Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 1232 comments are related to the topic:
My challenge (horses and foot in parallel)

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 3 of 31  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 31 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 1,232
By:
coolhand
When: 03 Sep 11 21:08
The race you selected to lay 3 horses was a maiden, these can be a minefield, with horses making their debuts or with very little experience, there could be a massive difference between how much training one horse has had compared to another, how quickly one horse takes to racing compared to another. 

I would steer clear of laying big prices in maiden races, as there can be any number of unknowns, or horses that dont run up to form as they are still learning, and it can spring a few surprises.
By:
acornel
When: 03 Sep 11 21:20
DAY 5: Horse Racing: -€88.09  Total P&L:  -€88.09

Biggest loss:
GB / Ascot 3rd Sep / 14:05 To Be Placed     Electrician     Lay     16170099117     03-Sep-11
14:05           C     23     2.39           23     (52.58)
GB / Ascot 3rd Sep / 14:05 To Be Placed     Ortac Rock     Lay     16170084419     03-Sep-11
14:04           C     20.58     2.39           20.58     (46.80)

GB / Kemp 3rd Sep / 17:55 7f Hcap     Requisite     Lay     16176655263     03-Sep-11
17:55           C     18.5     2.17           18.5     (37.98)

Biggest win:
GB / Muss 3rd Sep / 15:05 5f Hcap     Ingleby Star     Back     16171738524     03-Sep-11
15:05           C     6.6     2.00           6.6     11.20

Double-loss on strategy that LAY horses at high odds ... definitely need to improve my algorithm :-(
LAY low odds in WIN market strategy is still bleeding (-20 euros) ... luckily the other strategies produced some profit that minimized today's loss. Basically I lost what I won during the last 3 days ...

From the beginning I knew that some strategies will perform bad and some others will compensate the loss ... after some time I will perform an analysis of each one and I will try to fine tune or stop some of them.
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 03 Sep 11 21:29
A - coolhand has stated clearly what you MUST always bear in mind re MAIDEN races.....

If you have NO EDGE in MAIDEN RACES......then laying horses that have not run.....is purely playing RUSSIAN ROULETTE. BACKING certain horses that have not raced in such races....can be very profitable...IF YOU HAVE AN EDGE!

You don't have an edge or strategy A........re laying big odds horses......therefore you will get GUBBED when you have no EDGE.


You will get long runs of WINS.....but that is purely because you have been LUCKY....nothing to do with you having an edge. LORD BOBBIN stated this earlier on thread .....sorry if got name wrong!!!.....and he/she is of course spot on!

Remember LAYERS can be operating to a BOOK........the fact they might have a horse at BIG ODDS in PLACE market ....or WIN market just proves the MARKET gets it "wrong" ...OFTEN!

The BAILEY horse in that AW race that won at 66-1 SP just indicates just how "wrong" certain horses odds can be!

Stick to FOOTBALL mATCHES A........if LAYING....but try to do it at sharp end of market ....not just laying HIGH ODDS ones.....as you will get stung there too......

GL with bets.....

Why not set out your "thoughts" BEFORE laying one on here.....and you probably will get some valuable INFO on the race from some on here....

Better doing that than operating thread the way you are at present......as you have admitted you have little knowledge re HORSES.....and the hard fact will be that you WILL lose betting on HORSES IF you have no edge....
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 03 Sep 11 21:33
This is what LB posted earlier ....and he/she is spot on.....



LordBobbbin 01 Sep 11 22:03 
If you're laying a good number of horses at around 25s, then yes, quite possibly. And you might get two in quick succession, which can be really morale sapping!

A few months ago I had a system where I was laying horses between odds of 6.0 and 12.0, and I had a few nice runs (several of 18, 19+ consecutive winning bets, which seemed quite good in context of the relatively low 'big odds' on those bets). However, I still saw a lot of my winnings get wiped out by several 10/11/12.0 lays going awry in the space of a few days.  You can also get yourself into a neverending cycle, putting in a series of winning lays, seeing them wiped out by one losing bet, then making the money back again with another series of winning lays, only to have them wiped out yet again by a losing bet...  It can get very tiring constantly putting in hard work building your way back, only to be returned to step one every time!   

I suspect there are easier ways to make money here, even if your system will probably seem to be working well for a good period.
By:
acornel
When: 03 Sep 11 21:38
So both races were I lost big (today - 2 horses and on 30th of august) were maiden ... I'll try to use this parameter (maiden race) in my simulations that I did for the last X months races to see if I get smth interesting.

"Why not set out your "thoughts" BEFORE laying one on here" - this is impossible. My picks are generated by an automated program. Basically the bets are put few seconds before the start of the race.
By:
acornel
When: 03 Sep 11 21:41
Btw, many thanks for your comments. Hopefully they will help me to improve my program ...
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 03 Sep 11 21:55
A - .....ADRIAN M site rates such HORSES ( or should I say ......DOES NOT give RATING points to such unraced horses in such races) poorly......and so his AUTOMATED PROGRAM is flawed on such races too!


If your PROGRAM is based on market moves........then it is based on not a lot of substance....

There are "simple" software programs about .....i saw one years ago ....if not DECADES ago......that are pretty good on "SIMPLE" MAIDEN STAKES type races.......from BACKING perspective.... However, you might learn a great deal from such programs.....

Sorry ...can't remember the name of it......someone out there probably canDevilCool
By:
acornel
When: 03 Sep 11 22:22
The last Adrian M horses ratings dates from 19/03/2011 ... looks like he stopped this rating service
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 03 Sep 11 22:27
Acornel, if your system is working primarily on market moves, you might want to consider cutting out the middle man (your software!) and looking at using software to trade the pre-race momentum.    There was a chap called slt2005 who started a thread about this a month ago. I think the title started with 'Trading Horses' - it should be pretty easy to find.

I read the thread quite a bit myself (ignore my ramblings there!), and while the idea of chart trading the momentum didn't appeal to me, there were clearly a few who found it paid for them. In particular, there was one Australian chap, Ocho, who turned up about halfway through with some interesting insights.

Slt2005 seemed very sensible, and if this sounds like something that would be of interest then you might want to contact him and see how he's getting on. He may well be able to give you a few tips.
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 03 Sep 11 22:28
On Adrian Massey, I was looking at his literature a few weeks ago, and yeah, I'm pretty sure he stopped doing it earlier this year.
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 03 Sep 11 22:29
Oh, my first post above makes more sense if you change the first line to this..

Acornel, if your system is working primarily on market moves, you might want to consider cutting out the middle man (your software!) and looking at using 3RD PARTY software to trade the pre-race momentum.
By:
acornel
When: 03 Sep 11 22:51
Thanks for the info, LB ... I'm going to read Slt2005's forum

My system does not trade horses ... I put my bet and let it go till the end of the race.
By:
acornel
When: 03 Sep 11 23:11
I've just read Slt2005's forum ... not my domain, thanks anyway.
By:
coolhand
When: 03 Sep 11 23:37
If you do stick with your system bets, which are based on price and market movement, then the type of race where you are likely to suffer big losses will be Maiden races, because the market is blind, its structured around very little and as DFCIRONMAN says the prices can be very wrong.

For example;
York 225 tomorrow
Richard Fahey has two runners in the race, one with experience and a pretty solid debut effort, the other making her debut.  Everyone will see that Hanagan, Faheys stable jockey has chosen the debutant, and so the market will shape as though that one has the beating of her stablemate with experience, and a stables first string can often be overbet as a result.  There is no telling how she will take to crowds, to the stalls, etc, there are too many unknowns, whilst her stablemate already has that experience under his belt, but is also still learning.

If you look back to the 25th August i think, the first race at Carlisle, the race was won by the Fahey third string, completely discounted in the betting because he was the perceived 3rd string based on jockey bookings and the other two were supported, he won at 33/1.  If you watch the race youll see a bunch of horses learning how to run, including the winner, and there is no sure way to telling which will take to it quicker than the rest, you can get an idea, based on breeding, on trainers debutant winners, etc but its still very hard.  The race you lost on heavily today, both were stable second strings (on jockey bookings), but this is not a strong enough guide to go on.  Last season, i think it paid quite well to back Richard Hannon second strings in maidens when Richard Hughes was riding the other.

LordBobbin and DFCIROMAN please correct me if i am mistaken.
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 03 Sep 11 23:53
I can't say I know enough about the ins and outs of UK racing to say you're definitively right Coolhand, but your analysis sounds spot on to me.

If anyone is laying horses at long odds, it's important not to go against any horse that doesn't have established form - Acornel, you should probably set a minimum number of races (four or five perhaps) that horses have to have run before you consider laying them at big prices.  Maidens should probably be best avoided unless the majority of horses have a few races under their belt. When I'm looking at maiden races, my selection process is generally completely different to the one I use when analysing other types of race.

If you are laying at long prices, you need to steer clear of horses who are trying something different in today's races. Whether that's a change in distance, a new type of surface, a new barn, a significant drop in class etc.  You want to be looking for horses who are proven losers at today's distance and class.    As you know from my previous posts, I'm not convinced laying long prices will work for you in the long term, but the thing you have to avoid at all costs is taking long prices laying a horse who's an unknown quantity in today's race.
By:
acornel
When: 04 Sep 11 13:17
Ok, got it! I have to see now how to add this parameter in my system and also to check a little bit more in details what happened in the past (last X months - 1 year) in this kind of races / horses.

In the meantime I have to continue with my actual system so let's see what is going to happen today ...
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 13:34
Will post "brief" thoughts on some races A ....might be of use to you....might not!

1.50 NURSERY race type with relatively unexposed horses....so a lottery!

Drummoyne - is "interesting" one for me .....MJ horse at YORK.. EW  MY MAIN BET EW

Ladykin - is "obvious" one to hold a fair chance in race..

With Eaterbys havinga few gorses in race.....makes it "difficult" to have STRONG views on any!

Gl today.
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 13:42
Also LAYED     On The Hoof in WIN market ....as possibly better on softer going...

This is probably a dodgy lay ...as Easterbys dominating race with 4 horses .....!!!
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 13:45
It appears to be RAINING at YORK ...so that increases chances of one layed !
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 13:54
Small profit over all due to lay ...but lost on PLACE bets.......
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 14:00
2.10 race.....As JUVENILE HURDLE race....it is another lottery !

Backing to WIN
    Guards Chapel
    Rainy Champion
    Melancholy Hill


LAYED
    George Woolf .....I suspect needs more rain....

Hard again to have STRONG view on race.......


BTW - The winner of last years race was the TRAINER of the horse I have layed ...soon see if my TOTAL GUESS is "right" or "WONG"!
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 14:04
2.25 PASS .......looks a low class race.........
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 14:10
Guards Chapel ...backed to PLACE in 2.10
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 14:16
GC was very very "poor" !...Lost only £2 on race due to LAY not winning....and backed £2 on winner IR ...but layed some off IR....
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 14:18
The one that won is trained by S WEST ...who seems to do very very well in them. It had a race under belt ...so fitness factor was enough to win this low class race...
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 14:19
2.35...PASS ...a SPRINT with many runners in IRELAND....RED ARMY BLUES I might do a SMALL EW on
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 14:28
2.45 Small field race ...so again a bit of lottery!

Backing     My Condor to win

and SMALL RFC on 3/5.....as MC either wins or is nowhere PROBABLY!
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 14:39
Picked wrong 3 yo in 2.35 ....Lowest weighted one that one last time out wins again....
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 14:49
3.00 a CLAIMER type race ...so again low class...but looks "trappy".


WINNER probably for 1st 2 in market     Demolition and Porgy so backed both to win.....only

Small EW on BEST PROSPECT
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 14:51
About £18 down on HORSES......SUNDAY racing not the most "exciting" type races........

Nothing really stood out ij any race FOR ME ...SO FAR!
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 14:52
ij = in
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 14:52
3.05 PASS
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 15:00
3.15

NOVICE HURDLE race...and some 4 yods in race from A PERRET....."interesting"......but hoping a HIGH ODDS one places

Have layed     American Ladie in WIN market...might regret it later...and backed 2 high odds ones to PLACE

    Merstone Lady
    In Close     .....the "better" of 2 probably!
By:
coolhand
When: 04 Sep 11 15:13
DRCIRONMAN
Im sure you are aware of MJ stats at York recently, is this why its an interesting one?

2011 - 46 runners 0 winners
2010 - 54 runners 3 winners
2009 - 54 runners 3 winners
2008 - 23 runners 3 winners
2007 - 33 runners 1 winner

Did you catch the interview on RacingUK with MJs son?
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 15:14
£14.64 down ...SO FAR before 3.15 race
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 15:17
No coolhand ....he is a class trainer ....and in such a race it was worth a shout at the odds.......even if I lost on race...re that bet....the hedge cover bet on LAY on Easterby horse did enough for a small profit on that race..

Thanks FW ...on a dull day racing ...my comments are in line with racingDevilLaugh
By:
LordBobbbin
When: 04 Sep 11 15:18
Yes, interesting stuff DFC. It's nice to see someone going through each one on a race by race basis. As you say, most of these are very hard to get excited about, so it's a very good day on which to be selective.

Quite why some of the good racing from yesterday couldn't be held today instead, I don't know. Who on earth had the opportunity to get stuck into the majority of those races yesterday??  Or am I missing the point there...
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 15:27
3.30

GB / York 4th Sep / 15:30 6f Hcap     Internationaldebut     Back         04-Sep-11
15:24           18     2.00         18.5     04-Sep-11 15:24    
    GB / York 4th Sep / 15:30 To Be Placed     Whozthecat     Back         04-Sep-11
15:24           4.4     2.00         4.8     04-Sep-11 15:24    
    GB / York 4th Sep / 15:30 To Be Placed     Internationaldebut     Back          04-Sep-11
15:24           4     3.00         4.1     04-Sep-11 15:24    
    GB / York 4th Sep / 15:30 To Be Placed     Mass Rally     Back          04-Sep-11
15:23           14.5     3.00         15     04-Sep-11 15:23    
    GB / York 4th Sep / 15:30 To Be Placed     Parisian Pyramid     Back          04-Sep-11
15:23           2.04     24.00    
    2.08     04-Sep-11 15:23    
    GB / York 4th Sep / 15:30 6f Hcap     Midnight Martini     Back         04-Sep-11
15:23           19     2.00         19     04-Sep-11 15:23    
    GB / York 4th Sep / 15:30 6f Hcap     Parisian Pyramid     Back         04-Sep-11
15:22           5.9     6.00
        6.4     04-Sep-11 15:22    
    GB / York 4th Sep / 15:30 6f Hcap     Whozthecat     Back          04-Sep-11
15:22           19.5     2.00         19.54     04-Sep-11 15:22    
    GB / York 4th Sep / 15:30 6f Hcap     Mass Rally     Back     04-Sep-11
15:22           95     2.00         100     04-Sep-11 15:22    


FAVOURITE PARISIEN PYRAMID appear to have a STRONG chance of winning today ....but competitive race.....so backed some other too!
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 15:29
LB ....was watching SCOTLAND match ...where they raise hopes of fans ...then dash them .......REF helped a lot too ! so did not back much yesterday . NAP in comp BAUER won ...so gave a profit on day thoughCool
By:
DFCIRONMAN
When: 04 Sep 11 15:31
3.35 PASS
Page 3 of 31  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | ... | 31 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com