Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 83 comments are related to the topic:
BETFAIR set to be listed - get ya shares quick >>>>

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 3  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 83
By:
nairda
When: 22 Sep 10 10:44
im sure most of you haven't read the statement

Betfair currently has a diverse shareholder base including a group of 14 major investors holding approximately 75 per cent. of the Company’s fully diluted share capital. Based on indications received to date, Betfair expects the Offer to comprise the sale by over half of the group of major shareholders, board members and management team of Shares representing at least 10 per cent. of Betfair’s fully diluted share capital as at Admission. In addition to the group of major shareholders, Betfair has approximately 600 other shareholders, and approximately 25 per cent. of the Company’s fully diluted share capital is held by shareholders who have holdings of less than 1 per cent. each. These shareholders will also be given the opportunity to sell Shares in the Offer. No indications have yet been received from these shareholders with regard to their intention or otherwise to sell Shares in the Offer. Betfair does not intend to issue new Shares as part of the Offer. The final Offer size will be confirmed prior to Admission  (so that means min of 10%, as all shareholder haven't been ask yet)

Edward Wray and Andrew Black have each indicated that they intend to sell approximately 10 per cent. of their holdings in the Company in the Offer including over-allotment Shares.

As at 30 April 2010, Betfair had £150.9 million of cash and no debt  (10% of betfair value is siting there as cash)

as at 30 April 2010, Betfair held £284 million of customer deposits. (so £95 from each 3 million registered customers)
By:
betting_quant
When: 22 Sep 10 10:47
£150.9 mill + £284 mill= £434.9 mill @ 3% = £13 mill in interest a year
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 22 Sep 10 10:54
current assets less current liabilities is 59k ... they do owe the tax man and suppliers a big wedge of that 150k cash
By:
3132
When: 22 Sep 10 11:00
Mully would the small guys not be able to buy shares once they start trading ?
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 22 Sep 10 11:14
Interesting that implied commission (which is assumed to be average comm.) is 3%.

It requires annual commission of £11.5k to reach and maintain 3% yet the average comm. per active customer is £314 which would leave your average active customer on 5% commission.  A huge proportion of Betfair's income must come from a few 2% players.  At least half and probably more.  Assuming half if they raised the min. comm. level to 2.5% they'd increase revenues by £30 million alone on like for like business.

That they haven't is probably that they think they are in a more competitive market place than we think and/or that the margins for the sports exchange to function efficiently requires such a low percentage.
By:
zipper
When: 22 Sep 10 11:15
Roll  it  backs  lads  to  Nairda  commemt   11.09   thats  spot  on  .
By:
zipper
When: 22 Sep 10 11:20
Make  that  11.09  Yesterday
By:
askari1
When: 22 Sep 10 15:45
dustybin, you have a bm trying to do that w/ Betchronicle and ****. It's harder to do than it looks i.e to sit on winners' price and reap the benefits of their strategies. The strategies only work at certain volumes.

It may be that exchanges need winning liquidity providers for purposes other than e.g. smoothing the returns they wd make if they were betting the positions themselves.
By:
askari1
When: 22 Sep 10 16:39
Clydebank, how many players/entities do you think are on 2%? Suppliers may be in a business where they can determine pricing terms.
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 22 Sep 10 17:32
askari I actually used 29,000 betfair points as the threshold which is actually the 3.5% rate not the 3% rate of 49,000 so you'd need to be contributing £19.5k a year to reach average commission which is a staggering 62 times the average contribution. 

It's a minimum 60k worth of commission needed to reach 2% which is 191 times the average and the biggest players will pay significantly more than that.  There were 713,000 active customers most of which will pay a lot less in commission than the average of £314.  For every 1 person on 2% I reckon there is around 5000 on 5% comm and then maybe another 200 people on over 2% and under 5% so I'd plump for a figure of around 100-150
By:
askari1
When: 22 Sep 10 18:12
Thank you, Clydebank; I can see the reason behind these estimates. It's more than I wd have expected, but I only really play the horses.
By:
The Investor
When: 22 Sep 10 22:19
The mean and median Betfair points per customer are miles apart.
By:
Sandown
When: 23 Sep 10 11:04
Does anyone else think it strange to go public when earnings (EBITDA) have dropped by a third in the last year?

On profits of £45m and a valuation of £1.5 billion that means a p/e of 33.3 but against actual profit of £15m a p/e of 100. Seems OTT to me.
By:
Borrowed Time
When: 23 Sep 10 12:02
Is there a break-down anywhere, of the casino/exchange games revenue/profits ?

Someone told me, the casino was making over £40m this yr .. and they market make the exchange games, so, u would think a decent profit is made from that.

Would love to see abreakdown, for each part of the business.
By:
dustybin
When: 23 Sep 10 13:08
Sandown

Thats technology firms for you, they are massively inflated due to risk. They tend to do really well short term or land on their 4rse. I think bf's valuation is more based on the technology it owns rather than the profit it actually makes, which for me is quite scary as it signifies that they might be putting that up for sale rather than the way they are doing things at present, meaning bookies buying it to alter it imo.
By:
Sandown
When: 23 Sep 10 13:13
they are massively inflated due to risk.

Risk? Or greed or "Emperor's new clothes" syndrome or "lemingitis syndrome"
By:
nairda
When: 23 Sep 10 13:44
the listing is just a way for small sharesholders to get out, it not because big owners want to sell out or to raise cash

what i believe buyer (or not) need to belive in as Dustybin said is Betfair a Tech company or a bookmaker/gambling company...Betfair spends alot of it money on (what betfair says) is new technology each year (Im sure betfair new LMAX company is costing alot in start up cost) if you believe betfair is a great britsh technology company, then 1.50 bi value is very samll for a Tech company that had 10 year of profit and has no debt with 150m sitting there in cash..
By:
dustybin
When: 23 Sep 10 13:51
the listing is just a way for small sharesholders to get out, it not because big owners want to sell out or to raise cash

I actually beg to differ on this point. The lifecycle of the exchange could be far shorter than many believe and the continued storm that never goes away even after being 'defeated' (on tax/business users etc) will only need to strike once and its dead.

Time will tell.
By:
dustybin
When: 23 Sep 10 14:07
IMO

The 25% of the shares that are owned by the individuals would be mad not to sell. They are very unlikely to make the same gains within the next 10 yrs by holding them. Softbank arguably believe 1.5bn is overvalued now and may/maynot chose to sell some/all, whatever they decide this will be in addition to to 10% minimum made available by Wray/Black. All this is then offered to who first? The business sector which in all likelyhood will be bookies buying up to get the majority share.

This could on my understanding of affairs mean that there could potentially be a new controlling owner within a very short time span.
By:
askari1
When: 23 Sep 10 15:29
Sandown, it also appears that they made a significant portion of their profits by standing client bets.

I'm sure that the markets will strip out one-off investments and look at year-on-year profit growth, but what does this admission say about the sustainability of the exchange model?

During the first quarter of the year, Betfair ran a trial service with a small number of ‘‘High Roller’’ customers. The size and scale of the betting patterns of these customers is too large to be fully hedged through the Betting Exchange and so Betfair has necessarily accepted proprietary risk on these bets.

The trial with High Roller customers proved to be profitable. Revenue from the High Roller segment during the first quarter was approximately £25 million and EBITDA was approximately £7 million.


Maybe it is not that profitable to run a betting exchange. The value of the firm may lie in intangibles like employee skills and in technology.
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 23 Sep 10 15:53
Does anyone else think it strange to go public when earnings (EBITDA) have dropped by a third in the last year?

On profits of £45m and a valuation of £1.5 billion that means a p/e of 33.3 but against actual profit of £15m a p/e of 100. Seems OTT to me.
.........

If you had fully read the report and financial statements you wouldnt have written that.
By:
Sandown
When: 23 Sep 10 15:56
clydebank

Fair enough. What have I missed?
By:
askari1
When: 23 Sep 10 16:00
They made an investment in football, which, taken out, wd have allowed them to show continuing profit growth.

Imv they have tweaked their figs. before flotation (not actually misstated them, of course, but done a lot to make them look good). It cd even be argued that standing high-roller bets was designed to pimp their numbers.
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 23 Sep 10 16:17
sports revenue (ie the exchange element) grew by 12 per cent. to £223.7 million (FY09: £199.2 million)

During a year in which many other businesses have focused on cost cutting, Betfair chose to make
significant investments in FY10 in order to secure future growth, including:
– the start of £25 million technology investment programme over three years (‘‘the re-architecture
programme’’) to deliver a more cost-efficient, robust and flexible exchange platform to support
future international growth and maintain Betfair’s leadership in exchange-based betting;
– a marketing campaign to enhance Betfair’s positioning in football ahead of the 2010 FIFA World
Cup;
– further investment in LMAX ahead of the launch of its new exchange platform in the final calendar
quarter of 2010; and
– investment in Betfair US to position Betfair Group favourably in the event of any liberalisation of
the US online betting and gaming market.

1st qtr this year..
Current trading and outlook
In the first three months of the year ending 30 April 2011, Core Betfair revenue has grown strongly,
including a beneficial impact from the 2010 FIFA World Cup.
 Sports revenue increased by 24 per cent. to £63.5 million compared with the first three months of FY10,
underpinned by the 2010 FIFA World Cup which helped drive a 47 per cent. rise in the number of sports
active customers(3)
Revenue from the High Roller segment during the first quarter was approximately £25 million and
EBITDA(2) was approximately £7 million. The results will be reported as a separate segment in FY11 and
have been excluded from the Core Betfair revenue for the quarter stated above.
By:
Sandown
When: 23 Sep 10 16:19
Thanks askar1. Still say that its odd because normally one would want to inflate the earnings as much as possible suggesting that the timing isa awry somewhat. And, personally, I like to take the profits as they stand - the investment made in football or techonolgy whatever is built into the high PE in the first place.

What I find interesting from the high roller quote is this

The size and scale of the betting patterns of these customers is too large to be fully hedged through the Betting Exchange and so Betfair has necessarily accepted proprietary risk on these bets.

This tells me that the high roller players from the Far East that the BM's like VC have cultivated will not migrate to BF. Their market is confined to smaller players.
By:
The Calculator
When: 23 Sep 10 16:20
I agree with you askari1. Betfair should have forced FIFA to bring the World Cup forward to April so that the marketing spend occurred in the same financial year as the increased revenues. Anything else just smacks of cynical financial manipulation.
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 23 Sep 10 16:22
expenses for last year....

 Commercial and marketing: commercial and marketing expenses increased by 23.5 per cent. to
£87.3 million, representing 28.5 per cent. of Core Betfair revenue (FY09: 24.3 per cent.). The increased
expenditure grew in line with revenue plus an additional planned increase in brand spend to enhance
Betfair’s positioning in football ahead of the 2010 FIFA World Cup during the latter part of FY10. The
Directors do not expect this level of brand spend to continue in FY11 and anticipate that marketing and
commercial spend as a percentage of Core Betfair revenue will revert to levels going forward similar to
FY09.
 Technology and product: technology and product expenses increased by 22.8 per cent. to £55.2 million,
representing 18.0 per cent. of Core Betfair revenue (FY09: 15.4 per cent.). This reflected the start of
Betfair’s re-architecture project during FY10, which is expected to be completed during FY12 and which
is expected to result in Core Betfair spend on technology and product as a percentage of Core Betfair
revenue peaking in FY11.
 Operations: operations expenses remained unchanged at £17.4 million, representing 5.7 per cent. of
Core Betfair revenue (FY09: 6.0 per cent.), continuing a longer term downward trend as Betfair benefits
from economies of scale in this area.
 Corporate: corporate expenses increased by 1.9 per cent. to £36.5 million, representing 11.9 per cent. of
Core Betfair revenue (FY09: 12.3 per cent.). The Directors expect that there will be an increase in
corporate costs going forward as a result of the incremental expenses associated with being a listed
company.
By:
askari1
When: 23 Sep 10 16:43
Sandown, the question arises why they didn't feed through these high-roller bets to the exchange. Either:

1) the high-rollers wanted a market-leading price, wh/ the exchange and its commission model couldn't support on Asian hcaps and maybe other markets for the sizes the gamblers were playing in. Bf took a gamble in taking on some proprietary risk. This wdn't bode well for its long-term growth;

2) Bf made a calculated decision to stand the bets thinking they were getting value. This wd mightily displease bf's regular winners. The company is letting them fight it out, shrewdie to shrewdie, on the exchange while it stands the bets of the biggest losers. This maximizes profits for bf.

If it's the second, it exposes bf to a lot more risk and volatility of returns, and also threatens the marketing strategy e.g. in the US and Asia of introducing person-to-person betting.
By:
askari1
When: 23 Sep 10 16:46
The Calculator, business prior to flotation like to show a smooth upward trajectory of profit growth.

First, we had bf's recalibration of commission, then the cross-matching skimmer, then the pc, and now standing high-rollers (though it turns out that this took place in the first quarter of a new year).

It does look to me as if they're introducing successive new measures to show rising profitability, when in at least the core market of horse racing their profits are not obviously rising at an earlier pace.
By:
Borrowed Time
When: 23 Sep 10 16:49
It will be interesting to see what valuation the company puts on Goodwill.

The prospectus details, say Betfair has a loyal and stable customer base.

Maybe only a minoroty feel, some of Bf's customer relations, are awry.

I think, its a far bigger problem, and one which will drag on the company, now, and in the future  -   as future profits, are gonna hurt the user base (if they come from increased comm/PC)
By:
dlarssonf
When: 23 Sep 10 17:06
excuse my igonarance here, but this standing high roller's bets issue, are you then just a bookie rather than an exchange or am I missing the point?
By:
Sandown
When: 23 Sep 10 18:04
clydebank

All that telsl me is that spending on marketing went up by £17m and technolgy costs by £10m hence the profits hit. But, there would have been an increase year on year in both areas anyway. And its not unusual to spend in advance of some future event. Any evidence that the return will exceed the extra costs? Still left with a very high P/E ratio.
By:
Sandown
When: 23 Sep 10 18:05
BF has zilch experience in being a bookmaker - they got away with it but it probably scared the living daylight out of them.
By:
askari1
When: 23 Sep 10 18:19
Yes, I wonder why they did it at all. Did they need to show revenue and profit growth before the float?

Were they allowing some customer offers up on the exchange to go unmatched and giving these high-rollers a worse price? They shd come clean on this b/c some very unfavourable constructions could be put on their own standing of client bets.
By:
betting_quant
When: 23 Sep 10 18:22
Borrowed time, where did you get a prospectus from ?
By:
Borrowed Time
When: 23 Sep 10 20:22
Sorry, wasnt the prospectus .. was the intention to list details, on the corporate site.
By:
nairda
When: 24 Sep 10 18:59
Talking to someone about the flot..he said in the past, if a small shareholder in betfair wanted to sell there shares,the shareholder had to contact all 600+ other shareholders first and give first rights offer to the other 600 holders..the cost with lawyers need to sell a small shareholding in betfair would be very high...

I really think, this has less to do with what owners think betfair will or will not do over the next 5 years, and more to the fact betfair already has so many owners, the best way for those owners who do need to sell (we all hit in a down turn market)is to be on LSE
By:
The Betfairy
When: 24 Sep 10 19:17
I believe that is exactly it.
By:
dustybin
When: 25 Sep 10 09:14
What happens tho by opening the door and offering 10% of their combined 50% of the holdings, bert and ed find that all the rest want to sell?

That would be 60% wouldnt it?
Is there some safeguard that would stop 1 company taking the lot? (obv. that would give them outright control)

The above is extremely unlikely granted but Im just wondering how things generally work in these scenarios.
By:
cush
When: 25 Sep 10 23:45
Everyone on here can argue about  all the carp that surrounds this sort of process and delve into the minutiae of it as much as they want. That is just a distraction.

The facts are that Betfair was promoted as  being  a Jewel, hence it‘s name. It was supposed to have a relative perfection or purity about it, which raised it up in relation to  the companies that had preceded it e.g. the bookmaking companies.

The IPO has been , quite obviously,  inevitable for a long time now. Sadly, it is yet another chance missed. Missed by people who have either convinced themselves or have been convinced by other people, that the money they believe that they have acquired, affords them some sort of a real superiority. That really is a shame. This really could have been so much better.

The real facts of the matter are , despite all the promotion and investment that has gone into it,  that without the sort of customer’s who made it desirable in the first place, Betfair is absolutely worthless.

Betfair are not selling their business they are selling their customers. Considering that they are only were they think they are today because of their customer’s, that really is a shameful.
Page 2 of 3  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com