We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
I’m struggling with mishriff figgis…surely had to run
I’ve always loved the staying argument, so I’d say that’s the reason he’s dodging it but we both know that’s nonsense in this horses case |
|
By:
I rated the king George one of the best king George’s for as long as I can remember
I'm only talking about very fine margins, but personally I haven't rated a faster one by a 3yo. |
|
By:
Where is this st marks horse running?
Surely not the breeders cup classic? |
|
By:
I'm only talking about very fine margins, but personally I haven't rated a faster one by a 3yo.
I’ve gone back a fair bit but just think it’s one the best performances I can remember. Just a brilliant colt, I still think he’s got more as well figgis, I know that seems strange but I don’t think they have got to the bottom of him. I don’t know why but he’s a bit freaky for me, with a whole lot more still under the bonnet. I maybe wrong but I actually thought he won the George a shade snug and Buick hadn’t gone for 5th gear |
|
By:
Harry, possibly, but looking at the Arc field I don't believe he needs to be any better than that.
|
|
By:
Totally agree and because of the problem he’s had we will have the chance to get paid off here imo
The market has to consider the missed prep and his well being after all. |
|
By:
I’ll be waiting till the day on any bets but do enjoy talking about a good one, as we’ve been seriously lacking for a while and he’s a special colt imo
|
|
By:
Believe or not I know he was injured but I had the 5th home in the king George a low grade grade 1 horse in his own right and was tailed
|
|
By:
Harry, I have him in the top four fastest Derby winners this century. Three of those went on to win the Arc, the other (Authorized) just didn't perform on the day.
|
|
By:
Sorry, meant to say in the top 5.
|
|
By:
I won’t say what my early tissue is figgis with the likely runners. Let’s just say I hope the market takes into consideration his problems as it was clearly enough to stop him prepping.
I’ve watched the George to many times but my rating is probably ended up to high. I myself believe in it, let’s just say it’s much higher than the racing post and I’m always mercenary in cropping my own rating, so am struggling with what I’ve come up with and to cope with it.. should just Chuck the books in the bin ![]() |
|
By:
When you rated authorized figgis did you compensate your rating in regards how the 2 races were run? I had adayar derby steadily run whereas I had them going quick in authorized race? Just interested as that’s what makes this colt so good imo
|
|
By:
Harry, no I didn't, as for me even though the pace varied in both races it didn't deviate enough to hinder the final time performance, but I know others may disagree about that. I actually had Authorized's Derby performance a couple of pounds faster than Adayar. However, what was more important to me than a couple of pounds here or there was I thought Adayar achieved his Derby win much more comfortably. This is all subjective of course and in the eye of the viewer, but even at the time I thought Authorized had quite a hard race. That doesn't mean I think that Adayar could necessarily improve on what he did, but I think in general most horses are more likely to repeat a performance when they've not had too hard a race.
|
|
By:
what was more important to me than a couple of pounds here or there was I thought Adayar achieved his Derby win much more comfortably.
That’s really what I was getting at tbh. I view things slightly differently in regards times and have adayar if they’d gone faster, maybe being one of the best derby winners we have seen. Authorized was a brilliant winner, so we can cap him as was ridden out. Adayar is different as he is uncapped for me if you know what I’m getting at, in regards to how fast they went in the race. I believe the distance could of been much more in more punishing test I suppose is where I’m leaning. |
|
By:
I share some of the opinions of both Sandown and Figgis re Tarnawa. She is under priced on form.
However I do not agree that the Irish Champions can be just rejected as meaningless. What she surprised me with there was the sheer speed she showed pretty much matching the well proven and well evidenced turn of speed that St MB. If a horse runs very well in circumstances that went against them, my experience is that you should take note. She proved to me that she is right up there as a filly of high class and with her speed she is going to be a major danger. She will be far better suited back at 12 furlongs and I do expect her to achieve a personal best. She is a proven 120+ filly already and if she did run 124 in the Arc as seems quite possible, with her fillies’ allowance, she would be extremely dangerous. 3/1 is a short price admittedly. But not all races are won by the horse who appeared before the race to be over priced. Trouble with a reliance on speed figures or time figures is this. It shows what a horse can do in a race run at a true or fast pace. The Arc may be run at a fast pace, but equally it may be run like many French races with much depending on which has the fastest finish. I would select Tarnawa as fitting that requirement ideally. |
|
By:
Cryoftruth. I think the issue about Tarnawa is all about price and not chance. She undoubtedly has both speed and stamina and might be a worthy favourite in a year without either or both of Appleby's, who if they run, could make this an above average year for performance.
|
|
By:
I seem to be seeing this year's Arc differently than most. In regards to the form, this race is going to take no more winning than the King George, and probably even less. Maybe luck in running or lack of pace will make it more difficult but not the competition. Of the likely runners, I see only one true Gp1 horse in the field and that is the Derby winner. There may be more horses running here than in the KG but just like most Arcs there is a lot of dead wood.
Everything revolves around whether Adayar runs his race or not, as he doesn't need to improve against this lot. By my reckoning, when winning the KG he ran exactly to the pound of his Derby win. That can sometimes be a negative if brought out again quickly but, as we know, he's had a long rest. However, there is always an element of guesswork involved when a horse hasn't shown recent form. He wouldn't be the first good Derby winner to be a spent force this late in the season. If I could be sure Adayar was going to run his race against the likely opposition here I'd make his chance of winning around 80%. The 20% against would be more the chance of him being unlucky in running, rather than the very slim chance that any of these are going to improve past him. Acknowledging that without a recent run there has to be a doubt about his current ability makes pricing his chance more difficult. That said, on the day of the race I would still make him around a 5/8 chance. A cracking bet, in my view. |
|
By:
I agree mainly figgis but I think you overstate your case a little bit. But Adayar should be favourite I agree, and if you could be sure he would run to his best he would probably win.
Reminds me just a bit of Generous though who flopped despite being the best horse in the Arc and actually a more outstanding Derby winner that Adayar. |
|
By:
Cryoftruth, I realised at the time of stating 80% that many would see that as over confidence, and I can see why they would think that, but it is definitely a considered price, not just a hunch. As for Generous, he was indeed a very good Derby winner, but personally I have Adayar matching him on figures. As good a performance it was that day at Ascot, it was a very poor KG that Generous demolished. It's easy to say with hindsight, but despite his short price in the Arc I think quite a few were of the opinion that it might be one race too far, as he also ran a big race in the Irish Derby (his best performance in my view). The horse he beat at the Curragh, Suave Dancer, also looked an improved horse later when winning the Irish Champion Stakes.
As for the day of race price for Adayar, given the current form doubt, could I still see Adayar winning the race 8 out of every 13 run? Yes, I don't think that's overstating his chance. |
|
By:
As the dataform figures show in the OP, the advantage to 3 yr olds over middle and long distances later in the year is not confined to a race like the Arc.It's not a question of 4 & 5 year olds not being able to carry weight, but 3yr olds not having enough weight to carry as they mature earlier these days.
|
|
By:
Sandown, the figures show the significance in all age handicaps. I've argued this case many times before. WFA is a one size fits all scale based on the entire horse population throughout the season. Surely nobody really believes that 3yos improve a set amount by a certain date each month. It's a best fit scale as, taken as a whole, more 3yos will be closer to reaching full maturity as the season progresses. Perfectly sensible.
they mature earlier these day This is the crux of the issue. It therefore follows that some 3yos will mature earlier than other 3yos. The better 3yos earlier in the season, or even mid season, will not only contain better horses, but a fair few who are better because they've matured earlier. When the King George is run 3yos receive 11lbs from their elders (we can argue whether it should be less), but by the time the Arc is run they now only receive 6lbs. Now we can take it as correct that the 3yo population on the whole are faster in October than they are in July, but does that necessarily mean that the horses at the top of the tree mid season also improve that much by the end of it? That's not what I'm seeing. I'd say in the vast majority of cases that isn't so, as most of them were early maturers. |
|
By:
SMB could have been under-cooked for the Irish Champion as he was forced to miss the Juddmonte. If memory served there were a few credible older horses the year Found won. As such, I still believe this race will be between the 3 yr olds again.
|
|
By:
1:45 Goodwood was an interseting example, as it was an optional handicap:
Of the 10 runners, only one, Fox Premier was in for the claim (which meant he carried 6lb less than he would if racing off his handicap mark). This suggests that most trainers weren't really fussed much about getting up to 7lb advantage if it meant risking their horse being claimed, despite the claiming prices being set in the region of £20,000. In the race Fox Premier was wearing blinkers first time and was ridden like a trier from the front by Hayley Turner. Despite this he finished last. This seems to be just one of several examples where it is hard to see the how the weight carried made much difference to a horse's performance (on going that was not heavy). I have a database of detailed racing results going back 21 years and I am struggling to think of a query that would show me how much difference weight makes, or what the correct weight for age scale should be. |
|
By:
Lowering an out of form horse's weight isn't going to make it run to form. That is apart from the ones we all know of who are deliberately not run on their merits until the trainer is satisfied the horse is down to a winning weight. Any statistical method of judging wfa is going to be at the mercy of other influencing factors. For me, the best way is to take the fastest older horses and compare the difference in ability with the fastest 3yos, not including an outlier such as Frankel.
|
|
By:
The argument will be determined by commercial realities. As it stands now, elite 3 yr olds have a much better chance of winning one of the 2 most prestigious 12f GI's in Europe (other being KG) and should they win it, the owners will be hard pressed not to send it for stallion duties, the rewards being so much greater than prize money.
Without the WFA allowance they will have less chance than they currently have. Maybeit will determine the best horse but the breeders won't like it. Question is, will they keep the elite 3 yr olds in training for another year? I don't know , only the likes of Coolmore can answer that. I suspect this is all academic because people like Coolmore are pretty powerful and will vote against any changes at all.It will never happen. In the meantime, as backers, we can take note of the apparent advantage that the WFA scale presents. My idea of a separate WFA scale for G1's was not a serious suggestion by the way. Apologies for not saying that at the time. |
|
By:
The Guineas is definitely the early season benchmark of what a top 3yo miler is capable of in terms of speed. However, while the 3yo population as a whole generally do improve during the season, I find it extremely rare to find a Guineas winner who actually runs faster than his Guineas performance later in the season, even when meeting the older horses. Occasionally some of the beaten horses do, like Ribchester, but it's most unusual for the winners. Looking at 3yo Sussex Stakes winners over the years I find that they don't run any faster than that Guineas benchmark, and the same is true for the QE2 much later in the year. This is also true of the better Derby winners. Very few improve in line with WFA at the end of the season. If they are going to improve at all most of it is done in the off season before their 4yo career.
|
|
By:
There is never a bad time to reconsider WFA scales and that should happen by looking at the evidence.
Simon Holt, a while ago in the weekender, suggested that the WFA scale should simply be abolished,and that 2 and 3yos, should carry the same weight as older horses no matter what. I don’t much like Holt as he tends to write pieces in a way that implies that anyone taking an opposite view to his is an idiot. But be that as it may doing away with WFA is not very sensible. On average, and that is all it is, an average, a 3yo, is not as good as a horse with identical ability (say measured by official ratings, racing post ratings or Timeform ratings as an older horse. I cannot for example imagine many 3yos wanting to take a 4yo Frankel on at level weights, although that is perhaps an unfair example. Maybe a fairer one might be a fast 2yo like Kingsgate Native undoubtedly was, being asked to race of level terms with a 5yo sprinter. I recall the excellent and quite compelling research provided by Sandown regards the record of older horses especially 5yos in the Arc. It did suggest to me that a reappraisal of the wfa scale is overdue. But a review is not the same as it being abolished. I also think that the breeding industry might not be dead keen on the ides of 3yos running off level weights with their elders. Indeed if this did ever happen I would not imagine that many all age races would have any or many 3yos actually entered let alone running and such a move would spoil a deal of flat racing, as races like the Eclipse and King George would become an older horse race only. Look at this year’s Eclipse. If St Mark’s pBasilica had been running off level weights with Addeyb, the result could have been reversed. Would anyone seriously suggest that Addeyb was or is really a better horse than St Mark’s? |
|
By:
Would anyone seriously suggest that Addeyb was or is really a better horse than St Mark’s
That could never be answered unless SMB raced on as an older horse without the allowances. Notably they've decided to duck out of that prospect, partly because they're desperate for a new stallion, but partly because they fear that the hype around the horse will disappear if he fails to improve in line with wfa. Precocity is usually only talked about regarding 2yos, but precocity is a factor affecting all age groups before the time a horse is considered to reach full maturity. I've seen loads of horses that didn't run any faster at 4 than they did at 3. It then becomes clear that they were early maturers who benefited from the wfa scale. The wfa scale is there to balance the theoretical average difference between the age groups, but it needs be acknowledged that it also benefits horses who mature earlier than others. |
|
By:
Agree with that figgis. Celtic Swing was a great example. He was a very early maturing brute, so far ahead of his contemporaries at 2 that he was 20lbs clear of the others. They caught up when the 3yo season got going.
|
|
By:
COT, yes, but there are also many examples of 3yo champions who turned out to be early maturers. Workforce, Rip Van Winkle, Toronado, Hurricane Run, etc, while running to some decent form on occasions as 4yos didn't look quite so good without the allowances.
|
|
By:
I tend to the view that it’s the “greats” who prove their greatness at 3 and 4. Frankel obviously.
Going back, Mill Reef, The Brigadier, and Kris, Allez France and more recently Enable, and may others that could be listed. Imagine a 3yo giving weight to a 4yo Brigadier. Even a 3yo Frankel would have struggled with that! |