|
By:
Thalidomide victims were already compensated and its nothing to do with the State
|
|
By:
I have never sued anyone and feel it is unpatriotic to sue the State.
|
|
By:
I dislike group think and t
|
|
By:
to give away money and then go to a group who were not allowed defend themselves and demand they pay is just wrong.
|
|
By:
Probably to my shame I have done nothing.
I have vowed never to sue the state,taught my children not to sue the state. I know of two people who in my opinion defrauded the state by suing,one in just a blatant fraud,the other just succumbed to the barrage of messages telling him to go to the redress board. The redress board man always told us how well treated he was in the religious institution but he was inundated with requests from individuals to invent stories confirming dreadful treatment in an effort to maximise their compensation,he was written to by the redress board almost begging him to claim eventually he gave in for bogus reasons. I probably should have reported the fraud but part of my psyche refused to let me become an informer,not logical i know. |
|
By:
Thanks for the response.
I still find contradiction within your case. You are truly Irish. |
|
By:
Its now like a jungle.
The State is like a huge wounded buffalo crossing the Veldt,hovering overhead are some vultures,in the long grass a pride of lions,behind them some lingering hyenas,on the other side a Leopard with some Waiting jackals. Seems also my suggestion of a measly 100 Grand for all is not near enough. All sorts of individuals are being used to stripe the state for compensation,law professors human rights lawyers generally from England with big bills in their hands. In the ludicrously generous deal they have even managed to get included a six grand plus vat figure for some non existent work for some legal people in each case. What can never be stated is we are not liable,my children are not liable,the state is not liable. This is my impersonation of Joe Duffy and RTE if they were arguing my case. It will be the sick and the vulnerable who will pick up this tab,the not already compensated special needs families who will pay the price. These old broads will await their huge windfall by travelling to Dublin using their free passes whilst heading for their world cruises once again ensuring this money will benefit every economy except our own. When these have rifled the safe just wait for the next tranche of individuals and their ever brilliant legal teams. Ian Bailey Praveen. The Asylum seeker denied an abortion The top ups for those that couldn't handle the first tranche. The prisoners forced to slop out. All those in direct provision forced to consider prostitution. They make the bond holders the equivalent of a knitting circle. |
|
By:
A few more to be added to that list.
Jules Thomas Louise OKeeffe for. the fourth time All those that lost their cases but have been brought back in by the distinctly unpatriotic Louise OKeeffe. |
|
By:
All the forumites who were shocked by my opening post might now start to get my point.
Remember only one view was allowed,these women got a free run. We now learn that most of these women didnt have symphysiotomies but they gave them a few oul bob anyway. And once again the big winners were the legal profession. |
|
By:
So now the "forumites" might now get your point ? Are you for fkn real ? "to get my point" "we now learn " , absolute ar sehole material , on a gambling forum , ffs thats pitiful!
|
|
By:
I thought Tobywong would be on telling us that he predicted this all along whilst explaining he was a personal friend of the judge.
|
|
By:
Wildman hit the nail on the head with his OP. These compo schemes have no relation to fair and proper justice.
The most worrying aspect was the mention in the report of doctors sending in reports about the pain "Victims" were suffering and it was proven they had never gone under the procedure. http://www.irishtimes.com/news/crime-and-law/courts/circuit-court/10-000-for-accident-prone-man-in-ninth-personal-injury-claim-1.2881096 On another note, heres Irelands unluckiest man...... |
|
By:
Mincer exposed
,the Glin man taking Limerick to the cleaners for years Racingqueen.... Its out in the open now Mince....![]() ![]() . |
|
By:
A new large group has emerged.
This group is better trained and has learnt a lot from previous groups. These people will all be suicidal and all in the need of a few oul Bob for grandchildren and trips to Lourdes. Abandoning your baby is now compensatable. |
|
By:
Widmanfromborneo..........The more you and the old boys club sweep under the carpet, the bigger the scandal.
Old Ireland at it's finest, what a horrible nasty little country we live in. At least the Gaurd, Doctor and Clergy have no clout over the people anymore, these cover ups are costing the state a fortune. The nuns were damn right nasty, my poor old granny even looks over her shoulder while giving about them now. |
|
By:
You may think we live in a horrible nasty country I don't.
I think its a great country. Its oh so easy to blame nuns but you don't realise that times were tough years ago,infant mortality was high,Dublin had some of the worse slums in Europe. Nuns didnt kidnap these girls.their parents sent them there,someone had to look after them. Exaggeration is now the order of the day because it means more cash. No defence is allowed. One extraordinary aspect is the fact they missed their baby every day for years in these circumstances but the women who have abortions never miss theirs at all Mind you if they made that compensatable they wouldn't be long in missing them. The oldest boys club of them all is the legal profession,they are rubbing their hands with glee. As for your granny ask her does she feel any gratitude for the education those nuns gave her. |
|
By:
I wouldn't be sicking up for it Gant,it is hard to believe that it did go on.
Maybe i have been lucky but particulary in education never met a bad Nun or Christian Brother really, i got threatened to be sent off with the Good Sheperds and enough leatherings off them alright, i deserved a few i think. As bad as it was Gant there was edducation and hospitals from them for the relative needy, is todays country more horrible and nastier? a murder every day,the streets awash with heroin,crime through the roof, maybe in 50 years time we will be saying how did we put up with it. |
|
By:
She remembers the beatings and the nuns never called to her house for tea.
Thankfully people with your views are few and far between, even die hard members of the Gardai don't believe Noirin. Having visited the killing field outside Phnomn Penh in Cambodia, I wonder did Pol Pot spend time with the religious orders in Ireland......for a fee of course. |
|
By:
Pol Pot,Stalin,Mao, All Atheists Gant. Maybe if they'd spent some time in a religious order, Millions would be still alive . Hard to believe these evil bastards had such power.
|
|
By:
One extraordinary aspect is the fact they missed their baby every day for years in these circumstances but the women who have abortions never miss theirs at all
Mind you if they made that compensatable they wouldn't be long in missing them. What we need are brave, erudite and intelligent men such as yourself wildman telling us how it is on the public airwaves and in the media. I cannot say I don't believe your utterances but do you express them publicly without the comfort of anonymity? What's the worth of an opinion or prejudice that cannot be expressed courageously? I presume you know from sad or bitter experience that the mothers who have had abortions "never miss theirs at all". It's a pretty astounding statement to make and one wonders are mothers made pregnant by immaculate conception as you seem to forget there may be a "father" involved. I don't believe in scapegoating the nuns or priests in general - the "Church" was an egregious institution brainwashing all who came within its remit and I'm not so sure our society is much better today when examined in some ways. There will be a few in the Vatican today agreeing with your every word but for differing reasons. A former Taoiseach of the day proclaimed in the fifties: "I, as a Catholic, obey my church authorities and will continue to do so . . . There will be no flouting of the authority of the bishops in the matter of Catholic social or moral teaching." Presumably, this is your milieu. |
|
By:
“If you come here you’ll find no mass grave, no evidence that children were ever so buried and a local police force casting their eyes to heaven and saying, ‘Yeah a few bones were found – but this was an area where famine victims were buried. So?’,”
The Bon Secours hired Terry Prone as a PR 2 years ago and that was their statement. I haven't heard anything about compo but I'm sure there'll be a few, however I'd say the vast majority in Tuam anyway just want a genuine apology, and the graveyard marked, ffs they've built houses on top of them, if you buried a dog you wouldn't do that. |
|
By:
Royal Academy.
I wouldn't be let on the airwaves and if I was I'd be no good,I'm not a good speaker. My complaint is the compensation seeking,this idea that every misfortune is compensatable is wrong to me. I agree that fathers shouldn't evade their responsibilities. I think John A Costello was of his time and wrong as was Sean McBride. Societies move on,we were a dirt poor country back then. Hating your history,your parents and grandparents by judging them by today's standards is wrong. GANT007. You have taken self loathing to a new level. You think the nuns in Ireland were comparable to Pol Pot. The bulk of the corporal punishment meted out in schools was done by lay teachers. We now know corporal punishment is wrong and counterproductive but it was the norm then all over the world. |
|
By:
Wildmanfromborneo.........It's time to break away from the belief that the state was always right and the peasants were the problem.
|
|
By:
I don't think the State is always right,its not I just don't think it should be constantly sued.
I also think it should be allowed to defend itself. |
|
By:
Not even Matlock would get them out of the recent cover ups.
|
|
By:
Whatever one thinks of the Church (Personally I think its a joke that is deservedly on its last knees), one can only chuckle at the hysterical hypocrisy of the likes of the IT who one hand clamber for abortion whilst using the deaths of kids in care to batter the catholic church.
Hating your history,your parents and grandparents by judging them by today's standards is wrong. 100% correct. Everything is so clear and easy with hindsight. |
|
By:
It seems to me a lot of the views here are very narrow and allow for no nuance and, in some cases, don't particularly care about collateral damage.
I would rather have the Irish Times and Examiner than the options of Denis O'Brien or the redtops. A newspaper should challenge our thinking daily and "hypocrisy" is not an accurate reflection of a newspaper that offers the musings of both Una Mullally and Breda O'Brien. I personally feel that until abortion is available women will still live under the shadow of the crozier, even if I am ambivalent about the process. My other objection is to the word "hate": the comment "hating your history, parents and grandparents" is simply wrong for the vast, vast majority of those affected by State negligence/institutional abuse and reminds me of the grief that the holocaust survivor, Elie Wiesel, went through all his lifetime for thinking for a split second that he wished his father dead in the camp to allow himself live. What people hate is the system and the protected elite and, hopefully, there are fewer hiding places today in what is still a fairly unequal society. Hate doesn't come easy to us unless we are brainwashed. |
|
By:
That's an insult to Breda O'Brien.
|