cant jump!!!
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 03 Jan 12 20:42
Nah, mate - I was being facetious, not so dogmatic that i'd dismiss him on that limited evidence but I'd want to see him complete once (or even twice) before I thought about backing him - if I miss out on him at a big price, sobeit

You can come on here and say you told me so.
By:
shockster
When: 03 Jan 12 20:46
I think you'll find it's 3 falls for Kauto. Remounted at Exeter when it was allowed.  Anyway I get your drift, and there are obviously risks involved with backing QE.  However the potential is there and the falls I believe mask the ability.
By:
FOYLESWAR
When: 03 Jan 12 20:52
33s lads nrnb shockster or 40s with the risks attached good to see someone going against the crowd .good luck he is unexposed and if his jumping is sorted then who knows .
By:
shockster
When: 03 Jan 12 20:55
Just checked GC betting on here and 120 available on QE this morning, last price matched 42.  Not had a penny on myself but someone has.
By:
shockster
When: 03 Jan 12 20:57
Foyle, I'm on What A Friend and a few quid on Tidal bay lol, hoping Nicholls can weave his magic with either. Both under radar as in the shadows of his other stars.
By:
wellchief
When: 03 Jan 12 20:57
Shockster, ive said on here a few times that Quel Esprit is ridiculously well handicapped and I really want him to go for the Billy Hills chase on day one, but no bookie has him priced up.

Captain chris probably has the most potential of those behind the top three.  Do i think he will win the Gold Cup this year? No, but he can definitely be placed.
By:
buddeliea
When: 03 Jan 12 20:59
foyles,
he did not jump well at exeter either,but i take your points about Hobbs comments mate.
Lets wait for his next run then,no problem with that.
At least if he dont stay when hes right then he wont run in GC and you get yer money back.
By:
seary
When: 03 Jan 12 21:00
Its simple really, pricewise is all about value and at this present time, well up until today when the selection was made. Captain chris was the best value in the race.
Like others have said tom has to make this selection, so he had to pick something and you cant really argue that Captain chris a 20/1 shot is bad value in a race where anything could happen and also so much time before race is run.
CC finished third in a king george that form is nuffink to be sniffed at. Still if i was the owners i would give it another year and head fot the champion chase instead. why rush things??
By:
shockster
When: 03 Jan 12 21:00
Wellchief, I hope he goes for the Racing Post Chase at Kempton. Then we'll see if he stands up where he should go.
By:
buddeliea
When: 03 Jan 12 21:16
Seary,he finished 20 lengths behind the 2 horses he has to beat in the Gold Cup.

just cos a horse is a fairly big price dont make him the best value,especially when that horse has absolutely no top form at anywhere near 3m 2f.Added to that hes just failed to stay a race over 2f shorter than the race hes being tipped up for.
Its a complete guess by pricewise and personally i would want a bigger price than he advised,a lot bigger on his form this season.So i can argue all day that its bad value.
However i have just agreed to give the horse another chance on the srength of what Foyles says re the trainers comments that he werent right.I think pricewise will be hoping this horse stays better next time,otherwise he will have tipped up a non runner.
By:
tomdeane
When: 03 Jan 12 21:18
Foyles - Totally agree with what you are saying regarding Captain Chris.

To me he did not run like a non-stayer at Kempton, he just didn't travel at any stage and his jumping was bad. I think, given that he improves considerably in the Spring (or at least it seems he does), it was to his great credit that he grabbed third after such a laboured display.

Most horses with genuine class stay all day IF they can get into a rhythm. That is the major 'if' with him as he wouldn't have a hope unless he jumps better, but if he was to do that I think he has the class to stay the trip. Whether he is good enough is another matter but he really was the obvious one in my opinion.

As ever, I am a big fan of Pricewise and do respect him, but these ante-post features are about finding horses that will go off much shorter on the day, and to that end he's already on to a winner if he turns up, which does look likely at this stage.
By:
shockster
When: 03 Jan 12 21:22
Tom, whatever Pricewise picks goes off shorter.  come on.
By:
tomdeane
When: 03 Jan 12 21:23
Bud - you could argue that finishing 20l behind Kauto Star and Long Run when he was never comfortable at any stage of the race was a better performance than finishing 7l or whatever it was behind Ghizao getting 10lb at a similar time last term. He went on to win the Arkle like a very good horse.

Anyone that doubts it is possible for him to improve to play a hand in the Gold Cup should really study his form last season. There was not really any possible suggestion that he could reverse form with the other major players but he did, and he did it well, while looking as though the two miles was too short for him. Am sounding like I'm in love with the horse, and I'm actually not. Have never backed him, but just feel he is the one that would be silly to dismiss out of hand.

On another note, I agree with the person that said Synchronised at 171 is a total joke. Does anyone actually believe that? I'm sure he has improved, I'm sure he is not just a soft ground plodder. But I'm also sure he is a good bit further behind Kauto and Long Run than those figures suggest.
By:
tomdeane
When: 03 Jan 12 21:25
Shockster - true, but this is because he has such a good long-standing record and is far, far more often right than wrong regarding a horse's true price. Guess what I'm saying is that, as others have said, he has to put something up for these features and will probably very often pick the one that he sees as being too big - even if he doesn't really fancy it. His ante-post selections are classic value picks.
By:
shockster
When: 03 Jan 12 21:28
Guess I'm with Bud on this one CC not for me.
By:
buddeliea
When: 03 Jan 12 21:30
True he did not travel or jump.He got 3rd cos of Somersby not staying,the rest either injured or not good enough at this level.
He got beat 20 lenghts.
Any backers of CC for the Gold Cup best hope that Hobbs comments are on the mark.And if they are he has a serious amount of improvement to do.
Still think he will be in the Ryanair,but we will see.
By:
buddeliea
When: 03 Jan 12 21:40
Tom,but last year he had form at the distance required or a bit further.Now he has to prove he stays a lot further and failed at his only attempt,big difference mate.

At the end of the day Pricewise has tipped up a horse out of form,that is not travelling or jumping well,has just got thrashed by 2 of his opponents and has never run well at the required distance or anywhere near it.
By:
FOYLESWAR
When: 03 Jan 12 21:54
yep budd its all good debate and what the forum is all about ,if we all agreed on everything the game would be boring  ,the great thing about these threads is that it prompts knowledgable posters  to come up with opinions and insight that we can all learn from ,little snippets that may be missed without debate , i remember the thread put up last year by one of the owners of imperial commander from the year before when he won the gold cup ! reports of the wellbeing and progress of the horse , usefull  info direct from the horses mouth son to speak.
By:
ReaseHeath
When: 03 Jan 12 22:00
^ Kauto has just tweeted to say he's had a nice carrots and oats dinner with a couple of polos for dessert. He's off for a kip now but looking forward to his canter in the morning though he is missing his companion on the gallops Master Minded.He's catering with something called Big Buck's now who seems to think a lot of himself

@Kauto8Star
By:
Steamship
When: 03 Jan 12 22:15
Thanks for the serious good natured debate. Start looking for next weeks pick in the Champion Hdl.
By:
dtamutants
When: 04 Jan 12 01:36
I think that everyone saying that the GC will definitely be Kauto and Long Run forecast is faintly ridiculous, and I'd be really surprised if that's the case. I can't have Grands Crus winning the race either, because I just don't think he'll stay, and because of his inexperience. Long Run definitely deserves to be favourite, but he's far from bombproof, and I think if Captain Chris wins his prep, which must surely be the Ascot Chase as he wouldn't want to be taking on either Long Run or Time For Rupert and Grands Crus, then he'll definitely be single figures and would deserve to be.

As for next week, I think the Champion Hurdle horse will be Oscars Well. He's been running in 2 mile races with no pace which wouldn't have suited at all, while still running well, and given the improvement he showed in the Spring last year, and his liking for Cheltenham. He'll be much better suited to a much stiffer track, and a stronger pace which will hopefully be guaranteed by Overturn, and I think 25/1 NRNB is a great price.
By:
sizer
When: 04 Jan 12 02:43
Next weeks tip will be the Real Article.
By:
tomdeane
When: 04 Jan 12 07:04
Bud,

You might very well be right here, but I guess the major point I am making about him i simply that he could well be capable of major improvement on what we have seen so far from him this term (based on previous Spring improvement), and most importantly of all, I don't think for one second that the King George showed he didn't stay!

Maybe he won't stay the Gold Cup trip but I don't think the King George can be used as evidence against him. When Kauto Star got beaten by Denman he barely held off Neptune Collonges for second, and again last year, he only just got home in front of What A Friend in third. After those performances people are saying he probably won't get home well enough to win it again this year but they are casually neglecting the fact that he stormed up it to win in superb style in 2009 when regaining the throne.

I personally am convinced this is because he jumped and settled into a rhythm on that occasion, unlike the times he was defeated. And so it is for most horses - if you don't find your rhythm you can be made to look a non-stayer at any trip, which is why I think Captain Chris did pretty well to snatch third when he looked like being pulled up with almost a circuit to go.

Major 'ifs' and 'buts' and as I've said before I'm not particularly in his camp, but I do feel there is every chance he'll get the trip 'if' he jumps better and travels more kindly.
By:
buddeliea
When: 04 Jan 12 07:37
Ok Tom,thats fair points mate.
lets see how he gets on next time,maybe i am reading it wrong.
Surely not!!Laugh
By:
tomdeane
When: 04 Jan 12 07:51
Me too Bud! He might be a total non-stayer but time will tell. These reasoned differences of opinion are what makes the forum work!
By:
buddeliea
When: 04 Jan 12 08:00
They are indeed mate.
My feeling straight after the KG was that Somersby and Captain Chris simply did not stay.
Somersby who i was watching closely as i backed him jumped and travelled really well and just did not get home so no excuse-did not stay.
But as you rightfully point out CC did not travel and jump,so yes its certainly possible that was the reason he got beat so far,rather than simply not staying.
Hobbs says he werent right as has been pointed out.
Horse deserves another chance to convince us he is a GC contender.
Page 3 of 4  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com