Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 81 comments are related to the topic:
Football bets with Kelly staking

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 3  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 81
By:
Homer Jay Simspon
When: 13 Jan 11 09:42
Morning all.

Last night's profit came to £3,699.36 and the bank climbs to £7,322.72 taking into account my commission rate. There's no decent league football today so it's a day off. I was thinking about Saturday/Sunday while walking the dogs this morning and there is no way I will be able to run every game through the model and keep up with all the bets while doing the day job so I will have to be ultra-selective and work around the racing.

Thanks very much for all the advice/comments which I'll read again and reply to shortly.
By:
Homer Jay Simspon
When: 13 Jan 11 10:20
Tobermory - I've simply been taking the bank for the day and using a Kelly calculator to work out the stakes based on that bank for all bets. The recommended % of the bank to stake varies depending on the perceived edge and so it wouldn't make sense to enter a reduced bank for bet 2 of 4 as you suggest, as bet 2 would then be under-weighted.

Iquit - you make some interesting points. I should maybe point out that in my day job I use level stakes for all bets based on a % of my overall bank precisely as you suggest. Some decisions I make are very late, based on market movements, and I couldn't even contemplate trying to use Kelly staking when things are moving so quickly. However, I have read some extremely good papers relating to Kelly staking and I can see the merits in markets with 2 or 3 outcomes. I'm not quite sure why people seem to get so emotional about what seems to me to be a very logical and mathematically sound concept - bet more when your edge is greater. I don't see that as being an excuse to gamble, providing that your stakes are in line with your overall bank.

That leads me to another point. It seems fairly evident based on the views of the seasoned gamblers that if your model churns out anything above 10% edge, then it has to be the model that's flawed. Assuming that's the case, then Kelly staking will be in much better proportion to the bank than I've experienced so far by default. If I've stumbled across an edge greater than 10% then the logical move is to apply fractional Kelly staking to ensure stakes are in much better proportion to the bank (1/4 or even 1/8), but either way ditching the concept altogether doesn't have to be the only way forward.

Trevh - If you'd like this week's lottery numbers just let me know! Seriously I have warned people about 'following' these bets as I share your belief that something must be flawed. Although after last week's results which I didn't share here and this week's performance to date I must admit I am finding it harder to be cynical about what I'm seeing. No doubt the lucky run will come to a crashing end soon.

Kenilworth - come on that wouldn't be much fun, would it? I thought you'd enjoy seeing the inevitable happen!! Besides which I won't get very far with £4k.
By:
kenilworth
When: 13 Jan 11 13:35
Homer, I would get no pleasure from seeing it go t!ts up, I
assure you, that's why I'm saying take the money and run.
By:
kenilworth
When: 13 Jan 11 14:20
management, looks your telling the OP to ignore those who who disagree
with him, except for your good self !
By:
Avocado
When: 13 Jan 11 14:35
Betting at odds of 3 to 1 is relying on luck to win. Try betting at 1 to 3 instead.

Happy
By:
Avocado
When: 13 Jan 11 14:48
He will do all his money if he carries on with those random bets.
By:
top2rated
When: 13 Jan 11 14:51
Homer Jay Simspon

Your 'voyage of discovery' makes for interesting reading.

However, I do have a question for you given kenilworth's advice to "take the money and run".

Are you actually placing these bets? 

I'm confused because you appear to have added the profit from Tuesday's 'paper bets' to the bank and then calculated the stakes for yesterday's bets from that point.  Adding paper profits to the bank would suggest, imho, that this thread is purely a 'suck it and see' exercise.

Perhaps you would be kind enough to clarify?

Thanks.
By:
Avocado
When: 13 Jan 11 14:53
this thread is purely a 'suck it and see' exercise.

Sounds gay
By:
kenilworth
When: 13 Jan 11 15:09
Homer - don't let the bu99ers get you down. I believe it is perfectly possible to have a model that will (if not regularly), at least occasionally churn out price discrepancies of 10%+, so stick with it.

However I am a touch worried at the variance in your overs/unders modelling (compared to mine).


Management, did you not post the above ?
By:
jonnyg
When: 13 Jan 11 16:26
the management re Celtic game did you not take into consideration lack of celtic goals in the first half this season.

Under 2.5 celtic game seemed a spot on trade.

celtic away

0-0ht
0-0 ht
1-1 ht
1-1 ht
2-0 ht
0-1 ht
0-0 ht
0-0 ht

a cracking bet unders .Plain
By:
kenilworth
When: 13 Jan 11 17:13
management, who do you work for ? Some people have made various
comments, but instead of dealing with them individually, you
lump them together as ''buggirs''! Perhaps you were in a hurry
to get to your own constructive observations. We all do things
differently.
By:
kenilworth
When: 13 Jan 11 17:42
You started it by collectively critising, so perhaps you
should stick to football only.
By:
kenilworth
When: 13 Jan 11 17:58
''Unders'' in the Juventus match at 2.18 or better is a good price IMO.
By:
jonnyg
When: 13 Jan 11 18:17
unders has drifted because there is an expectation of 2.96 goals according to my shot on target calculations.Mischief Some big trader must be looking at my thread.Laugh
By:
jonnyg
When: 13 Jan 11 18:19
Also there is an expectation of one or more goals in the first half.[;)]
By:
jonnyg
When: 13 Jan 11 18:21
In the almeria game the expectation is 2.3 goals. how does a chap score 0.3 of a goal.Mischief
By:
jonnyg
When: 13 Jan 11 18:28
I have also got depoMischiefrtivo as more likely to score.

Sot had Blackpool more likely to score as well. Does not mean dep will win but again i would not be backing Almeria at 2.04.Plain
By:
jonnyg
When: 13 Jan 11 18:29
just shows you dont need a phd in maths to understand goal expectation.

what do you have for real game?

you first

haha
By:
jonnyg
When: 13 Jan 11 18:30
ok real game is 3.5925Plain
By:
jonnyg
When: 13 Jan 11 18:32
no wonder 3.5 overs/unders is evens the pair.Laugh
By:
jonnyg
When: 13 Jan 11 18:34
3.55

that is not exact enough

haha
By:
jonnyg
When: 13 Jan 11 18:49
i forgot to ask management

what did you think of drift on overs in blackpool game?

everything pointed to overs.

liverpool score more when gerrard does not play this season.

i had 2.585 goals for that game.
By:
jonnyg
When: 13 Jan 11 18:51
is it pure price manipulation like the hercules game which was screaming goals.Laugh
By:
kenilworth
When: 13 Jan 11 21:13
At the risk of sounding patroning, I thought
your rating on the Deportivo and Juventus
realistic.
By:
kenilworth
When: 13 Jan 11 21:34
I had Juventus at 2.0 and Almeria 1.72 (Unders that is)
By:
kenilworth
When: 13 Jan 11 21:58
management, thank you for drawing my attention
to Juventus and Almeria ''Unders''
By:
Homer Jay Simspon
When: 14 Jan 11 16:48
Bet 9 Greuther Furth £335.25 at 2.92
Bet 10 Alemannia Aachen £262.33 at 3.30

My ideal scenario in Germany 2 tonight would be to lay both home teams, but the balance of value sits with the away sides so that's the call. The draw prices look close to being accurate according to my model.

Whatever the results of these games I'll make this my last post on this little project here. I might start a blog or something where the contributions can be limited to sensible content. I should have known better after seeing this place fall into terminal decline, but it was worth a try!
By:
kenilworth
When: 14 Jan 11 16:56
Homer, what were you expecting ?
By:
jonnyg
When: 14 Jan 11 16:58
Aachen are just as likely to score but looks a draw on paper. same goes for furth. i see your resoning because both home teams are weak favs.
By:
Mums Irish Stew
When: 14 Jan 11 17:35
Homer, Sorry this will  be your last post on this thread as it has been great reading and refreshing to see new ideas just like Jonny G's thread SOT.
Some of us don't always make comments but please be reassured contributions such as this will always be welcome and respected by the silent masses. Good luck and will follow your blog with great interest if it goes ahead.
By:
Lusitano71
When: 14 Jan 11 19:33
unfortunate of you HJS to let the bad apples win, here you can block people or simply ignore them, the ignore one is pretty powerful
By:
kenilworth
When: 14 Jan 11 20:10
lusitano71, ''bad apples'' ? Who, what are you referring to ?
By:
top2rated
When: 14 Jan 11 22:03
I posted the following enquiry on 13 Jan 11 at 14:51. 

Homer Jay Simspon

Your 'voyage of discovery' makes for interesting reading.

However, I do have a question for you given kenilworth's advice to "take the money and run".

Are you actually placing these bets?

I'm confused because you appear to have added the profit from Tuesday's 'paper bets' to the bank and then calculated the stakes for yesterday's bets from that point.  Adding paper profits to the bank would suggest, imho, that this thread is purely a 'suck it and see' exercise.

Perhaps you would be kind enough to clarify?

Thanks.

Assuming he'd read it, a response from the OP would have been appreciated.
By:
Lusitano71
When: 14 Jan 11 22:23
i dont know kenilworth whoever or whatever HJS didnt like, i didnt say this regarding anyone because tbh i didnt even realised that anything was going on here, my point was, he should do his thing and dont let other people put him off, simples
By:
kenilworth
When: 15 Jan 11 00:29
Lusitano, In view of your response it was surely wrong to
use the expression ''bad apples'', unless you can be
specific, otherwise withdraw the comment. Perhaps you should to
see what the OP has to be sensitive about, before giving him
advice as to how to deal with it.
By:
Avocado
When: 15 Jan 11 01:16
Seems the cry baby who started this thread no longer has the balls to carry on. Tell you what Homer, take your kelly staking method and shove it up your anus.
By:
Lusitano71
When: 15 Jan 11 03:04
yes Kenilworth "bad apples" are guys that are always posting on the threads with a negative/destructive approach and/or with a superiority complex, thats what i call "bad apples" (though i'm not saying its you and i dont care who it was, i was speaking in general terms) but you are far from being a very constructive person here, i've seen too often your type of responses to know that..and i withdraw nothing
By:
kenilworth
When: 15 Jan 11 08:26
Lusitano, I don't get excited like you and a couple of others do, when
someone puts up a couple of bets that happen to be successful. Even a broken
clock will be right twice a day, and your enthusiasm tells me more about
your knowledge of betting than the OP himself. If my cautious attitude is
seen by you as being negative, I plead guilty to that, and I will be still
betting on here when you have disappeared with your tail between your legs.
In future point out to me when I am less than constructive, rather than
generalising, and I will address your observation. I won't hold my breath.
By:
top2rated
When: 15 Jan 11 11:12
[url=http://www.bbcode.org/images/lubeck.jpg][/url]


Shocked
By:
Avocado
When: 15 Jan 11 11:28
How did u come up with the price of 1.81?
Page 2 of 3  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com