We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
Green Desert was a lot better than Dubawi Gold and Native Khan over a mile. Who do you think was the best horse Frankel beat Figgis I am not getting an answer from AT?
|
|
By:
Had Dancing Brave not run in the 2000 Guineas Green Desert would have won it beating Gr1 winner and multiple Gr 1 winner Huntingdale and Sure Blade.
Had Frankel not run in the 2000 Gns Dubawi Gold would have won it from Native khan and Slim Shadey who never won a Gr1 between them. |
|
By:
In fact which horse Frankel did beat do you think DB couldn't have?
Nobody knows if Dancing Brave would've trained on as a 4yo. As a 3yo he didn't have one outstanding piece of form over a mile. The best was the Guineas beating the non staying Green Desert. Sure he did it comfortably and there will be people who say he was value for 7 lengths or whatever, but the fact remains he didn't win by as much as that. People can have a higher opinion of him than the bare form but he can't be rated on it. He won the Eclipse easily but, as A_T alludes to, Triptych was just an also ran in the best races until the better horses retired. DB would've needed to beat her by further to justify a very high rating. You can say that wasn't his style but that's just tough, they can't go rating horses on what they might have done. Dancing Brave was involved in a lot of races that weren't exactly slow but most weren't run at a great pace. He was then able use his brilliant turn of foot. The fastest paced race he was involved in was the King George. People might say he was idling in the lead there, I don't agree, but either way he was never capable of careering away from Shardari. How good was Shardari? For me he was a decent Gp1 older horse but no better. For all the talk about that Arc having the strongest field ever, it sounds good now, but most of these other runners weren't given a hope of beating the horses DB had already beaten. After Bering the next in the market was his old foe Shardari again. Shardari was obviously below par as Triptych reversed the Ascot and York form with him. So how good was Bering? He was France's best 3yo that year and massively hyped but didn't have one exceptional piece of form going into the Arc. If people think DB was better than Frankel I disagree but they're entitled to believe that. People have other preferences when considering horses greats and they might put winning over middle distances as a 3yo up there.Fair enough. I think it would be difficult for anyone to make a case though that DB gave a faster end to end performance on a racecourse. It would also be impossible to rate his winning performance |
|
By:
hard to say exactly brigust - Excelebration, Canford Cliffs, Fahhr, Cirrus, Nathaniel and others were all multiple group 1 winners. You're right Frankel didn't beat a multiple group 1 winning filly (is that a measure of greatness?) - not sure there were any competing at that time.
DB was a great horse - I put him up there with BG, Frankel, Mill Reef, Sea the Stars, Enable as being in the top tier of flat horses in the last 40 years. |
|
By:
beating Gr1 winner and multiple Gr 1 winner Huntingdale and Sure Blade
See when it suits you just casually spin off that such horses won Gp1s, no delving into the quality of those races. Sure Blade took an eternity to get past the again non staying Green Desert at Ascot. Those Gp1s were crap and the winners weren't even impressive. Huntingdale didn't train on, not that he was ever much cop anyway, and I say that as someone who backed him in what was my first Dewhurst bet. Which piece of Shardari's form prior to the King George made you think that if a 3yo beat him 3/4 of a length carrying 13lbs less it must be great? |
|
By:
Dancing Brave was simply racing against better horses than Frankel and his style of running was different as well.
You haven't answered the question Figgis. Who do you think is the best horse Frankel beat? Can I help you? Is it the horse who took 40 runs before winning a Gr1 and could then only win in the early or late season against horses not particularly trained for those races? Or was it the 2000 Gns 3rd? Or was it the Gr2 German 2000 Gns winner who won Group 1's beating Cityscape who couldn't win a Gr1 in Europe. Maybe it was the Thirsk Hunt Cup winner? Or maybe the Irish 2000 Gns winner? The choice is yours Figgis. |
|
By:
*It would also be impossible to rate his winning performances outstandingly high without resorting to "but he was value for more" excuses or giving extra points for the excitement factor.
|
|
By:
Brigust, as I asked you my question first, which you've obviously read but deliberately continue to ignore I'll wait for you answer first. Shardari?
|
|
By:
Are you kidding me? They gave Frankel 3lb extra for winning the Queen Anne Stakes ffs. That is an insult to intelligence. You ask them which horse ran to form and they won't even give you an answer. They were always giving Frankel extra for beating trees.
A an awaiting your asnswer Figgis. Cat got your tongue? In any other circumstance you would be all over it like a rash. Is the question too difficult? |
|
By:
About Shardari Timeform rated him 134 and that is higher than all of the horses Frankel beat with the exception of Cirrus des Aigles and Shadari would have beaten him. He couldn't win a top race in the height of the season ffs.
|
|
By:
Frankel, best older horse beat- CDA, but it was far from Frankel's best performance.
Best 3yo beat - Excelebration Best 3yo performance - The Guineas, 8lbs faster than any Guineas winner I've seen since '85 Best overall performance - Queen Anne, but the International was only 2lbs lower. Brigust, forget the hype, which piece of form from Bering prior to the Arc told you that this was anything more than a general standard of PDJC winner? Was it that 1 1/2 lengths beating of that memorable opponent Altayan? |
|
By:
About Shardari Timeform rated him 134
Right, so your only point of reference is Timeform. Ok, Timeform rated Frankel 147, end of discussion ![]() |
|
By:
here's one for you brigust. of the horses beaten by DB how many were good enough to win G1 races the following season?
|
|
By:
What you fail to grasp Figgis is that Frankel's era was a shoite era.
Excluding Frankel the 2000 Gns was terrible and the Derby was probably worse. A German 2000 Gns winner won Gr1 races in the UK for the first time ever.A Thirsk Hunt Cup winner won two Gr1 races for the first time ever. Cirrus des Aigles started winning Gr1 races for the first time ever after 6 odd years. It was just a terrible era. A German filly who had been beaten in Germany won the Arc and our King George for the first time ever. The UK racing scene was at rock bottom and every record shows that. According to Timeform ratings there have been FIVE horses in their list rated 135 and higher for Frankel's era and TWENTY FIVE for Dancing Brave's era. |
|
By:
OMFG - will you two shut the f**k up.
Same old, same old. ![]() |
|
By:
High Uncle you just back from the Lib Dem conference?
|
|
By:
According to Timeform ratings there have been FIVE horses in their list rated 135 and higher for Frankel's era and TWENTY FIVE for Dancing Brave's era
Yeah they'd lost the plot back then hadn't they, 25 you say? Dear oh dear, what a case of overhype. Explains how they rated Reference Point 140 for beating no marks narrowly ![]() |
|
By:
It was a shoite era Figgis. Try to live with it ffs.
|
|
By:
Reference Point was rated 139.
|
|
By:
In Frankel's era we have Battash and Cracksman. Battash isn't the best sprinter and Cracksman isn't the best 10f horse but they both fit into Frankel's era.
|
|
By:
Penzance, sorry 139, I was actually wondering if it was a pound less when I put 140. He was my first Derby winner and I backed him ante post after Doncaster, as I'm sure a lot of others did, it was hardly a performance that went unnoticed. So I have a soft spot for him and followed his career but there's no way you could get 139 out of his winning performances. There wasn't the same scrutiny applied to what Timeform did back then though, understandably in pre-internet days.
|
|
By:
That only leaves Harbinger whose single high rating in the KG was a complete stitch up and Cirrus des Aigles ffs. The only genuine horse is Sea the Stars. So thank your lucky stars for clever calculations Figgis. It should be only ONE in Frankel's era.
|
|
By:
![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() ![]() Don't you just love him? |
|
By:
Every time a Reliant Robin comes bobbing round the corner Timeform give it 135 just to get it on the list.
![]() ![]() |
|
By:
Pinatubo (back to the thread) may make the list but the era expires at the end of the year. Can you see anything else that could attain a high rating. Enable isn't going to make it and nor is Stradivarius. Can't think of anything else.
|
|
By:
brigust hasn't answered my question
|
|
By:
A_T, 132 Triptych, 129 Enable. Evens the pair, would you play?
![]() |
|
By:
AT Triptych won 5 Group 1's Prix Ganay, Coronation Cup, Juddmonte, Irish Champion Stakes, Champion Stakes. No bad eh?
Anything Frankel beat match that??? |
|
By:
AT that was in 1987. I'd go for Triptych Figgis, so does Timeform.
|
|
By:
As you've said yourself it's what they beat not the name of the race. Narrowly beating the likes of Most Welcome and Ascot Knight? Can't say I'm that impressed
![]() |
|
By:
You really don't want to be going down that road Figgis. Sovereign Debt, Cityscape.
|
|
By:
so does Timeform
Timeform obviously do cos it's their figures ffs. Thing is Timeform now are a different team than back then. At one point they were even using different length calculations for timefigures compared to form figures, hard to believe really. But then you see how they totally lost the plot on a lot of races back then and it's not really a surprise. They never really had to explain themselves though back in those days. They might ruffle a few connections' feathers and cause a few disagreeing head shakes to those who bought their annuals but that was it. Whereas nowadays, disagree with them or not, the ratings can at least be shown to add up. |
|
By:
Brigust, there is a big difference in comprehensively beating an admittedly moderate Group horse like Sovereign Debt 4 lengths and poking home by a head or neck against another moderate performer like Most Welcome. Distances never seem to figure in your posts, it's just he beat that, but he only beat that. No mention that one was a neck and the other was 4 lengths. Extraordinary for someone who constantly carps about ratings where distance is fundamental.
|
|
By:
Cruz delayed unleashing Triptych's now famous final burst until even later than usual. Triptych responded magnificently when let down inside the final furlong , producing an electrifying tun of foot which left her rivals standing, she won going away, ridden along with only hands and heels, by two and a half lengths from Most Welcome.
There is much more to a result than just the numbers Figgis. Added to that she ran 10 times that season including third in the Eclipse behind Mtoto and Reference Point and third to Reference Point on heavy ground in the King George she won the Fuji Stakes in Japan as a prep for the Japan Cup where she finished an unlucky in running forth. Triptych ran 41 times all over the world and when you compare that with the closely monitored 14 times Enable has run I would still say had she been managered as sparingly as Enable she would have achieved more. I would take the Evens any time you like Figgis. |
|
By:
Added to that Most Welcome was rated 131 by Timeform which is higher than Enable is and light years higher than Sovereign Debt.
|
|
By:
At one point they were even using different length calculations for time figures compared to form figures, Figgis I have heard Timeform representatives asked a hundred times whether or not they have changed there calculation figures and a hundred times they have said they have not and their calculations are consistent. I cannot believe you are saying that current methods they are using are actually downgading current horses when compared with the past. There is nothing I have seen and heard from Timeform or from the results to back that claim up. Their absolute consistency is one thing they are adamant about.
Are you really saying you think Timeform are now using calculation methods that are having a negative effect on their ratings? |
|
By:
The inconsistency between the time ratings and form ratings was apparently put right by John Whitley in the 70s when he joined. I've read him speak about it. Whitley left in the early 80s.
Are you really saying you think Timeform are now using calculation methods that are having a negative effect on their ratings? I'm not saying that at all. I'm saying no matter if the methods remain consistent (at least in theory) in any line of work, the fact is some some people are just better at the job than others. From the mid 80s there was a definite deterioration that lasted a while, in my view. |
|
By:
I am sorry Figgis but I do not believe there is an inconsistency. Mainly because that does not show in the ratings. Naturally with the small increase in the number of racehorses at the higher level (I know the increase at a lower level is much greater but we are looking at the higher level) the probability of an increase in the better horses can, and should be expected be expected.
However the figures do not back that up. According to Timeform the numbers of horses reaching their 135+ list are as follows: 1940-50 12 1950-60 15 1960-70 15 1970-80 18 1980-90 22 1990-20 15 2000-10 4 2010-20 3 That can only be described as a reduction in quality horses. Up until 1990 there was a steady and acceptable increase in top horses but the decline is palpable. |
|
By:
A_T, 132 Triptych, 129 Enable. Evens the pair, would you play?
Definitely. Enable is a better horse than Triptych was. |
|
By:
AT Triptych won 5 Group 1's Prix Ganay, Coronation Cup, Juddmonte, Irish Champion Stakes, Champion Stakes. No bad eh?
so only 1 |