Keith Melrose gives his thoughts on this weekend's Fighting Fifth at Newcastle, just don't ask him whether he thinks the meeting will beat the weather!
There are seemingly countless trials for the Champion Hurdle these days, but the Fighting Fifth is the first British Grade 1 for two-mile hurdlers and as such often the first proper indicator of how the division is shaping up. It's fitting, then, that reigning champion Binocular should make his reappearance in the race. Nicky Henderson's six-year-old suffered a disjointed campaign last season, which kicked off with defeat at odds on in this race, before finally getting it right in March when storming to success at Cheltenham. That win belatedly proved Binocular a top-class performer, a rare commodity among hurdlers over the minimum trip since the days of Istabraq, and there's no reason to believe he won't enjoy a flawless prep for his main target this time around.
If there's going to be a hiccup on the champion's road back to Cheltenham this Saturday, then it's surely going to be brought about by the exciting Peddlers Cross, who only made his racecourse debut at the Betfair Chase meeting last season but went unbeaten in five starts during that campaign, which incorporated Cheltenham Festival success in the Baring Bingham. An impeccable jumper, Peddlers Cross has demonstrated plenty of speed thus far (winner of a Grade 2 novice over the trip at Haydock in January) and could well develop into a Champion Hurdle contender this term, even though he's sure to make a chaser in time and almost certainly isn't an out-and-out two-miler.
Another who's very much on the up is Philip Hobbs' Nearby, who has seemingly been a staple of Saturday afternoons so far this autumn, racking up a hat-trick of victories in competitive handicaps, including the Elite Hurdle at Wincanton last time. The step up to graded class is the next logical stage in Nearby's development, and he has the form to get in the shake-up in a Grade 1 which lacks depth, but he's looked all about speed to date and as such may not be able to show his very best under the much more demanding stamina test this poses.
Two more established names among Binocular's rivals are Starluck and Sublimity. The first-named is a strong traveller who can flatter to deceive with his finishing effort, as he has done at the last two Cheltenham Festivals (fifth in last year's Champion Hurdle). There is no doubt that he is a very smart hurdler on his day, but the Christmas Hurdle at Kempton, in which he was runner-up last year, is likely to be Starluck's ultimate aim this side of a return to Cheltenham. Sublimity has usually found one or two too good at the highest level since taking the Champion Hurdle in 2007, including when finishing runner-up in the last two renewals of this (behind Punjabi and Go Native respectively). With the current champion and a couple of up-and-comers in opposition this time, he's likely to come up short again.
Surely no one's expecting anything earth-shattering in the conclusion to a tipping piece on a seven-runner Grade 1, so for all there are some anomalies in the current market (Sublimity really shouldn't be almost five times the price of Starluck for starters) the bottom line is that a fit Binocular should make a winning reappearance. The exploits of Silviniaco Conti may have weakened his position at the top of the hurdling tree, but there's no doubt surrounding the Champion's superiority over last year's crop and the improvers he faces here have a significant gap to bridge.
(Read more at http://betting.betfair.com/horse-racing/timeform-features/)