Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
Joel
24 Mar 10 08:04
Joined:
Date Joined: 14 Feb 04
| Topic/replies: 34,629 | Blogger: Joel's blog
Anyone else had an incorrect statement this week?

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 1 of 3  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 99
By:
jabten.
When: 24 Mar 10 10:48
Haven't checked it for a long time as it seemed to be right each week. What's wrong with yours this week?
By:
Joel
When: 24 Mar 10 11:22
The report said I had made a lot more than I actually had
By:
Eddie the eagle
When: 24 Mar 10 11:28
I would check the numbers again and have in mind that losses from markets that are partially settled wont count towards PC until the market is fully settled.
It's also easy to forget winnings from the Aussie wallet.
By:
Ghetto Joe
When: 24 Mar 10 11:37
remember betfairs commission calculation means the Gross PL less Total Charges won't match your bethistory figure for the same period
By:
Joel
When: 24 Mar 10 11:38
I emailed them and they said the figures don't add up either, they are looking into it.
By:
inner city sumo
When: 24 Mar 10 12:28
What a f**king shambles.
By:
nortons
When: 24 Mar 10 12:49
Joel, if your pc charge is incorrect how the hell can we be confident that they take the correct amount each week from the rest of us?
By:
1.01 Layer
When: 24 Mar 10 12:53
Just checked my last two weeks and both are incorrect as per my P&L.
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 06 Apr 10 16:30
Just checked mine for this week and it is wrong. What is wrong is that the total commission generated figure for the week is understated. I've had no partially settled markets and no Aussie wallet markets.

These are my figures:

Commission paid this week £210.78 (double and cross checked)
divided by commission rate of 3.3% means my winning markets for the week were £6,387
My gross win for the week is £1,218 (confirmed)
Which means I had losing markets totalling £5,166
implied commission equals 3% of £5,166 = £154.98
Commission generated = (Commission + Implied Commission) ÷ 2
=(£210.78+£154.98)/2 = £182.88
and I've only been credited with £150.39 according to my statement

Waiting for a call back at the moment
By:
Ghetto Joe
When: 06 Apr 10 17:00
Probably taken a bit extra this week to pay for the NEW! casino tab
By:
Eddie the eagle
When: 06 Apr 10 17:24
CLYDEBANK , there is an error in the calculation from Betfair if you have got the numbers right.


Joel , what happened in the end in your case ?
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 06 Apr 10 20:48
Looks like I'm going to have to sort this out by email. The initial response I got was along the lines of it's not possible to work it out and the computer is never wrong.
By:
DStyle
When: 06 Apr 10 20:50
any bets settled between 00:00 and 01:00 BST on Monday morning?

it's working on GMT, not BST
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 06 Apr 10 21:56
No the gross profit for the week is correct - confirmed as per the premium charge report
By:
Ghetto Joe
When: 06 Apr 10 22:03
"divided by commission rate of 3.3% means my winning markets for the week were £6,387"

Depending on how big or small your wins were you can't rely on the comms paid as being 3.3%. You'd be better off calculating implied comms by downloading the betting history for the period and just adding up the losing markets to 3% rounded in something like excel
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 06 Apr 10 22:07
commission paid is simply my commission rate for the week

irrespective of that i've added each separate commission payment up and it concurs and cross checks.

hopefully I'll get a swift correct response and the email won't be buried as too hard.
By:
Ghetto Joe
When: 06 Apr 10 22:15
If you manage to get a swift concise response you'll be the first one :)

Considering how much they take in PC charges they certainly like to make it hard to cross check the figures, although I'd guess that's more by design than simply overlooked.
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 07 Apr 10 14:42
No response yet. A bit worrying because I'd imagine plenty of people who do pay it are unaware how to calculate it, have to trust that it is done correctly, and would be unaware if it is wrong. The total charges being understated will mean you'll pay more in the future even if you don't actually pay it in the week that it is understated. I often check it or roughly check it and havent noticed it to be wrong before but I certainly dont always check it and I' be unlikely to pick up an overcharge of £30 if I hadnt checked it.
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 07 Apr 10 14:45
Should also add that by removing "the commission paid" figure from the calculations (after the premium charge review) they have made it harder for users to check it is right and less likely that someone could see at a glance it is wrong.
By:
tol5tov
When: 07 Apr 10 14:55
is it done by ip address or name of account holder,could i open one in wifes name with her card.
By:
Lay Low
When: 07 Apr 10 16:09
Should also add that by removing "the commission paid" figure from the calculations (after the premium charge review) they have made it harder for users to check it is right and less likely that someone could see at a glance it is wrong.

When they removed the commission paid value after the review, Betfair said that took no part in the calculation and only confused matters. I agreed with them at the time. Now that I have read Clydebank's post, it would actually make matters simpler if it was reintroduced.

Knowing the "week's commission paid" and the commission percentage it is easy to work out the week's profit of all winning markets. Multiply this by half the commission percentage and this will give you the week's commission generated by winning markets.

Then knowing the week's gross profit and the week's profit of all winning markets it easy to calculate the week's loss from losing markets. Multiply this value by -1.5% and you have the commission generated by losing markets.

Add these together you get the total commission generated. This with the gross profit is everything you need for a very simple calculation.

Why are Betfair trying to make it difficult?
By:
chrisblues
When: 07 Apr 10 16:22
it gone on for too long where is the link ? for it to find it in my account
instead of going to feedback and cut and paste the link
By:
Lay Low
When: 07 Apr 10 16:24
https://account.betfair.com/regpay-myaccount/premiumcharge/summary.htm
By:
chrisblues
When: 07 Apr 10 16:31
got a link thinks but i mean they should put it in" my account "
By:
Lay Low
When: 07 Apr 10 16:35
got a link thinks but i mean they should put it in" my account "

Betfair will say that only a very small percentage of customers will need it.
By:
Gerbs
When: 07 Apr 10 16:48
they removed the comm paid as for most people paying it there was a big difference in what you had paid and what you got credited with in the comm generated
By:
mabroad
When: 07 Apr 10 19:37
https://premiumcharge.betfair.com/PremiumPortal/portal

Does this help people?....I fell off my chair today after being charged £154 in charges....Never heard of them before.... absolute scandal they are applied....Anyone know the rationale for them apart from theft????
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 07 Apr 10 20:03
If you've not been pre warned you should get your first charge refunded.

The rationale for the charge is that if you win too quickly you cost Betfair money and therefore they'd rather not have you as a customer. The charge is applied to top up your contribution to the point where you are considered break even.
By:
mabroad
When: 07 Apr 10 20:51
thanx....no pre warning was given and just thought they had messed up my account balance
By:
turtleshead
When: 07 Apr 10 21:13
"The rationale for the charge is that if you win too quickly you cost Betfair money"

Yes, that is what they say...which is of course a total pile of crap.

As many people have stated, just about any customer can be hit if they have a good run. Big winners, small winners, losers, gamblers, arbers, position takers, market makers, all that needs to happen is for you to have an unusually good run...and wallop. And as has also been pointed out, once you get hit, it's almost impossible to get rid of it, other than by hitting a large number of losers! And then would you get a refund to compensate? Pigs might fly....

Imagine walking into a betting shop and being told that because you've had a decent run recently, that even money winner you just backed is being paid out at 4/5. Absolutely no difference whatsover. It's disgusting. It's obscene. And many other words I could think of.

Betfair, where winners are welcome? Betfair, where you get 20% better odds? LMAO.
By:
mabroad
When: 07 Apr 10 21:54
Thanx for your informed comments.....I was of the impression that they had the perfect business model of taking 5% from markets so didn't really matter who won and who lost to them.....As you have said I might just be on a lucky streak which could end tomorrow and never return for 10 years!!
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 07 Apr 10 22:35
The reality is that in Betfair's own words very few people qualify to pay premium charge. I would say therefore those that do (assuming they are not trap bettors, insiders or hooverers) are not reponsible for the churn rate of customers that leave Betfair, since they match a tiny proportion of leaving customers bets, and therefore are not uneconomic customers.

The actual situation is that it makes sense to charge those customers more who derive the greatest benefit from using the site more since they won't leave or are at least unlikely to leave. The follow on question is who derives the greatest net benefit from the site and how likely are they to leave? The big winners or the quick winners?

This thread is actually about the incorrect calculation of the charge mind.
By:
Joel
When: 07 Apr 10 22:49
Eddie the eagle 07 Apr 02:24


CLYDEBANK , there is an error in the calculation from Betfair if you have got the numbers right.


Joel , what happened in the end in your case ?


Eddie, BF admitted they had made an error, it was on 1 particular Aus Race which for some reason had counted twice or something. Don't know what would have happened if I didn't pick it up myself...going to have to check more thoroughly from now on.
By:
CLYDEBANK29
When: 07 Apr 10 23:08
2 completely different types of mistake then since mine shows the correct profit. It's the charges that are wrong.
By:
tol5tov
When: 08 Apr 10 01:04
tol5tov 07 Apr 14:55


is it done by ip address or name of account holder,could i open one in wifes name with her card.

anybody ?
By:
The Investor
When: 08 Apr 10 01:43
CLYDEBANK29 07 Apr 14:45
Should also add that by removing "the commission paid" figure from the calculations (after the premium charge review) they have made it harder for users to check it is right and less likely that someone could see at a glance it is wrong.


This decision was horrendous.
You can't even see how much your Net profit is by looking at your PC statement.
Of everything Betfair has ever done, this really baffles me the most. I know it's not important in the scheme of things, but this decision was so completely devoid of logic that I had some difficulty letting it go.

The only time I had a go at them over the phone was when they did this 'because it was confusing customers'. They went on to tell me I could look at the week's P/L on the site then deduct the PC. I said this is going to waste 5 minutes of my time every single week, why don't you just leave it there... I don't like to waste my time on wholly unnecessary menial tasks.

What's really confusing for me is how Betfair seem to believe that NET profit is such a trivial metric for its customers that they don't need to provide the information to calculate it on the PC portal.


I've never checked my PC payments. I think the treatment Clydebank has received so far is pretty dire. It's a serious issue if Betfair is messing this up.
By:
The Investor
When: 08 Apr 10 01:50
On a positive note I should add that Betfair Customer Services have almost always been very polite and helpful with regard to requests and problems. In this case I was frustrated, as I believe Betfair should strive to provide complete and accurate information and the CS agent disagreed with this.
By:
askari1
When: 08 Apr 10 03:41
Bf are a bookmaker. Anyone who consistently or long-term wins money from them is a bad customer for them.

The question becomes whether they need winning liquidity providers or market makers.

Perhaps they don't? They just need a tissue to be able to put up the money themselves.
By:
sweetchildofmine
When: 08 Apr 10 03:48
askari1 08 Apr 03:41
Bf are a bookmaker. Anyone who consistently or long-term wins money from them is a bad customer for them.

The question becomes whether they need winning liquidity providers or market makers.

Perhaps they don't? They just need a tissue to be able to put up the money themselves.


they arent though are they? hence they dont make a book
Page 1 of 3  •  Previous 1 | 2 | 3 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com