We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
Charlie Fellows is also aiming She’s Perfect there 5/1
|
|
By:
I have found the trials very disappointing. Whirl was the best winner, but I still have her 5 or 6lbs behind even an average Oaks winner. I'm not saying she can't improve more but I wouldn't back her to do so. A lightly raced, stoutly bred filly such as Minnie Hauk could improve massively when trained to the minute and contesting a really well run 12f race for the first time, but, again, I couldn't back her to find the 11 or 12lbs I reckon she'd need to find in an average year.
It's possible that Desert Flower could run a few pounds behind her 2yo best and still win. Furthermore, I have realised this year's Guineas was even slower than I thought. It was a difficult card for time comparisons, as most of the card was filled with improvers and/or lightly raced unknown quantities. Afterwards I gave the race the benefit of the doubt and rated it as high as was plausible, meaning I had Desert Flower a couple of pounds behind her 2yo best. Which seemed quite disappointing as it appeared that she had every opportunity to run up to her best, and that was probably as good as she wwas going to be as a 3yo. As other runners from that card have reappeared I have reevaluated some races and now have Desert Flower's Guineas win a good 8lbs slower than her Fillies Mile win. The sectional enthusiasts will say it was a well run race, pointing to the 99% closing sectional. This is where I differ, as I believe what can be an efficiently run race for inferior horses can be insufficient for a superior animal. And I don't subscribe to the theory that every single horse will run faster later if it has been inconvenienced by too slow an overall pace. I now have this year's Guineas as the slowest time performance since Sky Lantern's win. And we saw later how superior she really was when she got a fast pace at Ascot. So I have done a complete one-eighty on this race. I now think that we didn't see the best of Desert Flower in the Guineas and she ought to put up a big performance at Epsom. With her only real opponent, Lake Victoria, having targets over shorter I can see DF winning the Oaks comfortably. |
|
By:
I cannot write as knowledgeably and succinctly as 'figgis'. I'm far from a horsey-expert. The days of Extel taught me very little except trust the ticker-tape reader at your peril; his delivery was very different to the race reports of The Sporting life. I think he made it up most of the time. The start and finish were accurate; the in-betweens were not.
I'm going to keep it simple. I do not think Desert Flower will stay on breeding. On the other hand Appleby's other Guineas winner Ruling Court will, I think; Delacroix will not stay given he's by Dubawi. And, I'm putting my money where my mouth is. |
|
By:
I wouldn't argue with anyone who believes DF won't stay on breeding. It's not a subject I know much about or have ever been very interested in exploring in depth. My brief study on it many years ago led me to believe that it's only ever a very, very rough guide. Although, there are possibly people out there who have become expert at using it as a predictive guide.
I prefer the evidence of the racecourse and the way connections choose to run them early on as 2yos, as you'd expect gallops clues dictating which trips to run them over. After a couple of runs in weak affairs over 7f Godolphin had no qualms about stepping her up to a mile for Pattern events. On watching DF win the Fillies Mile my thoughts were that she was definitely an Oaks filly if training on, but wasn't too sure if a faster filly might beat her in the Guineas. I'm happy to stick with my immediate thinking on that score. |
|
By:
With The Lion In Winter a probable absentee, and Delacroix "Class-less" I'd like Appleby to whip Collmore twice again next week in the Classics.
|
|
By:
Some wonderful posts on here. Keep up the great work lads. Great read.
|
|
By:
Delacroix will not stay given he's by Dubawi
Why would that make him a non stayer? |
|
By:
9 still in the oaks
|
|
By:
I think AOB will run more than one in The Oaks to ensure a stern pace to chisel out any stamina limitation of the worthy fav Desert Flower.
Delacroix is by Dubawi. And, Dubawi has not sired a Derby winner, I believe. |
|
By:
Being down to six was a joke Impossible as punters are waiting to know what Moore will ride, the other two will then be unwanted.
At least you chose Giselle before his say so, how sad to have to wait to only back what he rides! Suppose it saves on form study! ![]() ![]() |
|
By:
Plenty of Oaks winners from ballydoyle that were not ridden by the no 1 stable jockey. Was, Qualify Snowfall.
|
|
By:
Dubawi has not sired a Derby winner, I believe.
True, but he sired last year's Oaks winner. |
|
By:
|
|
By:
In this race you have three to choose from from the top four in the betting, must be a fanboy nightmare!
![]() Do you have an opinion or one that you’ve backed like Impossible Try My Best? I’ve not had a bet and won’t now, thought that Whirl was a good thing for the Dianne, but maybe they think that they have another for that. |
|
By:
Desert Flower will win. Backed pre 1000G.
|
|
By:
|
|
By:
no doubt coolmore will let them all run , one at the front , to stretch the fav, and if any stamina limitations , whirl and giselle to pick up the pieces, id like to back the supp entry e/way but i dont think shell stay , imo should let the burrows horse take her chance, but end of day if fav stays fav wins
|
|
By:
SBS said before the 1000 guineas that he felt she’d be better over further. Might have been the target, he’s not often wrong when he’s got one.
|
|
By:
"no doubt Coolmore will let them all run"
Indeed, when they do not have a shortie of the fav to minimise the chances of others. But, The Lion In Winter will be an absentee come last dec. Betfair market is usually spot-on, regardless. |
|
By:
Just to have an interest I did a small Oaks/Derby win double
Wemightakedlongway 16/1 and Purview 33/1 |
|
By:
Purview is a non Kincsem
![]() |
|
By:
They shouldn’t have taken your bet
|
|
By:
No Epsom bid for promising Dermot Weld Derby entry as trainer opts to 'give him more time'
Dermot Weld will not be winning his second Derby this year after the trainer ruled Purview out of Saturday's showdown at Epsom. The Kingman colt went into plenty of notebooks after chasing home Derby favourite Delacroix in a trial at Leopardstown last time on what was only his second start, but Weld has resisted the temptation of having a crack at the world's most famous Flat race. Instead, the Rosewell House trainer, who famously teamed up with the late Pat Smullen to land the Derby with Harzand in 2016, will take the patient approach with the promising Purview. "He's not going to run in the Derby," said Weld. "I'm very happy with him and he's in great order, but he's a big horse and I'd just like to give him a little more time. Everything might just have happened a bit too soon for him at Epsom. From the post 31st May |
|
By:
They (Juddmonte) are Supping the French Colt New Ground
|
|
By:
Delashay
They shouldn’t have taken your bet I was wearing a sign that said MUG ![]() |
|
By:
They were wrong to have it in the list. Easy to miss a bit of news.
|
|
By:
I backed Elwateen when confirmed, but seriously thinking of the cash out. Had she got a prep run I think she would have chased up the favourite in the 1,000, but I said afterwards that the step up for the French Oaks looked a better idea than this race. The expected rain firms up that belief. She is relatively weak in the market. If the favourite doesn't get home this looks almost as tricky as the Derby. Strange comments from Joseph saying his filly was a legitimate contender, but at the same time not committing her to the race. Was he just being contrary? She beat a promising horse on soft last time, but quite likely that one didn't want that ground.
|
|
By:
….. is the only other Irish runner after Dermot Weld scratched his Leopardstown Trial runner-up Purview.
Catherine Macrae Reporter Published on 2 June 2025inDerby festival Last updated 14:08, 2 June 2025 They were wrong to have the market up, I’d ask for my money back. It was updated at 2:08 If you put your bet on that morning on the 2nd they should have taken the market down. |
|
By:
Minnie Hawk 9/2
Giselle 7/1 Whirl 15/2 Before jockey confirmations. Let’s see how they change. They are out of line to the market with their OR’s |
|
By:
Having rewatched Newbury , I cant see the sense in Qilin Queen at 42 and Revoir at 12.5 , I see the logic but not the price differential . The former may not stay but not much pace about the latter .
|
|
By:
said it was weird on another thread that they were running Lion in the Dante as they don’t use it to target Epsom usually. Continuous ran but wasn’t entered for Epsom. I think they’re changing up their running plans to keep things fresh so punters have no idea as to their plans, hence running horses in trials for races that they’ll never go for.
I had the pleasure recently of visiting Coolmore and Godolphin studs in Ireland recently. You are very mistaken if you think that what punters think is given any wconsideration in that regard, you are very much mistaken. These people are investing millions in bloodstock so the focus is all about creating the next big stallion earner (Wootton Basset is currently Coolmore's top stallion on E300,000 per cover , so with upwards of 120 plus covers a year that equates to E36M pa minimum), I shouldn't think that punters come into that equation. |
|
By:
Horseracing without punting is very, very unlikely to exist. Punting gives it the buzz, a stimulant some will try to achieve with other recreational activities.
Only the egos of the very rich and powerful will think having the best stallions and breeding the best horse will attract or increase betting revenue; betting revenues in east Asia surpass those of others in the world many folds despite a much inferior breed. For instance (from Google) the average turnover per race in the UK is £16k; Ireland (£22k); France (£24k). But, in Hong Kong a whopping £155k. Thus, is turnover per race directly related to the quality of the horses or breeding? Nope. It's solely on betting. Punters will bet on anything, anywhere some more so than others. I'd do the same too if I knew my money would not be going into the bookies satchels or pay out as dividends to their shareholders. |
|
By:
I shouldn't think that punters come into that equation.
They most definitely don’t come into any equation, they aren’t up upfront, hint rather than say - is that wrong with all the going’s on in this years Derby market? Glad that you enjoyed your trip Sandown, no one picked up or talked about them running their number one in the Dante. Anyone recall their last number one who showed up there, won en route to taking the Derby??? I’ve enjoyed your contributions to the Arc threads. |
|
By:
If anyone fancies the Lion to do that then add a smilie before the race.
They haven’t used the Irish trials in years for their first choice. Though impressive winners have been made favourite the same as Delacroix has. With all the talk of the Lion a sleight of hand trick was played this year. If the Lion was their number one by as far as was talked of, would a stall difference of four matter? Figgis sees the draw as inconsequential. If only they were drawn next to each other bang in the middle next to Ruling Court! |
|
By:
In a well run race yes I do see the draw as insignificant. If we get a falsely run race then I fully accept that the draw could prove vital. On the other hand a good jockey can negate the effects of a poor draw if he's proactive early on while the pace is slow. However, a good jockey can still make a poor decision. How do you factor all these possibilities into your price? A horse that you have a perfectly good handle on up to now can suddenly improve 10lbs or more past your selection on the day. My point is I don't see these matters as worth wasting too much time on and diverting away from the main aim of judging what is the most likely outcome in a normally run race in an average year. Everything else can be lumped under your '**** happens' allowance and factored into the price you'd take.
|
|
By:
TLIW was scratched for The Dewhurst. He also missed The Guineas as he did not come to hand, but everything seemed fine with him. However, he was rushed for The Dante because of Epsom, otherwise no Epsom. As such, I think he's Coolmore's No 1 contender all along. Of course, the draw intervenes similarly to Delacroix too. The only one of theirs backed is Lambourn probably because of his good draw, no stamina limitation and/or probable softer going.
If any of these does not win ie Ruling Court, TLIW or Pride Of Aras one can safely assume the winner will be another Serpentine or Ruler Of The World. Hopefully, it's not another US Army Ranger or Cliffs Of Moher. I think if TLIW can get a good position 3f into the race then he'd have a good chance unless he's undercooked again or have regressed since The Dante. If so, retirement is almost a certainty. |
|
By:
Was played this year *?*
I think he was their number one. |
|
By:
|
|
By:
7 of the 9 have tips by their name on the post!!
|