Forums
Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
acey deucy
22 Feb 24 10:04
Joined:
Date Joined: 29 Sep 02
| Topic/replies: 34,103 | Blogger: acey deucy's blog
List of equine fatalities in the Grand National

Article
Talk
Read
Edit
View history

Tools
From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Becher's Brook, historically the most dangerous fence. By William Barnes Wollen, 1890.
This is a list of equine fatalities in the Grand National, an annual steeplechase horse racing event held at Aintree Racecourse near Liverpool. The Grand National is a National Hunt handicap race that is held over a distance of 4 miles and 3½ furlongs, with a field of 34 horses jumping 30 fences.

According to the British Horseracing Authority, modern steeplechase races have an average of just over 4 equine fatalities for every 1,000 horses taking part in a race.[1] The Aintree Grand National yielded 7 equine fatalities out of 439 horses taking part between 2000 and 2010, a rate of almost 16 equine fatalities per 1,000 horses taking part (or 0.64 fatalities per race of 40 horses). In the five years to 2023, the fatality rate has risen, averaging 25 equine fatalities per 1,000 horses taking part (or one fatality per race of 40 horses).[2][3]

Background
The high number of equine deaths in the Aintree Grand National race has made it a focus for animal rights activists. While course officials have taken safety measures over the years, such as improving veterinary facilities and reducing the severity of fences,[4] some campaign for further modifications and even the abolition of the event that was inaugurated in 1839.[5]

After the 1989 Grand National, in which two horses died in incidents at Becher's Brook (the sixth and 22nd fence on the course), Aintree began making significant changes to the fences that are jumped during the National. The brook on the landing-side of Becher's was filled in to prevent horses rolling back into it, and the incline on the landing-side has been mostly levelled out, whilst retaining a drop to slow the runners. Other fences have been reduced in height, toe-boards have been made taller, and the entry requirements for participating horses have been made stricter, such as the requirement for runners to have been placed fourth or better in a previously recognised steeplechase over a distance of at least three miles.

Some within the horseracing community, including some with notable achievements in the Grand National, such as Ginger McCain and Bob Champion,[6][7][8] have argued that the lowering of fences and the narrowing of ditches, primarily designed to increase horse safety, has had the adverse effect by encouraging the runners to race faster. During the 1970s and 1980s, the Grand National saw a total of 12 horses die (half of which were at Becher's Brook); in the next 20-year period from 1990 to 2010, when modifications to the course were most significant, there were 17 equine fatalities.

List of fatalities
The animal welfare charity League Against Cruel Sports counts the number of horse deaths at 40 over the three-day meet from the year 2000 to 2013.[9] The following list details the equine fatalities during, or as a direct result of participating in, the Grand National, that is, the showpiece steeplechase itself rather than all the various races held over the entire three-day "Grand National meeting" (which includes two other races over one circuit of the National course: the Fox Hunters for amateur jockeys and the Topham for professional jockeys).

The list includes, where applicable and where known, the fence at which the fatality occurred.[10]

Year    Horse    Fence No.    Fate    Going    Ran    Details    Source
2023    Hill Sixteen    1 (& 17)    Fell    Good    39    Fell at first and sustained "unrecoverable injury"    [11]
2022    Eclair Surf    3 (& 19)    Fell    Good-soft    40    Fell at 3rd fence, was stabilised and taken back to the stables, only to be euthanised the day after due to head trauma.    [12]
2022    Discorama    While running    Pulled up    Good-soft    40    Pulled up before the 13th fence, was found to have incurred a pelvic injury and was euthanised.    [13]
2021    The Long Mile    While running    Pulled up    Good-soft    40    Was euthanised after the race.    [14]
2019    Up For Review    1 (& 17)    Brought down    Good-soft    40    Jumped successfully but was brought down by another fallen horse    [15]
2012    Synchronised    While running riderless    Fell    Good    40    Fell at Becher's Brook but continued running riderless until the 11th fence where he fractured his right-hind tibia and fibula and was euthanised.    [16]
2012    According to Pete    (6 &) 22    Brought down    Good    40    Fractured his left-fore humerus and was euthanised.    [16]
2011    Ornais    4 (& 20)    Fell    Good    40    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died.    [17]
2011    Dooneys Gate    6 (& 22)    Fell    Good    40    Fractured his thoracolumbar upon falling and was euthanised.    [17]
2009    Hear The Echo    While running    Collapsed    Good-soft    40    Collapsed on the run-in and died.    [18]
2008    McKelvey    While running riderless    Collided with barrier    Good    40    Unseated rider at 20th fence and continued running riderless until he collided with railings, was unable to regain his feet due to injuries, and was euthanised.    [19]
2007    Graphic Approach    While running riderless    Collapsed    Good    40    Fell at Becher's Brook but continued running riderless before collapsing with concussion; he was euthanised several days later.    [20]
2006    Tyneandthyneagain    1 (& 17)    Fell    Good-soft    40    Continued running riderless until falling later, was diagnosed with a spinal injury and was euthanised.    [21]
2003    Goguenard    (3 &) 19    Brought down    Good    40    Injured in a mêlée by another falling horse and was euthanised.    [22]
2002    The Last Fling    (8 &) 24    Fell    Good    40    Broke his back upon falling and died.    [23]
2002    Manx Magic    (4 &) 20    Fell    Good    40    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died.    [23]
1999    Eudipe    (6 &) 22    Fell    Good    32    Broke his back upon falling and was euthanised.    [24]
1998    Pashto    1 (& 17)    Fell    Heavy    37    Collapsed after falling and was euthanised.    [25]
1998    Do Rightly    4 (& 20)    Fell    Heavy    37    Suffered a heart attack whilst jumping the fence.    [25]
1998    Griffins Bar    While running    Fell    Heavy    37    Incurred a shoulder fracture after jumping the fifth fence and fell; later was euthanised.    [25]
1997    Straight Talk    14 (& 30)    Fell    Good    36    Incurred a leg fracture upon falling and was euthanised.    [26]
1997    Smith's Band    (4 &) 20    Fell    Good    36    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died.    [26]
1996    Rust Never Sleeps    While running    Pulled up    Good    27    Pulled up lame before the 13th fence, diagnosed with a broken shoulder and euthanised.    [27]
1991    Ballyhane    After finishing    Collapsed    Good-soft    40    Suffered a haemorrhage after completing the race and died.    [28]
1990    Roll-A-Joint    8 (& 24)    Fell    Firm    38    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died.    [29]
1990    Hungary Hur    While running    Pulled up    Firm    38    Incurred a leg fracture while running towards the 19th fence, pulled up and euthanised.    [29]
1989    Brown Trix    6 (& 22)    Fell    Heavy    40    Incurred a shoulder fracture upon falling.    [30]
1989    Seeandem    6 (& 22)    Fell    Heavy    40    Broke his back upon falling and died.    [30]
1987    Dark Ivy    6 (& 22)    Fell    Good    40    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died.    [31]
1984    Earthstopper    After finishing    Collapsed    Good    40    Collapsed and died after finishing the race.    [32]
1983    Duncreggan    8 (& 24)    Fell    Soft    41    Injured in fall and later euthanised.    [33]
1982    Again The Same    8 (& 24)    Pulled up        39    Upon his return home the horse was found to have broken a bone in his knee and was euthanised.    [34]
1979    Kintai    15    Brought down    Good    34    Injured in fall and later euthanised.    [35]
1979    Alverton    (6 &) 22    Fell    Good    34    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died.    [36]
1978    Rag Trade    While running    Pulled up    Firm    37    Pulled up lame before the 21st fence and later euthanised.    [37]
1977    Winter Rain    6 (& 22)    Fell    Good    42    Injured in fall and later euthanised.    [38][39]
1977    Zeta's Son    (9 &) 25    Fell    Good    42    Injured in fall and later euthanised.    [38][39]
1975    Land Lark    15    Fell    Good    31    Suffered a heart attack while jumping the fence.    [40]
1975    Beau Bob    (6 &) 22    Fell    Good    31    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died.    [40]
1973    Grey Sombrero    15    Fell    Firm    38    Incurred a shoulder fracture upon falling and was euthanised.    [41]
1970    Racoon    3 (& 19)    Fell    Good    28    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and was euthanised.    [42]
1967    Vulcano    3 (& 19)    Fell    Good    44    Injured in fall and euthanised.    [43]
1960    Belsize II    (4 &) 20    Fell    Good    26    Injured in fall and euthanised with a suspected cervical fracture.    [44]
1959    Slippery Serpent    13 (& 29)    Fell    Good    34    Broke a leg bone, which was initially treated, however was euthanised three days later.    [45]
1959    Henry Purcell    6 (& 22)    Fell    Good    34    Broke his back upon falling and was euthanised.    [46]
1954    Dominick's Bar    2 (& 18)    Fell    Soft    29    Suffered a heart attack while jumping the fence.    [47][48]
1954    Paris New York    4 (& 20)    Fell    Soft    29    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died.    [47][48]
1954    Legal Joy    13 (& 29)    Fell    Soft    29    Broke a leg in a fall and was euthanised.    [47][48]
1954    Coneyburrow    (12 &) 28    Fell    Soft    29    Injured in a fall and later euthanised.    [47][48]
1953    Cardinal Error    4 (& 20)    Fell    Good    31    Injured or possibly killed in a fall.    [49]
1953    Parasol II    8 (& 24)    Fell    Good    31    Injured in a fall and later euthanised.    [49]
1952    Skouras    6 (& 22)    Fell    Good-firm    47    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and was euthanised.    [50]
1950    Limestone Cottage    8 (& 24)    Fell    Good    49    Injured in fall.    [51]
1946    Symbole    6 (& 22)    Fell    Good    34    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died.    [52]
1940    Second Act    16    Injured on landing    Good    32        [citation needed]
1938    Cabin Fire    8 (& 24)    Fell    Good    36        [citation needed]
1938    Rock Lad    16    Injured on landing    Good    36        [citation needed]
1936    Avenger    (1 &) 17    Fell    Good    36    Incurred a cervical fracture and was euthanised.    [53]
1931    Swift Roland    6 (& 22)    Fell    "Perfect"    43    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died..    [54]
1931    Drin    8 (& 24)    Fell    "Perfect"    43    Incurred a leg fracture and was euthanised.    [54]
1930    Derby Day    4 (and 20)    Fell    "Perfect"    41    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died.    [55]
1929    Stort    11 (and 27)    Fell    "Average"    66    fell at the 11th running loose, incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died.    [55]
1926    Lone Hand        Fell    Good    30        [55]
1922    The Inca    6 (& 22)    Fell    Good    32    Incurred a leg fracture and was euthanised.    [56]
1922    Awbeg    8 (& 24)    Fell    Good    32    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died..    [56]
1907    Kilts    1 (& 17)    Fell    Good    23        [57]
1901    True Blue        Fell    Snow    24        [57]
1891    The Emperor    While running    Fell    Good    21    Having been pulled up, fell and broke his back while running back to the stables.    [57]
1882    Wild Monarch        Fell    Heavy    12        [57]
1872    Primrose    (2 &) 18    Fell    Hard    25    Injured in fall and was euthanised.    [57]
1871    Lord Raglan    15    Fell    "Perfect"    25    Broke a leg and was euthanised.    [57][58]
1869    Huntsman's Daughter            "Average"    22    Reports state only that the horse was euthanised after the race.    [59]
1868    Chimney Sweep    While running at 1    Collided with barrier    Heavy    21    Injured when collided with barrier on the Melling Road and was euthanised.    [57]
1863    Telegraph    5 & 21    Fell    Good    16    Injured in fall and was euthanised.    [57]
1861    The Conductor        Refused    "Average"    24    Injured in mêlée and was euthanised.    [57]
1857    Garry Owen        Pulled up    Heavy    28    Ruptured his loins.    [60]
1857    Albatross        Collapsed    Heavy    28    Fell dead while running towards the fence.    [60]
1856    Banstead    2 & 18    Fell    "Average"    21    Injured in fall and was euthanised.    [57]
1855    Miss Mowbray    (6 &) 22    Fell    Heavy    20    Incurred a cervical fracture upon falling and died.
1854    Bedford    9 & 25    Fell    Good    20    Injured in fall and was euthanised.    [57]
1849    The Curate    2 (& 18)    Fell    Heavy    24    Injured in fall and was euthanised.    [61]
1849    Equinox    (3 &) 19    Fell    Heavy    24    Injured in fall and was euthanised.   
1849    Kilfane    (4 &) 20    Fell    Heavy    24    Injured in fall and was euthanised.   
1848    Counsellor        Fell    Heavy    29       
1848    The Sailor        Fell    Heavy    29        [62]
1848    Blue Pill        Fell    Heavy    29       
1845    Clansman    15    Fell    Heavy    16    Fatally injured in fall.   
1839    Dictator    (9 &) 25    Fell    Heavy    17    Burst blood
Rate reply:
| report
Pause Switch to Standard View Has The Grand National Had Its...
Show More
Loading...
Report acey deucy February 22, 2024 10:06 AM GMT
I have not missed a Grand National for over 50 Years nothing could touch it for excitement but i think it has just about had it's Day. It still gets massive crowds but i think the fatalities will finish the Race for good in the end.Attitudes are changing so we all better get used to it.
We need to talk about this.Plain
Report GEORGE.B February 22, 2024 10:11 AM GMT
is there a wiki page for the list of horses slaughtered in abattoirs before ending up in a Belgian's sandwich box?
Report GEORGE.B February 22, 2024 10:23 AM GMT
Jump racing can be particularly cruel at times, for example, the demise of One Man at Aintree, but ban jump racing, which is what this leading to as fatalities are obviously not just confined to the National, and there will be no more Red Rums, Aladanitis or Desert Orchids, which is a sad thought.

Jump racing, the epitome of triumph and tragedy, but who wants to stop 'living' and ensconce themselves in a risk-free boring world where we're confined to out 15 minute cities?
Report GEORGE.B February 22, 2024 10:24 AM GMT
* out = our
Report acey deucy February 22, 2024 10:41 AM GMT
Plus The Antis have got a Hard On for the Race this is there Christmas Day now.Plain
Report stewarts rise February 22, 2024 10:42 AM GMT
Acey, I'm sure if you could find a list of all drivers killed in Motor racing sports,motor cycling sports, marathon running, skiing sports, ski diving sports etc, the lists would also be long. Do you want everything with a risk to live and limb banned?
As George says it's not just the GN where there are fatalities.
Report acey deucy February 22, 2024 10:54 AM GMT
Yeah fair enough stew but they had a choice....Now i dont want to sound like some raging Anti here because i am certainly not.
Report mecca February 22, 2024 11:02 AM GMT
I reckon that the GN will still be going 100 years from now.... and beyond
Report scrabbler February 22, 2024 11:52 AM GMT
The race has changed beyond recognition. There is no anticipation as the field approaches Beecher's of the Chair. I went to my first one at the course when Noble **** won.How many previous runnings would he have got round- let alone win ?
Report differentdrum February 22, 2024 12:02 PM GMT
For those who take a close interest it's increasingly become just another long distance race, but for those (the vast majority) who watch one race a year they won't notice the differences, so the answer is no.
Report Hayden February 22, 2024 12:07 PM GMT
It's still probably the main hope of recruiting new punters to horse racing and without new interest we'll all take the sport of horse racing to our graves.

Apologies if there's anyone out there in say their thirties who are actually interested in the sport.

It would interesting if posters could post their age IF under say 40yo  as i'd suspect there are just a handful that post on here , so come on do a Masked Singer , who are you ?
Report formoftheace February 22, 2024 12:49 PM GMT
I won’t be giving the race a second glance……red top rags will squawk and howl and the prize money will be bait for the Irish,but the race is a spent force…..
Report acey deucy March 4, 2024 11:52 PM GMT


How a Spanish Aristocrat Became Grand National’s Most fearless Jockey
In the chronicles of the Grand National, the narrative of Beltran de Osorio y Diez de Rivera, an aristocrat of Spanish lineage, stands as a testament to the embodiment of courage, passion, and, to some, a breathtaking level of recklessness.
His journey from a young boy, enamored with the world of horse racing, to becoming one of the event's most legendary figures, is a tale woven with the threads of ambition and resilience.
Beltran's odyssey into the realm of equestrianism began in childhood, with a simple gift from his father that sparked a burning passion for the sport.
At the age of five, he was introduced to the joy of riding with his first pony. This joy turned into an obsession when, on his eighth birthday, he was presented with a newsreel clip of the 1926 Grand National.
The thrill of the race, the challenge of the course, and the spirit of competition captured his imagination, setting him on a path that would lead him to the hallowed grounds of Aintree.
Rising through the ranks at his home club, Puerta de Hierro, Beltran quickly made a name for himself as a promising equestrian.
His talent was not confined to the fields of Spain; it carried him to the global stage, where he competed in the 1952 and 1960 Summer Olympics, showcasing his skill and dedication to the world. However, it was his foray into horse racing that marked the beginning of his storied association with the Grand National.
Despite his tall stature, which many considered a disadvantage in the tightly contested world of horse racing, Beltran made his mark early on, securing a second-place finish at the Sussex Stakes at Lingfield Park.
This early success was a prelude to his storied attempts at conquering the Grand National, starting as a "gentleman rider" in 1952.
Over the years, his participation in the race became the stuff of legend, highlighted by his resilient return year after year, despite the toll it took on his body.
Beltran's numerous attempts at the Grand National, particularly in years like 1963, 1965, 1966, and notably in 1973 with 16 bone screws in his body, in 1974 where he finished in a commendable 8th place, and his last ride in 1976 at the age of 58, underscored his indomitable spirit.
That final race left him with severe injuries, leading to the Jockey Club stewards' decision to not renew his riding permit, a decision made in light of the undeniable risks he faced each time he took to the course.
Yet, the Duke of Alburquerque's story does not end with the trials he faced at Aintree. He continued riding in Europe until the age of 65, retiring with a legacy that resonated particularly in Britain.
His daring and injury-defying performances, alongside his horse Nereo, became emblematic of his fearless approach to the sport, earning him a place in the hearts of racing enthusiasts.
Upon his death in 1994, Beltran was remembered not just for his exploits on the track but as a figure who embodied the qualities of a traditional Spanish Grandee, with a presence that was as commanding in life as it was in the world of horse racing.
A racing journalist poignantly described him as "an immensely popular character in British racing," a man whose courage and perseverance left an indelible mark on the sport.
Beltran de Osorio y Diez de Rivera, the "Iron" Duke of Albuquerque, remains a figure of inspiration, a reminder of the power of passion and the enduring spirit of those who dare to chase their dreams, no matter the cost.
Post Your Reply
<CTRL+Enter> to submit
Please login to post a reply.

Wonder

Instance ID: 13539
www.betfair.com