Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Bloodstock & Breeding

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
Keith Lard
28 May 10 10:59
Joined:
Date Joined: 17 Apr 04
| Topic/replies: 111 | Blogger: Keith Lard's blog
Come on then. Which ones are best bred for the derby & oaks?

Derby

Midas Touch looks a likely type to me (though I know next to nothing about breeding) being a Galileo out of a Darshaan mare. The dam side of Cape Blanco's pedigree is very speedy, so I see him going for the French Derby. Both SNA & Jan Vermeer will stay fine won't they? I'm on Midas Touch at 14s after he won the Derrinstown and am more than happy with that.

Oaks

Rumoush will stay won't she? Her sister has won over 12f, so that'll do for me. Love that she's a half sister to Ghanaati and Mawatheeq (from a blue blood pov). Akdarena is stoutly bred (too much so?). Doubts about Timepiece staying? I like the fact that Aviate has taken over from Rumoush at the head of the market and my dough will be on Tregoning's filly.

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 1 of 2  •  Previous 1 | 2 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 65
By:
Prima Donna
When: 28 May 10 13:11
I suppose when it comes down to the top races what is needed is a real turn of foot,horses that have this are as a rule few and far between,that always stamps there class and sets them as a rule above the rest.
Montjeu had this more so really than Galileo,for this years Derby I think Midas Touch could be found out for that, to me he could be just lacking for toe when push comes to shove,his win the other day looked good but to my eye he came with a long run and imo went past dying horses,you could think he may be one for the St.Leger,but we will have to see,but good luck with your selection.
Jan Vermeer will stay every yard of the trip,his win also looked very good indeed but in a way that race was very much set up for him with only a small field,Cape Blanco won his race in a fashion of a horse that would make you feel he will also stay,in a way the good horses need a mix of speed and stamina,but most important of all a turn of foot,horses also need to on top of there form going into the Derby,Cape Blanco finishing lame was not a good omen as he has had a break.I like SNA and feel that his class along with his turn of foot will come through I'm going to forget his GNS run because the race started slowly then finished like a sprint,a staying horse with speed can and do get themsleves beat like this,what I do know is that SNA has been working very well since NMKT so for me along with his pedigree I very much hope he does it.
By:
sageform
When: 28 May 10 13:50
Derby: Bright Horizon Galileo/Kissogram-Caerleon. Plenty of stamina and dam was a group winner. Caerleon should help with coping with fast ground if required.
Midas Touch. Galileo out of a Darshaan mare. Plenty of stamina and I love Darshaan mares. Again should cope with fast ground.
Bullet Train: Sadlers Wells out of a Danehill mare. The two most infuential sires of the last 20 years.

Oaks is more open. Akdarena is out of a Shirley Heights mare. Aviate by Dansili not sure to stay. Gertrude Bell by Sinndar whose progeny are mostly very slow but out of a miler. Gile na Greine, Galileo/Danehill. Timepiece by Zamindar but stamina from Sadlers Wells mare.
By:
push
When: 28 May 10 17:20
I would say you have selected the best bred horse for the Derby and Oaks , Keith. Always worth having a saver on the best bred horse in Classics. Ghanaati and Makfi would have been the best bred in their Guineas.
By:
perrydinho
When: 28 May 10 19:03
I always have a look at the Derby a year in advance and have a couple of ante post nibbles on correctly bred types - only 4 or 5 current sires can get a derby winner & all need a decent broodmare sire with no stamina worries

That took me to Moby ****, Don Leone (both of which are useless) and fortunately Midas Touch

Midas Touch looks a stand out, right down to winning his trial in a fast time (just like his sire did in 2001 before going on to epsom glory). The only negative stat was getting beat in a Group race after winning a maiden as most derby winners dont. Jan V has excellent credentials as well and obviously SNA will be a danger to all if back to RP form but for me Midas Touch has it all... although so did Fame and Glory on the same basis last year!

For those looking to 2011, i reckon the winner will come from this lot (currently weeding them out)


Sire    Dam    Dam Sire
Dalakhani       Shemala      Danehill
Dalakhani       Special Delivery      Danehill
Dalakhani       Rainbow City      Rainbow Quest
Dalakhani       Atlantic Destiny      Royal Academy
Dalakhani       Alchemy      Sadler´s Wells
Dalakhani       Canouan      Sadler´s Wells
Dalakhani       Lisieux Orchid      Sadler´s Wells
Dalakhani       On Fair Stage      Sadler´s Wells
Dalakhani       Peace Talk      Sadler´s Wells
Dalakhani       Lune Rouge      Unfuwain
Dalakhani       Thakafaat      Unfuwain
Dalakhani       Vadawina      Unfuwain
El Prado       Hasheema      Darshaan
Galileo       Distinctive Look      Danehill
Galileo       Kind      Danehill
Galileo       Kitza      Danehill
Galileo       Last Love      Danehill
Galileo       Maroochydore      Danehill
Galileo       Secret Garden      Danehill
Galileo       St Roch      Danehill
Galileo       Charroux      Darshaan
Galileo       Puce     Darshaan
Galileo       Tadkiyra      Darshaan
Galileo       Hanami     Hernando
Galileo       Miss Riviera Golf     Hernando
Galileo       La Sky      Law Society
Galileo       Walkamia      Linamix
Galileo       Comeraincomeshine      Night Shift
Galileo       High Praise      Quest For Fame
Galileo       Key To Coolcullen      Royal Academy
Galileo       Tina Heights     Shirley Heights
Galileo       Magnificient Style      Silver Hawk
Galileo       Silverskaya      Silver Hawk
Galileo       Skidmore Girl      Vaguely Noble
Hernando       Mydarshaan     Darshaan
High Chaparral       Pay The Bank     High Top
Hurricane Run       Figlette     Darshaan
Hurricane Run       Flaming Song      Darshaan
Hurricane Run       Borghesa      Galileo
Hurricane Run       Kiftsgate Rose      Nashwan
Hurricane Run       Sachet      Royal Academy
Medaglia D´Oro       Vanity Flair      Affirmed
Medaglia D´Oro       Kendall Hill      Theatrical
Montjeu       Bywayofthestars     Danehill
Montjeu       Prove     Danehill
Montjeu       Alasana      Darshaan
Montjeu       Gwynn      Darshaan
Montjeu       Jaya      Ela-Mana-Mou
Montjeu       Welsh Love     Ela-Mana-Mou
Montjeu       Colorspin      High Top
Montjeu       Dancingintheclouds      Rainbow Quest
Montjeu       Red Azalea     Shirley Heights
Oasis Dream      Alexandrine      Nashwan
Oasis Dream      Maganda      Sadler´s Wells
Oasis Dream      Modesta      Sadler´s Wells
Oasis Dream      Wyola      Sadler´s Wells
By:
ben10
When: 28 May 10 19:49
Oasis Dream? What gives him an edge over, say, Pivotal or Dansili?
By:
potentialmillionaire
When: 28 May 10 20:25
Do Pivotal colts get a top class 1 1/2 miles. No, that's the job of his fillies. Dansili would be more likely, Rail Link, Zambezi Sun suggest he shouldn't be ignored. Dynaformer, Medaglia D'Oro, Street Cry, Monsun, Hurricane Run, Shirocco may all throw a spanner in the above too.
By:
potentialmillionaire
When: 28 May 10 20:28
Jeez, why didn't I re read that, apol for H.Run and M. d'oro!
By:
ben10
When: 28 May 10 20:39
Don't really get top class Oasis Dreams over 12f either, seems a strange inclusion imo when like you say there are plenty of other sires who can throw a spanner in the works.
Those dams don't look much cop to me either and Wyola's Oasis Dream colt has already raced, Approve, a 5 furlong winner for Willie Haggas
By:
push
When: 28 May 10 20:52
STS, another example of the best bred horse in a Classic.
By:
potentialmillionaire
When: 28 May 10 21:05
Too early to say Oasis Dream won't do it, I think.
By:
ben10
When: 28 May 10 21:12
Can definitely say Approve won't ;)
By:
perrydinho
When: 28 May 10 23:56
I agree that Pivotal and Oasis Dream are unlikely but this is a work in progress going from a list of 400+ down to hopefully 2 or 3

also not sure about danehill as a broodmare sire for the derby

not looked in that much detail yet but nothing has caught my eye as yet

STS def had the best dam last year but before the event his danzig top line was not copper bottomed to be at his best at 12f & its still probably safer to keep him as a special one off. Best bred horse did not win in 1996 unfortunately for me! although his half brother did in 1993
By:
perrydinho
When: 28 May 10 23:59
and forgot to mention, foaling date before April, desirable verging on the essential as is being located at top stable (Stoute/Johnston/Godolphin and the coolmore operation)
By:
perrydinho
When: 29 May 10 00:19
1999 - b h Fairy King (USA) - Sheer Audacity (Troy)
2000 - b h Grand Lodge (USA) - Sinntara (IRE) (Lashkari/MillReef)
2001 - b h Sadler's Wells (USA) - Urban Sea (USA) (Miswaki)
2002 - b h Sadler's Wells (USA) - Kasora (IRE) (Darshaan)
2003 - ch h Kris S (USA) - Angel In My Heart (FR) (Rainbow Quest)
2004 - b h Danehill (USA) - Sought Out (IRE) (Rainbow Quest)
2005 - b h Montjeu (IRE) - Out West (USA) (Gone West)
2006 - b h Mark Of Esteem (IRE) - Percy's Lass (Blakeney)
2007 - b h Montjeu (IRE) - Funsie (FR) (Saumarez)
2008 - ch h Galileo (IRE) - Park Express (Ahonoora)
2009 - b c Cape Cross (IRE) - Urban Sea (USA) (Miswaki)

which seems to suggest on average, elite class sire & a stoutly bred mare with Mr P only appearing on the bottom line and then only via the exceptional blue hen Urban Sea

and going back to this years field, which of these pedigrees would look most at home on that list

bay colt Azamour (IRE) — Best Side (IRE) (King´s Best (USA))
bay colt Beat Hollow — Highbrook (USA) (Alphabatim (USA))
bay colt Galileo (IRE) — Approach (Darshaan)
bay colt Galileo (IRE) — Kissogram (Caerleon (USA))
bay colt Galileo (IRE) — Vagary (IRE) (Zafonic (USA))
chesnut colt Galileo (IRE) — Healing Music (FR) (Bering)
chesnut colt Galileo (IRE) — Laurel Delight (Presidium)
chesnut colt Galileo (IRE) — Shapely (USA) (Alleged (USA))
bay colt King´s Best (USA) — Soviet Moon (IRE) (Sadler´s Wells (USA))
bay colt Medaglia D´Oro (USA) — Bayou Plans (USA) (Bayou Hebert (USA))
bay colt Monsun (GER) — Ailette (Second Set (IRE))
bay colt Montjeu (IRE) — Apache Star (Arazi (USA))
bay colt Montjeu (IRE) — Leaping Water (Sure Blade (USA))
bay colt Montjeu (IRE) — Shadow Song (IRE) (Pennekamp (USA))
bay colt Motivator — Model Queen (USA) (Kingmambo (USA))
bay colt Red Ransom (USA) — Style Setter (USA) (Manila (USA))
bay colt Sadler´s Wells (USA) — Kind (IRE) (Danehill (USA))
bay colt Selkirk (USA) — Surval (IRE) (Sadler´s Wells (USA))
bay colt Smart Strike (CAN) — Abita (USA) (Dynaformer (USA))


when you add in the form profiles, surely all roads lead to Midas Touch
By:
perrydinho
When: 29 May 10 00:48
So unless Coolmore do something odd... if its to be a typical winner, its Midas Touch


Horse    Pedigree    Foaling        RPR        BM AWD       
Midas Touch    bay colt Galileo (IRE) — Approach (Darshaan)    22-Feb-07    ok    130    ok    11.7f    ok   
Workforce    bay colt King´s Best (USA) — Soviet Moon (IRE) (Sadler´s Wells (USA))    14-Mar-07    ok    128    ok    11.2f    ok    Mr P topline/beaten in the Dante…
Jan Vermeer    bay colt Montjeu (IRE) — Shadow Song (IRE) (Pennekamp (USA))    06-Feb-07    ok    135    ok    8.2f    x   
Chabal    bay colt Galileo (IRE) — Vagary (IRE) (Zafonic (USA))    10-Feb-07    ok    130    ok    8.7f    x   
Coordinated Cut    bay colt Montjeu (IRE) — Apache Star (Arazi (USA))    14-Feb-07    ok    126    ok    9.6f    x   
Bullet Train    bay colt Sadler´s Wells (USA) — Kind (IRE) (Danehill (USA))    28-Jan-07    ok    125    ok    9.1f    x   
Azmeel    bay colt Azamour (IRE) — Best Side (IRE) (King´s Best (USA))    14-Feb-07    ok    125    ok    8.7f    x   
    bay colt Medaglia D´Oro (USA) — Bayou Plans (USA) (Bayou Hebert (USA))    11-Feb-07    ok    124    x           
    bay colt Beat Hollow — Highbrook (USA) (Alphabatim (USA))    06-Mar-07    ok    121    x           
    bay colt Motivator — Model Queen (USA) (Kingmambo (USA))    12-Mar-07    ok    116    x           
    bay colt Selkirk (USA) — Surval (IRE) (Sadler´s Wells (USA))    01-Feb-07    ok    104    x           
    bay colt Galileo (IRE) — Kissogram (Caerleon (USA))    20-Mar-07    ok    97    x           
    bay colt Monsun (GER) — Ailette (Second Set (IRE))    05-Apr-07    x                   
    chestnut colt Galileo (IRE) — Healing Music (FR) (Bering)    10-Apr-07    x                   
    bay colt Montjeu (IRE) — Leaping Water (Sure Blade (USA))    13-Apr-07    x                   
    chestnut colt Galileo (IRE) — Laurel Delight (Presidium)    20-Apr-07    x                   
    chestnut colt Galileo (IRE) — Shapely (USA) (Alleged (USA))    01-May-07    x                   
    bay colt Smart Strike (CAN) — Abita (USA) (Dynaformer (USA))    18-May-07    x
By:
ben10
When: 29 May 10 01:04
Could be right about Midas, I'd want a strong pace though.

What about this one for next year Mischief

Voodoo Prince

    * 2-y-o (09Feb08 b c)
    * Kingmambo (USA)  (9.9f) — Ouija Board (Cape Cross (IRE)  (8.7f))
    * Trainer E A L Dunlop
    * Owner Lord Derby
By:
perrydinho
When: 29 May 10 10:35
Given the Mr P sire line, French Derby for Voodoo Prince

Would be lovely if Ouija turned out to be a great producer, that nassau with the equally wonderful Alex Gudrun was one of the all time great filly races
By:
push
When: 29 May 10 10:44
Perry, foaling date is not that important for the Derby. winners foaled in April =STS, Oath, winners foaled in May = C in Chief, Erhaab, High Rise. 
As for next year i like the pedigree of  Galileo -Magnificient Style ( Silver Hawk ).
By:
perrydinho
When: 29 May 10 12:02
Foaling date not that important but its just common sense to have it on your side for races up to the derby and where it falls in a horse career ... although as someone who has two foals this year on 22nd april and 8th may i hope your forgiving attitude is prevalent in the sales ring in december '-)

all the stats are just guidance towards the typical types and the clever and fun bit is the interpretation

Your Galileo -Magnificient Style ( Silver Hawk ) ticks a lot of boxes, although the high class mare has got plenty of blacktype performers none has really done it at gp1 level and the best performers were from her earlier crops
By:
ben10
When: 29 May 10 12:27
Yeah perhaps it's just a little too stout for a modern Derby horse.
On paper Ouija Board's colt looks a real prospect, ignore the stamina index of Cape Cross, she had plenty of stamina and her family has loads as well. Kingmambo, granted, doesn't get stayers but I like the blend and it all depends on how good Ouija Board is as a mare imo. I think in Derby horses now a days you want one that will just about get 12f but be better a 10f, i.e they have a bit more tactical speed.
By:
mightymoyes
When: 29 May 10 13:21
any news yet on where voodoo prince will make his debut?
By:
push
When: 29 May 10 14:10
Ben 10 take a look at the pedigree of Authorized, you will not get a more stamina packed  pedigree than that , and he won the Derby, also Montjeu had plenty of stamina in his pedigree.
By:
potentialmillionaire
When: 29 May 10 22:00
Ben 10, Kingmambo has had 100+ winners at 12f or beyond including Lemon Drop Kid, Rule of Law, Alkaased and El Condor Pasa. Sure he could do with a little help from the dam, but I wouldn't rule out Ouija Board on that score!
Mighty, don't expect Voodoo Prince just yet.
By:
Prima Donna
When: 29 May 10 22:46
I am of the opinion like you PotM, Kingmambo is a secret sire of stamina, this horse IMO should be treated with caution when covering.
By:
ben10
When: 30 May 10 11:17
Authorized's best performance for me was in the International and he was a good winner of the RP Trophy, although I do agree on paper he looks fairly stout tbf.
Kingmambo doesn't get stayers in the same way Montjeu does for example is what I meant. As I pointed out though Voodoo Prince should want a trip. MM, if he does want a trip I wouldn't expect to see him out until around September; Ouija Board herslef didn't race until October.
By:
push
When: 30 May 10 12:02
Rewilding , would have to be one of the contenders for best bred horse in the Derby being a half brother to Dar Re Mi.
By:
perrydinho
When: 30 May 10 13:31
Thinking about Voodoo Prince, if he has a classic in him its likely to be the 2000gns

out of Mr P stallion, the fantastically bred Kingmambo who was by Mr P himself out of the all-time legend Miesque, who herself was by Nureyev, and out of a cape cross mare who was out of a half sister to lord derbys teleprompter

of all kingmambos 12f performers, most were older horses/raced outside the UK where 11f+ races are less competitive compared to the 7-10f races, and surely if Mr P was going to give us a derby winner he would have done it by now


Admittedly there was some stamina in Ouija's dam but overall it just reads mile/10f and also being a first foal it may not be the best she will produce

that said, i watched in awe from the centre of the course as Ouija powered clear in her oaks having thought she would not stay, so what do i know ;-)
By:
RipVanWinkle
When: 30 May 10 16:46
He's just going to be a hype horse and turn out a total flop. The **** i was hearing last year about Benvenuto Henrythenavigator's full brother was unreal i was hearing guineas and st.james palaces that he would be suited to ascot it was clear rubbish cause he turned out to be a donkey.

I would say not to back him and dont get fooled by all the talk about him before his debut cause it can cost alot hope i'm wrong cause i'd love to see him do well cause not to often do top notch racemares turnout top notch in the breeding shed.
By:
potentialmillionaire
When: 30 May 10 21:09
Perry, I think statistically a mare's 2nd or 3rd foal is likely to be her best followed pretty closeley by the 1st apparently. This goes against our conventional thought doesn't it, but I think I am quite inclined to go with it, particularly as both English Guineas winners are 1st foals!
I think a mare like Ouija Board does a great service to the profile of our game and it's fun to speculate how she'll get on in the paddocks too. I wish Voodoo Prince well!
By:
push
When: 30 May 10 22:08
New Approachs dam was old by the time he was foaled, so i would not count it against a mare , just on age.
By:
push
When: 31 May 10 20:13
Using RPost Ratings, Rewilding only needs to improve 4 lbs to be rated Tiger Hills best offspring.
By:
Prima Donna
When: 31 May 10 20:24
says it all then!Typical Darley OB sire.
By:
push
When: 31 May 10 20:29
Thought you would like Tiger Hill as he is by Danehill
By:
Prima Donna
When: 31 May 10 20:35
Don't like him at all Push,I remember when he first stood with Darley he was expensive,also didn't sell that well a lot of breeders got burnt fingers he was getting the hard sell last year,don't think he will make it buyers are very cold on him just now.Would't touch him with a barge pole,but you are right he has a great sire line,thats about the only thing I like about him.
By:
push
When: 31 May 10 20:39
Rewilding , out of a half sister to Darshaan, if he runs well in the Derby, i will follow him in the St Leger, Rewilding has potential to improve.
By:
Prima Donna
When: 31 May 10 20:44
Push,yes I agree with you Rewilding has a very high class family,and I too think he would be a class horse for the St.Leger Godawful do well with that race.Saying that though I expect him to run well next Sat',if you are on him good luck and with Workforce.
By:
push
When: 31 May 10 20:50
Hey , on JV,  at 40-1, just wish i had not layed so much off, thought he was going to France. Backed him right after his maiden win, and in France when he won at 16-1. Just hope the ground is not too firm for him at Epsom. I am on Workforce by  default as i thought he would run well in the Guineas and thus be a short price for the Derby, anyway been able to lay that one off easily at the crazy price he is.
By:
Prima Donna
When: 31 May 10 21:02
I really have never known a year for all the fuss with Ballydoyle runners with the massive thread about Steinbeck then SNA its almost given me a headache,I hope Henry Cecil wins next Sat' with Bullet Train,he may not be goodenough but if i'm right he said that about Commander in Chief,anyway glad you have some good prices I will be at Epsom this week,maybe you will hear me burst into tears when SNA gets stuffed again,or cheering when he swoops past them like a champion.
By:
push
When: 31 May 10 21:10
You sticking with SNA then ? I hope Bullet Train does not win, not much of a winner for my Derby portfolio. I tell myself that Bullet Trains form is not good enough to win, and he is rated too low, but i am surprised how much money there is for him , so maybe he has improved alot since his last race ? Just hope for Aidans sanity he gets the winner this year.
Have a great day at Epsom, and back Midas Touch ( eachway )Grin
Page 1 of 2  •  Previous 1 | 2 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com