Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
kenilworth
10 May 14 14:27
Joined:
Date Joined: 04 Nov 05
| Topic/replies: 15,627 | Blogger: kenilworth's blog
Games played.3
Goals scored.5
Draws so far.2

You ignore the stats at your
peril in 2 legged affairs,
especially the first legs.
Pause • Switch to Standard View Playoffs going to form
Show More
Loading...
Report DFCIRONMAN • May 10, 2014 4:40 PM BST
2012-2013

Promotion Play-offs - Semi-finals

    By date
    By game week

Aggr.     Yeovil Town     2 - 1     Sheffield United
Fri     03/05/13     Sheffield United     1 - 0     Yeovil Town     View events     More info
Mon     06/05/13     Yeovil Town     2 - 0     Sheffield United     View events     More info
Aggr.     Brentford     4 - 4     Swindon Town
Sat     04/05/13     Swindon Town     1 - 1     Brentford     View events     More info
Mon     06/05/13     Brentford     P 3 - 3     Swindon Town     View events     More info
==================================================================================================

2011-2012

Promotion Play-offs - Semi-finals

    By date
    By game week

Aggr.     Stevenage     0 - 1     Sheffield United
Fri     11/05/12     Stevenage     0 - 0     Sheffield United         More info
Mon     14/05/12     Sheffield United     1 - 0     Stevenage     View events     More info
Aggr.     Huddersfield Town     3 - 2     Milton Keynes Dons
Sat     12/05/12     Milton Keynes Dons     0 - 2     Huddersfield Town     View events     More info
Tue     15/05/12     Huddersfield Town     1 - 2     Milton Keynes Dons     View events
================================================================================================

2010-2011

Play-offs - Semi-finals

    By date
    By game week

Aggr.     Huddersfield Town     4 - 4     AFC Bournemouth
Sat     14/05/11     AFC Bournemouth     1 - 1     Huddersfield Town     View events     More info
Wed     18/05/11     Huddersfield Town     P 3 - 3     AFC Bournemouth     View events     More info
Aggr.     Peterborough United     4 - 3     Milton Keynes Dons
Sun     15/05/11     Milton Keynes Dons     3 - 2     Peterborough U…     View events     More info
Thu     19/05/11     Peterborough U…     2 - 0     Milton Keynes Dons

========================================================================



Surely K ....all games should be weighed up on their merit. It is likely such games will be TIGHT affairs, especially in 1st legs....but still believe b better to weigh each game up on what you believe is relevant information.

As 1st leg is likely to be TIGHT, then backing DRAW might be reasonable initial bet taking this factor into a/c or DRAW/WIN for 1 or both teams....depending on game.


Reasonable post though K...Cool.hope your stalker leaves you alone on this one. GL with bets.
Report kenilworth • May 10, 2014 5:39 PM BST
DFC, your post appreciated. Goals in playoffs are
historically lower than they are in league matches,
as perhaps because they are two legged affairs,
which by their nature are different from one offs.

My stalker? I don't see many of his posts, blocked
on my threads so don't read them, when I see his
forum name on other threads I don't even read them,
thanks for the comments anyway. GL.
Report green army • May 10, 2014 6:17 PM BST
hahahahaha nice one grandad - DFC ken invented stalking had 2 years of it on my thread with his mate hejik, and only stopped when his mate got banned, now I'm having my bit of fun, which amuses me, which is all that matters

oh and ken is wrong as usual, statistically over the last few years there are as many goals per game in the play offs as in league games, even tho the markets would suggest otherwise
Report kenilworth • May 11, 2014 10:34 AM BST
UPDATE.



Games played.4
Goals scored.7
Draws so far.3

You ignore the stats at your
peril in 2 legged affairs,
especially the first legs.
Report kenilworth • May 11, 2014 2:42 PM BST
UPDATE.



Games played.5
Goals scored.8
Draws so far.3
Report SHAPESHIFTER • May 11, 2014 4:06 PM BST
Kenilworth, you always talk about 'sample size' yet here you are saying to form a trend based on 4, 5 matches.....
Report green army • May 11, 2014 4:14 PM BST
you're right ss, the stats over the last 10 years show less draws and roughly the same goals per game, ken just felt such a plonker when he predicted brighton v derby being a 0-0 that he's trying to justify it, I think ken should have a cooling shower with conchita wurst, they can compare beards
Report SHAPESHIFTER • May 11, 2014 4:22 PM BST
The big trap I find is 'generalization' of stats.  Bookies love them and post them.  Lots of money if you keep things in perspective.

Last year, for the NFL, I priced up a game between Detroit and the Vikings.  Every angle was the Vikings.  Made a decision on Tuesday and then watched the media for team reports.

Then, all the stats starting appearing:

Minnesota never has beaten detroit in ages, nine visits to Detroit without a win, stat after stats over a decade of encounters.

Stuck to my guns.  Put the bet on.  Vikings not only beat the spread but won.

I do use stats but when you see stats based on a team from ten years previous, you can't really take it serious.

But bookies know enough people will to keep them in clover and, of course, are the first one to shovel us the information. #opta
Report kenilworth • May 11, 2014 4:54 PM BST
SHAPESHIFTER
Joined: 04 Apr 03
Replies: 2860
    11 May 14 16:06

Kenilworth, you always talk about 'sample size' yet here you are saying to form a trend based on 4, 5 matches...


Shapeshifter, The average goals per match in the first legs of Football league
playoffs 1986/87 to 2012/13 is 2.1 also these matches have produced 37% draws.
Those figures are what I take note off, they exist. Ignore them if you like.

I am not forming a trend based on 4/5 matches, I am reporting the results of
the matches played so far. if you don't think stats over 26 years of the present
format, are worth noting that is up to you or anyone else.
Report SHAPESHIFTER • May 11, 2014 5:08 PM BST
a) which teams were involved with these play-offs?
b) which players from 1986 are still playing?
c) have there been rule changes in the past decade?
d) how much weight do you put on a match from 1993 as opposed to last year?
e) how much different are these stats top those of the entire season?
f) etc
g) etc
h) etc

So, as mentioned, the amount of weight I put into this information is, infact, nil.

I will, however, when betting put weight into how I assess each team, price it up, then find the value within the markets.
Report SHAPESHIFTER • May 11, 2014 5:08 PM BST
Again, stats like this are a bookmakers dream.
Report kenilworth • May 11, 2014 5:27 PM BST
SHAPESHIFTER, please don't patronise me, if you want to ignore
the trends of around 150 matches that's ok by me.


I will, however, when betting put weight into how I assess each team, price it up, then find the value within the markets.

In pricing up playoff first leg matches, do you take
into consideration the fact that these matches over
150 matches produces only 2.1 goals per match, also
37% of them are drawn? If you ignore those facts then
that is your choice, I take note. These matches are
different from ordinary league matces IMO. GL.
Report green army • May 11, 2014 5:45 PM BST
I wouldn't bother SS, ken wont listen. As you point out the are a huge number of factors that impact on any game today, the fact that Gillingham drew 0-0 with Blackpool in 1987 is not one of them.

Earlier this year Ken put up 16 consecutive losing bets, a few of them odds on then he gave up. But don't discourage him too much he can be very funny.
Report SHAPESHIFTER • May 11, 2014 5:56 PM BST
Curious:

what are the stats for play-offs

The last five years

The last three years

Last year
Report kenilworth • May 11, 2014 6:03 PM BST
Look them up yourself if you don't mind.
Report SHAPESHIFTER • May 11, 2014 7:09 PM BST
Here's a nice one that involves history and averages:

Man United v Sunderland
Prior to this year, Sunderland had never won as visitors.
9-2-0 the record

So the bookies pump home
"Man U have never lost at home to Sunderland"
notice how the draws are presented

Average number of goals over those meetings back to 1999:
2.54

Interestingly, if you took the average of the last 5 matches at Manchester, the difference was slight: 2.40

But using a decades worth of data wouldn't have 'predicted' this years result:

RESULT 2013/2014 0-1 Sunderland
Report SHAPESHIFTER • May 11, 2014 7:16 PM BST
Here's another double:

The bookies say:
"Chelsea's record at home against Sunderland prior to April's match was 9-0-2 and they averaged only a goal per match to be scored against them"

Result 2013/14 1-2 Sunderland
Report SHAPESHIFTER • May 11, 2014 7:18 PM BST
Man City V Sunderland

“Man City have never lost at home to Sunderland” (8-1-0 at home).

RESULT 2013/14 Draw
Report SHAPESHIFTER • May 11, 2014 7:27 PM BST
But what about this:

The powerhouse Man City was priced up as +1 1.40 when visiting Sunderland this year.

The record of Sunderland versus Man City at home prior to this season:
4-1-4

But look at the last three years:
The results were:
1-0
1-0
1-0

and this year.... 1-0

So what bearing did the match ten years ago have?

Sunderland won 1-0
Report kenilworth • May 12, 2014 9:48 AM BST
Two points.
The bookmakers do not pump historical data to the industry,
the media do that.

My reference to the playoff stats has nothing with to
with individual club head to heads, it is to do with
teams that finish between third and sixth at the end of the
season from the Championship and Division 1, also from fourth
to seventh in Division 2 also with the lower placed side at home
in the all important first leg, and just about every match
the bookmakers have both sides odds against.

in my opinion head to heads between individual sides are meaningless,
do you agree?
Report kenilworth • May 12, 2014 10:36 AM BST
SHAOESHIFTER, in answer to your questions...
a) which teams were involved with these play-offs? Every team placed 3rd to 6th Championship, Div1, Div2 (4th to 7th.
b) which players from 1986 are still playing? None, they are probably too old.
c) have there been rule changes in the past decade? None that I am aware of.
d) how much weight do you put on a match from 1993 as opposed to last year? Only if the teams qualify for the playoffs.
e) how much different are these stats top those of the entire season? Around 25% less goals scored, also around 25% less matches drawn
Report kenilworth • May 12, 2014 10:13 PM BST
[b]Final results from 6 playoff 1stleg matches.[/b]


Games played.6
Goals scored.9
Draw results.3
Unders.......5
Overs........1

Hope these match results
were helpful to someone.
Report green army • May 12, 2014 11:13 PM BST
indeed, wise wise words, I'm going to go out and get a tattoo to celebrate
Report SHAPESHIFTER • May 14, 2014 10:45 AM BST

May 12, 2014 -- 4:13PM, kenilworth wrote:


Final results from 6 playoff 1stleg matches.Games played.6Goals scored.9Draw results.3Unders.......5Overs........1Hope these match resultswere helpful to someone.


Kenilworth, will answer your questions when I have a moment

What were the odds on the six matches for Under 2.50 (I assume you backed them all)

Report kenilworth • May 14, 2014 3:23 PM BST
SHAPESHIFTER, you are quite capable of digging
up the prices if you wish, but what you assume
about what I backed is your choice.
Report SHAPESHIFTER • May 14, 2014 8:44 PM BST
Yawn....
Report kenilworth • May 14, 2014 9:28 PM BST
Did it really take you 5 hours to come
up with that?
Report kenilworth • May 27, 2014 9:31 AM BST
Final tally


Games played.15
Goals scored.33
Draw results.7
Unders.......9
Overs........6

All matches on 90 mins play.

Stats pointed to low goals,
and draws.
Hope you joined in.
Report stu • May 27, 2014 11:57 PM BST
Really fellas (SS and Ken) - I respect both of you guys opinions. Two posters that I would always read and consider their opinion on these forums.

I think there's a really interesting point here, and your positions are both valid (while still being contradictory with one another).

I think the argument about longer term stats vs smaller samples that are recent is an excellent one. But I see the problem/debate as something that is very pertinant. I use both, but still find it hard to decide on the stronger view. I think for that reason you disagree, while both being partly right and partly wrong. This is a dilemma that faces anyone who uses stats to decide on their tissues, 'true' prices etc.

No need for fighting on a personal level, this is a key predictive statistics question!
Report green army • May 28, 2014 9:20 AM BST
hahahahahahaha
Report kenilworth • May 28, 2014 1:57 PM BST
stu, I hear what you say, but disagree re
my views. Seven draws from 15 matches,
9 goals from 6 1st leg matches...
What bit did you disagree with?
Report stu • May 28, 2014 7:50 PM BST
Not arguing personally, from those results your point was supported.
I'm saying the debate between longer term and shorter term statistics is a key question when making predictions, and something I've long considered difficult. While larger samples give stronger foundations, shorter term reflects some more closely related factors (e.g. where teams/players have altered). The key I think is deciding at what point older statistics lose their relation to a current match, and why.
Report kenilworth • May 29, 2014 6:35 PM BST
stu, Actually the results prove nothing, no more than if
betting based on the stats had shown a loss. In my view
backing, say the draws, I was getting 12/5 about true
7/4 chances, results prove little if nothing at all.
Getting the value was the important thing and always will.
Getting favourable results was/is very welcome but in my
view, results from 15 matches doesn't prove anything
conclusively.
Report green army • May 30, 2014 12:17 PM BST
here here, wise words, if you can't stand the heat then don't take the horse to water, whats your WC strategy ken ?
Report stu • May 31, 2014 10:52 AM BST
Ken - not sure why you thought we were disagreeing. I didn't say conclusively prove anything, that's why I used the word 'supported'.
Results only ever support a view, rather than prove it.

Not sure why you suggested I was talking about proof?
Report stu • May 31, 2014 10:53 AM BST
However, back to my main point - you see the point about long v short term stats? How do you deal with that issue?
Report kenilworth • May 31, 2014 2:35 PM BST
stu, I think at times when I put a post together,
I'm talking to myself, and it reads differently from
what I am trying to say!!
Anyway, regards long and short term stats, I am
very much in the 'long term' camp, as in my view,
they are much more reliable, short term being too
impetuous. different rules for different stats I
suppose, head to heads I completely ignore as I
can't see how, say Sunderland v ManU from 3/4/5 years
ago can connect with those sides playing, say tomorrow,
besides the odds compilers ignore that sort of thing
and they tend to know their job. I think the crucial
thing is spotting something that does have an effect
but others have overlooked for instance, say 2 wins
within 6 matches would have a diff of 4 points because
of a couple of bad refereeing decisions, whereas this
would hardly show within, say 24 matches. etc GL.
Report stu • June 1, 2014 9:48 AM BST
Yep, I agree that knowing which shorter term factors to ignore is a good strategy. Not always easy though. I still think some shorter term factors will influence results - a good example being team confidence, though difficult to measure precisely of course...
Report stu • June 1, 2014 9:50 AM BST
Also interesting you mention the h2h issue - I remember chatting to someone a long while back about 'bogey' teams. They were of the view that certain bogey teams were a factor, even when dating back way beyond current sides, due to the issue of team psychology. Not sure how the stats would back it up though, as I've never tested it precisely.
Post Your Reply
<CTRL+Enter> to submit
Please login to post a reply.

Wonder

Instance ID: 13539
www.betfair.com