Forums

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
sheppy123
28 Oct 13 18:51
Joined:
Date Joined: 28 May 12
| Topic/replies: 2,522 | Blogger: sheppy123's blog
Phew! I just hate it when this happens...

OK, like a lot of people I keep trying different systems. They've all failed so far but hey, I'll just keep trying till I've no money left in the bank!

Anyway, this isn't a system but this morning I noticed that "On His Own" was running at Naas. I thought that with it being the fav to win the 2013 National, and the fact Ruby was onboard the price would contract before the off, so I got on it @ 8.
About an hour later it was 9's which pissed me off, so for psychological reasons I bet on it again. And then to my absolute horror I found it @11's. Now this is how dumb I am. It could've been injured for all I knew but I just had to back it again. Things were getting very psychological! And then just before the race it was about 17! I backed it 5 times altogether! My intention was always to lay it off a few notches down, but now I just wanted my money back. Fortunately I did, but I'm hoping that I've learned a lesson from this??? Phew! Where do you draw the line!?!

So can somebody tell me why this horse drifted so much???

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 1 of 5  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 186
By:
smithy91
When: 28 Oct 13 19:14
happens all the time i'm guessing with horse racing from what I've seen. unless you know your horses surely its the most dangerous trading pre off you  can do?
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 28 Oct 13 19:22
why don't you ask the horse racing forum?

It's the oldest horse in the race, so it likely has the least improvement, it's aim is probably the GN, the fave had 10lbs in hand and I don't even follow horse racing.  It hadn't run for 4 months which probably meant the market was a good guide to it's fitness.
By:
sheppy123
When: 28 Oct 13 21:08
Thanks guys!

I've gone through many stages of trying to analyse which horses have the most chances of winning and failed miserably! It's like rocket science to me!

So I try and look for other systems that don't require too much knowledge.

Still looking...
By:
roadrunner46
When: 28 Oct 13 21:20
dont worry about it, most people will never work out horse racing, your not alone there are millions of you out thereLaugh
By:
Stevie Gerrard
When: 28 Oct 13 21:24
He's on quite a good mark at the moment for a return to chasing but perhaps just needed a run to put him spot on so they put him over hurdles today. Even at his best he'd struggle to beat these over hurdles, like Clydebank says he's 10lb badly in with the fav and with others in the race too.
By:
s.kenbo
When: 28 Oct 13 21:36
roadrunner. LaughLaughLaugh
By:
sheppy123
When: 28 Oct 13 21:43
Thanks StevieHappy
By:
sheppy123
When: 28 Oct 13 21:48
roadrunnerLaugh

I think calculus is easier to understand than horse racing!Laugh
By:
Stevie Gerrard
When: 28 Oct 13 22:21
Also if you look back at his last hurdles win shep you'll see that he was actually beaten by another of today's rivals Sesquinane (later disqualified) and he was worse off in the weights with that horse today as well. The Grand National, whilst being a big race is a 4m 4f handicap chase and today was a 2m 4f hurdle against horses like Rule The World who was 2nd in the Sun Alliance hurdle to the current champion hurdle fav The New One.
By:
HARRY22
When: 28 Oct 13 23:06
Unless you are in the know stay clear sheppy...spend your cash on a holiday and enjoy the sun Cool   You will lose your entire bank trying to guess which horse will shorten or drift.
By:
sheppy123
When: 29 Oct 13 09:31
HARRY22 - that's great advice and I should take it. But it would take a hell of a lot to keep me away from horse racing!Happy

What I need to do is take far less chances, and think more before putting the bet on. I do too many things on the spur of the moment.

Stevie Gerrard - Thanks for the info, it was very educational. Phew!Happy
By:
BJT
When: 29 Oct 13 10:22

Oct 28, 2013 -- 11:06PM, HARRY22 wrote:


Unless you are in the know stay clear sheppy...spend your cash on a holiday and enjoy the sun    You will lose your entire bank trying to guess which horse will shorten or drift.


lol.  A horse that has gone from 8 to 9 to 11 is a pretty good place to start guessing.....LaughLaugh

By:
zipper
When: 29 Oct 13 10:46
Sheppy  the reason they drift  somebody dont fancy them .. in this game money talks .. hope that helps  .. could spend all morning  giving reasons ..been on course 40 years  been on here about 10 years ..and i DONT back drifters
By:
sheppy123
When: 29 Oct 13 12:57
Thanks zipper. I definitely can't argue with your great experience.

For many years I've found drifters very appealing. I think it's psychological more than anything else.

I can't bring myself to back a horse @ say 10 when it was 50s a few hours before.

I always think that a horse may have over drifted cos of the hype of the favourite etc.

Phew! It looks like a holiday in the sun might be a better option!Laugh
By:
Darlo Bantam
When: 29 Oct 13 14:29
To the OP: there's certainly an argument that if you think you have value at 8s, then you should back again when it drifts. However, if you were backing hoping rather than expecting it to contract, then I'm not entirely sure that's a wise policy to back again. However, I seem to have seen more horses than normal recently drift/come in and then do the opposite to what the market was expecting.
By:
sheppy123
When: 29 Oct 13 15:22
Thanks Darlo. Yes it's all about value isn't it??? But, for me, I felt the need to back it again for psychological reasons which isn't the right thing to do. It's like I felt ripped off when it drifted so wanted to back it again. I hate to admit that I've done this lots of times, and although it isn't a winning strategy long term, it does feel good when it wins.

A memorable drift for me was "Goldboy". It was racing @ Naas a few weeks ago. I'd backed it @ 6 and within minutes in was 12's! I couldn't resist backing it again, which was really dumb really cos I didn't have a clue why it drifted! Anyway, I was absolutely delighted when the bloody thing won! I bet the layers were gutted though!

I'm gonna have a break from the horses soon cos I lose more money than I win and I need to come up with better strategies.
By:
Darlo Bantam
When: 29 Oct 13 15:59
It's like I felt ripped off when it drifted so wanted to back it again. I hate to admit that I've done this lots of times, and although it isn't a winning strategy long term, it does feel good when it wins.

I do this far too much too.
By:
sheppy123
When: 29 Oct 13 16:31
Hahaha I'm glad it's not just me then!Laugh
By:
HARRY22
When: 29 Oct 13 19:34
spot on from zipper..not a huge racing fan but I have had some very good advice on this sport and zipper has it right.

Darlo....he doesn't know if he has value or not,he is just guessing unless he has a tip off and by the way if drifted he isn't in the know Shocked
By:
scotbet
When: 29 Oct 13 19:57
Sheppy123

I remember a few years back I bet on the GN - horse was Paris Pike on the day of the race - was trading around 9/1 - 10/1 with all the layers but 15/1 on here I went in at that price thinking great will get a bit out of this as it will return 11/1 even 12/1 on here ...didn't it do that ...No

Speak to BJT he's seem to know his onions.Happy
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 29 Oct 13 22:20
sheppy123 - Reasons for it drifting were given by some posters above.

Reason why it never completed the 2013 GN .....probably down to going not suiting it......it suited the older horses.

Since your have already noted it was a "favourite" for this year GN......IMO ...a "false" fav.....I suggest you pay more attention for this horse being entered for next year's GN.


It will all depend though on the GOING on the day , and strength of opposition ....all 39 of them!


Currently on AP 44s BF odds...............not bad for last years fav....with all the risk of such a market and loss of bet if does not run...

Not a great deal of logic re horses drifting.................did MON MOME drift when romping in at 100 SP? etc etc ......
By:
HARRY22
When: 29 Oct 13 22:32
Not a great deal of logic re horses drifting.................did MON MOME drift when romping in at 100 SP? etc etc ......

Try it over 300 horses that drift and you may not make this comment...mon mome was a steamer from 110/1 Grin
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 29 Oct 13 23:28
With favourites approx 66 % lose.............do most favourites "shorten"?

Either you have an edge or not..........deciding NOT to back a horse because it drifts is just a lemming approach to betting. Similarly lumping on ones that shorten , means you are late catching the value.

If you have selected/backed  a horse because it has factors in favour on the day.....if it drifts, it really should not bother you......unless you are a "trader". DevilLaugh
By:
sheppy123
When: 29 Oct 13 23:32
Thanks guys, you're advice is much appreciated!

I've actually won a few quid today backing drifters.

Jazzy Lady and Brave Brook.

Unfortunately I layed them a few notches down which is typical isn't it!

But, like I said, my system isn't profitable in the long term so I need to try a different strategy.

I wish I had more faith in my ability to understand all the complications of the sport, I might be more successful???
By:
sheppy123
When: 29 Oct 13 23:33
Actually, that should be "your" advice, not "you're" advice!

I had to say this so I can sleep tonight!Laugh
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 29 Oct 13 23:42
COSMIC HALO , last month, was backed by me at 55 BF initially.........I believed it was "value" as was top rated on my "system". It drifted out to 90s before the off ....so I backed it again.

Why should I blink when a horse has a number of factors in favour for a race....and it drifts massively?


If you blindly back drifters , then that can't work long term.

GL in your search S.
By:
sheppy123
When: 29 Oct 13 23:42
Thanks Ironman, you said some really interesting things here.

I wish I could say something like... Jazzy Lady should be about 25. If it's over, then it's a value bet.

The Betfair graph never ceases to amaze me. It often looks like a rollercoaster the way it's gone up and up and up, and then back down again! It's like people can't make their minds up?!?
By:
HARRY22
When: 29 Oct 13 23:53
DFC...it was top rated in the whole field? how many runners in this?? what price was the fav?
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 30 Oct 13 00:07
The ratings and result was as follows...

YORK


15:35                (WAS NAP IN COMP...AND WAS 50-1 SP JUST BEFORE OFF ...SO LATE MONEY CAME!

1,Cosmic Halo                         1ST 33                    63.93   0.00
2,Laughing Jack     25                                          41.42  35.00
3,Aerodynamic       25                                          43.00  39.00
4,Bishop's Castle                     3RD 5 F
5,Day Of Destiny      25
6,King Of The Celts   50
7,Save The Bees                        4TH 12
8,Morocco            6  2ND F
9,President Lincoln  50                                         89.94  10.00
10,Christmas Light   16                                         18.65  18.00
=============================================================================================
11,Patriotic    25                                   29.00   28.00 
12,Fragonard                           2ND  14                          15.23    2.00
13,Arc Light          7  3RD F
14,Tiger Reigns       33
15,Nemushka       14     
16,Bank On Me       8 5TH F   
17,Barren Brook   7.5  4TH F
18,Super Say      16                                     19.94  10.00
19,Invincible Hero   25                                       39.48  8.00
By:
HARRY22
When: 30 Oct 13 00:24
I remember this race..I had christmas light in competition.

so your ratings have the top 3 horses at 33/1 25/1 25/1..

interesting system if it is working for you long term.
By:
HARRY22
When: 30 Oct 13 00:35
DFC are you using horse form as one of your main pointers in the system you have?
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 30 Oct 13 00:57
You don't always get 3 at top of ratings at high odds...........just happened with that race.

The only other 2 races rated that day were :-




16:05

1,Rosairlie          20                                      31.72  13.00
2,Nashville           8
3,My Destination     40                                      79.00  49.00
4,Rocktherunway                  3RD 12
5,Pearl Spice         3 F   
6,Getabuzz            14
7,Medieval Bishop     25
8,Hit The Jackpot   25                                       51.57  3.80
===============================================================================================
9,Flashman                       2ND 7 2ND F
10,Body Language  8  JT 3RD/4TH F
11,Tartan Jura   25                                          35     20
12,Recession Proof 16 
13,Porcini       N/R   
14,Eagle Rock          1ST 8 JT 3RD/4TH F     
15,Hawk Mountain  10   5TH F
16,Sula Two       16                                         31.00   4.80



FONTWELL PARK
17:20

1,Chestnut Ben     1ST  2 F
2,Celtic Charlie 25                                         39      41
3,Wak A Turtle     3RD  7 4TH F
4,Osmosia          2ND  11 5TH F
5,Novikov    5 2ND F
===================================================================================================
6,The Grey One    20                                      24.76    18.00
7,Safe Investment  2.75 2ND F
8,She's Humble    14                                      17.68     8.00

..........................................................................................


RATINGS are not "easy" to weigh up as to the "best" betting strategy.......as seasons progress, then different STRATEGIES have to be adopted for TURF/NH/AW........


Generally the "system" will indicate "VALUE" , for BACKS and LAYS, using RANK positions compared to odds etc.

Due to personal circumstances have had to shelve it the last couple years, and unlikely will be in a position to use it til NEW YEAR. It takes a great deal of energy to use it, and , as I am a full-time carer, recovering from major op last year, then it is difficult to operate it efficiently  due to my energy levels being low, and time disrupted through caring duties.

I still plan to use it in JANUARY onwards, as BETTING STRATEGIES are clear after analysing ratings results, and by then I a hoping my fitness levels are up..............though the caring duties may well cause havoc to plans.Sad

COSMIC HALO was a bit odd in market movements.....as was a big drifter ....out to 90s BF, then near off money did come to shift odds from 50-1 SP to 33-1 SP.......though as already had it at 55s and 90s BF , then I never even noticed the shortening of odds until after the raceTongue Out.

Time for kippppppppp...


GL with bets.
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 30 Oct 13 01:04
"FORM" ......If you mean race results in terms of RACE RECORD...YES.


If you mean ....did horse run well in going.....NO.


Many factors used in ratings.....though GOING is always the KEY FACTOR for certain subjective decisions made when rating a race.

Better get some sleep!


G M the nooooooooooooooooooooooo
By:
BJT
When: 30 Oct 13 02:43
Realistically, horses drift for a number of reasons the same way that they get backed in, and to blindly ignore such events is negligent.  Obviously in some cases these are intertwined.

The other night there was a pacer that was to go around with a price opening 21 dollars.  It went off at an SP of 2.80.
Now you can imagine that every other horse in the race drifted plenty, and there was a massive plunge on this horse.  If this was in the formbook, it simply wouldn't have opened up at 21.00 now would it.
This was a first starter, so more exaggerated, but did have trials under his belt for the form students.

While this is a massive example of why horses drift through no fault of their own, it does show that simple form systems really don't provide enough information.

It doesn't show in the formbook the temperament of the horse.  The coat of the horse on race day.  It doesn't show a horses training schedule, feed pattern, training times. 
So when a horse that is usually well mannered and relaxed in the mounting yard, shows up agitated, coat a little wooly, sweating up, then you can throw the formbook out the window because this is the first time it has been presented in such a state, and the results of the horse previous really don't add up to knowing anything about what it will do. 
You know the ability of the horse, but using up excess energy, lowers race performance.  Hence, a drift in the odds.

In the UK, it is legal to run your horse dead so really that decision may affect the odds, considering they are doing it for a reason.


There are many many reasons why a horse will drift in the market.  Very few of these reasons you will find in the formbook no matter how detailed it is unless it is a private formbook of a well informed race goer.

There are also different levels of drift.  There is the no hoper drift where it is already known the horse won't be allowed to win.  There is the mild sweat up drift, where the horse has been judged to present poorly at which point people become layers.  There is the "I have a lot of money to fool the traders and take their money" drift.

With each kind of drift, the line moves on what is value.  The no hoper drift, could go out to 1000/1 and still be a good lay.  The slightly agitated horse that was pushed from 10-15 may have a line closer to 12.50 (for example) but was pushed too far by the sheep.  The ones that got on early well done, the ones that followed later, may have been better backing.


Point being, there is no hard and fast rule about horses that drift or shorten.  There can be many reasons.  Just because it is drifting doesn't mean it can't win, but it probably does mean that its chances are less than what the formbook suggests.
There are 2 reasons why most of the drift happens on the day.
1.  Because there is more money to soak up from running a good horse with well hidden talents.
2.  Because the presentation of the horses on the day, shows where they are at in their campaign and if they are aimed at this race, need the run or really just unhappy to be there.
By:
sheppy123
When: 30 Oct 13 10:06
BJT and Ironman - you clearly know your stuff and I enjoyed reading your info. Thanks!

BJT - Thanks for taking the time to explain about drifters, it was really helpful. Much appreciated!

There was a lot of stuff to take in so I plan on reading it all again.

I have a question for you...

Is it known then that some horses aren't gonna win like it's fixed??? So, if this was the case the insiders would be laying like crazy causing the drift.
By:
PittsburghPhil
When: 30 Oct 13 10:35
In the UK, it is legal to run your horse dead


ShockedShockedShocked

Is that true ???????

You're kidding, I hope.

That is absolutely staggering if it's true. Why would anyone bet on races where you don't even have to LOOK as if you're trying? That would mean that it would be possible to blatantly rig races with impunity.

Please tell me this isn't true.
By:
BJT
When: 30 Oct 13 13:52

Oct 30, 2013 -- 10:35AM, PittsburghPhil wrote:


In the UK, it is legal to run your horse dead Is that true ???????You're kidding, I hope.That is absolutely staggering if it's true. Why would anyone bet on races where you don't even have to LOOK as if you're trying? That would mean that it would be possible to blatantly rig races with impunity.Please tell me this isn't true.


Rule (B)57 – Pacemakers
• The BHA is of the opinion that the Rules of Racing do not prohibit the running of
horses as pacemakers as such, provided they are run on their merits as required by
Rule (B)58.
• The BHA gives notice that other than the pure act of pacemaking, riding to benefit
horses which have one or more owners in common or are under common control or
are from the same stable or team is unacceptable, and breaches of Rules B(57) are
likely to be treated as serious.
A Rider shall not:
• Make a manoeuvre in a race in the interests of another horse in common ownership
or under common control or from the same stable or team whether or not such a
manoeuvre caused interference or caused his horse to fail to achieve its best
possible placing.
• Commit a riding offence with the intention or with the consequence of giving
advantage to another horse in common ownership or under common control or from
the same stable or team.
• For the avoidance of doubt this Rule does not prohibit pure pacemaking as such, and
the phrase “common ownership” means that the horses in question share one or
more owners in common and “common control” shall be similarly construed.
• Penalties - 5 to 10 days

Technically, it isn't illegal in the wording of the rules, but it isn't policed at all and even if it was, the jockey would be suspended for around a week.  A well paid vacation no doubt.



http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w6Sid0fqd_4

Watch this race, and listen to the commentator for the first half of the race.

"Ian Mongan having a look around to find Frankel".
"Bullet Train clearly being restrained in an attempt to try and get Frankel on his back, his rider looking round persistantly".
"Bullet Train trying to get in front of Frankel in 3rd and 4th place but unable to slipstream him".....
"Bullet Train just trying to make a nuisance up the inside once more".


This was one of the most high profile races in the world and took UK racing to the world.  This commentator clearly isn't phased by what was going on, it was expected, as the horse has done exactly the same in every race.

First rule.  Broken.  Wasn't run on its merits at all.  It ran to slipstream his teammate, and when he couldn't do that, he went up to pressure his main rival in the race.

Second rule.  Broken.  riding to benefit
horses which have one or more owners in common or are under common control or
are from the same stable or team is unacceptable, and breaches of Rules B(57) are
likely to be treated as serious.


Third rule.  Broken.  Jockey not allowed to make a manouvere to give advantage to another horse in common ownership under common control of the same stable.

Fourth rule.  Broken.  Commit a riding offence, ^^ to give advantage to another horse under common control.


This event to be shown to the world, and this is what the commentator has to call?  Just another race in the UK I am afraid, the thought that it was a rort never even crossed his mind.




What about this one?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=6elMmgyzBCk

In all interviews they go over their team tactics.  The caller calls his role.  The horse sets his pace, then pulls out with over 2 furlongs to go after being passed by the field.  Apparantly the horse started favourite in a derby and he had one simple task in this race, to help his mate.  Turns out he did a siht job, but at no point was JV being ridden to get the best possible finish.  He was ridden dead.  Same with BT every race.

So many more examples of this kind of thing.  Hard to deny when the rules are set in stone, and they blatantly break them over and over again without recourse.

So maybe it was negligent to say it was legal when what I really meant was perfectly acceptable by everybody in the game over there.

By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 30 Oct 13 14:10
You are on "dangerous ground" re some of comments above BJT.......

Stirring the hornets nest may end up with you being stungTongue Out

Topic may be deleted if another separate thread started............
By:
BJT
When: 30 Oct 13 14:16

Oct 30, 2013 -- 10:06AM, sheppy123 wrote:


BJT and Ironman - you clearly know your stuff and I enjoyed reading your info. Thanks!BJT - Thanks for taking the time to explain about drifters, it was really helpful. Much appreciated!There was a lot of stuff to take in so I plan on reading it all again.I have a question for you...Is it known then that some horses aren't gonna win like it's fixed??? So, if this was the case the insiders would be laying like crazy causing the drift.


Some horses for sure are ridden dead.  Drift certainly doesn't mean it will be ridden dead, but it doesn't take long to watch the ones that are ridden dead.

There are also other things though.  The same way that a horse may train up a storm at home without anybody to see to plunge on, it may also do the opposite.
For example.  So I don't single out the UK racing scene, I will use an example from over here in Aus.
We have a mare More Joyous.  Winner of 8 G1 races.
In her last start, she was sent out at 2/1. 
In a very public spat on live television, the owner and trainer, ummmm, had words.  The trainers son, one of the biggest bookmaking families in the country, who was running a very nice book on the race and offering up deals on the horse.  Tom Waterhouse, the son and bookmaker, was also heard telling people that the horse couldn't win.

As it turns out, the horse wasn't eating, and couldn't even bend her neck down to the ground to get some grass going.  Was in a bad way.  The issues were found either the day before, or the morning before Waterhouse was telling people (highly regarded figures only obviously, not publicly) not to waste their money as she couldn't win.

Here is the owners interview:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=X1C-V6pKRdE

Tom Waterhouse had discussed with Johns on the Thursday before the All Aged Stakes on April 27 that he didn't favour three of the favourites, including More Joyous. As the drinks flowed in a corporate suite the following night at the Manly game, Johns recounted a version of this conversation to Hayson, a well-known punter, who passed along a version of the story to former jockey Allan Robinson. Robinson spoke to Singleton the following day, who was left with the impression that his champion mare was "off" and was going to finish closer to last than first. Singleton exploded. Gai stood her ground. More Joyous ran second last.

Johns started stressing.

But instead of being careful, Johns caved to pressure from a Sunday Footy Show producer the following morning to explain to viewers his role in the controversy. He said Tom Waterhouse had told him More Joyous was "off".

http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/news/time-for-troubled-andrew-johns-to-man-up/story-fni0cx4q-1226640001137



So yes, some horses run dead due to jockeys, some run to their full health known to be way below par, some are there for their mates, and some drift because punters like something else.

Page 1 of 5  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com