Peyton Manning

Agree 100%, guy is poetry in motion.

Romo is giving him a good run tonite

Tony Romo showing Manning how it's done here

overrated, prefer Brady myself

Romo blows all his good work on that throw

You could argue Mannings the best regular season qb ever, his post season record record leaves a lot to be desired however

Romo just done a Romo there and handed the game to Denver

he is currently playing in one of the most potent offenses ever.  He has about 5/6 ridiculous threats at his disposal.

Ware, the sack king could not get anywhere near Manning all night.

He is definitely the sharpest (genius) as he chose the best offensive line in football.  they even got Tebow a playoff win.

I would prefer Rodgers or Brees personally by the time they have finished their careers.

better than Montana.....

I would prob perfer Rogers myself but I would take Peyton over Brees any day

If we are talking about the whole package I would take rodgers but he has years ahead of him to prove he is one of the best.  Manning sees things better than other qbs,reads the game superbly,his brain is so sharp that makes up for his lack of mobility.  Also the king of the boot leg after the dallas game,that was funny

He's crap when the big ligtht's get switched on

Peytons the best ever. Nobody else is even close. Rodgers took over Brett Favres playoff team. The same team that earned Matt Flynn a 20m contract.  Brady's team went 11-5 without him. There are many many high quality qb's ruined by bad teams. Bellichick was sub .500 as the browns coach, now he's a genius. Typically its the undrafted or later drafted men that succeed because they go to better teams and are often eased/earned into the position.