We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.
Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.
Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.
To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home
|
By:
To be fair he has advanced a little bit, 4/5years ago he was all in on 1.0x bets he at least now is not staking 100% on bets. A glorified martingale is doomed to failure but give it another 5years and he may be ready to move to the next stage.
|
|
By:
omg ref wtf!?! 16 Mar 14:51
schalke has earned my grudging respect with this thread. still don't get why he starts with such small stakes though, if you work 60 hour weeks then where does all the money go Overheads, bills, house ... you know, the joys of being self-employed !! Hardly see any of my earnings ! |
|
By:
Lori 16 Mar 15:09
You worked out a way to scam people in your rigged casino yet Schalke, or have you finally accepted you have no idea what value does for your bankroll? I know what finding value does to my bankroll but I still need the results for it to work. And about last night, only one comment on it, you told me that if you get better odds on something then it will win, which is still very untrue ! Just like if I gave you double the odds on Chelsea tonight, doesn't mean they are going to win cuase you got better odds, only the players can win that match, not the odds you get. |
|
By:
next bet: (Tennis) Robredo to bt Sela @ 8/11 - £2.01 to win £1.46
|
|
By:
Still waiting for our test of value.
Feel free to start the wheel spinning. |
|
By:
Lori, I have proved it in itself mate ..... the proof that the odds can't make you win is quite simple really, the reason you can't win and havn't won in the last 24 hours is because you need me to spin numbers, you need a RESULT !!! You need something to happen, and without me spinning the wheel you win NOTHING, zero, zilch, nul and big fat O !!!!! And that is my point Lori, you can't win because you got good odds like you say you can, you can only win with a result !! End of discussion !
|
|
By:
So you've proved that if I don't bet I don't win.
What makes you think you're the only place I can get 37/1 about 36/1 shots? |
|
By:
the reason you can't win and havn't won in the last 24 hours is because you need me to spin numbers, you need a RESULT !!!
Spin the wheel then and give the man a result :) . If you wont spin the wheel surely Lori hasnt lost anything either :p Just spent the last 60 mins reading this thread. Good stuff! :) |
|
By:
As I said before Schalke, we all want to cover numbers 1 to 36 and the zero on your roulette table, at 1p per number per spin at 37/1.
If you don't spin the wheel to not show a result, you will make nothing. If you do spin the wheel you will lose 1p per spin guaranteed. If you were offering us all 35/1 you would make 1p per spin guaranteed. How can that small but crucial difference in the odds from poor value to value mean nothing to you? |
|
By:
Oh and just a quick question Lori (if you dont mind) , what does EV and EG mean? Im a £5 punter who gambles for fun, just interested. cheers.
|
|
By:
McNabbToOwens 16 Mar 23:03
the reason you can't win and havn't won in the last 24 hours is because you need me to spin numbers, you need a RESULT !!! Spin the wheel then and give the man a result . If you wont spin the wheel surely Lori hasnt lost anything either Just spent the last 60 mins reading this thread. Good stuff! He says that getting better odds makes him win, well, he has got the odds and I don't see any winnings .... |
|
By:
As I said before Schalke, we all want to cover numbers 1 to 36 and the zero on your roulette table, at 1p per number per spin at 37/1.
If you don't spin the wheel to not show a result, you will make nothing. If you do spin the wheel you will lose 1p per spin guaranteed. If you were offering us all 35/1 you would make 1p per spin guaranteed. How can that small but crucial difference in the odds from poor value to value mean nothing to you? Sorry, but it''s one number and one number only .... that was the whole point of the arguement, not covering the whole board FFS !!!! I am offering 37/1 on one number and only one number !!!! Lori and co think that because they get better odds they can win, well, they can't prove it because they can't guarantee it ..... if they could prove it then there wouldn't be such a thing as gambling as nobody would lose. |
|
By:
\im not one to argue Schalke, gambling should be fun, thats the way i see it, :)
But I know that Value is the only way to win long term. The results will take care of themselves. I, however, am not smart enough to work out what is value and whats not. I bet with my heart, which is why im a long term loser. Best of luck though mate :). |
|
By:
I don't see any winnings ....
I don't see any odds on an event, given that the event hasn't occured because your casino went bust. |
|
By:
McNabbToOwens 16 Mar 23:08
Oh and just a quick question Lori (if you dont mind) , what does EV and EG mean? Im a £5 punter who gambles for fun, just interested. cheers. Expected Value and Expected Growth. Everyone's goal is to bet with a positive expected value, for instance betting £1 on a fair coin at 2/1 would return £3 on one spin, £0 on the other so your expected value would be +£0.50 per flip. However it is possible to still have a negative Expected Growth (which is a measure of where you expect to be if you repeat the series forever basically) if you overstake your bankroll. For instance if you went all-in every single time, you can see that you'd be doomed to failure. Kelly Criterion (you can google the wiki, or find online calculators) maximizes our growth in such situations and tells us our correct bet size with the assumption that it's a repeatable series and that you want to win as much as possible in the long run. |
|
By:
Shall we try one more time before bed Lori? Can you easily answer a question?
Prove me wrong .... any question or requests in the next 10 mins you answer properly, no big fancy words, no takin the p!ss, just answer, can you do that? Pick a number between 1 and 35 ........ and I will give you odds of 50/1 seeing as I am in such a good mood today. |
|
By:
I'm starting to feel like Charlie Brown from peanuts when Lucy holds the football for him and pulls it away.
I posted a very simple formula for my picks yesterday and you refused to spin the wheel. I'm not falling for that again. |
|
By:
Goodbye Lori, I will never reply to anything you ever have to say again
|
|
By:
Sorry, but it''s one number and one number only .... that was the whole point of the arguement, not covering the whole board FFS !!!! I am offering 37/1 on one number and only one number !!!!
But one time offers dont exist tho, surely a value punters portfolio would look something like: 1, 37-1 on a 36-1 shot on roullette 2, Backing Red Sox at 1.9 vs Blue Jays when they should be 1.7 (why they are odds on with Dice K on the mound is anyones guess tho :p) 3, Backing Stricker at 16-1 when he should be 12-1 in that field. and so on and so on. The results will take care of themselves using the correct staking. Im not smart enough to work out what is value tho. Which is why im a losing gambler. Smarter people that me have tried on this thread tho. It reminds me of a thread on the NA Forum when ODwyer said the only way to win on Baseball was to do a DelBoy All in style of accumulator :|. Best of luck tho, i mean it. Im not taking the** here. I get value, i really do. I wish i could work it out. |
|
By:
OK thanks Lori, its a lot to get your head around.
Im struggling to understand it but want to impliment something for the baseball season. Been looking up on it for the last half hour :) |
|
By:
The most important thing to take from it is to bet small relative to your bank size. If you can do that, then you'll still win if you find value.
If you win over a longish time (Maybe one season from your previous posts, maybe half a season if you're comfortable with why you're winning) THEN start worrying about stuff like Kelly as when you start winning you'll probably still be bad at assessing just how much value you're getting... which is a must with kelly betting (perfect for stuff like 37/1 roulette wheels though, not so perfect for baseball betting) If you're betting baseball in the 1.5 to 3.0 range, a very handy rule of thumb (others will say variants of this, use whatever suits your mentality) would be to bet 1% of your bank on most bets, 2% on the ones you really like, and 3% maybe 1-2 times a season (and not when chasing , just when you think it's a cracker ) That approximates things very well for someone starting out using value imo. Far more important would be to get accustomed to the modern style stats at baseballprospectus.com and thehardballtimes.com and throw traditional ERA in the trash ;) |
|
By:
Cheers mate. I actually have baseballprospectus2010 to help me out with all my fantasy drafts :^0 . Not enough pictures for me tho :p
|
|
By:
If you trust their ERA projections instead of real ERA's for the first 40% or so of the season, you certainly won't do any damage (except in obvious injury or breakthrough related circumstanceS)
|
|
By:
£40 start
67p / £2.01 / £6.03 / £19.10 / £40.00 - Total in Banks - £67.81 Stake Increase £1.93 .. 1p / 3p / 9p / 30p / £1.50 .. current (£1.58) 120. (Tennis) Petrova to bt Peng @ 8/15 - £2 to win £1.07 - WON 121. (tennis) Pennetta to bt Peer @ 8/15 - £0.67 to win £0.36 - lost 122. (Tennis) Nadal/Ljubicic Double - £2.01 to win £0.89 - WON 123. Chelsea/Sevilla to qualify Double - £0.67 to win £0.73 - lost 124. (Tennis) Robredo to bt Sela @ 8/11 - £2.01 to win £1.46 - WON level Total Banked : £4.89 124 Bets ----- 78 wins ----- 1 Void ----- 45 losers ----- Highest run of losing bets: 3 ©Schalke 04© |
|
By:
next bet: (Tennis) Federer to bt Baghdatis @ 1/14 - £0.63 to win £0.05
|
|
By:
It reminds me of a thread on the NA Forum when ODwyer said the only way to win on Baseball was to do a DelBoy All in style of accumulator
superb thread that one , i'll check if it still exists :) |
|
By:
[i]Having some trouble getting Schalke's numbers to add up. Could someone who knows anything about soccer or happens to know the odds from the games in the double below put me right. (There are more to do but I will probably put those off until tomorrow now as the numbers given deviate on a regular basis)
Schalke 04 13 Feb 11:49 £40 start 55p / £1.65 / £4.95 / £15.50 / £24.50 - Total in Banks - £47.15 Stake Increase £1.43 .. 1p / 3p / 9p / 30p / £1 .. current (£0.58) 30. (Tennis) Hass to bt Istomin 2-0 @ 8/13 - £1.62 to win £1 - lost 31. (Basketball) Boston Celtics to bt New Orleans Hornets @ 10/21 - £4.86 to win £2.31 - lost 32. (Darts) Phil Taylor to bt Simon Whitlock @ 1/2 - £15.20 to win £7.60 - WON 33. (Tennis) Dementieva/Pennetta Double @ 17/55 - £0.54 to win £0.17 - WON 34. (Tennis) Querry/Roddick Double @ 41/55 - £0.54 to win £0.41 - WON level Total Banked : £0.20 (Lori note: total 47.15+.58+.2 = £47.93) Schalke 04 14 Feb 18:49 £40 start 55p / £1.65 / £4.95 / £15.50 / £24.50 - Total in Banks - £47.15 Stake Increase £1.43 .. 1p / 3p / 9p / 30p / £1 .. current (£1.01) 34. (Tennis) Querry/Roddick Double @ 41/55 - £0.54 to win £0.41 - WON 35. Football Accumulator ----- £0.55 to win £43.35 - lost 36. (Tennis) Pennetta to bt Safarova @ 8/11 - £1.65 to win £1.32 - lost 37. Millwall/East Stirling Double - £4.95 to win £8.16 - WON 38. (Tennis) Djokovic/Andreev Double @ 42/55 - £0.55 to win £0.42 - lost -55p Total Banked : £0.20 (Lori note: £47.93 from post 1. -0.55 +8.16 -0.55. Total should be £53.34, however it's only £48.36. Can I assume that bet 37 was actually to win £3.21 and return £8.16, rather than win £8.16?) |
|
By:
I just realised the "current" bit in brackets is basically meaningless, but the question is still applicable to that bet.
FWIW I think there are so many errors that it's going to take days to get my spreadsheet to tally up here, but I may continue the project anyway as it'll be fun to see how "bet one" loses money as time goes by and how the bank is only maintained by huge wins in banks four and five until the inevitable loss. |
|
By:
Schalke,
Man Utd draw Stoke in the FA Cup at home. For the sake of arguement you're forced to have a £10 bet on the to qualify market. The odds are: Man Utd 1.01 Stoke 100 What's your pick? |
|
By:
GOM - he will only tell what his pick is once he knows the winner as picking the loser makes no sense
|
|
By:
Lori,
Why do you say the first bet will lose money as time goes by? |
|
By:
Overall Schalke will lose money as time goes by because he doesn't bet for value. However because of the five bank chase scheme, this will only be apparent when he finally and fatally picks five losers in a row. This can take some time at 1.5 shots.
However, it will show up more quickly in the earlier banks as that is where he has the most bets and strips out the nonsense overstaking that puts him back on track (until it goes wrong) If bank one starts to show a sustained profit (and actually, betting at 50-60p, if he did it with some though he probably could without too much difficulty. I'll contest that he won't even be able to do this though) then it would be more interesting. If the thread runs any kind of distance then bank two may be a better analysis purely because he can't use rounding errors so well to get value. Rounding errors aside, bank one is a larger sample size than the other banks and so we can assess the nature of his picks much more quickly than following the running total. It's already been pointed out that he's not getting value over all his bets and will therefore go broke, but that may not be as clear as showing how each bank is doing and over how many bets. If I can make his numbers add up (they're not terribly inaccurate, I believe he's telling the truth in fact, but I need a lot more accuracy to produce a total) I'll try to publish the figures from each bank where I may be able to show those on the edge of believing that he needs value to win, but who are not really sure, a much more clear picture. I only started last night though, and even I, with my gambling orientated life, have better things to do with my time, so it'll take me a little while to get on top of that project. |
|
By:
*I've cleared up the mess on bet 37 fwiw, Schalke did note that it was reduced to a single on Millwall though I've had to deduce the price and payout from the other numbers.
|
|
By:
Just to give an example of why this is not a trivial exercise.
62. (Tennis) Baghdatis to bt Simon @ 2/5 - £1.74 to win £0.12 - WON I have to check the running total after each update (as Schalke's totals seem to be correct as they're based on his accounts, he just doesn't check if he's been paid out the right amount) |
|
By:
Also, the "current" in brackets is usually partly or fully part of the bankroll, on this occasion (and in fairness most errors have been against Schalke, not for him, so he's not **ing) for instance, 10 pence appears in the bank, while the 20 pence won appears in brackets next to current..
Schalke 04 26 Feb 12:27 £40 start 61p / £1.83 / £5.49 / £17.30 / £31.00 - Total in Banks - £56.23 Stake Increase £1.93 .. 1p / 3p / 9p / 30p / £1.50 .. current (£0.00) 78. (Darts) Jenkins to win 8th leg v Lewis @ 4/7 - £0.60 to win £0.34 - WON 79. (Darts) Over 12.5 legs - Whitlock v Barneveld @ 1/2 - £0.59 to win £0.30 - WON 80. (Darts) Taylor highest checkout v Wade @ 1/2 - £0.59 to win £0.30 - lost 81. (Tennis) Verdasco to bt Monaco @ 1/2 - £1.79 to win £0.90 - lost 82. (Tennis) M.Youzhny to win 2nd set v Melzer @ 4/6 - £5.40 to win £3.60 - WON level Total Banked : £1.19 Schalke 04 26 Feb 18:56 £40 start 61p / £1.83 / £5.49 / £17.30 / £31.00 - Total in Banks - £56.23 Stake Increase £1.93 .. 1p / 3p / 9p / 30p / £1.50 .. current (£0.20) 79. (Darts) Over 12.5 legs - Whitlock v Barneveld @ 1/2 - £0.59 to win £0.30 - WON 80. (Darts) Taylor highest checkout v Wade @ 1/2 - £0.59 to win £0.30 - lost 81. (Tennis) Verdasco to bt Monaco @ 1/2 - £1.79 to win £0.90 - lost 82. (Tennis) M.Youzhny to win 2nd set v Melzer @ 4/6 - £5.40 to win £3.60 - WON 83. (Tennis) Djokovic to bt Baghdatis @ 1/3 - £0.59 to win £0.20 - WON level Total Banked : £1.29 |
|
By:
In those instances, I'm giving the benefit of the doubt to Schalke and allowing him a 30p win instead of a 20p win on the bet. There are errors in both directions so my assumptions will not always be correct. I feel it's the fairest method given that he's declared he'll never speak to me again because of the discussion over his generous casino.
|
|
By:
I've discovered that sometimes he posts before his balance is updated. That helps makes sense of some stuff.
This one is truly bizarre though. On winning a 4 pence bet, his balance stays the same, but his bank dipped 50 pence. I'm going to give him the benefit of the doubt and assume the 50p is actually borrowed from the bank because he needed to put it in the electric meter. Have also given credit for a 4p win that he forgot while the lights were out. [i] Schalke 04 08 Mar 22:03 £40 start 65p / £1.95 / £5.85 / £18.50 / £37.00 - Total in Banks - £63.95 Stake Increase £1.93 .. 1p / 3p / 9p / 30p / £1.50 .. current (£0.43) 99. (Tennis) Hantchucova to win 1st set v Cibulkova @ 8/11 - £0.64 to win £0.47 - lost 100. (Basketball) Houston Rockets to bt Minnesota Timberwolves @ 1/2 - £1.92 to win £0.96 - WON 101. Inter to bt Genoa @ 4/11 - £0.62 to win £0.23 - lost 102. Independiente DNB to bt River Plate @ 4/9 - £1.92 to win £0.85 - WON 103. Wigan DNB to bt Liverpool @ 4/6 - £0.65 to win £0.43 - WON level Total Banked : £3.41 Schalke 04 09 Mar 09:47 £40 start 65p / £1.95 / £5.85 / £18.50 / £37.00 - Total in Banks - £63.95 Stake Increase £1.93 .. 1p / 3p / 9p / 30p / £1.50 .. current (£0.43) 100. (Basketball) Houston Rockets to bt Minnesota Timberwolves @ 1/2 - £1.92 to win £0.96 - WON 101. Inter to bt Genoa @ 4/11 - £0.62 to win £0.23 - lost 102. Independiente DNB to bt River Plate @ 4/9 - £1.92 to win £0.85 - WON 103. Wigan DNB to bt Liverpool @ 4/6 - £0.65 to win £0.43 - WON 104. Palmeiras or draw v Sertaozinho @ 1/14 - £0.63 to win £0.04 - WON level Total Banked : £2.91 |
|
By:
Ok here it is. My total is 55p higher than Schalkes. 50p he mysteriously deducted from his bank. 4p was logged as a void bet, and 1p went missing somewhere around the time of the Taylor 5p win, some bookie skanked him of a penny.
The table below gives on the left his bet size in pence how many bets he's had at that level and how he's doing winning/losing on those bets. It's further broken down into payouts and losses within each size bracket. Note that he's winning £32.02 overall and his three biggest bets, all of which have won, have made him £32.59 So the sample size of 121 is losing, the sample size of 3 is winning. [pre] 1-100 78 -565 Lose 32 -1814 Win 46 1249 101-200 30 +41 Lose 10 -1729 Win 20 1770 201-300 3 +462 Win 3 462 401-500 4 +241 Lose 1 -486 Win 3 727 501-600 6 -236 Lose 2 -1134 Push 1 0 Win 3 898 1501-1600 1 +760 Win 1 760 1701-1800 1 +1442 Win 1 1442 1801-1900 1 +1057 Win 1 1057 Grand Total 124 3202 |
|
By:
Cheers for answer Lori,
regarding that missing 50p if you check his post above that one (09 Mar 09:43) he says the bookmaker has essentially shortchanged him. Don't know who he was/is using so won't comment on that. |
|
By:
Cheers, I missed that.
I will give Schalke one piece of credit, and that's that I managed to construct his entire betting history based on his comments and his tables, which is pretty decent record keeping. There are certainly some winners who could learn from that. |