Forums
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 2  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 74
By:
mesmerised
When: 02 Sep 22 19:34
Nobody beats Richard Gasquet EIGHTEEN times in a row

Except Nadal on Saturday, which is my pick.
By:
SamuelMertensBertens
When: 03 Sep 22 02:55
assuming Nick gets it done:
Norrie
By:
n88uk
When: 03 Sep 22 10:32
Cameron Norrie
By:
anubis7
When: 03 Sep 22 11:47
Jannik Sinner
By:
Journeyman
When: 03 Sep 22 12:34
J.Sinner
By:
edy
When: 03 Sep 22 15:59
Day 5 Summary:

anubis7 - Korda, Isner, de Minaur, Schwartzman, Moutet
Journeyman - Paul, Kecmanovic, Berrettini, Rublev, Kyrgios
mesmerised - Khachanov, Kecmanovic, Medvedev, Norrie, Davidovich Fokina
n88uk - Paul, Kecmanovic, de Minaur, Shapovalov, Kyrgios
SamuelMertensBertens - Paul, Kecmanovic, Murray, Shapovalov, Kyrgios
By:
Journeyman
When: 04 Sep 22 09:27
C.Ruud
By:
n88uk
When: 04 Sep 22 10:31
Pablo Carreno-Busta
By:
anubis7
When: 04 Sep 22 11:11
Pablo Carreno-Busta
By:
mesmerised
When: 04 Sep 22 11:15
Ruud
By:
SamuelMertensBertens
When: 04 Sep 22 14:43
Ruud
By:
edy
When: 04 Sep 22 15:15
Day 6 Summary:

anubis7 - Korda, Isner, de Minaur, Schwartzman, Moutet, Sinner
Journeyman - Paul, Kecmanovic, Berrettini, Rublev, Kyrgios, Sinner
mesmerised - Khachanov, Kecmanovic, Medvedev, Norrie, Davidovich Fokina, Nadal
n88uk - Paul, Kecmanovic, de Minaur, Shapovalov, Kyrgios, Norrie
SamuelMertensBertens - Paul, Kecmanovic, Murray, Shapovalov, Kyrgios, Norrie
By:
edy
When: 05 Sep 22 11:10
Day 7 Summary:

Journeyman - Paul, Kecmanovic, Berrettini, Rublev, Kyrgios, Sinner, Ruud
mesmerised - Khachanov, Kecmanovic, Medvedev, Norrie, Davidovich Fokina, Nadal, Ruud
SamuelMertensBertens - Paul, Kecmanovic, Murray, Shapovalov, Kyrgios, Norrie, Ruud

newly out: anubis7, n88uk
By:
mesmerised
When: 05 Sep 22 14:54
Sinner
By:
Journeyman
When: 05 Sep 22 15:04
Nadal
By:
SamuelMertensBertens
When: 05 Sep 22 16:03
Sinner
By:
mesmerised
When: 05 Sep 22 17:28
if all our picks go through tonight, I think JM is likely not to make the final two as he's picked Berrettini, Ruud and Kyrgios already so will be left with just Khachanov to pick.
By:
Journeyman
When: 05 Sep 22 18:41
Correct Mes. Hoping Khachanov has his shredded wheat tomorrow morning!

Could have been worse, I nearly picked Norrie today.
By:
mesmerised
When: 05 Sep 22 23:54
even worse than that, you picked NadalSad, what happens if Sinner loses, we all walk off into the sunset sharing Gold? bit like Gianmarco Tamberi and Mutaz Barshim in the 2020 Tokyo Olympics High Jump.
By:
SamuelMertensBertens
When: 06 Sep 22 00:57
Shared joy is double joy.
By:
Journeyman
When: 06 Sep 22 01:14
Yeah exactly.
A mugging Sinner makes all three of us a WINNER!

Oh hang on. The doorbell just rang.

it's my freshly laundered Ilya Ivashka T-shirt.
By:
SamuelMertensBertens
When: 06 Sep 22 05:04
Berrettini
By:
mesmerised
When: 06 Sep 22 10:06
Sir Nick of Kyrgios
By:
edy
When: 06 Sep 22 14:42
Day 8 Summary:

mesmerised - Khachanov, Kecmanovic, Medvedev, Norrie, Davidovich Fokina, Nadal, Ruud, Sinner
SamuelMertensBertens - Paul, Kecmanovic, Murray, Shapovalov, Kyrgios, Norrie, Ruud, Sinner

newly out: Journeyman
By:
Journeyman
When: 07 Sep 22 07:00
Well organised as always Edy and congrats to Mes and caramba.

Turns out my last remaining pick (Khachanov) would have won me the whole thing so thanks Rafa. Cry
Going forward I'd throw the suggestion in the box that everyone submit their picks to Edy
and he posts the list of picks once all the picks are in.
Just a suggestion.

How do we get through a whole week of these remaining players Laugh
By:
mesmerised
When: 07 Sep 22 10:40
another shared slam Sad
By:
Journeyman
When: 07 Sep 22 12:38
^
Shared slam wins is literally all I have (US Open 2018, Aus Open 2022)
so I'm not going to moan about it. Grin

Closing the advantage play loophole is another matter.
I'm not fingerpointing here btw, I late picked this week as well for whatever reason so Mea Culpa,
but with 4 months till the next slam it's time to have a sensible discussion.
By:
SamuelMertensBertens
When: 07 Sep 22 14:28
another shared Slam Excited
By:
SamuelMertensBertens
When: 07 Sep 22 14:43
Late picking/making pick's based on what others have picked makes the game more fun and adds a strategic layer to the competition imo. There's also nothing unfair about it as everyone can do it.
I will also bring my favorite argument, sending picks to edy means more work for edy. He'd have to check his dm and then post the picks in the thread which means significantly more work than just letting us post them here and just check if we posted before the match started or not. One could also argue that by sending edy picks, he would have the advantage of seeing picks before others. Not that I think he'd abuse this but there could be accusations and the integrity of the game could be compromized.
By:
edy
When: 07 Sep 22 14:49
Well done mes and SaMeBe!

As for

Going forward I'd throw the suggestion in the box that everyone submit their picks to Edy
and he posts the list of picks once all the picks are in.
Just a suggestion.


was in the process of writing something, but.....I agree with what SaMeBe outlines. Two more problems I see: It's not only more of a hassle for me, but I think it would reduce participation as it would be an extra hassle and hurdle for everyone.

Furthermore, I'd either have to be the one making a public pick or involve someone else to send my pick to.
By:
Journeyman
When: 07 Sep 22 15:01
Fair enough. Based on what you're both saying the 'sending picks to Edy' idea is a non-starter.

There's also nothing unfair about it as everyone can do it.
^
This isn't true though.

Not everyone can do it. You're assuming that everyone playing is willing and able theoretically to monitor the picks made throughout the day. People have different lifestyles and commitments etc.

I don't think being able to make late choices based on what others have picked makes any difference in the first few rounds but by the time it gets to R3 through QF it's a clear advantage.

Was really just opening up to gauge thoughts of participants. I accept the picks to Edy idea is off the table.
By:
edy
When: 07 Sep 22 18:03
Keep the suggestions and opinions going! I'm generally open to the secret pick thing, but I can't see a practical way of doing it. The comp should remain accessible and easy to take part in (and easy to administrate)
By:
edy
When: 07 Sep 22 18:06
I thought if it would be an alternative to set a strict deadline e.g. for the scheduled start of play for each day. It would reduce the possibilities to maneuver, but at the other side it would be a nuisance for those that forget, or thought they could make it but then got busy with stuff and don't make it for the deadline, while not really bringing an advantage for those that can't be here all day to submit picks at point 11 am for RG.
By:
wisewords
When: 07 Sep 22 18:48
that's a very long sentence, edy!
By:
SamuelMertensBertens
When: 07 Sep 22 18:54
Germans love long words and long sentences.
Page 2 of 2  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com