Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
Schalke 04
04 Aug 11 18:55
Joined:
Date Joined: 10 Apr 05
| Topic/replies: 23,230 | Blogger: Schalke 04's blog
Catfleppo / takethestand / Schalke 04

Details to follow

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 1 of 5  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 174
By:
catfleppo
When: 04 Aug 11 19:17
Ok, this week I have my bot playing the bridgestone invitational golf tournament that started at 12.30 today.  It is running with a maximum exposure of £100 (currently £80.81) .

I will match many bets over the course of the weekend but never exceed the £100 agreed in the challenge. I will post my result here on monday and a full copy of my bets will be available to Mr Baboon should he wish to verify that I haven't cheated.

Neither the program or the program's writer (me) have the first idea about golf so it is a perfect illustration of how value, and value alone, wins.
By:
parrys
When: 04 Aug 11 19:24
I understand and agree with the value concept but how can you know something is value without knowing anything about the sport ?
By:
catfleppo
When: 04 Aug 11 19:32
Actually, I've changed my mind about publishing the bets.  Instead I will publish a list of all the runners with the average odds and stake for each one - verified by betfair.

parrys, getting value is the hard part however you do it.
By:
MrBaboon
When: 04 Aug 11 19:48
catfleppo ...we'll take your word
By:
Schalke 04
When: 04 Aug 11 20:19
Put your bets up on this thread before they take place, otherwise it's a pretty pointless thread for people to follow. 6 months you have, you can do all your bets in january if you wish, just post them up here, once your £100 is gone then thats you out of it, but of course none of us wil llose it all will we ...
By:
catfleppo
When: 04 Aug 11 20:25
I've already explained that I can't do that, I don't control what bets get taken so I don't know in advance.  I will, however, prove I haven't cheated.
By:
Schalke 04
When: 04 Aug 11 20:29
RULES

1. £100 per player
2. As many bet a day as you like
3. What bookmaker or exchange it's price is at
4. Bets to be put up in fractions
5. Bets to be put up at least 5 mins before bet starts
6. NO in-play markets
7. Stake and winnings of bet must be written up
8. Player with most money end of 4th Febuary is the winner
By:
Schalke 04
When: 04 Aug 11 20:30
Catfleppo ... forget your programme, this is a betting challenge, YOU have to find the value bets, not your programme, otherwise it's an unfair challenge. Looks like it's just me and takethestand that are in the competition
By:
catfleppo
When: 04 Aug 11 20:36
Mr Baboon is the mediator Schalke, not you.  I would have thought a brainless program that can only seek value because it has no knowledge of the sport is exactly the opponent you need to prove your point?
By:
MrBaboon
When: 04 Aug 11 20:41
Schalke you prepared to take on cat's bot?
By:
Schalke 04
When: 04 Aug 11 20:45
Nope ... but he won't be able to post up his bets will he, so then his bets won't count. Bets MUST be placed prior to the event starting to eliminate the threat of after-timing.

Prove a point catfleppo ... theere is no point to be proven here, it's to see who can win the most money using £100 in 6 months, and you seem so confident that getting value alone will put you miles ahead, well, here is your chance to beat me and takethestand ... I have to say your lack of confidence is quite clearly showing which is a surprise after all you have spouted
By:
Schalke 04
When: 04 Aug 11 20:47
Mr Baboon can be the mediator, fine with me, but those rules are the rules that have to be used for a challenge like this ... he can just make sure they are kept to, but we are all betting individuals with respects as fellow betteros, I dount there will be any cheating.
By:
MrBaboon
When: 04 Aug 11 20:50
Do i get paid as a mediator?
By:
TheInvestor2
When: 04 Aug 11 20:50
If it's verified by Betfair, what does it matter if catfloppo is aftertiming?

If you're offering bets, you can never control what gets matched. Obviously taking prices offered (paying the spread) is a more difficult way to make money for the average winner.
By:
catfleppo
When: 04 Aug 11 20:52
I am totally confident that I can beat you with my value-only betting strategy but if you choose to impose your own techniques on me then I won't play.

I will prove I'm not cheating if that's your problem - posting bets up prior to the event it not the only way of doing this.

You have said many times that value on it's own doesn't win, so prove it - my bot can only win if it gets value, it has no other means.
By:
MrBaboon
When: 04 Aug 11 20:54
catfleppo do you only bet via the bot?
By:
catfleppo
When: 04 Aug 11 20:59
MrBaboon, win or lose I will donate £100 to a charity of your choice on the conclusion of the challenge.

I have the occasional punt on f1 for fun but my serious betting is all done with my bot.
By:
MrBaboon
When: 04 Aug 11 21:23
No need for charity donation this is all for fun.

Is your bot infallible ?
By:
catfleppo
When: 04 Aug 11 21:41
No, but it usually wins on golf tournaments
By:
Schalke 04
When: 04 Aug 11 22:26
This is just a wee £100 quid competition, getting bets verified by Betfair, jesus efin nora !! It's not that bloody serious, I really can't be bothered with this cr@p, catfleppo it's simple rules, 99% of the forum would accept the rules, it's fair, we all start the same, bet the same, but nooooo, you want to use your wee bot to hold your hand cause without it you can't pick good value bets to save yourself, otherwise this would be no problem to you. !! Again, look at takethestand, he stuck the whole lot on Hearts, his challenge could have been over in 90 mins, show a bit of bottle catfleppo FFS !!
By:
Schalke 04
When: 04 Aug 11 22:30
catfleppo

I am totally confident that I can beat you with my value-only betting strategy but if you choose to impose your own techniques on me then I won't play.

I will prove I'm not cheating if that's your problem - posting bets up prior to the event it not the only way of doing this.

You have said many times that value on it's own doesn't win, so prove it - my bot can only win if it gets value, it has no other means.


Posting bets up before play IS the only way of doing htis I'm afraid, otherwise it's pointless .... I have said value on it's own doesn't win, yeah, well according to you my 1 from 7 thread isn't getting value but it's winning so there you go, point proven already mate ! .... your bot this, your bot that, so what you are saying is that you aint got a clue about betting.
By:
catfleppo
When: 04 Aug 11 22:42
Lol, you have reminded me of girl I used to work with who used to describe people as 'getting in a right sweaty'. 

If I'm clueless why won't you take me on?
By:
Schalke 04
When: 04 Aug 11 22:46
You know what mate, I have lost interest .... and I'm sure TTS will lose interest too, you are doing everything you can to avoid the challenge as you would end up looking like a complete idiot, because I am 100% certain you aint got a clue where to start with £100 doing betting. Byzy bye
By:
catfleppo
When: 04 Aug 11 22:48
I'm not avoiding anything, in fact I have already started.  Maybe takethestand has more conviction.
By:
MrBaboon
When: 04 Aug 11 22:52
must be bedtime now
By:
Schalke 04
When: 04 Aug 11 23:01
Honestly pal, you are an annoying **** !! Youv already started, get a life mate !!
By:
TheInvestor2
When: 04 Aug 11 23:21
I think Schalke has realised he has lost before he has started. Very rude!
By:
catfleppo
When: 04 Aug 11 23:25
I already said I have allocated £100 to the bridgestone invitational golf tournament.  It's what I would do anyway so it's no big deal if you've got cold feet. Anyway, takethestand might still be up for it.
By:
TheInvestor2
When: 04 Aug 11 23:32
If the deal is to place only pre-off bets and only take prices rather than offer, restricting yourself to Betfair would not be optimal.

If you accept bets with any bookie, I'll join in the challenge.
By:
catfleppo
When: 04 Aug 11 23:37
If that's the deal I'm out, 99% of my value comes from making offers.
By:
TheInvestor2
When: 04 Aug 11 23:42
I'm pretty certain that most winners here offer more than take me included, although not to that extreme ratio.

Schalke's idea of the challenge seems more geared to traditional punting rather than taking full advantage of the opportunities for profit on here.
By:
catfleppo
When: 04 Aug 11 23:51
Well, i thought the challenge was his (outcome predicting) betting vs my (value) betting but he seems to now only want to do it if I bet like he does. Maybe you're right and he realises he will lose.  Maybe he knows more about value than he's letting on [;)]
By:
Trevh
When: 05 Aug 11 02:32
Nah, Schalke is well and truly a predicting the outcome punter, and to be fair some of his selections are good, but I would be very very surprised if that even enabled him to defeat commission long term (years) yet alone make a wage. The main thing that lets him down is the suicidal staking theories of course.

I can't join in the challenge because there is no way I could post bets pre off. I don't use any bots, but like Catfleppo I don't know what I'll be matched on pre off or for how much from one hour to the next, and I don't want all my activities posted for all to see either!

Fwiw I think your offer Cat is very generous and would be a good demonstration of outcome predicting versus value betting.
By:
TheInvestor2
When: 05 Aug 11 03:25
Yeah, just make this a freestyle competition where everyone does what they like!
By:
takethestand
When: 05 Aug 11 08:36
Takethestand +£57.95
Catflappo ZERO
SCHALKE 04 ZERO

CoolLaughSilly
By:
catfleppo
When: 05 Aug 11 08:43
He he, congratulations tts.  How was the curry?
By:
takethestand
When: 05 Aug 11 08:53
Last night I was not particularly happy to be taking on a bot, it didnt seem to be what this was all about.  I understand Schalke's stance.

However, win or lose, I would like to demonstrate that the ability to pick consistent winners, worrying about price as secondary importance, is a valid method that can, over time, return big profits.

Last nights game offered both methods, i would have considered backing Hearts at 1.4 last night as last week it was clear they were far superior, not just slightly, considerably.  The price was CRAZY so I took a chance and staked accordingly.

I'm curious about catflappo's bot.  What sort of return (%) do you expect from a golf tournament?  I dont want to be wasting my time if its clear I cant keep up.  I think alot about the human aspects of betfair and dont want the chase to keep up cloud my judgements.

boy i'm rough this morning[:x]
By:
takethestand
When: 05 Aug 11 08:55
curry .....and cobra were just grand.  Not seen the mrs drink that much in a good while [;)]
By:
takethestand
When: 05 Aug 11 09:00
I will ONLY be using betfair.  I closed all my other accounts except Purple as I was out of UK for a long time.  Gambling took over my life for a period and having all those accounts didnt help either.  Emmigrating soon and also dont want 10+ bookies showing up in bank statements.
Page 1 of 5  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com