Forums

Tradefair & Financials

Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
paddletoe
19 Apr 10 18:18
Joined:
Date Joined: 24 Jul 07
| Topic/replies: 10,649 | Blogger: paddletoe's blog
Woner if someone could give me some advice about the pros and cons.

If i did buy gold it would be with money i dont need for the medium to long term so thinking more 5 to 10 years plus down the line.

I know its cheaper to buy gold and it being kept for you but i would probably want to keep it myself. It would be nice to look at now and again.

I would probably go for gold coins so i can easily hide them round the house.

One thing that i dont like is the fact there is about a 9% margin in the difference between the buy and sell price which means your down 9 % as soon as you buy the gold.

What i really want to know is in say 10 or 20 years what would the maximum upside and downside be in terms of value if i got say £20,000 worth of gold sometime soon.

From what i can gather from looking at the main factors which affect gold prices the biggest upside in value would come if we lived in a mad max style world. However, that is not something i would hope for!
Pause Switch to Standard View Thinking about buying Gold
Show More
Loading...
Report Rollo Tomasi April 19, 2010 6:38 PM BST
Think how many people now know there could soon be gold at your house.

If/When you buy some are you going to make it even easier and put a flag on your roof?

[pre]


PHYSICAL GOLD HERE

I
I
I
I
\/




[/pre]
Report mightymoyes April 19, 2010 10:10 PM BST
how many people can tell by reading the thread where his house is?!
Report Sir Denis Eton-Hogg April 19, 2010 10:22 PM BST
i can
Report Sir Denis Eton-Hogg April 19, 2010 10:35 PM BST
well its probably as good a store of wealth as any in these uncertain times but in all honesty at the end of the day u cant eat a piece of paper with the queens head on it and u cant eat a gold coin. at the end of the day its a bubble like every other investment
Report Sir Denis Eton-Hogg April 19, 2010 10:35 PM BST
at the end of the day
Report chisel April 20, 2010 10:00 AM BST
Paddletoe

Although gold has increased in value , its performance in comparison to equity markets during the past 12 months has been poor!
Report uptheowls April 20, 2010 11:39 AM BST
The only asset to make new highs since the financial crisis.

Poor showing Gold.
Report gatespeed April 20, 2010 12:35 PM BST
at the end of the day u cant eat a piece of paper with the queens head on it and u cant eat a gold coin

yes but u can always trade that gold coin for bread..you have been able to for thousands of years and you will be able for a thousand to come - cant say the same about fiat money can you?

Bottom line is mate if u study the history of money man has tried in vain countless times to operate a monetry system without gold and failed every time.. i cant see any reason why we're different this time

As for a bubble? Think of 50 people you know... ask yourself how many of those people own gold? when your mates, family, people at work and the like start talking about owning gold.. then u might consider a bubble forming, but at that time gold will be well north of where it is now.
Report Sir Denis Eton-Hogg April 20, 2010 1:14 PM BST
u dont need half the world to have invested for it to be a bubble. i speak as a gold investor but at the end of the day its gone up in value because its more in demand. whether that demand will be there in the future its very hard to know
Report V4 Vendetta April 20, 2010 3:22 PM BST
I've been long Gold for a while and have just taken physical delivery of some. Unless you have a lot of cash and want the physical for credit risk and financial collapse protection, then stick with futures rolled on a spreadbet (tax free) or an ETF. If you want physical for the previous reasons, you're right to buy some relatively smaller pieces (in terms of your total investment) as you might need to barter them in the unlikely even that all the economies collapse.

In terms of prices, I wouldn't think of holding it for 10-20 years. It's a good investment when it's good and it's bad when it's bad. It barely outperforms cash unless you include the spike years in the 70s and early 80s. We're having a spike now which I expect to go to at least $1400 this year and peak at either $2000 or $5000 if we have a double dip. Once it's gone down consistently for 9 months or so, I will probably exit it entirely assuming that is at least two years away. When it goes down, I think it will bounce off around $500, but that will not be before 2015 in my view simply because of the reflation policies going on and the upcoming Prime crisis (following the sub-prime...).
Report paddletoe April 20, 2010 3:38 PM BST
Yes Goring i saw you took delivery of a dozen gold bars on another thread. Out of interest may i ask why you bought bars rather than krugerands as the later would seem easier to sell in whatever quantity you wished.

If the worst came to the worst it would be a lot easier and economical to barter with krugerands than an expensive gold bar.
Report V4 Vendetta April 20, 2010 3:58 PM BST
I'd already bought them a while ago but had them in the vault. I would have had to pay a spread to change over so I didn't bother. I'm also figuring I'd have time to leg out of a few if it went Mad Max, but in short it's probably a mistake.
Report V4 Vendetta April 20, 2010 4:00 PM BST
I'm still a dip buyer so I'll get 1oz or 100g tablets next time - the bulk buying prices are pretty good once you buy a 1kg total or so anyway. I'm also easy about being long the physical because if the bubble breaks, it's easy to lob out a futures hedge and it's likely to be a less scary environment in terms of inflation/mad max if that happens. If it goes bad on the way up, you have nothing to buy them with etc.
Report Sir Denis Eton-Hogg April 20, 2010 6:15 PM BST
gold is a bubble but its a bubble that is hard to see bursting in a spectacular way coz we all know the world economy is fecked due to high oil prices and that aint gonna change
Report V4 Vendetta April 20, 2010 9:54 PM BST
The high oil prices are caused by the same thing that is causing all the high prices - low interest rates. Too low, too long.
Report niceone April 20, 2010 10:30 PM BST
I have also being thinking about buying some gold for the long term. A mix of sovereigns, kregerrands and some small ignots. As part of a varied portfolio i reckon its a good idea.
Report wykhamist April 21, 2010 12:43 AM BST
3 main ways to own gold:

1. bullionvault where they store it for u safely
2.Physical gold ETF like PHAU
3. Physical gold in your house. You can buy bars easily from Bairds

I am holding gold because I fear for the long term value of sterling and other fiat currencies. Gold will maintain its purchasing power as it has done throughout history.
Report V4 Vendetta April 21, 2010 8:26 AM BST
Unless you bought it in 1980-82 when you got muellered...
Report V4 Vendetta April 21, 2010 9:12 AM BST
Palladium going for it this last 24 hours. :D
Report MONEY TREE April 21, 2010 10:00 AM BST
upside = could be worth more than you paid.

downside= could be worth much less than you paid.
Report V4 Vendetta April 22, 2010 1:55 PM BST
Alternatively, moneytree.

downside - only $1150
upside - unlimited, probably...
Report chisel April 22, 2010 2:48 PM BST
The high oil prices are caused by the same thing that is causing all the high prices - low interest rates. Too low, too long.

I really dont think so Goring!

You still shorting the FTSE? I love it that investors in Gold are so focussed on one thing..Financial Meltdown! If you had come out of Gold last year and invested in Equities, particularly miners etc your returns would have been astronomical. You do know that you can take profit dont you ? Hence the mini dips on the FTSE, DOW..Onwards and upwards then!
Report chisel April 22, 2010 2:51 PM BST
Oh and in cas eyou want evidence, do you not think it ironic that as the oil price rose so did Interest rates. The price of oil actually fell when rates were cut.

It fell too far, and has regained some of its losses. Admittedly , I am concerned that th emedia.markets are talking the price back up! There is no shortage of the stuff after all!
Report V4 Vendetta April 22, 2010 3:46 PM BST
chisel 22 Apr 14:48

You still shorting the FTSE?


Yes, it's down 50 points today.

I love it that investors in Gold are so focussed on one thing..Financial Meltdown! If you had come out of Gold last year and invested in Equities, particularly miners etc your returns would have been astronomical. You do know that you can take profit dont you ? Hence the mini dips on the FTSE, DOW..Onwards and upwards then!


If you've only got a few bob I guess you have to put all your eggs in one basket. I have been long equities for a while (and gold) and am making a better correlation adjusted return as a result.

Oh and in cas eyou want evidence, do you not think it ironic that as the oil price rose so did Interest rates. The price of oil actually fell when rates were cut.

No because interest rates are responding after the fact as they're set by little old men instead of the market.

It fell too far, and has regained some of its losses. Admittedly , I am concerned that th emedia.markets are talking the price back up! There is no shortage of the stuff after all!


There's no shortage, but there's even a greater abundance of greenbacks, hence the 'rise' in both oil and gold.
Report uptheowls April 22, 2010 4:38 PM BST
Chisel - the HUI (Gold Miners Index) bottomed in October 2008 at 150, it is now at 425, an increase of 183%.

If you want to use your Tardis to make investments, then Gold Miners are right up there.

We don't all have it buried at the bottom of our garden you know.
Report MONEY TREE April 22, 2010 9:40 PM BST
I BOUGHT A LOAD LAST YEAR, WILL BE WORTH LOADS IN 10 YEARS.
Report ror April 23, 2010 12:24 AM BST
MONEY TREE tips gold? Uh oh!
Report Mrben April 23, 2010 7:46 AM BST
everytime i trade gold i lose money so dont listen to me.However if you buy gold long term you gotta keep it and not trade it.Long term you need physical delivery now not derivitive or trading instruments.Why? Because gold has long flat periods punctuated with spikes.If you miss one of those upward spikes you will miss a large part of the return.
I dont like gold as an investment because it just sits there, no divis, no rent, no interest.!0 year hold is a long time.Consider the compounding effect of interest etc.Consider the risk it may fall.My view is that cash will beat it once compounded.Just as it is possible gold will rise so too is it possible interest rates will rise.
The downside of interest is tax.I imagine it would be easy to cash gold in with no tax.Not same interest.
The reality is that all long term investment classes are showing poor returns.Pundits are saying that stocks have had a huge run.Only if you bought somewhere near the bottom.Long term holders are still behind 2008 prices and will be for a while.Real estate long term holders are behind.Gold long termers are finally in the black for a while now after 20 years of blot.
But if your buying now to become a longtermer- best of luck.
Report chisel April 23, 2010 9:36 AM BST
Mr B

What do you considr a long term holder??? I am a little confused as a LOMG TERM HOLDER of property would surely be well ahead! We are talking 7 - 10 years right?

I agree with you on gold, I think there are better places to invest for a) a speculative punt and B) a long term return with relatively low risk.. But , I must admit that a lot of your posts appear to suggest a long term holder is someone that has invested in teh last two years..

Can you clarify please

Goring

I have little doubt that you are a sensible investor. You obviously have the cash to play with so good luck to you ! i am of teh opinion that governemnt support is here for a long while yet. GDP fell 6% , and we have got 0.1% of it back. Our economy is based on GDP increasing year on year, tis is the only way we can fund our deficit and our public services. The only way to get this back is long term low interst rates.. Inflation is an issue, but I am convinced that with unemployment, lower wages, smaller bonuses , paying down debt , people will continue to excercise care with their money. I know I am!
Report V4 Vendetta April 23, 2010 9:59 AM BST
I agree almost entirely with that last paragraph. Low rates is another way of saying, "inflate" or print money. Whether or not it finds its way into the restricted CPI basket in the short or medium term is one question, but the thing about Oil and Gold is they ain't finding more of it at the same rate as they're printing money. One way or another, this is the main and common reason for the increase in those prices.
Report Mrben April 24, 2010 12:05 AM BST
hisel 23 Apr 18:36
Mr B

What do you considr a long term holder??? I am a little confused as a LOMG TERM HOLDER of property would surely be well ahead! We are talking 7 - 10 years right?

I agree with you on gold, I think there are better places to invest for a) a speculative punt and B) a long term return with relatively low risk.. But , I must admit that a lot of your posts appear to suggest a long term holder is someone that has invested in teh last two years..

Can you clarify please

As you know chisel i'm a trader not a long termer.Yes I would agree 7-10 years is long term.My main issue with alledged long term returns are they are somewhat illusory.They also do not consider opportunity cost nor are they compared to compunding cash.Most long term returns come from spikes in value.If you are not a holder during that spike you miss a large amount of the returns.I often wonder if there is any analysis of if an investor sold after the spike and moved to the thing that has been flat for a period of time what the results would be.
Examples- sydney real estate peaked in 2003 and was virtually totally flat untill mid 2009 to now.The total rise if you bought in 2003 to now is about 2% capital gain a year.If you took interest costs off you are wayyyyy behind even though prices have risen 20%.If you bout stocks in 2003 you would have about a 12% per annum gain here in aust up to date.However if you bought 2006/07 you are about breaking even.2007./08 you are about 20% down.
Now you have you money invested you could have had it in cash.This point is often ignored when quoting gross returns.
Here is my own real life example. Bought a house here in brisbane for 269,000 in 2003. Currently valued at 450,000. So i'm 181,000 in front- right? Actually if i sold today the result would be 181- buying costs 9k, minus sellingcosts 15k, minus interest paid approx 70k= 87,000 divided by 7 years= 12,500 a year. A gain of about 4.6%.Not much different from cash. My other house bought in 2006 is about 5.5% return.
If you buy gold today at 1150 where will it be in 5 years? Its quite possible its still 1150.It may spike in 1 year or 8 years you don;t know

Most hard assets will rise in the long term.They need to rise to justify the investment.My point is for all the extra risk are they really much better than cash?There are plenty of share investors who wish they were in cash.Plenty of usa property holders who wish they were in cash.Plenty of uk property holders who wish they were in cash.
Report paddletoe April 25, 2010 1:37 AM BST
Mr Bean your net capital gain on the value of your house over 7 years were you to to sell it now does not take into account 7 years rent whether its a tenant paying that rent or if your living in the house. If your living in the house surely you have saved 7 years rent which must be added into any capital gain on the house.
Report paddletoe April 25, 2010 1:39 AM BST
P.S, sorry for spelling your name wrong. I was not trying to compare you to our own Mr Bean over here. It was a genuine typo.
Report Sir Denis Eton-Hogg April 25, 2010 2:44 PM BST
Plenty of uk property holders who wish they were in cash.

i doubt that
Report Mrben April 26, 2010 3:49 AM BST
yes paddle in part your right.WE lived in that house for a few years first then rented out.Rental returns here are yielding about 4% and falling due to falling capacity to pay, rising living costs govt charges etc.Also if the house was sold it would be subject to 24% capital gains tax.Also you lose 40% tax on net rent.I did'nt calculate it but it may add a bit to say 6 or 6.5%. Hardly exciting.

Considering the extra risk involved such as long term maintenance- which I have'nt had to spend yet, the returns above cash are just not there.
Report chisel April 26, 2010 10:17 AM BST
Paddletoe

I agree with you

Mr B . The example of a house is a ridiculous one I am afraid. I like your style, and good luck to you , but you are a short termist. The point is that people are not happy being "in cash" as interest rates are so low and inflation high in comparison.

Your argument is simply**ers. It is lucky however, that you ARE making money with your investments!
Report V4 Vendetta April 27, 2010 7:28 PM BST
Gold now up 2% since 22nd, equities flat (Dow).
Report Sir Denis Eton-Hogg April 28, 2010 12:14 PM BST
breaking new records
Report V4 Vendetta April 28, 2010 8:12 PM BST
I've got a bar out of storage to stroke today.
Report Sir Denis Eton-Hogg April 29, 2010 2:17 AM BST
but can you eat it?
Report V4 Vendetta April 29, 2010 11:45 AM BST
It is possible and, of course, would do you no harm. Most Au in the body is found in the big toe simply because it doesn't react much at all with anything and falls under gravity. You would have to eat it a bit at a time, but teeth are harder than Au so, yes!
Report chisel April 29, 2010 12:02 PM BST
i just tried to eat my wedding ring, and can assure you that my teeth were not as strong as the Au!! A trip to the dentist is now required!

Good luck to anyone else that tries to eat gold!
Report V4 Vendetta April 29, 2010 12:27 PM BST
Your ring is probably 18ct only and cu with a lot of silver and copper. Makes a big difference. Try it with pure Gold and it'll give.
Report clouded leopard April 29, 2010 1:10 PM BST
Göring 28 Apr 20:12
I've got a bar out of storage to stroke today.



:D
Report PierreLaRogue April 29, 2010 2:15 PM BST
I was meant to buy gold at 500 an ounce a year or so ago, but had trouble with bank transfer so didn't bother :(.

I wanna know, if the stock markets crash again (i think they will) will the price of gold fall or rise? it seems when stocks fall gold falls too, anywon have an opinion on this?
Report V4 Vendetta April 29, 2010 6:35 PM BST
It depends a bit why they fall. If Goldmans goes bust (again) for example, they have a lot of Gold positions which might be unwound so both equities and Gold might fall for a period. If the stock market falls because California drops into the sea, Gold would rise quite a lot.

The key point is that, whatever the reason for the drop, the solution is the same - print more money, hold rates at zero, print more money and finally, print more money. As they print it faster than we find more Gold, it's inevitable that the price rises over the medium term.
Report paddletoe April 30, 2010 12:23 AM BST
Purely in terms of value gold would rise most if there was global economic failure and anarchy.

However, in practical terms the value of your gold is only worth as much as its security so unless you have the means to ward off other people in an anarchist society having such a high value asset could be your downfall.

Taken to the extreme buying gold as insurance against global meltdown is a bit like being offered a million to one on your own death. Its not a bet you want to win.
Report V4 Vendetta April 30, 2010 6:43 AM BST
I'd agree with all that.
Report V4 Vendetta April 30, 2010 8:16 AM BST
Yellow stuff going for it again this morning (as is everything else apart from the USD I suppose).
Report wykhamist April 30, 2010 11:18 PM BST
I think you are wrong in assuming gold is of no use in a doomsday scenario, unless of course there is a complete breakdown in law and order.

If the major currencies collapse then a new one will emerge which is backed by gold. Those holding gold will be able to convert their bullion to this new currency.

Of course there is a slight danger that governments will try to confiscate gold from their citizens, as they have done in the past. Thats why I keep a proportion in Zurich rather than London.
Report paddletoe May 1, 2010 11:26 PM BST
I never said gold would have no use in a doomsday society. It would just not be as valuable.

Charleton Heston could of had all the gold he wanted in Omega man but instead he stocked up on food to eat and weapons for protection.
Report donny osmond May 4, 2010 9:27 AM BST
what happened to charlton heston at the end of that film ?
Report V4 Vendetta May 6, 2010 6:29 PM BST
Nearly $1200 now :D  I'm getting my big ones out and rubbing them...  :D
Report Clueless1 May 14, 2010 12:05 PM BST
Happy
Report Sir Denis Eton-Hogg May 14, 2010 1:09 PM BST
i dunno what yr so happy about. the gold price merely marks the clock counting down to armageddon
Report fitzy May 14, 2010 1:37 PM BST
Can someone possibly give me a percentage regard silver prices over the last 6 months or so. Greatly appreciated thanks.
Report V4 Vendetta May 17, 2010 5:01 PM BST
100%
Post Your Reply
<CTRL+Enter> to submit
Please login to post a reply.

Wonder

Instance ID: 13539
www.betfair.com