Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 163 comments are related to the topic:
2025 2000 Guineas

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 3 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 163
By:
Figgis
When: 04 May 25 16:50
As the horses will be racing in future it ought to be important to take a view on past events.
By:
Figgis
When: 04 May 25 18:52
I see Shadow Of Light is a possible for the SJP. Given the speed he showed last year over 6f it was no surprise to see him quicken impressively off such soft early splits. However, the race was so slowly run that, for me, it proved nothing about his stamina for a strongly run mile. At the moment I remain doubtful.
By:
Figgis
When: 05 May 25 11:17
I see the RP analysis is that FOG should have won but I also see they rate the winning performance well up to scratch. Whereas I rate the performance half a stone below a typical winning effort. That isn't necessarily to say that RC is half a stone below an average winner, just that the way the race was run didn't allow for a proper Gp1 performance. As said previously, maybe RC was also hindered by the early pace but had the tactical speed to still prevail. But my view at the moment is that he was advantaged by how the race was run. FOG is a longer striding horse and RC had already shown some fast fractions when winning in Meydan.

RC might show himself to be the real deal but, for me, this year's Guineas was won by a Gp2 performance. Even if RC does stay the Derby trip, in anything but a substandard renewal he is going to need to run faster than he's shown so far.
By:
Delashay
When: 05 May 25 11:45
The thing is the racing post weren’t riding Field of Gold! As for Ruling Court if he’s thought as a a Derby prospect he shouldn’t be quickening up like that (seeing off a miler 10f type in the process) off such a slow pace should he?
The Jacques Le Māoris looks tailor made for Shadow of Light the St James’s Palace isn’t the be all and end all, but his guineas run was massive against two race fit rivals.

As said I’d love to know his body weight for the Guineas and wherever we next see him. Come on Charlie give us the info that should be there for all punters to see, just not those who are on inside ;)
By:
Figgis
When: 05 May 25 12:30
As for Ruling Court if he’s thought as a a Derby prospect he shouldn’t be quickening up like that

I don't think you could say he's a doubtful stayer just based on that.

The Jacques Le Māoris looks tailor made for Shadow of Light the St James’s Palace isn’t the be all and end all, but his guineas run was massive against two race fit rivals.

Even the Marois is usually run at a decent pace. The Guineas was run in a time just over a second quicker than the moderate handicap over the same trip while carrying 3lbs less than that winner. It was more of a test of tactical speed rather than being a proper Gp1 mile test. Actually I've never seen a Guineas run in that manner before.
By:
roadrunner46
When: 05 May 25 13:47
Sounds like the plan was to set a steady pace for the race with the Godolphin pacemaker and turn the race into a sprint, knowing they can press the button on ruling court and steal the race, they are tactical geniuses or just taking a leaf out of the coolmore book
By:
Delashay
When: 05 May 25 15:07
I appreciate all your time and knowledge Figgis I re: times and comparisons. It’s not what I use. The mile at Deauville is the easiest you’ll get, actually 7f and a bit, I think he’d have no trouble in it. If not then the new Jean Pratt of 7 first.

Re: Ruling Court, I’m not saying he’s a doubtful stayer but saying the opposite maybe he’s quite the horse if he can stay having bagged a slow run mile.

More fool all the other jockeys and they should be given as much stick as Shoemark  then Roadrunner if they let the rag set the fractions. Scorthy and Seaguls both jumped equally as well, Hawkeye just behind who the jock said was to be ridden forwards  to make use of his stamina but didn’t. Interesting they all finished well behind the pacemaker despite only going slow up front, you’d expect that if they went too fast?

I don’t think Godolphin wanted to win with Shadow, hence my comments about the race weight fitness wise.
By:
Delashay
When: 05 May 25 15:16
We have the Irish Guineas and French guineas, Aiden always targets Ascot and remember how Paddington appeared? Looks like a big carrot 5/2 for field of Gold not knowing who’ll come forwards from the stable across the water.

Not many horses do the Guineas St James’s double and here’s a horse who was going to break the Craven / Guineas hoodo and now people want to back him to win at Ascot as though he won the guineas. Only the best archive those rarities.

I think Gosden’s post race frustration was that he knows it’ll only get tougher from now on.
By:
Figgis
When: 05 May 25 15:31
Delashay, I understand your reasoning and maybe it's a pointer that RC is less likely to stay. It's just that, while he quickened well, they weren't astonishing sectionals given the slow early pace. I really have no opinion whether he'll stay or not.

Interesting they all finished well behind the pacemaker despite only going slow up front, you’d expect that if they went too fast?


Yes that is something that I was very surprised about. On watching the race live I knew they were going slow very early, but given how they finished quite strung out I was expecting to find that they'd quickened up early enough, with me being too involved to notice, which is what usually happens in the Guineas when the very early pace is slow. First reaction was I thought FOG was possibly just flattered by staying on late and I'd overrated him.

I wasn't expecting to find the race was so slow comparatively. I accept that there may be something I have missed or not been able to account for, such as a big change in the tailwind between races, for instance. Possibly I have still overrated FOG's Craven win, but at the moment I don't see it that way.

As for Ruling Court, if he was a runner that was going to be undervalued in future I'd give him the benefit of the doubt. As that's not going to be the case I want concrete evidence he's a proper Gp1 horse, but the way the Guineas was run doesn't provide me with that.

I'm prepared for this statement to be revisited and ridiculed in future if RC goes on to win the triple crown or proves himself an outstanding performer, as it's only my feeling at this stage of the season, but I wouldn't be surprised if we saw the best of RC on Saturday and he doesn't do a great deal afterwards.
By:
Delashay
When: 05 May 25 15:36
Irish 2000 25th May 21 days away (come too soon but didn’t have a hard race) 4/1

Prix Du Jockey Club 1st June 31 days away 20/1 only odds I see from some outfit.

St James’s Palace 17th June 45 days away  5/2

Which do you chance? I think he’s made for the race at Chantilly, stiff uphill, big strong horse can hold his ground.

Not knowing where he’ll go is another reason why 5/2 makes no appeal, sorry impossible!
By:
Delashay
When: 05 May 25 15:46
Fair enough Figgis it’s what I was saying he was ready for the day, yet wore the second string hat! It’s good to have an opinion and it’s easy for others to laugh after.

The Dante is a weird one if Lion In Winter shows, he never run his best there (sometimes Leger types) but maybe they think the return to that track will be to his liking.

Lots to look forwards to :)
By:
impossible123
When: 05 May 25 19:29
Immediately in the post 2000G race I think Mr Gosden eluded to connections of Field Of Gold (FoG) had a tendency/liking for running their 2000G runner in the St James's Palace (SJP) at Royal Ascot (17th June). For instance Kingman (2nd at Newmarket) went to Irish 2000G, then SJP. However, Cosmic Year (CY) had been earmarked for the Irish 2000G this year on 24th May prior to the defeat of FoG. However, this might change now, but FoG will not run against CY.

I do not think the French Derby is on the agenda of FoG, and winning the SJP is more prestigious as a sire. Post this FoG could go for The Eclipse at Sandown (10f) on 5th July.
By:
Figgis
When: 05 May 25 22:45
https://www.timeform.com/horse-racing/features/ratings-update/ratings-update-reaction-to-newmarkets-guineas-meeting--552025

The Timeform view is that FOG possibly should have won ridden more proactively.


https://www.attheraces.com/racecard/Newmarket/03-May-2025/1535

Simon Rowlands view is that FOG should have won.

My view is more with Timeform's regarding the ride, in that he possibly would have won. Nevertheless, I do believe if it had been a truly run race FOG almost definitely would have won, and won easily.
By:
Delashay
When: 06 May 25 10:41
I like Gosden as a trainer impossible, he’s one of the last of the old school, but I take what is said largely with a large pinch of salt. It might be wrong to compare Kingman and Goldie as the former was an out and out miler, the latter will get beyond a mile so more options are open to him.

Do we think that the pink and green silks have others who are guineas grade? What are your views on Cosmic and Jonquil?  That’s open to all and your figures also Figgis.

Thanks for the links, I’m not a fan of Timeform but it seems everyone is largely in agreement the best ride won and as said earlier Buick won the race twice. The old adage, “You snooze you lose…” comes to mind.

We all have our fav jocks and my list has dwindled dramatically with all the retirements. Take a look back at the ride given to Cicero’s Gift in the St jame’s Palace won by Paddington. Race comments read, “Midfield, not clear run repeatedly from over 2f out, eyecatcher.”
The horse was drawn 2 next to Shelby and Chaldean but broke slow and was never given a chance. It’s why @ 2/1 added with all the other speculation as to target I’d not be a backer as I’m not a fan with my money and trust and there are other horses who could show up.
By:
Figgis
When: 06 May 25 10:57
What are your views on Cosmic and Jonquil?


I have Jonquil's best 8lbs below FOG's Craven, and Cosmic Year a further 1lb below. Although as I've said before I wouldn't quibble about 1lb either way. Both open to further improvement but I wouldn't say either of them had easy races last time, so I don't see progression as guaranteed.
By:
impossible123
When: 06 May 25 16:20
Mr Gosden is good, no match to Sir Cecil, Harwood, Stoute or Cumani though. These were supremos of trainers, highly reliable, punters-friendly and never multi-targeted their star charges.

I still think SJP is the key target for FoG unless connections decide to take in the Irish 2000G too on the way.Post this either the Eclipse at Sandown or another 10f prestigious race.
By:
Delashay
When: 06 May 25 16:31
Thank you Figgis and yes you could be right about having had not such easy races.

Impossible I now see that Goldie has been installed as 5/4 fav for the Irish 2000

Rashabar isn’t in the French 2000 this weekend but is said to be rerouted here, his odds of 25/1 look way too big in comparison given their respective runs in the Lagadere. Maybe they’ll meet here before the Ascot showpiece.

They were great trainers agreed, I’m glad that Gosden is still going. He was all class when Rewilding came to grief at Ascot and I enjoy his sense of humor. He seems to like the wayward types who’ve reformed so respect to him and Shoemark for quitting the bottle along with Murphy.
By:
Delashay
When: 06 May 25 16:50
^ Harwoood was before my time
By:
impossible123
When: 06 May 25 17:03
Gosden is eloquent (his missus is a brief) nevertheless has a tendency to hoodwink punters eg So Mi Dar, the easy winner of the Musidora who did not make Epsom due to a slight injury (Gosden's description) but would be targeted at the Irish Oaks. The horse ran in Yarmouth and Chantilly instead. Another was Jack Hobbs whose 1st target was the Hardwicke but ran in the Prince Of Wales on unsuitable ground instead.

Field Of Gold is 5/4 for the Irish 2000G. It looks like a decision has been made to atone for the disappointment at Newmarket.
By:
impossible123
When: 06 May 25 17:08
Harwood and Starkey were a great team esp on big races. Dancing Brave, Lear Fan, Warning to name 3 I'd remember; Cataldi winning the Lincoln. Those were the days when horseracing was fun, competitive and a proper sport; no multi-targets or dodging another star performer from another target.
By:
elisjohn
When: 06 May 25 18:29
agree Imp, harwood was a fantastic trainer, and the days of rouisillon, d brave, kalaglow, warning, d brave was a wonderful era , but id have Gosden better than Luca imo, but hern, stoute cecil, era , nothing on a par with those now
By:
impossible123
When: 06 May 25 19:13
Agree, however, Cumani did not always have the pick of the expensive buys of the big owners. Nevertheless, he did have some very good horses eg Bairn, Markofdistinction, Sudden Love, etc; Fish 'N' Chips won a very big handicap at Goodwood.
By:
impossible123
When: 06 May 25 19:18
I forgot about Kahyasi the Derby winner. Sorry Mr Cumani.
By:
Delashay
When: 07 May 25 11:05
Purple Moon and Bauer, I wish there was better footage of Dancing Brave winning the Arc to see his sweeping run.

The news just broke about Shoemark and I don’t like anyone being given the tin tack. As I said you have certain jocks who you trust to carry your money. It’s like the betting shop punters who’d moan about Spencer always leaving it too late, just don’t bet!

This decision was likely made a few days ago when he was 4/1 for the Irish Guineas as highlighted. Now 5/4 so someone has filled their boots before any news as to where he will show next has been released.
I don’t like greed.

Impossible now you see why 5/2 for the Ascot showpiece with that doubt of taking in the Irish guineas first made no appeal.

How shabby we can get odds from every bookie for next years chelts but no anti price market for the Prix Du Jockey Club before the French Guineas has been run!

Always in their favour like the disappearance of 1/4 odds for all group one races with 8 or more runners.
By:
impossible123
When: 07 May 25 17:07
Had Field of Gold won last saturday he'd be going straight to the SJP - his key target. It's over 3 weeks between the Irish 2000G and the SJP. I think the Irish 2000G is his for the taking.
By:
Delashay
When: 07 May 25 18:04
And as said to do the Guineas SJP double is very rare. Hope you took the chance @ 4/1 like they have, not the 3/1 that the lazy post reported earlier. Interesting Seagul would like to see him in the Derby going further!
The stiff Curragh mile will help but beware come over likes the race and Rasbabar had the better of him on ground that he disliked, maybe Meehan fancies taking his scalp too?
25/1 for a horse who has form with him and left him in his wake…
By:
Delashay
When: 07 May 25 18:08
Taking in the Irish Guineas looks desperate to get the mile G1 on his cv before stepping up in trip. The SJP would be eggs all in, lack of confidence?
Still the jock change is to your advantage.
By:
Delashay
When: 09 May 25 16:11
Hi to all the ITV gang! Yesterday Weaver talking about Shadow of Light body weight and the end of the show today all guessing the weight of Illinois. The point is we shouldn’t have to guess when a horse is at its ideal racing weight!

The French Guineas has been drawn, some with shockers in the colts version whilst Ballydoyle send over a few for the Pouliches.
By:
Delashay
When: 09 May 25 16:33
Three at first look three of the French have entries for the Ascot race where Goldie is Fav. All three are conditioned by trainers open to travel. 20/1 33/1 & 50/1 for Ascot respectively. They have a terrible record in the colts race, better in the Coronation, but Head’s colt handed 18 of 18 could still be a lurker for Ascot (has to find more on figures) if the draw does for him here, they’ll be hoping for a Lope De Vega run.
Was 16/1 everywhere before the draw now 40’s, 33 & 25 about, though some still at 16/1 and even 14/1.
By:
eric_morris
When: 10 May 25 11:41
Has anyone asked O’Brien whether he is going to prepare his best horse for the Guineas with a promise from him you can hit his gonads with a frying pan if he doesn’t do that before all of the Guineas discussions take place?
By:
Delashay
When: 10 May 25 17:20
I’ve read two conflicting stories about a horse in the French 2000 tomorrow, one where the trainer says his charge lacks class,  in another he says he’s a champion! Trainers, who’d trust them!
By:
elisjohn
When: 11 May 25 15:39
posted 30/03, , fancied h mattise  for 2000 gns in an open race, ffs
By:
Delashay
When: 11 May 25 17:03
I’m not sure that winning in France from a favourable draw means that he’d of won the English 2000.
Given he likes a bend you should of been backing for Ascot.
By:
brandyontherocks
When: 11 May 25 20:52
Have
By:
Delashay
When: 14 May 25 20:56
Why is Twain not listed for the Irish 2000 on the RP?
By:
Delashay
When: 17 May 25 11:35
I found this part of the article regarding Cosmic Year worth picking through.

“ That Listed win might well be followed by the Irish 2,000 Guineas and even the presence of Field Of Gold, in the same colours, hasn’t stopped Charlton unpicking the race.

"I think he has slightly unique skills," he explained. "I think he's probably quicker than the others who will turn up in the Guineas, so if we can use that to our advantage he'll have a chance.
"Oisin [Murphy, who rode him to his first two successes] has always been convinced he'll stay a mile and I think he will because he's very relaxed when he gets cover.

"The time people tell me he's too quick to stay the Guineas trip on what they say is a stiff track, but on everything we've seen we think he will, particularly if Aidan [O'Brien] doesn't have one of those ten-furlong horses that needs a flat-out pace."

He must be alluding to Twain here who I feel will go back France for the Prix Du Jockey Club but he might also mean Field Of Gold when he says he feels that Cosmic is a quicker type.
Separating the Juddmonte three will mean one stepping up in trip and potentially one or two back should Cosmic not stay the mile.
By:
impossible123
When: 17 May 25 19:27
I think it's very unlikely Cosmic Year (7/1) will run against Field Of Gold (8/11) in Ireland. I also think they will not meet in the SJP at Royal Ascot either.
By:
Delashay
When: 17 May 25 21:13
If he did happen to go care to say if you’d be on or stick with Field of Gold who you were keen on also for the SJP? Are you still having seen the French 2000?

Presuming you are right where do you think the Cosmic might rock up and Jonquil?
By:
impossible123
When: 17 May 25 22:27
Field Of Gold is not a betting proposition in Ireland even with Mr Murphy onboard; no bet on Cosmic Year either. Horseracing is only a game to me. And, I do not respect anyone who does not provide a specimen when asked by the coppers post wrapping one's car in a tree esp if the person has a history of substance abuse. This repetitive and flagrant flouting of authority is abhorrent to me.
By:
impossible123
When: 17 May 25 22:38
Sorry, I do not know where Cosmic Year and Jonquil might rock up. It could be the French Derby on 1st of June unless Field Of Gold is an absentee in the SJP. The same is true in Ireland. As an aside, the French Derby is also too early for The Lion In Winter going on what AOB has repeatedly stipulated the horse needs more time before Epsom.
Page 3 of 5  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com