TOM BRADY or PEYTON MANNING

I'm in the Brady bunch.Manning's never been on Family Guy.Gigidy Gigidy Goo.

but to answer the question, on the basis of their whole careers, brady

wanna_b_pro 15 Oct 18:58
Peyton for me, Brady inherited great team


garbage

Tom was put into a good team, peyton wasnt in as good a team. Tom gets all the credit because he is on a good overall team

before the brady injury it was manning...nothings changed...the guy is top class...he is a great QB and great leader of that offence...always in total control

both awesome but peyton just edges it for me all be it hes an inbred

PEYTON MANNING ,

In time thou , Will " CHAD HENNE " Blow them Both out of the water ?

TOM BRADY , hasn't that " Girl " lost his Nerve.......................................... :^0

From CHFF:

Tom Brady's 2.3-to-1 ratio of TDs to INTs is the best in pro football history. His regular-season (87-24) and postseason (14-3) records as a starter are each the best among active quarterbacks.

The straight dope: Some bloom has come off the Brady rose over the past couple seasons. His brilliant, record-setting 2007 campaign ended with one of the great offensive clunkers in the history of the game in Super Bowl XLII, and last year his season was over a few minutes after it started. But even if he never takes another snap, his rise from unknown back-up to elite, championship-winning statistical juggernaut has been the singular storyline of the first decade of the 21st century.

Hes won all the hardware imaginable, and his career 92.9 passer rating is fourth all time, and best among any cold-weather quarterback. We can only imagine what his numbers might look like had he the benefit of playing in a stat-ballooning dome or anywhere but arguably the worst-weather arena in the game.

His 2007 season was arguably the most explosive in the history of the game. But Brady's greatest attributes are his efficiency, his care with the ball and his remarkable consistency. The greatest part of his 50-TD season, for example, was that he threw just 8 INTs, despite slinging the ball all over the field game after game. His rate of 2.3 TDs for every INT is unmatched by any quarterback. And even when he doesn't light the world on fire every game or every week, the duds are fewer and farther between than they are with any other QB in the game today. That consistency at quarterback over the past decade is the single biggest reason why the Patriots have been the most consistent winners in football over the past decade.

CASE CLOSED.

btw he still has randy moss and wes welker...where are the big numbers this season?....you have to take into account offensive line.pass protection etc.....not doubting how good brady is...just not as good as peyton manning

HARRY22 16 Oct 09:54
what a load of rubbish....you dont have to win superbowl after superbowl to be classed as the best...a lot of bradys success was down to patriots having an excellent defense

or was it down to manning being a bottler when it really matters?

not talking about this year red, over their careers

if manning has the big play Defensive players the patriots have had i would bet peyton would of played in more superbowls..manning will be going back this year i hope

:^0 if we are going from superbowls big ben is better than manning when it matters??

I find it funny the way people on here think brady is better just because he is on the pats, Peyton is a better QB and most people know it. The fact that Cassel could come in and run the system aswell as brady says alot

the soft schedule got them to 11-5 last year

the pats beat 2 teams with winning records last year (jets w2, cards w16)


and manning blowing it time and again in the playoff makes me a mug ????

You a mug because your opinion is always so closed. When did you start following the pats?

And now your talking about stats look at Bradys college stats and see what you think.

college stats are relevant how ?

like only scoring 3 points