Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 451 comments are related to the topic:
Slicer's World Cup Thread-Final ever thread and postings

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 11 of 12  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 451
By:
tier
When: 15 Jul 10 12:44
whelk could You explain it a little more I cant understand what hedge bets are You talking about? and how much are You thinking for this spreadsheet?
By:
whelk
When: 15 Jul 10 14:32
OK, let's pretend there is a holy grail. I'm sure that everyone else has done these calculations.

You lay HT 0:0, £35.71 at 2.8, but that loses you 64.28 if there's no goal.
You bet Correct Score 0:0 as a hedge £32 at 9.4, so you actually make £1.94 after commission if there's a first half goal.
At half time and no goal you lay Correct Score 0:0, £65.39 at 4.6 making you £31.73 after commission. So 0:0 at half time loses you £32.55.

Any holy grail has to make a profit whatever the outcome, so it obviously isn't that one. Experiment with other 3 bet combinations.

So you have to think like a bookie. On course, I can get more money on the favourite by offering 13 to 8 when everyone else is offering 6 to 4, but this is a betting exchange so you can't offer odds unilaterally in the same way. But inplay markets are dynamic and you can use the movements that occur to emulate a book with the aim of creating an overround. This book has your original bet(s) as part of the book. If the first bet wins you are in profit and move on.

Things like red cards can go either way but are generally not fatal.

The spreadsheet is simply a way of quickly calculating the required odds to overround the book.

I think the real problem is that punters think about outcomes, who will win, will it be overs or unders.

This problem requires that you understand how each market moves.
By:
tier
When: 15 Jul 10 15:01
whelk was it You back in 2008 who discovered sth to do with one red market? Also as You notice now Slicer is saying that staking isnt so...he is more of suggesting that it is a bet building overround without trading/hedging bets. I think I would be interested in Your spreadsheet...so how much? :P
By:
whelk
When: 15 Jul 10 19:14
Just to illustrate.

Lets assume that bet one wins you £100 and you have a £100 hedge bet at 8. The price has now gone to 11 so you lay 72.73 at 11 and red out with a £27 loss on that market but a £70 win overall.
By:
jepfrog
When: 15 Jul 10 19:20
how could equate these hedge bets to correct score, how would you treat 0-0 arb at half time and then how do you place hedge bets on which scores
By:
whelk
When: 15 Jul 10 19:44
I've already said that I don't believe there is a reliable three bet combination.

My previous post was an exaggeration for illustration purposes. You would more likely red out to make a few pounds overall.

Laying HT 0:0 is an obvious candidate because if a goal is scored you win and if there's no goal you build your book.

There aren't any easy solutions, which is why you need an overround calculator on your spreadsheet and some stats on the way markets change over time.

I'm quite interested in the Maths. It's all about manipulating numbers.
By:
tier
When: 17 Jul 10 21:16
but if You have layed HT 0-0 and then backed FT 0-0 as hedge bet the same amount then You cant sell it out after a goal...so I dont understand what hedge bet that is what moves from 8 to 11. But anyway how can I get this spreadsheet of Yours?
By:
whelk
When: 17 Jul 10 22:38
Lay ht 0:0 and bet CS 0:0 doesn't work. I showed you why.

Redding out. Assume you have a bet on one market that wins making you £100. On another market you have a hedge bet, this time £100 at 5.4. When the goal is scored the odds go to 20 so you lay £27 at 20 so that you're now losing £73 on that market but you've made £100 on the first bet.

There are other things that have to be done if the first bet doesn't win.

1. I was just showing you the sort of the early examples everyone was playing with when this idea was first raised and why there's unlikely to be a three bet solution.
2. I don't encourage betting. My father left the family in poverty.
3. This problem requires a high level of maths. Linear, quadratic and some other equations I don't think have a name. These feed into an overround calculator. This feeds into a decision tree.
4. The spreadsheet would require a manual. It's not a 'type in a few numbers and win a fortune' effort but a piece of analysis.
5. You can make a small return but it requires some effort in play.

I shouldn't really have made the comment about the spreadsheet. I'm confident in it, but I wouldn't want others to risk their livelihoods.

I assume that there are others who like the puzzle element of this problem and are working on it themselves.
By:
cpfc4me
When: 18 Jul 10 03:30
If it was a genuine puzzle, it would indeed be fun trying to solve it, but there is no Holy Grail - possible a holey one. It's like trying to form a rectangle using three straight lines. Do people really believe that there is an inefficiency in the highly liquid football markets that no one else has yet discovered?
By:
tier
When: 18 Jul 10 07:01
why do You think no one else has discovered it? I think if there is HG then Slicer is not only one who knows it. It is a well kept secret I believe.

Whelk I see now but is the bet number 1 in Your system still lay HT 0-0 ?
By:
whelk
When: 18 Jul 10 10:10
There is almost certainly not a slicer style holy grail.

Whatever the relative efficiency of the markets, there are odds changes which allows for various kinds of investment behaviour. The lines aren't actually straight and you have to provide the fourth one yourself.

Is it 0:0 HT?

You're looking for an easy answer. If there was an easy answer then it would be easy to find.
By:
freddiewilliams
When: 18 Jul 10 11:43
thats it...i cant wait any longer for the great dr slicer to post on here......im going to my local cop shop to report him missing.
anyone know who he looks like?
By:
REM
When: 18 Jul 10 11:46
There are only so many possible combinations of bets to test. It is interesting to do these, as you realise how well various markets dovetail with each other. Look closer and you'll see how it all works like clockwork. The minutes tick away and the prices adjust.
By:
whelk
When: 18 Jul 10 12:03
That's why there is unlikely to be a slicer holy grail.

Every market is different so there is more than just combinations of bets.

If you start by saying, "the first bet is to lay HT 0:0," then you've fallen into a trap.
By:
cpfc4me
When: 18 Jul 10 20:24
tier: why do You think no one else has discovered it? I think if there is HG then Slicer is not only one who knows it. It is a well kept secret I believe.

There can be no Holy Grail because the prices available on an exchange are not fixed. A simple illustration is to imagine that you could lay the HT 0-0 at 2.0, and back the 0-0 FT at 20.0 - at half-time the bet is either in the bag, or if there is still no score, you lay the FT 0-0 at 4.0 to lock in a profit (silly prices, but they are to illustrate the point).

Such a Holy Grail would not be 'discovered' by just one person. Thousands of people are active in these markets, including some pretty smart people, and any such inefficiency would be obvious to many, and once it is observed, the prices will adjust so that the strategy is no longer profitable. AS REM above says, related markets move together very efficiently. They have to - any inefficiencies are immediately identified, the value is taken and the prices adjust.

Slicer's claims that there is a Holy Grail are clearly nonsense. The price required for bet three may simply not be available. This isn't a casino where the prices are fixed. And ask yourselves this: If Slicer really was a Fields Medal winner and had found a Holy Grail, would someone that brilliant then tease on a public forum of his discovery and give clues which can only result in his advantage vanishing? Slicer may love the attention and admittedly can be mildly entertaining, but there is no Holy Grail.
By:
whelk
When: 18 Jul 10 21:05
I agree that the simplistic answer is very unlikely.

I'm suggesting that there are some complex solutions, although they aren't very profitable for the amount of effort involved.
By:
ikim
When: 18 Jul 10 21:05
ITCANBEDONE, kmabet discovered ( regarding slicer's posts ) and also I know how can be done...for all of you who think can't be done just keep thinking that way...Slicer maybe is not the smartest guy in the world but he discovered a tiny line which i believe no one saw before...regards to kmabet ( Sliced ) and best wishes to Slicer...

p.s. Slicer, u are the most intelligent person i ever meet on all forums, stay in good health and take care ;)
By:
tier
When: 18 Jul 10 21:09
yep thats all true cpfc4me but I think we must consider one BUT also. And this is that there is very easy to make an overround book if You take 0-0 odds maybe 1-0 and 0-1 at KO and all others at HT. now that green what You get must be placed as a lay at KO to HT 0-0 and combined with ft 0-0 back. this might be possible....

And when doing it like this then none of this applies what You have said because it will not matter. Markets are formed before KO. So when You get some prices at KO then afterwards when there is no goal You can be pretty sure where the prices will be at HT because all of that what You said makes it sure they will be. Now that guarantees You that You get certain odds for bet 3. The thing is that certain odds must be taken before KO also (selection of game)

What You said about value. You are right at KO there is value and You can take it also if You know what it is (again selection of game) and by HT the value is lost but for You the price is now exactly where You expect it to be...

hope You understand what I mean.... I am not a true believer myself anymore cause I have tryed so many variations of it and it always seems that it almost works and You need so little more....But I still believe a little :P
By:
ikim
When: 18 Jul 10 21:13
One more think...maybe in a year or 3-4, when this bet will be discovered and add to public, YOU here, and all other members on these forums, ukbetting tips, pounter, lay the odds...and HERE too, u need to give a BIG credit and say to yourself that YOU were fouls all those years...coz, often there is a insulting on Slicer and his ego...he have HOLY GRAIL from the start, and his ego was normal, all the time...
By:
cpfc4me
When: 18 Jul 10 23:09
ikim; 18 Jul 10 21:05

"Slicer maybe is not the smartest guy in the world..."

"p.s. Slicer, u are the most intelligent person i ever meet on all forums"

Confusion reigns.

The bottom line is that it's impossible to 'discover' something that is based on variables. This is nothing like finding a proof for a mathematical theorem where everything remains constant. This is an exchange, and the prices required to make any system work are only available if someone is offering them, and if someone is offering prices that are value (to a backer), they will soon stop offering those prices.

Don't be too accepting of claims by people that they have 'discovered' a Holy Grail, whether they are "not the smartest guy in the world" or "are the most intelligent person"...

tier: the idea of a Holy Grail fails when you write "You can be pretty sure where the prices will be at HT" - "pretty sure" isn't a Holy Grail - it's a gamble.
By:
tier
When: 18 Jul 10 23:48
yep of course HG fails due to that and also due to the fact it is inplay betting. But I think it is (if it does exist) with very high precent winning ratio.

And this value thing is also tricky I would say. Because these odds might be value only to the one who knows things. As I have said earlier how do You define value? If sth is at X odds at KO and everyone thinks it is value. Now we come to 0-0 at HT and these odds have moved to its "true" price...Who says it is now true price? It can just as easily be the opposite that it didnt have value at KO but now has value....

But what is certain is that arbers keep the markets efficient right? So take all the pre KO markets and You can calculate prices at HT. I did so and it works quite nicely. FT 0-0 price at HT is very predictable and calculatable and since it is the opposite of everything other scorelines and all markets are related anyway due to arbers therefore are all the odds calculatable what they would be at HT IF IT IS 0-0 THEN. Now if there is a goal then it is different because then it depends which team scored first and at what minute and so on....but according to HG this does not matter anymore because bet1 wins.

As to ikim I dont believe that kmabet (Sliced!!!) found Slicers bet. He took his information from uk betting tips and confused the same redding out one market sentence with Slicer quotes. But actually it was said by whelk back in 2008 regarding to hes system which he briefly just talked here also. But of course I didnt get the chance to ask Slicer about red market because he disappeared before that. But if bet1 is lay 0-0 HT and bet 2 back 0-0 FT and bet 3 is placed at HT and thats it then I cant see any opportunity of redding sth out it is just impossible because you cant red HT lay due to the fact it loses by HT and You cant red out FT back also because by HT it has either all green or it has lost and is not in play anymore....
By:
ikim
When: 19 Jul 10 00:09
First of all, reply to cpfc4me:

--Smartest and intelligent imo is not the same, that's the reason why you are snuffing regarding HIS bet...

Reply to tier:

--You said "i can't see any opportunity"...again same as for cpfc4me...that's the reason why you are snuffing regarding HIS bet...
By:
ikim
When: 19 Jul 10 00:13
And tier, i often see u have doubt regarding HG...but man, u are on every forum on slicer's tread :)

p.s. don't stop believe it...tooks me 8 months x 10 hurs a day to find it what Dr. Slicer did...:)
By:
whelk
When: 19 Jul 10 00:31
Redding out is just a way of minimising your hedge bet(s) losses if the first bet(s) win.

The point about devising systems like this is that they have to be dynamic to account for the fact that markets can be stubborn or can change when the state of play changes. You will have observed that there are certain times during a game that the market may behave differently because people are consolidating, waiting for a set piece to unfold, etc.

You need an underlying mathematical model and you can only create this by observation. cpfc4me is correct in observing that the actuality will often differ from the model.

In play, your spreadsheet has to account for market changes.

I think too many people are looking for a single easy solution. Bet one, bet two as a hedge and bet three if bet one loses/wins is an attractive answer but you have been shown by me and others that it can't work in that simple way.

So you have to do the maths and, take it from me, they will be hard if you haven't a background in numbers.

The other thing is that you have to sit watching a match unfolding on a screen. You need something else to do if you're not to go mad.
By:
FunBob
When: 19 Jul 10 22:31
@ ikim

Hi Kmabet

gotcha (again)
By:
ikim
When: 20 Jul 10 01:51
@ FunBob...if go trough my lines here, u can see that English is not my native, so i'm not kmabet, if u want to say that...
After all, my last post here...
By:
chat
When: 20 Jul 10 17:30
The price for the FT 0-0 at HT is easily derived from the price for FT 0-0 and HT 0-0 at KO - its obvious that it is equal to the quotient of the former devided by latter.Nothing new.If,however, there is say a red card for a key defender or a goalkeeper got injured and replaced with a non-fit second goalkeeper during first half that would alter the price for sure.But how the price for 0-0 changes has nothing to do with the fact that there can not be a holly grail as Slicer describes it,nor as many of the wannabes would like.Ikim you spend 8 months of ur life to figure it outLaugh?
Man it takes no more than a week even for a non-math guy like me to figure it is bs.
The only way you can achieve a "holly grail" if one can call it that way is to constantly make maximum accurate (more accurate than bookies or the other punters on exchange)estimation of the probability for a event hence  max. accurate estimation of the prices and when there is a value to bet on it using appropriate mm(usualy Kelly criterion).In-play betting offers good possibilities for it.
But to hope to lock on a risk free profit using a mechanical system assuming there is a discrepancy between prices in a cross market basis is nothing more than a foolish dream.Anyone who doesn't understands this and did not make an effort to clear(it is quite  simple calculations), this to himself is far far away from reality.
By:
flatliner
When: 28 Jul 10 03:18
t
By:
whelk
When: 28 Jul 10 07:19
I think chat just read enough to assume that it has something to do with HT 0-0 and CS 0-0 which, as a stand alone solution, clearly can't work. What we have is an interesting mathematical problem with a number of solutions and the ability for continued refinement.
By:
chat
When: 28 Jul 10 18:49
I read more than enough on this - here and elsewhere,always find it amusing.
The matter of fact is that if one want to obtain an edge over the market he must take value prices.And if one can detect,estimate and take value prices he dont need a predetermined strategy whatsoever.He only needs to continue betting on value.
But value is:
1. Subjective and hard to determine
2. Almost non-existing at BF or existing for very limited time and in very limited percentage (its rare to find and explore more than 2,3% of value) at BF
So claims for 8%/12% EXTRACTED with a secret RISC-FREE method is nonsense.
And about your thoughts on making profit with more complex trading approach - it does not matter how sophisticated approach that is.
You NEED to get value bets in order to profit.And if you are so good in finding those bets you dont need to trade (cover) it(because you will take non-value bets doing it hence decreasing profits).
By:
whelk
When: 28 Jul 10 20:17
'Value' is nonsense word much beloved of mug punters and bookies.

I think we've already established that the method slicer described is not a likely answer.
By:
buzzer
When: 28 Jul 10 20:26
How can you say value is nonsense. Three people can bet the same selections and one can lose, one break even and one win due to the prices taken on those selections! If you're laying genuine even money shots at 5-4 you'll lose over time whereas if your backing evens shots at 5-4 you'll win.
Slicer was taking everyone for a ride with his holy grail and to be fair he got a hell of a lot of mileage out of it but to suggest it doesn't matter what price you get because 'a winner is a winner' is ridiculous.
By:
TameTheTiger
When: 28 Jul 10 20:47
Only 2 replies in 18 months ? You should post alot more "chat".
By:
whelk
When: 28 Jul 10 20:48
I've heard the 'value' word so often. I used to work for a bookie at White City and Wembley years ago and heard the punter's patter. I worked for Sam and Terry in their shops and the patter was the same. "OK, it lost, but I had 11 to 4."

If you have 'information'- and that's often a nonsense word too - then maybe price is not that critical, but there's not one in a thousand punters who have the ability to work out 'value', although you rarely meet one who admits they can't. Punters are clever when they win and victims when they lose.

Slicer's grail is a bit of fun but it posed a question that was worth investigating and revealed some interesting mathematical facts about the markets. What I can tell you for certain is that the simplistic answer based around 3 bets that everyone is looking for can't work ... although there's an interesting logic that has to be understood which points you to other answers.

I just enjoy playing with the numbers. I think people misunderstand what is needed. You have to be able to write a spreadsheet program (or work it out some other way).
By:
jepfrog
When: 28 Jul 10 20:50
Finding hard to see any risk free approach.
maybe value or percentages of wins better than losses.
Following system seems to present value in long run where heavy favorites are involved.
back AUQ/lay over 3.5 (treat as arb), put some on 3-1.
Scores such as 1-3,2-2,2-3 & 3-3 are unlikely percentages.
such a system produces approx 10% return.
can anyone prove why this would not work in long run
By:
The One That Got Away
When: 28 Jul 10 21:21
jepfrog Joined: 15 Jun 08
Replies: 20 28 Jul 10 20:50   


Finding hard to see any risk free approach.
maybe value or percentages of wins better than losses.
Following system seems to present value in long run where heavy favorites are involved.
back AUQ/lay over 3.5 (treat as arb), put some on 3-1.
Scores such as 1-3,2-2,2-3 & 3-3 are unlikely percentages.
such a system produces approx 10% return.
can anyone prove why this would not work in long run
 


Taking Liverpool game into consideration tomorrow:

Back Any UNQ (FT Market) £100 @ 5.5 (+£427.50) (-£100)
Lay Under 3.5 Goals £157.49 @ 3.4 (+£149.59) (-£377.98)

This first 'arb' would give you a profit of £49.52.

You would then need to cover all possible permutations (scorelines you have mentioned above), so,

1-3 17.5 £31.08
2-2 40 £13.60
2-3 48 £11.33
3-3 190 £2.86
3-1 190 £2.86
3-2 130 £4.18

Dutching all of the above possible scorelines with the potential profit that you may make (£49.52) will never match your potential losses as to break even you would need to dutch bet £65.91 minimum to break even……..
By:
The One That Got Away
When: 28 Jul 10 21:25
There may be more value available pre-ko as i assume the 3-2, 3-3 and 3-1 may rise in price but the markets are to efficient to guarantee any risk-free approaches.

Even ignoring the current prices available for the above scores still would not make you a profit....
By:
jepfrog
When: 28 Jul 10 21:31
You would then need to cover all possible permutations (scorelines you have mentioned above), so,

1-3 17.5 £31.08
2-2 40 £13.60
2-3 48 £11.33
3-3 190 £2.86
3-1 190 £2.86
3-2 130 £4.18

Dutching all of the above possible scorelines with the potential profit that you may make (£49.52) will never match your potential losses as to break even you would need to dutch bet £65.91 minimum to break even……..


I know,
but i would only cover 3-1 to big favourite,maybe 2-2.
its not risk free.
By:
The One That Got Away
When: 28 Jul 10 21:37
Oh sorry jepfrog, i mis-read it!.

It could gain you a nice steady profit but could also be risky if you hit a bad scoreline (3-1, 3-2 etc) which im sure may happen on a few occasions!
By:
jepfrog
When: 28 Jul 10 21:41
I cover 3-1, so 8-10% gain, 3-2 will happen 1 in 25 to fav. so should gain in long term
Page 11 of 12  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 7 | 8 | 9 | 10 | 11 | 12 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com