Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

Welcome to Live View – Take the tour to learn more
Start Tour
There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
crispyman
08 Oct 11 15:38
Joined:
Date Joined: 13 May 08
| Topic/replies: 483 | Blogger: crispyman's blog
Had a 14/1 winner in a shop multiples bet yesterday with ppower, tried to collect today and was told I missed the price by 26 SECONDS and I was being paid at 11/1.
Havent collected yet and will ring later to argue my case, any advice on what grounds I can use and threats I can give them?
Pause • Switch to Standard View Underpaid by 546 quid
Show More
Loading...
Report bf_fananatic • October 8, 2011 3:44 PM BST
Did you take a price and more importantly did they accept the wager at the struck price, unless there is a clause in there rules that states there prices are timed and not just the struck bets then how on earth can they prove at what point you were given or offered the price, explain to them that they will have to pay at the taken odds or you will take it to the governing body, you will win the case as is quite clear they are under paying the pay, don't give in as its another case of bookmakers clawing money from winnings bets.
Report bf_fananatic • October 8, 2011 3:52 PM BST
I hope everybody reads your complaint on here as I got robbed of £800 from a winning bet which they accepted they where instructed of the race for the bet when I was asked pre-off, They got away with it but you clearly have a valid case as they cant evade the payment if legally challenged, and its free to post a complaint, cant remember the name of the body that deals with it but they do go with the punter if the bet is ok.

P.s. all customers please take note that this is why an exchange is 100 X better than any bookmaker and lets hope people understand how good and fair exchanges are in comparisonBlush
Report crispyman • October 8, 2011 5:21 PM BST
Yeah prices were all on the slip and they just put it through, rang them there and they wouldnt make an exception, is it worth going to the small claims court about?
IBAS is usually the first step made but they tend to favour the bookie.
Report toffee87 • October 8, 2011 8:28 PM BST
if its on the slipthen thats what they have to pay you at - IBAS will rule in your favour
Report Banks. • October 8, 2011 8:46 PM BST
if its on the slipthen thats what they have to pay you at - IBAS will rule in your favour

That`s not necessarily true.

IBAS will check what the company price was at the time of acceptance not the price on the slip. They will have an audit trail of price changes and will rule based on that.

If the price on the slip was all that mattered then a few dodgy members of staff could wipe out the industry in a day!

I reckon you will lose at IBAS based on the info you have given so you would be better trying to get an amicable settlement off them. Taking it to court is a possible but a lot of hassle for a monkey. You would probably lose in court too. Your best hope would be for them to make a commercial settlement beforehand as it won't be worth them putting much resource into a £500 dispute.
Report metal guru • October 8, 2011 9:00 PM BST
why would going to a small claims court be a "lot of hassle?"it would cost 50 quid and if they think they are on shaky ground then they'd pay up before the court date.
Report Banks. • October 8, 2011 9:14 PM BST
Based on what the OP has said they won't be on shaky ground and they would almost certainly win. His only hope going that route is that they pay him off beforehand as a commercial decision even though they know they will win at court.
Report metal guru • October 8, 2011 9:20 PM BST
the OP has said that they told him that he missed the price by 26 seconds despite marking a different price on the slip-thats all.try and take a balanced view of things
Report Eldrick • October 8, 2011 9:21 PM BST
I understand the argument that the bookie has audit trail of price changes, but I don't understand why they aren't obliged to tell the customer about these changes on the spot - if he's missed the price by 11 seconds it's a bit unfortunate all round of course.

The status quo that bookies can silently change prices at any moment and you don't find out about them until you go to collect your winnings is absurd - the punter probably wouldn't want the bet any more if they were actually given the full information about it

Bookies should be dragged into the 21st century, the whole process is putting a bet on in shops is utterly archaic
Report Eldrick • October 8, 2011 9:21 PM BST
(26 secs, sorry)
Report Lori • October 8, 2011 9:24 PM BST
Why they don't do it the Vegas way is beyond me, then there's no comebacks or arguments for anyone and the staff don't even need to know anything at all, which in this country would be a huge bonus.
Report Feck N. Eejit • October 8, 2011 9:27 PM BST
If bookmakers are going to go down betfair's now-you-see-it-now-you-don't road maybe they should be forced to have a 26 second bet placement delay.
Report Banks. • October 8, 2011 9:49 PM BST
I agree that the current situation isn't ideal.

I suppose the option is that every bet is captured while the punter is at the counter. I can imagine this would be a bit of a nightmare.

You would get loads of people not getting on at the off and christ knows what you would do in the morning when the old boys come in for their through the card 5p doubles at every meeting taking a price on every selection. They would tie up the counter for an age.

I suppose it is a trade off between getting on and having confirmation at acceptance.
Report Eddie Batt • October 9, 2011 1:06 AM BST
My brother had some aggro with Powers last year and to cut a long story short shop staff have discretion of up to 30 seconds with prices.
For some reason possibly because long standing staff tend to have shares they seem to take a hardline with prices and I have had a couple of occasions where I missed a price by seconds and they wanted to settle at sp disregarding any prices in-between.
First off I would ask the staff what discretion they have -if that gets you nowhere I would write a letter to head office detailing your problem.Don't lose your rag with the staff and likewise keep the letter polite-their customer service isn't too bad.
Report baracouda30 • October 9, 2011 6:44 AM BST
Having worked in a bookies I have a question...

When you put the slip on the counter did you say "I want to take the prices, please" or words to that effect?

If not, then to me it's your fault. If you did, then it's their fault (though I would normally expect a little squiggle or signature from the staff member to signify prices have been taken).

In a busy shop (no idea how busy this one was when you placed the bet) the staff will need a bit of communication from people. They generally aren't mind-readers.
Report askari1 • October 9, 2011 7:57 AM BST
I'm with Banks up to the point where he says that a court wd side w/ the bookie.

We don't know, because the courts are at too low a level to generate case law and the bookies make an effort to prevent this kind of case reaching court.

For a court case, your risk to reward is a whole lot better than a big high st bookie, so I wd speak to the area manager, emphasise that you are a straight bettor looking for the best price but not taking arbs and ask for the 500 odd quid as a goodwill gesture.

Forget about slip price--this is a red herring. Try saying rather that you had a verbal contract struck at the price you wrote down.
Report mrbojangles • October 9, 2011 10:11 AM BST
Is the Green seal service still available?
Report birch2 • October 9, 2011 2:12 PM BST
The crux of the issue here is around the acceptance of the bet by the counter staff - as barracouda points out -which as yet has not been adequately explained in this case.

If the bet was accepted with a denoting of the price, by the member of staff, then you have a cast iron case, however if the Op wrote the price down and the slip was processed without any acknowledgement by the member of staff, then you will lose

I'm not saying this is the case here, but from my experience up to 50% of punters who take prices ,do so by writing the current price on the slip, without gaining the 'approval' of the cashier at the exact time of transaction. For these, if there is a post mortem after, then they only have themselves to blame. However, if the bookmaker is hiding behind the palp rule after the staff have accepted the price, then the bookmaker should taken to task
Report Banks. • October 9, 2011 3:09 PM BST
If the bet was accepted with a denoting of the price, by the member of staff, then you have a cast iron case

That is not true and is the reason why there is always so much misunderstanding with such disputes.

A cashier taking a bet does not constitute a contract under law. The bet is accepted by the company and the employee is essentially an agent. If the agent acts in such a way that a bet is taken by them at terms which the company would not accept then it has little standing in law.

If this wasn't the case what would be stopping you getting a mate to get a cashier role with a firm and writing 1,000,000/1 on the slip?

Whilst much of this needs to be tested in law it is clear that the word of a member of shop staff most definitely does not constitute a contract between punter and firm.
Report hectoratoratora • October 9, 2011 3:30 PM BST
Banks im afraid you are wrong .The customer "offers" to place the bet,the cashier then "accepts" it ,which means there is a legally binding contract assuming both parties acted in good faith.If either party acted fraudulently the the contract will be void,but other than that there is a enforceable contract .
Report TheVis • October 9, 2011 3:30 PM BST
I know of a similar case which lost in court where a punter had written a price on the slip (in this case there was no indication either that staff had confirmed price) and by the time the bet was entered into system price had changed.

He was paid out on the changed price took to small claims and lost his claim.
Report TheVis • October 9, 2011 3:32 PM BST
PS Lori - what is the Vegas way?

Is that where you have a bet at a sports book and the odds and stake (and I guess return if it wins) are clearly stated on your slip?
Report LordBobbbin • October 9, 2011 4:00 PM BST
I don't know if this is just because I don't understand how multiples are processed, but I'm totally confused at what most of you posters seem to think the OP walked out of the shop thinking he had bought.     

Surely, at the point at which you hand over your money, you know whether you've placed a bet at a particular price (and exactly what that particular price is), or whether you're getting the SP (or whatever the equivalent is for Multiples). If the price changes in the meantime, shouldn't you be given the right to refuse the bet? If I thought 14/1 was good value but less than that wasn't, I'd certainly expect to be given the option to turn down the bet if the price had fallen in the meantime. Are Multiples really so vague that people hand over their money with no clue as to what price they've taken?   

And this idea of writing down your price and handing it over to the cashier without anyone checking it sounds very dodgy. If you walk to a cashier with an official coupon marked with the exact price (even if it is written by you), surely they're under an obligation to check the price that you're asking for, and to notify you before accepting your money if it won't be possible to give you the price that you've asked for. Aren't you given some printed receipt that confirms exactly what the bet was?
Report Banks. • October 9, 2011 4:33 PM BST
Banks im afraid you are wrong .The customer "offers" to place the bet,the cashier then "accepts" it ,which means there is a legally binding contract assuming both parties acted in good faith.If either party acted fraudulently the the contract will be void,but other than that there is a enforceable contract .

I think we are pretty much saying the same thing. The problem is that the price the cashier offered was not the official company price for one reason or another and therefore the contract between punter and company was not agreed at the terms written on the slip.

There are quite often occassions where incorrect shows are transmitted. If you place a bet and have it accepted by the cashier at the price shown on the screen it can still be amended if the price on the screen was wrong and the cashier acted in good faith.
Report birch2 • October 9, 2011 8:24 PM BST
Banks - you are splitting hairs here over what is an incorrect show (which is ultra rare) or a fraudulent act by the cashier and what the OP describes (which is an everyday occurrence)

If you take the latter, a contract has been made and is enforceable under current law.
Report petetheto • October 9, 2011 9:03 PM BST
was the 26 seconds taken up when the cashier was searching for a price of one of the other horses in your multiple bet ?
Report Banks. • October 9, 2011 9:09 PM BST
A delayed transmission of a price (assuming that is what happened in this case) is the same as an incorrect show.

They will settle at the company price which may or may not be what is being displayed in the shop for whatever reason. They will have an audit trail showing the time of price changes will be used to determine settlement.

The bottom line is that if a price is incorrectly given for whatever reason it can be corrected. In terms of bet settlement the law does not differentiate between fraudulent errors, genuine mistakes or mistakes caused by poor IT etc.
Report Banks. • October 9, 2011 9:10 PM BST
was the 26 seconds taken up when the cashier was searching for a price of one of the other horses in your multiple bet ?

Wouldn't be surprised if it was but from a legal point of view it makes no difference. He will have been the victim of crap customer service which will not make any difference in law.
Report cadizza • October 10, 2011 12:57 AM BST
Only way to stop crap like this happening is:

1: Every bet must be captured/translated straight away

2: Mark sense slips, like the Ozzies have where the price is laid corresponding to the exact price at that time in the Computer System. Those machines some LBO'S have do that and are simply Internet Terminals. 26 seconds is far too long for a single (as Banks says it's poor CS more than anything writing that price on - the price written on means nigh on sod all).

These errors keep happening and they are basically mainly happening due to inept Staff.
Report No_BS • October 10, 2011 2:03 AM BST
Why are your bookies so backward, they still use paper slips written instead of electronic slips, we don't have shops as you speak of but if you bet with them on cause you get a printed slip with your payout on it.

Once the the slip is printed that's your price the bookie has to pay out that price no changing later because he is not happy with the price.
Report LordBobbbin • October 10, 2011 5:51 AM BST
I think it would be hard for the betting shop to get away with arguing the original price was a 'mistake'. If the price given to the customer was 110.0, when all records showed that the real price at the time was around 11.0, the shop would be justified in claiming the cashier had made a mistake. In that case the contract could be rendered void - note that hasn't happened in this case, since the bookies are still happy to pay out, albeit at 11.0 rather than 14.0.       However, the difference between a price of 14.0 and 11.0 is nowhere near significant enough to merit the sort of 'mistake' that would prevent a contract from having been agreed.

The problem here seems to be down to the stupid ways in which bookies run their business - if that's so then I suspect the court would be inclined to rule for the OP. The bookies should be making it absolutely clear (on the receipt given to the OP, perhaps) whether or not a specific price had been agreed between the OP and the cashier. I don't know what the OP was given by way of receipt here. Presumably the OP gets something to take away as proof of the bet having been agreed?
Report TheVis • October 10, 2011 7:28 AM BST
Out of interest do you think the OP would have been paid out at the higher price had the horse drifted in the 26 secs?
Report Banks. • October 10, 2011 7:53 AM BST
Why are your bookies so backward, they still use paper slips written instead of electronic slips, we don't have shops as you speak of but if you bet with them on cause you get a printed slip with your payout on it.

You get a price on your slip on course because you are betting in singles.

The problem in shops is the range of bets that couldn't be put on marksense slips. There are too many multiples/strange instructions. If it all went to marksense in shos the bet range would be dramatically reduced.
Report Lori • October 10, 2011 9:15 AM BST
If the agent acts in such a way that a bet is taken by them at terms which the company would not accept then it has little standing in law.

Can he not sue the agent?

(Which would surely lead to some protection from the company or they'd have no staff within a day if successful as nobody is going to work under those conditions)
Report baracouda30 • October 10, 2011 9:28 AM BST
The bookies should be making it absolutely clear (on the receipt given to the OP, perhaps) whether or not a specific price had been agreed between the OP and the cashier.

Indeed, but if the customer is not making them aware that he wants to take a price they will assume he wants it at SP. You can't scan EVERY bet and ask EVERY customer "do you want to take any prices"?

Where I once worked, the stock reply would have been "if I wanted to take the price, I would have asked for it".
Report baracouda30 • October 10, 2011 9:30 AM BST
When I say you can't scan every bet, I mean with your eyes before you put it through the machine.
Report Feck N. Eejit • October 10, 2011 9:35 AM BST
I take it this is something to do with the epos system? If that's the case and the bookmaker goes rigidly by timed shows why do they even encourage people to slow down the cashier by asking for shows? Why don't they just make it you asterisk any runner you want the current show for and the epos system does the rest?
Report cadizza • October 10, 2011 11:14 AM BST
Crispyman

What was the actual bet here?

I would of thought a good chance something including a 14/1 in a multiple would have to be close to being a PTL and a Manager should of been looking at it.
Report askari1 • October 11, 2011 9:57 PM BST
I'm w/ Lori in thinking that there's also a potential negligence case against the cashier.

This is especially so if the customer has a bit of a reputation as a shrewdie and has bet in the shop before asking for a price.

Banks is right (tho' looking at it from the layer perspective) to say that all bookmaker rules stipulate that the price at which a contract is struck is the 'system price', not the price written down on the slip.

A bookmaker will claim these overarching rules then supersede what one wd normally think is the ordinary law of contract. But it is not clear to me that these arguments wd be accepted in court; and it is more likely that a bookmaker wd pay up rather than have its rules tested against the Unfair Terms in Consumer Contract Regulations incorporated in the Gambling Act.
Report baracouda30 • October 11, 2011 11:28 PM BST
Just walk up to the counter with your betting slip and say "I would like to take 14/1 on that horse" as you place your bet and money on the counter.

For the life of me, I can't see what's so immensely complex about that approach.

Can someone point-out what I have missed? Thanks.
Report John_Cherry • October 12, 2011 12:31 AM BST
I think the problem here is delayed transmission of prices.

It was explained on the horse racing forum where someone got short changed.
You can go up to the counter, look at the price say 14-1, the cashier sees 14-1,
the punter sees 14-1.
He takes 14-1.

However the software or some such that changes the prices on the screen is slow.
The ACTUAL price of the horse is 11-1 but the shops software is slow in updating it.

IIRC the chap who put his bet on and was told the price had changed once he'd gone to get paid, was advised that even though he'd 'taken a price', he's best to go up to the counter and confirm, say a minute before the off, that he actually has that price.
I'm not sure of the veracity of the last sentence, but the fella said it and if true is obviously nonsensical.
Report LordBobbbin • October 12, 2011 5:50 AM BST
What would be the point of confirming, a minute before the off, whether or not you actually had the price you wanted?   Once the bet has been struck and the money handed over, that's it. The time to confirm the price is before you hand over the money.
Report LordBobbbin • October 12, 2011 6:02 AM BST
Baracouda30, are you actually saying that somebody walking up to you with an official shop betting slip giving the price of 14/1 can have their price ignored by you, but if they say out loud 'I want a price of 14/1', you'll immediately snap to attention and ensure they're given that price (or told before giving you their money if the price has changed)?

If they're giving you an official slip with the exact price on it, it's your duty to look at the price and tell them if they're going to get a rawer deal. You say you can't be expected to look at every slip. Well why not?    The shop either accepts betting slips from customers or it doesn't. And if it does accept betting slips, then the people behind the desk can't be selective about whether or not they read the prices on the slips. If the shop's system isn't workable then the shop needs to change the system.

With the sophistication of technology available today, I wouldn't have thought it was too hard to create a system whereby slips were fed into some sort of central computer, and, where a price had been specified, the customers found out there and then whether they'd get the price they wanted or not.
Report Feck N. Eejit • October 12, 2011 8:02 AM BST
It's like walking into a shop, buying a mobile priced at £200, paying by debit card and having an extra £50 deducted after you've left the shop because the price change hadn't reached the shop. You find out when you get your bank statement and they refuse to take the mobile back because it's been used.
Report baracouda30 • October 12, 2011 10:04 AM BST
LordBobbin

It's not so much ignoring it as not knowing it's there. In a multiple bet, perhaps with only one or two horses where they want a price, perhaps with those prices written in incredibly small writing, perhaps with a big queue of people behind them all huffing and puffing about having to wait (that's what happens when you come in at opening time!) it's possible a cashier won't spot everything written on every slip.

You can't look at every slip when it's busy in a shop. Some people come in with wads of bets. One old girl I remember did about 30 or 40 5p patents every day. Another bloke did 0.5p e/w accas (with about 8 horses on each). Someone else did doubles, trebles & acca on one slip. If you had to check each one meticulously when putting the bets through, there would be uproar. All of these people tended to come in during "the rush" in the first 15 minutes after opening. On a busy Saturday we'd occasionally have 700-1000 bets all waiting to be "captured" after the morning rush had subsided.

I repeat...if you want a certain price, make sure the person bejind the counter is made aware of it.

Now, if you do that and they confirm the price, then in my book that is the price they should honour, even if it "changed".
Report Blades • October 12, 2011 10:21 AM BST
I feel the OP has been robbed. BUT has anyone ever been told the price increased and they have been paid out MORE??? I assume this has never happened but I am curious.
Report I'M THE MAN • October 12, 2011 11:24 AM BST
Incidents like this happen very rarely,its not the staffs fault as anybody in the industry knows how this occurrence can happen,got to feel sorry for the chap and he should be paid out the correct return,Unfortunately major firms have strict rules and staff have to abide with them and their systems,most independents would have paid the money out with a smile and like,.. they give back prices and give you the chance to put a bet on after the off....long live independents
Report dixie • October 12, 2011 11:41 AM BST
Blades

I asked for 13/8 in one of Baldies shops.  When I looked at my slip it had 7/4 on it.
Report baracouda30 • October 12, 2011 1:14 PM BST
Yes, Blades. I have seen that happen.

Have also seen someone ask for a price, I've looked at the screen and the price has drifted, so given them the higher price. People who work in bookies (generally) just want to get things right. If Joe Bloggs wins an extra £20 on top of what they were expecting, there's more chance of a tip.

The idea that the staff begrudge people their wins is ridiculous, in my experience. Unless the customer is a known t0sser, of course.
Report John_Cherry • October 12, 2011 4:12 PM BST
The punter is a strange breed.
My nephew works in one and he gets cold glares off punters and direct abuse because
the fobts are fixed and he's to blame.
He has genuinely been offered outside for a fight.
Punters are nasty to him because he's 'willing a bet to lose' etc.
99% of the public in bookies are cu*ts.
Report crispyman • October 14, 2011 11:41 AM BST
fair play to them they contacted me during the week and paid me at 14s
Report trickytree83 • October 14, 2011 11:54 AM BST
hahaha brilliant
Report LordBobbbin • October 14, 2011 12:50 PM BST
Well done Crispy for holding out!
Report baracouda30 • October 14, 2011 2:16 PM BST
Well done for getting the extra.

Next time, ask for them to confirm the price you have written on your betting slip. It'll save a lot of hassle. [;)]
Report LordBobbbin • October 14, 2011 2:46 PM BST
Yeah, that's good advice from Baracouda!    And Baracouda, thanks for your lengthy and knowledgeable replies to my questions.
Report toffee87 • October 14, 2011 5:42 PM BST
i cant believe they initially refused to pay at 14s

To use a supermarket analogy - if a price says £2.50, not only do they honour that price even if it is out of date but they give me double the difference if they charge me more at the till
Report askari1 • October 14, 2011 5:55 PM BST
Well done to crispyman but my view is that bookies are justified in having prices determined by systems, not by slips.

However, when a customer asks for confirmation or marks a price as a shrewdie, the onus shd be on the cashier to check the price is current.
Report kingell • October 14, 2011 7:42 PM BST
Tesco c0cked up the price of terry's chocolate orange the other day
Tills read bar code as 29p, should've  been nearly £3 or so.
One customer spent £50+  a " saving" of  £400 or so.
Cashier never batted an eyelid when presented with  4 or 5 trollys of Terry's
Report cadizza • October 14, 2011 8:16 PM BST
The most important part of your job when you work in a bookies is knowing your punters.

I think you would agree with that baracouda?

The way I do things is I translate any large bets instantly and I also run a discretion on prices on bets of around 10 seconds. A good member of staff can identify who is and who isn't taking the piss - it really is not that hard.

Sadly the majority of Staff are poor and I honestly think those high up really do want that these days.

Glad you got paid out but I am surprised you did.
Report baracouda30 • October 14, 2011 9:46 PM BST
Agree with the first part of your post.

In a busy shop, at a busy time (first 15 mins after the doors open) it's not possible to translate a bet straight away. Everyone behind the counter is simply taking bets, giving change, paying out yesterdays wins etc. At least, that was my experience.

The incident that started this thread was probably not in those circumstances, so it was left to a cashier to spot that the customer had written 14/1 next to a horse and that he wanted that price. Apparently, the customer didn't being it to the attention of the cashier. For the life of me, I cannot fathom why you wouldn't say "I want to take the 14/1 on xyz horse, thanks".

Yes, a good member of staff knows the majority of the customers, but you are making lots of assumptions (was the staff member familiar with that particular shop, for instance).

Just ask for the price!!
Report cadizza • October 14, 2011 9:58 PM BST
Fair enough but for me it is essential and avoids things like this happening - experience and an actual will to get things right for the Customer has installed that in to me now.

True on assumptions - problem is some Staff waste time checking prices of regulars who are betting to win a pittance anyway and 99 out of 100 times the prices are correct and not going to majorly affect the return anyway.

Last thing you need on a busy time is a 10p LUCKY 15 with no prices marked on and someone wanting them, now that really is a pain in the neck and the bloke wanting a £5 Lucky 15 deserves more time spent on him - not because of his stake but because of the liability he is attempting to take out.
Post Your Reply
<CTRL+Enter> to submit
Please login to post a reply.

Wonder

Instance ID: 13539
www.betfair.com