We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
I will still lose even if I get value on everything I bet if the teams/players I bet on don't win.
No you won't because one of two things will happen, as I've pointed out ad nauseum 1) You will win 2) The Earth will be struck by a PHA, the odds of which I also posted in this thread. |
|
By:
I just dont see the point having a go and argueing
It doesnt affect you I know nothing of Schalke 04 apart from what i've read here although I think we live within 40 miles |
|
By:
tipping away m8, could be better but looking at this thread could be a lot worse too
the sense you've talked here (and on a kelly thread somewhere) is making an old dog like meself re-think tactics, impressive stuff stay lucky m8 |
|
By:
Who's having a go. Many people would pay good money for the advice given here and I'm giving it freely.
He's going to lose all his money and I'm trying to explain why. If that's his enemies, I'd hate to see his friends. |
|
By:
Schalke : If I was to give you £37 and told you that it was £1 per spin on the same number for 37 spins are you saying you could guarantee a profit
Under those circumstances I could not guarantee a profit, and as the 'house' you could not guarantee one either - poor business, the more punters you have the more you will lose. But there's a BIG BUT, in that each time we play this game for a mere 37 spins, you are giving away your traditional house edge of 2.7% to the punter - namely me, for which I thank you very much. I shall be most happy to play another 37 spins when ever possible, in the knowledge that I cannot lose long term as I have a 2.7% edge over you. Perhaps to save us both time in reaching the inevitable conclusion of every 37 block of spins, we could instead simply flip a coin which will give the same results, since you have agreed to pay me out at true odds plus 2.7% . If you believe you can avoid your inevitable losses by only allowing one flip of the coin then halting the game, why would you agree to that one flip in the first place? It makes no sense. |
|
By:
Don't win too much from me please naal :( :)
I'll see you around your various haunts no doubt, good luck. |
|
By:
Lori, I will lose my money yes if the teams and players I back don't win, but if they win then I won't lose ... odds, prices, money will not affect the way they perform in the sports !!
You cannot sit there and say I will lose if the events I place bets on constantly win .... you just can't say that !! You are basically condeming my thread to calculations and completely ignoring the selections which you have absolutley no control over, you can try and work out my thread in a spreadsheet but you can't say how Andy Murray is going to perform tonight against Robin Soderling, can you ! That is my point, the point I have been trying to say for ages ! |
|
By:
He's saying that by analyzing your betting habits he can predict this venture of yours won't succeed. You should listen to him.
|
|
By:
What i can say though, beyond all doubt, is that if you carry on this thread, bank five will eventually lose a bet.
It's not a bit of fun, or a laugh, or even difficult to grasp. It's a certainty I can imagine you on The Titanic as all around are listening to Thomas Andrews declare that it will sink (or was it just Rose he told, I forget.. anyway I digress). You'd be pointing to all the people in the lifeboats shouting "you can't predict the future, it might not sink" and then when challenged by the maths of the situation you'd change your tune to "Actually, not only can you not predict the future, but it won't sink. I'm staying here and you won't be able to prove me wrong." and as each second goes by without drowning you'd be chirrupping louder and louder "Stop you fools, get out of those lifeboats, we've been here ages and it's not sunk yet" |
|
By:
^^^^^
This |
|
By:
if there was a bookies on titantic offering 1.01 on sinking schalke would be on the lifeboat
|
|
By:
It's not a ceartainty, maybe on paper it is to you but if you have no conr#trol over my picks or if they will win or lose ....
|
|
By:
Will Andy Murray lose tonight Lori?
|
|
By:
Schalke 04 19 Mar 16:32
You cannot sit there and say I will lose if the events I place bets on constantly win .... you just can't say that !! You are basically condeming my thread to calculations and completely ignoring the selections which you have absolutley no control over, No man can predict the future, the odds we get here on BF represent the opinions of all the punters good and bad, rolled into one and signalling the expected outcome. Thoses odds usually aren't far from true, in that if you were to simply back or lay them you would only lose to commission long term. The question therefore is, how can you cover that commission and show a profit? |
|
By:
No reply, point proven !
|
|
By:
Trevh 19 Mar 16:59
Schalke 04 19 Mar 16:32 You cannot sit there and say I will lose if the events I place bets on constantly win .... you just can't say that !! You are basically condeming my thread to calculations and completely ignoring the selections which you have absolutley no control over, No man can predict the future, the odds we get here on BF represent the opinions of all the punters good and bad, rolled into one and signalling the expected outcome. Thoses odds usually aren't far from true, in that if you were to simply back or lay them you would only lose to commission long term. The question therefore is, how can you cover that commission and show a profit? "Highlighted section" .... EXACTLY !!! No-one can predict what the results will be, thats my point, no odds or prices can determine what will eventually happen, Lori seems to think he does though, he has no idea what my picks will be and he has no idea if they will win or lose .... The only way you can cover commission is to get better prices, but getting better prices is useless if it still gets beat, you need results at the end of the day, that is what betting is all about ! |
|
By:
What point?
Grays sports almanac only covered 1950-2000 and the Delorean was hit by a train. |
|
By:
I can predict the future, I just can't predict it to the degree of detail that you think I should be able to.
This is your problem, not mine. |
|
By:
Will Andy Murray lose tonight?
|
|
By:
You are full of **** Lori
|
|
By:
iif he was 4/1 to do so i'd say yes
if evens i'd say no |
|
By:
Schalke you're right to a point in saying winners matter over value. We'd all rather back a poor value winner than a good value loser. What you're saying is hardly a revelation.
The thing is that before the event we don't know the result but the best judges can spot the value. With the roulette example I'd rather lay the 37/1 than back the 35/1 if I knew it was going to be a loser, who wouldn't? The point is you don't know the result before hand so the only bet to make there is the value. Over a series of thousands of bets the value bettors always win. Lori is correct btw in that this system is doomed to inevitable failure but if you enjoy doing this as a hobby and don't mind blowing your £40 eventually then it's still a cheap hobby. |
|
By:
No sets of odds will determine how Andy Murray will play tonight
|
|
By:
What relevance does that have to this discussion? I have no way of telling. Thankfully it's not at all important as the sequence of winners and losers in the long run has no impact on the net result.
|
|
By:
Lori 19 Mar 17:09
What relevance does that have to this discussion? I have no way of telling. Thankfully it's not at all important as the sequence of winners and losers in the long run has no impact on the net result. Because it is the foundation of my arguement, thats why !!! Getting value has absoluely no control whether your bet will win or lose .... You have no way of telling ... finally, he spits the words out, thats correct Lori, you have no way of telling if Andy Murray will win or lose, you have absolutley no idea if my bank 1 bet will win, bank2 bet, bank 3 bet, bank 4 bet, bank 5 bet, you have no idea what the pick is and you have no idea what the result will be. I could go on picking 1 winning bet from 5 until the day I die, or I could pick 5 losers in a row tomorrow, you have no idea what is going to happen, that is my point. The odds may suggest that this thread will fail but in saying those exact words prove that it can succeed !!! If the chances are 100/1 that this makes money then there is still odds to oppose that, it's not impossible for this thread to go on forever, so you have to withdraw the statement that it will most certainly hit 5 losing bets in a row, because you just have no idea whether it will or won't. Odds may suggest something but they don't guarantee it ..... Also, when the funds are at a certain amount there will be a 6th bank, 7th bank, 8th bank and so on ... what does that say about the thread failing? |
|
By:
I could go on picking 1 winning bet from 5 until the day I die,
Trust me, that is something you don't want to happen. |
|
By:
Also, when the funds are at a certain amount there will be a 6th bank, 7th bank, 8th bank and so on ... what does that say about the thread failing
It makes absolutely bugger all difference obviously, unless you get to the point where your first bank is under the Kelly limit, which not only involves you getting a bigger ratio of money vs bank, but also involves you at some point actually gaining some ability in assessing odds. |
|
By:
lol, I would happily pick 1 winning bet from 5 bets till the day I die if it were bank No.5 that won every time lol ....... if you offered me that in writing I would sign on the dotted line.
|
|
By:
for some reason, that doesn't surprise me.
|
|
By:
It's guaranteed profit, why wouldn't I take it?
|
|
By:
I looked up the example given ... Justine Henin = 1.7 ..... A.Mauresomo 2.1
Youre using a reliable statistical model and estimate that Amelie Mauresmo has a 50% chance of winning the match. The odds of 2.1 are overestimated, making this a value bet. The Kelly criterion allows you to calculate the optimum stake: Kelly % = (2.1 * 50%-1) / (2.1-1) = 4.54% Therefore, you should stake 4.54% of your betting portfolio, i.e. 45.4 euros (4.54% x 1000 euros). Oh dear, Justine won 6-0 6-0 |
|
By:
Oh dear
|
|
By:
I think you should be saying od dear to yourself Lori .... why wouldn't I take 1 winner from 5 if bank 5 were winning all the time? I will put up an example of my 5 banks with 1 winner from 5 and you can tell us all why it's not going to win if it were repeated over and over and over .... I can't wait to see what you say :D
|
|
By:
Where did I say it would lose?
|
|
By:
Schalke 04 19 Mar 17:23
lol, I would happily pick 1 winning bet from 5 bets till the day I die if it were bank No.5 that won every time lol ....... if you offered me that in writing I would sign on the dotted line. Lori 19 Mar 17:29 for some reason, that doesn't surprise me. whats that all about then? |
|
By:
Surely the simple answer here for you Schalke is to continue doing exactly what you have been doing, picking selections you have a gut feeling for.....but then narrowing those gut feeling selections to the only ones of them that appear to be also value as well.
Value isnt fact I know, but it is easier and easier to recognise the more time you have studied markets and you are no newcomer so this shouldnt be so difficult. Less bets, all at perceived value prices and an enjoyable experience all round for you. If your gut feelings are good then theres no need for 5 banks, just a small percentage of your single bank on each selection. The 5 banks suggests a mentality of "I refuse to lose so I will keep bailing myself out"......eventually this has to catch you out and will leave you frustrated with a zero balance. So a very small adjustment to what your already doing will make it an enjoyable hobby and probably profitable too. |
|
By:
Schalke 04 04 Feb 14:55
Well, got £40 left that I am using for betting, tried so many different things in betting and this is the last ... the last few days I have turned the £40 into £42.81. The forum is the best place to keep a history of it ... smaller bets will be placed at bookies, and the larger bets if I need them will be placed here. Every £1.43 I win at the moment increases the stakes, I have divided the money into 5 banks at the moment, and the following gets added to each bank as every £1.43 is won. Sometimes though I will back lower than the money in bank 1 like I have with the first bet of the thread, this further increases the amount of bets and profits This is also for every bank .... |
|
By:
All banks are maximum limits, not minimum
|
|
By:
I think Schalke might be the most clueless long term betfair user on this forum.
|
|
By:
And probably the only one who would disagree with you.
|