X Factor 2010
Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
1. It's a fair tool, the judges decide after the sing-off.
2. Sometimes the judges are told how to vote, other times it is open for them to make the decision.
3. The decision is already made, and the quality of the performance in the sing-off is wholly irrelevant to the outcome.
What do y'all think?
2. Sometimes the judges are told how to vote, other times it is open for them to make the decision.
3. The decision is already made, and the quality of the performance in the sing-off is wholly irrelevant to the outcome.
What do y'all think?
Show More
Katie surviving - after forgetting lines, sitting down, saying sod it, desperately shouting "don't give up on me" rather than singing it, and doing it against good opposition - should remove any residual belief in 1. [;)]
Henry
Yes I thought she was just awful last week and I personally think TreyC was one of the very best singers on the show. Did well every week for me. Katie's sing off was especially awful so why Louis saved her I don't know. It could be he's told to yes or do we believe his explanation that he thinks Katie has 'something'?
Yes I thought she was just awful last week and I personally think TreyC was one of the very best singers on the show. Did well every week for me. Katie's sing off was especially awful so why Louis saved her I don't know. It could be he's told to yes or do we believe his explanation that he thinks Katie has 'something'?
Post Your Reply
Please login to post a reply.
Wonder
Instance ID: 13539