Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Horse Antepost

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 287 comments are related to the topic:
2024 1000 Guineas Newmarket

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 5 of 8  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 287
By:
Figgis
When: 24 Sep 23 13:56
COT, take out the winner and Cherry Blossom only beat My Mate Alfie by a neck, with some very ordinary types close up behind. These sales races have big fields, but in most years they contain an awful lot of dross. The time backs up that it was no better than a Gp3 performance by the winner. A good 10lbs behind Fallen Angel, I'd say. Vespertilio has much better form and is a slightly bigger price.
By:
Figgis
When: 24 Sep 23 14:16
*beat My Mate Alfie by a neck, while in receipt of 5lbs
By:
Howellsy
When: 24 Sep 23 15:33
I think she's run to a literal mark of around 106. It has to go down as a superb debut - redolent of Lush Lashes, who was less impressive but who proved group 1 class after a few hiccups at 3.
By:
JayTrumpOldTomDubbl
When: 24 Sep 23 17:24
I would be in agreement with the comments of figgis. One Look surely be sold. Owned by a syndicate. Mums Tipple comes to mind. Won sales race by 11 lengths and big money turned down. I wouldda sold mums with bridle saddle and jockey if he delayed exiting the plate. Perhaps entering in the 1000gns was very good sales work. Very shrewd business man Mr 2me.
By:
cryoftruth
When: 24 Sep 23 18:34
My Mate Alfie lumped 10 stones and got an official rating of 96 when second in a nursery. Seems no reason to think he ran any worse on Saturday when utterly annihilated by One Look. If you only allow her 7lbs for ease of the slaughter she is pretty good.

4th behind the brilliant One Look on Saturday was the filly Storm in Miami who also has an official rating of 96. Presumably this  filly officially rated 96 is one of the “very ordinary ones”.

It is as I say very hard to calculate “easily”. But if you absolutely hack up, cantering all over horses rated 96 or in Cherry Blossom’s case 101 and win by miles, you deserve just a little respect.

If you rate the race against any of the 2nd, 3rd or 4th, you end up with a high figure. If you look at the second, she got beaten a stone. She is rated 101.

If you rate the race against the 4th, and she was beaten about 18 lbs, well add 96 and 18 - that is 114.

That is an amazing figure for a filly’s first ever appearance on a racecourse. Of course it’s hard to know how much the winner had in hand, but if she had been given an inch of rein at the 2 furlong marker, she might have won by 12 lengths instead of the easing up 6.

Comparisons with Mum’s Tipple ignore the fact that he was not making his first appearance like One Look when he won his auction race at York. Nor did he have a group 2 second behind him.

And maybe Coolmore or Godolphin will snap her up. Not sure that would be a bad thing as both organisations understand form better than most.

I like One Look, she looked amazing. She has a fantastic turn of foot. The pace of the race was clearly against her. Her turn of foot would have been far more effective off a faster pace.

She was going very easily but would have been much more impressive had they gone a better pace.

That’s the trouble with speed figures. They tell you how fast a race was run rather than how good the runners were. That’s why old speed figure men like Ken Hussey often added a “class factor” to speed figures as you would often get a group one winner rated 40 on speed figures the same day as a player apparently ran 100!

I think she showed signs of greenness and although she slaughtered them all, she looks sure to have benefitted from the experience. She could be anything.

And, even if Figgis is spot on and the performance is only equivalent to a group 3, just how many 2yo fillies manage a group 3 performance first time out can any of you identify in racing history?

Not many I suspect.
By:
Figgis
When: 24 Sep 23 18:55
That’s why old speed figure men like Ken Hussey often added a “class factor”

The pace of the race was clearly against her

Personally I didn't see the race as slowly run

COT, as far as I'm concerned Hussey was 'the man' when it comes to speed figures. The class factor, as you call it, was incorporated into the going allowance, as standard times for Grade 1 courses, for instance, will obviously be faster than standard times recorded at Grade 3 tracks. There is no class factor added from race to race.

just how many 2yo fillies manage a group 3 performance first time out

Very few, it was exceptional in that regard. However, there won't be many trained to put up that kind of performance first time out, even if capable. Therefore you have to question if it's beneficial in the long term.

Anyway, One Look may very well develop into a Gp1 performer. I'll leave her progress for others to predict. But the statement so often trotted out in the racing media, 'sure to improve', is more often proved wrong than correct.
By:
penzance
When: 24 Sep 23 19:14
110-112 performance to me that run.
By:
cryoftruth
When: 24 Sep 23 19:21
Nice answer Figgis, and although she might be a group 1 Filly, she may go on to be less than awesome. Who can tell.

But nice to have a disagreement with civility.

I was a fan of Ken H as well, but more because of his repeated attacks in his articles on the Quality Street Gang  aka BOLA. He was no a big fan of the big bookies and quite rightly too.


And best of luck to you.
By:
Howellsy
When: 26 Sep 23 19:33
The rpr is 106, which is interesting since they usually work on a slightly higher scale than the OR. Let's see what the handicapper does.
By:
jamesp
When: 28 Sep 23 10:51
I seem to recall that a few juvenile fillies have won at Group 3 or Listed level on racecourse debut, but it's quite a rare occurrence.
Hermana Estrella won the Gr.3 Coolmore Stud Sprint at Naas a couple of years ago, beating subsequent Gr.2 Queen Mary winner Quick Suzy by a length and 5 lengths. She was given an official rating of 106 after that debut win and was next seen down the field in the Irish Guineas and never raced again (presumably she had setbacks and problems).
One has to be impressed by One Look's remarkable winning debut, but I'm inclined to be a bit sceptical for reasons already outlined above. She must have been prepared specially for the race and she was clearly very well suited by the soft ground. The runner-up and fourth evidently failed to get the trip in the ground, and the jockey of the third reported that his mount ran around in the closing stages. Was it a flash in the pan, or is she an exceptional champion filly in the making? Frankly, it's impossible to say after one run, but I'm not backing her at this stage.
By:
jamesp
When: 28 Sep 23 10:59
Just 10 fillies have been left in the Gr.1 Prix Marcel Boussac on Sunday. Clear form picks are Darnation, Opera Singer and Les Pavots (winner of the Gr.2 Prix du Calvados), all of whom have won pattern races on soft ground. Julica is unbeaten in two starts in the provinces, which she has won by an aggregate of 9 lengths, and she could be anything.
By:
impossible123
When: 28 Sep 23 11:35
'jamesp', thanks for your incessant contribution here.

Good to see Opera Singer has been declared for The Marcel Boussac. She'd be one of the fav no doubt on sunday. As such, it may mean Ylang Ylang Fillies Mile bound on 13th Oct at Newmarket.
By:
impossible123
When: 28 Sep 23 13:05
Maybe not. Ylang Ylang is running tomorrow in The Rockfel. She's is 4/1 with Shuwari the fav at 2/1.
By:
penzance
When: 28 Sep 23 13:45
TForm have One Look 108p
By:
jamesp
When: 28 Sep 23 14:50
Top 6f filly Ramatuelle misses both the Gr.1 Cheveley Park Stakes and the Gr.1 Prix Jean Luc Lagardere (for which she was originally an entry). I guess she's finished for the season, but they may still be considering the Breeders' Cup Juvenile Fillies Turf.
By:
JayTrumpOldTomDubbl
When: 28 Sep 23 19:54
Goodness I would not say that the contributions of jamesp are incessant. Far from it. I find his posts interesting and very insightful showing a deep understanding of his topic. He also shows ability to communicate his perspective effectively to others so that we can appreciate his insights. I appreciate his posts and the posts of many others on this particular topic.
By:
jamesp
When: 28 Sep 23 20:46
'Incessant' does tend to have a negative connotation, but I'm sure that this was not intended: 'ongoing' or 'continuing' is what was meant, I think...Cool
By:
impossible123
When: 29 Sep 23 08:00
Sorry 'jamesp', I did not mean it that way. I meant your diligent approach to gathering and feeding us info. Keep up the good work, I'm most appreciative!
By:
Figgis
When: 29 Sep 23 20:21
A good performance today from Carla's Way. Not as good as Fallen Angel (6lbs better), Ramatuelle or even Vespertilio, but ahead of every other filly I've seen so far. She'd only need to find around another 4lbs to be up to average Guineas winning ability. Of course, we don't know which fillies will improve next year, or by how much, and which will go backwards, but at this stage I'd have her ahead of the likes of One Look, Matrika (needs to find about a stone, for me) and Darnation. I have Opera Singer just behind Carla's Way, and on Sunday we'll get to see how that one has come out of her latest impressive win.
By:
jamesp
When: 30 Sep 23 15:06
Yes, it was a good performance from Carla's Way in the Rockfel. Connections are not sure she will get further than 7f on a stiff track but may try her over the sharp mile at Santa Anita in the Breeders' Cup. Shuwari came from a long way back and I'm not sure that the winner would beat her again over a mile.
Fallen Angel backers will have been pleased to see Porta Fortuna win the Cheveley Park Stakes this afternoon: she may not have been ideally suited by the yielding ground when beaten nearly six lengths in the Moyglare, but it's good to see Fallen Angel's form boosted in this way. Ramatuelle remains the best 6f filly in Europe and would have won the Cheveley Park very comfortably if she had turned up and reproduced past form: her close second to Vandeek in the Prix Morny is extremely smart form, boosted by the latter's impressive win in the Middle Park Stakes this afternoon.
By:
jamesp
When: 01 Oct 23 14:01
Scintillating performance from Opera Singer in the Boussac. She looks a champion in the making and clearly has enough speed for a mile next spring. I've taken 7/1 for the Guineas to add to 10/1 Fallen Angel. I'm not looking to back anything else for the race, though we'll have to keep an eye on what happens in the Fillies' Mile and Breeders' Cup in the closing weeks of the season...
By:
Jack Bauer "24"
When: 01 Oct 23 14:14
I've also managed to take some 7/1. She's a lovely big filly and should continue to improve.
By:
impossible123
When: 01 Oct 23 14:37
Opera Singer seems to have locked on to this prize. It will take a very good one to beat her if she turns up. Those running in the Fillies Mile might have a say, a place at best, I believe..
By:
Figgis
When: 01 Oct 23 17:35
Very impressive from Opera Singer with a performance that I'd say matches an average Guineas winner. That said, I still have Fallen Angel a couple of pounds ahead. I wouldn't expect either filly to make much, if any, improvement between now and next year. The top 2yo fillies rarely do, it's the lesser ones that may possibly catch them up. Fallen Angel is due to run again in the Fillies Mile. Personally I'm not sure that's a good idea after the big effort last time. The same goes for Opera Singer if she were to run. If any of them do disappoint in that race then it possibly won't hinder their chances in next year's classic anyway, but they will probably end up being a better price.

There's the O'brien factor to take into account. He obviously knows how to ready one for the Guineas, whereas Burke has it to prove. Nevertheless, I'd still side with Fallen Angel next year if she makes the race.
By:
impossible123
When: 01 Oct 23 18:28
Opera Singer could go to America or finish for the season. Her target is the 1000G, and middle distance races, according to AOB. But, no mention of The Oaks though.

I think Ylang Ylang may go to the Fillies Mile for a Gp 1 accreditation - she finished strong in The Rockfel over 7f. Then 1000G and The Oaks perhaps.
By:
jamesp
When: 04 Oct 23 08:44
Opera Singer has unsurprisingly leapt to the top of Timeform's juvenile fillies' rankings:
114p    OPERA SINGER (f)
111    RAMATUELLE (f)
110p    FALLEN ANGEL (f)
108p    CARLA'S WAY (f)
108p    ONE LOOK (f)
108    PORTA FORTUNA (f)
By:
impossible123
When: 04 Oct 23 17:16
I'm surprised Opera Singer is still available at 6/1. I thought he'd be a lot shorter eg 3/1 given her annihilation of her opponents in France.
By:
brandyontherocks
When: 04 Oct 23 20:19
If you make her that price then you should be backing her at 6/1
By:
impossible123
When: 04 Oct 23 21:34
I've loads in single, double, treble and acca. This season the fav bombed out in the Classics except Derby. Hope 2024 will be much better given City Of Troy, Opera Singer, Henry Longfellow, Ylang Ylang (Oaks), Diego Velazquez (Derby/Leger). What price AOB winning all 5 Classic again plz?
By:
jamesp
When: 09 Oct 23 00:03
Fallen Angel won't run in Friday's Gr.1 Fillies' Mile and won't run again this season. She'll reportedly be put away and prepared for "a Guineas" (note, "a" Guineas, not "the" Guineas).
The Gr.1 Prix Marcel Boussac winner Opera Singer has surprisingly been left in the Fillies' Mile, along with 8 other fillies including Rockfel 2nd and 3rd Shuwari and Ylang Ylang.
By:
Jack Bauer "24"
When: 09 Oct 23 01:54
If she has fully recovered from her last run, I would rather they send her to Newmarket and give some experience of the track rather than keep her going for another few weeks and then send her to the USA.
By:
impossible123
When: 10 Oct 23 14:03
The Marcel Boussac is only 2 weeks ago as such unlikely Opera Singer will run in the Fillies Mile, another 1m gig. I think this 1m will suit Ylang Ylang though as she was running on in The Rockfel over 7f after a tardy start. Ylang Ylang could be an Oaks filly.
By:
jamesp
When: 10 Oct 23 19:03
Well yes, she's clearly highly regarded and might develop into an Oaks filly, but she'll need to step up significantly on her last two runs and she's got the talented Shuwari to overcome...
By:
jamesp
When: 11 Oct 23 15:07
Opera Singer was not declared this morning for the Fillies' Mile on Friday. Market leaders are the Rockfel 2nd Shuwari and 3rd Ylang Ylang, and one or two of the lightly raced runners look interesting.
By:
jamesp
When: 12 Oct 23 19:16
Just eight runners for the Fillies' Mile tomorrow. The May Hill at Doncaster has been the key trial for this over the years, with 12 of the last 27 Fillies' Mile winners having either won or been placed in the Doncaster race. This points to the lightly raced See The Fire as a likely winner tomorrow. It's tempting to back her at 7/1 (she looks solid each way), but this year's May Hill looked a rather substandard renewal and she'll need to improve significantly. Ylang Ylang is certainly worth one more chance with this step up to a mile, having dwelt at the start last time in the Rockfel over 7f, but I see no particular reason why she should reverse Rockfel placings with Shuwari, who also made a sluggish start last time. Fillies without any previous pattern race form (in races of at least Listed status) have a poor record in this race, with just three of the last 27 winners boasting no pattern race form, which suggests that Classical Song has a lot to find. I can't see any value angle: I make Shuwari the likeliest winner, but 2/1 isn't especially tempting.
By:
JayTrumpOldTomDubbl
When: 12 Oct 23 19:57
So to sum up jamesp is it fair to say you make it a two horse race ? With STF + CS trying to step up which is quite possible. But for me its Shuwari all the way. Got a very poor ride last time out which helped in no small way to get her beat. She wasn't unlucky just a poor ride. I couldn't have Ylang Blank. One report on her last run states 'not remotely involved' seems accurate enough when you look at the race.  Y blank needs to do an Augustine Rodin again. I will take some of that 2/1 and look forward to the 'figgis' comments. That Fallen Angel form for Shuwari is very strong.
By:
brandyontherocks
When: 12 Oct 23 21:14
I am not too quick to criticise the rides on Shuwari and Ylang Ylang in the Rockfel.

They were both slow out of the gate and especially with Shuwari they have ridden her from behind before.

I think they were both caught out with the pace up front. And Carla's Way was not stopping this day. She looks a quick filly.

I am not a huge fan of Ylang Ylang, and I do not see her as a classic filly for next year (I think Opera Singer looks nailed on for the Oaks) but with the likely soft ground tomorrow she would be my idea of the winner. Where stamina will be the name of the game.
By:
Figgis
When: 12 Oct 23 23:35
JTOTD, strictly on past ratings I have Ylang Ylang ahead, but have to go back three runs for that figure, with no obvious excuse for her last two efforts. I have Shuwari only 1lb behind, but thought she was beaten fair and square last time by the quite impressive Carla's Way. Caught You Looking a further 3lbs behind, See The Fire another 2lbs lower.

I agree with jamesp that Classical Song has a fair bit to find, but she did win comfortably. For me, it's a no bet race, as even my highest rated Ylang Ylang has about 5 or 6lbs to find to become an up to scratch winner. Unless one of the more unexposed types improves a bundle, I don't see anything that should trouble Fallen Angel or Opera Singer next year.
By:
jamesp
When: 13 Oct 23 09:23
JTOTD, I don't make it just a two horse race: I do like Shuwari, but not enough to back her at today's odds.
Nothing in today's race shouts 'Guineas winner' to me at this stage.
By:
JayTrumpOldTomDubbl
When: 13 Oct 23 11:10
Very good jamesp maybe the 4.2 now on here might interest you. But has Shuwari lost a leg. Almighty drift. Still took a bit of the 4's but the drift goes on. Never a good sign.
Page 5 of 8  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com