Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

Classics 2016

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
elisjohn
20 Jun 11 18:29
Joined:
Date Joined: 15 Jun 03
| Topic/replies: 20,403 | Blogger: elisjohn's blog
if tom kicks 2 furlongs out i also see him beating c cliffs 4 lengths

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 1 of 2  •  Previous 1 | 2 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 59
By:
elisjohn
When: 21 Jun 11 06:58
timeform not dBlush
By:
Stake & Chips
When: 21 Jun 11 11:02
Do you think Frankel could give Canford 14lbs in a handicap? Shocked
By:
Far From Trouble
When: 21 Jun 11 18:48
Canford Cliffs will beat Frankel in the Sussex, even with the wfa allowance
By:
Led on bit
When: 24 Jun 11 13:12
Seriously, has anyone actually heard either Henry Cecil or Teddy G say that Frankel is DEFINITELY going to the Sussex and not the Juddmonte? I haven't. I've only heard a suggestion from Queally and a quote from TG saying it's the "obvious race to go for". TG got Workforce's targets wrong last year and I'm waiting for Cecil to come out and say where he goes..
By:
elisjohn
When: 26 Jun 11 16:56
see   frankel on track for goodwood thread on horse racing, but again its tg quoting
By:
Somerset_Moan
When: 26 Jun 11 21:13
Do you REALLY think CC is four lengths better than Frankel?? Do you?

IN THE SUSSEX STAKES CC HAS TO GIVE FRANKEL 8LB

a) CC won't turn up  - easier grade 1s to be had and he stays 10f now and coole more have an interest in improving his breeding profile and keeping him unbeaten this year

b) Ridden properly, Frankel will eat CC for breakfast - his kick is devastating.

c) I love CC, but he 'ain't no' pegasus and he'd need to be to out-kick Frankel +8lb

d) We don't know still if one or both will be there
By:
mightymoyes
When: 26 Jun 11 23:38
Somerset_Moan 26 Jun 11 21:13 


a) CC won't turn up  - easier grade 1s to be had and he stays 10f now
---------

how do you know he stays 10f?
By:
Rondetto
When: 27 Jun 11 21:38
I've always thought Canford Cliffs would get 12 furlongs and was pretty surprised when there was no mention of him at least trying.

There is now but that has only come about because of Frankel so let's not kid ourselves about that.

I'm in a kinda awkward position as I've been raving about Canford Cliffs ever since he bolted with Hughsie at Ascot as a 2 year old and had the man using the word "Freak" before Frankel had even seen a racecourse.

I'm a huge fan of the Hannon horse but one has to be realistic. He would have to give weight to Frankel which may prove to be impossible.

I suppose it's all down to which horse has the greater acceleration and of course the tactics.

A study of the sectionals bring up an interesting fact. When Frankel beat Treasure Beach and co on softish ground in the Royal Lodge at Ascot he actually recorded an almost identical time over the last 2 furlongs as Canford Cliffs did on good ground when beating Dick Turpin.

Considering his tender age and the fact he was on his ownsome all the way up the straight that has to be taken seriously.

I was a bit peeved that Henry didn't listen to those who reckoned the quickest way to get Frankel beaten was to continue with those Guineas tactics.

Was pretty obiious to me if Duwabi Gold and Native Khan could run him down to 4 lengths he could be in trouble if he tried those tactics with better animals. Ok so they got away with it again,just, but against a horse who wouldn't blow wind up CC's backside.

None of that reflects on how good Frankel could be if they get the nonsense out of their heads.

If they restrain him until 2f out with wfa I would expect Frankel to win, try it any other way and he will be beaten IMO
By:
Far From Trouble
When: 27 Jun 11 23:14
Canford Cliffs has enough raw speed to lay up with anything and keeps on finding that bit more to get his head in front, he won the QA a lot more comfortably than the winning margin suggested, and he seems to do just enough

Chances are Frankel isn't going to race like he has this season in this, but he'll still be the first to play his hand, giving Canford something to aim for and catch, which I believe he inevitably will do.

As long as people keep underestimating Canford Cliffs then i'm happy as i'll get a better price. He's a MUCH better horse than he is given credit for
By:
Somerset_Moan
When: 28 Jun 11 00:00
Mightymoyes- it's all a matter of personal opinion... BUT...

a) Look at his entries
b) Listen to the trainer
c) WATCH HIS RACES

Were you at Ascot? I was - he outstayed cityscape and Goldie... but was not going away.

He wants further now and will get chewed up by Frankel at 8f once they ride him properly.. Don't get me wrong, I love CC... but he ain't Pegasus... and giving weight to Frankel he'd need to be
By:
Somerset_Moan
When: 28 Jun 11 00:05
Far from trouble - how close were you to the rails at Ascot?

Goldie didn't fire, Peslier was 2lb overweight, but still CC had to work to get by

He's a lovely horse but he'll need to be a lot better than that to give Frankel weight

I'm not sure one or both wil turn up at Goodwood... but Ascot for the QE11 is the REAL test this year and I'd love to see them both in training next
By:
Far From Trouble
When: 28 Jun 11 00:19
Canford Cliffs always runs the same though. Hughesy gets to work it takes him a fair few strides to get going, he gets in full flight then he gets to the front and just does enough

Frankel may well be his toughest test to date, but i'm a massive fan of CC and it surprises me that more people can't see how much class he oozes

I'm not even considering weight for age allowance, totally irrelevant
By:
Somerset_Moan
When: 28 Jun 11 07:38
Well we're all entitled to an opinion, but from a BETTING perspective, the Wfa allowance is everything.

You MIGHT consider CC a better horse, even three lengths better... but in the Sussex he gives 8lb, which - strictly speaking -is 4 lengths, so Frankel "Should" win by a length...

I happen to think Frankel is at least as good as CC, so with the WFA I shall be wading in on Frankel - ANYTHING above 4/6 on Frankel is just a licence to print money  IMHO...

We'll just see... although I'm far from convinced one or both will go to Goodwood
By:
Baxta
When: 28 Jun 11 10:53
SURPRISE SURPRISE!! It's you again, Somerset_Moan, going on about ths BS 8lb WFA being 4 lengths...
Oh I better not forget though, you were there, at Ascot, (with binoculors)
By:
neill d
When: 28 Jun 11 23:14
Someone said Goldi didn't fire, I disagree, that is as good as she is and Canford won snug imo, he is an underrated horse.
By:
ilikewavingatbuses
When: 29 Jun 11 05:47
canford is a miler, he will not say 10f against top class staying animals.

as for a mile and a half.. a son of tagula?

gl
By:
ilikewavingatbuses
When: 29 Jun 11 05:52
i dont think canford is underrated at all, sure he was fav until just before the off against a 3 times breeders cup mile winner..underrated?

hes also started fav  for all but 2 of his races and that was the guineas and his QA win. who is underrating this colt? everyone knows hes a machine, look at his record!

people are still entitled to have questions and doubts about taking on horses he hasnt yet faced.

just like there are still questions with frankel such as will he get further than a mile (which i believe he will if they allow him to settle), doesnt mean hes underrated, we all know hes a machine too!!

canford is not underrated imo, everyone raves about him (for obvious reasons).


all the best!
By:
ilikewavingatbuses
When: 29 Jun 11 05:58
sorry one final point.

i dont think the weight allowence makes much of a difference personally.

its there for a reason, frankel isnt simply geting weight, hes a year younger which accounts for the older horse having an advantage regarding filling out and general experience and growth. i realise frankel is a powerhouse anyway but fundamentally he is still a year younger  and with respect to this he is entitled to receive weight. the weight he receives wont entitle him to beat canford it'll be whether hes good enough!


morning!
By:
neill d
When: 29 Jun 11 13:15
Sorry ILWAB, I didn't mean in betting terms, I meant more in terms of ya know great horses. We know for example that Goldi will be remembered as a great racing mare, I would just hope that Canford is remembered in the same way. I think he is a great miler and I wouldn't be surprised if he beat Frankel, I won't bet on it though, I kind of feel that Canford needs one more big win to cement his legacy with the public, I reckon, whatever wins out of Canford and Frankel will be second only to STS in the last couple of years in terms of greatness. Maybe it is because he didn't win the Guineas at Newmarket, maybe it is the way Hughes rides him these days with the only just do enough style, maybe it was the timing of the Queen Anne, maybe it was the SYT debacle or Goldi carrying overweight, but I don't really feel he got the credit he deserves, He is probably the best out and out specialist miler I have seen, It is just a gut feeling.
By:
ilikewavingatbuses
When: 01 Jul 11 01:19
yes canford is a fantastic horse.

like u i think frankel would have too many guns for him if ridden with restraint and confidence but impossible to be confident.

funny i always thought MAKFI was underrated. he beat both goldi in soft and canford on good. fair and square and i think its fair to say he did not like ascot as many horse dont. i feel he has not got the recognition he deserved.

his guineas win was impressive and came from exactly the same place as canford. hes rarely mantioned in the same breath as the others even tho hes beat them.
By:
neill d
When: 01 Jul 11 13:00
Ya a good horse, but I think hughes said Canford was taking the piss a small bit, he seemingly needs to be shaken up quite vigourously these days and Hughes maybe didn't realise it at the time.

Makfi is definetly underrated I agree, It might be the fact that he was a Tregonning cast off and the Luvvie British media don't like reminding his ex trainer about his subsequent exploits.
By:
Far From Trouble
When: 01 Jul 11 13:15
Makfi was found wrong after Ascot (sore throat or summat) but Canford Cliffs had improved no end by then

Makfi a fine horse in his own right
By:
buddeliea
When: 03 Jul 11 08:56
i dont think the weight allowence makes much of a difference personally.

its there for a reason, frankel isnt simply geting weight, hes a year younger which accounts for the older horse having an advantage regarding filling out and general experience and growth. i realise frankel is a powerhouse anyway but fundamentally he is still a year younger  and with respect to this he is entitled to receive weight. the weight he receives wont entitle him to beat canford it'll be whether hes good enough!

Absolutely spot on ILWAB,and as Canford has better form and proved he can beat the best he is a worthy fav,and Frankel has it all to prove.
By:
brandyontherocks
When: 03 Jul 11 13:18
wfa makes a huge dif in my opinion


look at the top all aged group 1's over the years and a good 3 year has a huge advantage over a good older horse. in this race 6 of the last 10 have been 3year olds.

some horses obviously improve with age, but the results show that 3year olds do have an advantage at the weights.

and the 8lb frankel is receiving here will make him very hard to beat. if he hasn't bottomed himself out
By:
tobermory
When: 04 Jul 11 22:58
Agree with Buddelia re WFA

It is fair enough: it makes it a test of speed rather than a test of strength , in which the older horse would have an advantage.

Wrong to talk about the race like it is a handicap.
By:
caward
When: 04 Jul 11 23:52
WFA will make a difference at this stage of the season, 3yo are growing at a faster rate than older horses but having said that i don't believe Frankel will need the 8lbs to beat Canford & will have to much pace for him. Goodwood will also suit Frankel much better with a mainly downhill finish. Canford is a brilliant horse but if TQ gives Frankel a better ride there can only be one result IMO.
By:
buddeliea
When: 05 Jul 11 17:42
Well as he is yet to prove himself against the top milers imo it is hard to say with confidence that there can be only one result,but like you say its your opinion.
Imo CC deserves to be fav,and beating Goldikova amongst others is far better than the average 3yr olds beaten by Frankel.Well thats what i think the 3yr olds are this year.
He will need every ounce of the allowance imo,but if they do meet it will be some race i reckon.
By:
Lady Margaret
When: 13 Jul 11 13:21
http://www.sportinglife.com/racing/news/story_get.cgi?STORY_NAME=racing/11/07/13/manual_125239.html&BID=464
By:
Lady Margaret
When: 13 Jul 11 13:22
Oops!

Frankel impressed the Newmarket work watchers on Wednesday morning.

Henry Cecil's colt, brilliant winner of the QIPCO 2000 Guineas and St James's Palace Stakes, worked on the Racecourse Side with two stable companions.

Newmarket correspondent Tony Elves told At The Races: "Frankel had the companionship of two lead horses, Bullet Train and Tranquil Tiger. He sat out the back and was beautifully settled and when Shane Featherstonhaugh asked him to go he just glided past and finished about four lengths in front.

"It was a brilliant bit of work, didn't take anything out of him, and was just what you want going into the Sussex Stakes."

Frankel is 11-10 with Sky Bet for the Glorious Goodwood showpiece in which he faces a mouthwatering clash with Canford Cliffs.
By:
Man From Atlantis
When: 13 Jul 11 23:40
Think Timeform will have to either bump up CC rating after this race or take a lump off Frankels imoLaugh
By:
Man From Atlantis
When: 15 Jul 11 09:01
Anyway where do you get the 14lb difference from?

1    FRANKEL
Sir Henry Cecil     141    
2    BLACK CAVIAR
Peter Moody             135    
3    SO YOU THINK
Aidan O'Brien             134    
4=    CANFORD CLIFFS
Richard Hannon             133
By:
ilikewavingatbuses
When: 15 Jul 11 12:37
has to give him weight for age!
By:
grendel
When: 15 Jul 11 12:57
weight for age is accounted for in the ratings, the ratings are what the horses would be (granted maturity in line with the wfa scale) when fully mature.  As the wfa allowance for 3yo's at the time of the race over a mile is 8lbs and they have Frankel 8lbs above Canford Cliffs, they rate Frankel the same now as a 3 yr old as Canford Cliffs is now that he is fully mature.
By:
buddeliea
When: 16 Jul 11 07:59
i have a strong feeling timeform will be proved wrong
By:
grendel
When: 16 Jul 11 09:48
Anything that happens from now on will not prove Timeform wrong about past performances on the clock, there is NO DOUBT whatsoever that Frankel has superior figures SO FAR time-wise to anyone who does speed ratings.  Canford Cliffs last 4 wins have a highest winning distance of 1¼ lengths, therefore he cannot earn a speed figure much more than the horse finishing second, if Frankel produces a performance time-wise akin to his guineas run then Canford Cliffs will have to put up a speed figure perfomance way above what he's achieved so far, if that happens then Canford Cliffs rating will shoot up rather than Frankels figure coming down.  The times of the other round course races on that day will place the performances into the right context.

My own personal speed ratings put the average of Frankels top 4 performances on 97 on my scale, Canford Cliffs I have at 91.  These are lengths per mile and work out at a difference of 19lbs.  These also take wfa into account and as currently Frankel receives 8lb the real level weights difference I have at 11 lbs.

The question is how much higher a perfomance can Canford Cliffs achieve if he's set a harder task as his running style is such that he only does just enough to win, another question is what sort of performance will we get from Frankel at Goodwood.  I suspect we'll see Frankel kick for home between the 4f and 3f pole, and as he tied up 1f out after kicking 5f out in the St Jamess Palace maybe he will run right up to the line and post an economic performance.
By:
mythical prince
When: 16 Jul 11 22:26
who cares about weight for age. frankel should have to give canford cliffs weight, not the other way round! [;)]
By:
buddeliea
When: 17 Jul 11 09:15
ok,put it this way,if CC beats Frankel as i think,then the ratings that timeform have stated will need to be altered.
By:
grendel
When: 17 Jul 11 11:00
Not necessarily, it all depends on whether Frankel's performance is somehow 4 or 5 lengths inferior to his best runs. Like i said, the other round course performances will put the race into its context.  It will either need a much improved time performance from Canford Cliffs or a regressed run from Frankel in order for Canford Cliffs to finish ahead of Frankel, or a combination of both.

The wet week ahead if it runs into early the week after could see Canford pulled out imo.
By:
buddeliea
When: 17 Jul 11 17:22
If they both put in performances similar to their last races i fully expect CC to win.Of course they may well not do that but i still think CC is the better miler,he has beaten much better milers.Not Frankels fault of course,he can only beat whats put against him,but the likes of Goldikova are different league.
Hopefully they will both turn up with everything in their favour,then we will know.
By the way i think Canford is well capable of improved time performance if he needs to,again hopefully we will find out soon.
Page 1 of 2  •  Previous 1 | 2 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com