Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

General Betting

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 6770 comments are related to the topic:
Koo's Comeback Thread

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 14 of 170  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | ... | 170 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 6,770
By:
johnt
When: 27 Mar 08 08:34
Good Luck Koo.

You should start a blog.

http://john2e.typepad.com/

;-).
By:
Koo's worst nightmare
When: 27 Mar 08 08:45
3 times too much on the visored beast imv koo.
By:
nuboy
When: 27 Mar 08 09:11
Koo im off to guernsey for a couple of weeks,i will catch up on your diet when i get back,be lucky.life is sweet.
By:
stewarty b
When: 27 Mar 08 12:08
Koo, as you know, I have wished you all the best for the future. I don't normaly give tips, but I would advise you to get yourself a girlfriend. Yes, I know they can be a distraction, but as long as she knows her hours you should be OK. ;) GL
By:
Sweep Moggy
When: 27 Mar 08 12:48
our lass is northern for girlfriend Stewarty b, hope this helps
By:
stewarty b
When: 27 Mar 08 13:46
Sweep Moggy, ''our'' sounds like too much sharing imo. ;)
By:
Koo...
When: 27 Mar 08 15:07
Horse Racing: -GBP14,892.99 Total P&L: -GBP14,892.99

a day for damage limitatrion after plunging on the last hurdle faller. Was a bit down for then so deposited the 10k max limit. Didnt need that to fall when clear there though. Got 1.24 for about 7 soa decent bet i thought. However these things happen. The punting gods swing in roundabouts.
But have to keep the head and play normally for rest of day and see how much i can get, tryiong to start from scratch.

600 off simple seb at leafy a good start
By:
billy
When: 27 Mar 08 15:19
Sorry to be a pain in the arris again, but would you have been caught out like this on day one, koo ?
By:
Koo...
When: 27 Mar 08 15:23
Probably billy............. maybe wouldnt have laid the first one so big. But i thik the first one was basically getting carried away. So i suppose no. But i would have hammered the faller. As I often thik the end of races give the best value backs.
Backed another faller, but fairly sure it was beat anyways. Though the 20k tank looks to be running fairly dry today.

Gotta keep playing as normal still as possible
By:
Gunslinger
When: 27 Mar 08 15:49
Currently he is a flawed genius, its as simple as that. But the flaw I believe can be corrected and erradicated.

He easily has the talent to consistently make 1500 per day on average which is half a million a year but seems to be betting to try to make 2M per year. The 1500 average could easily include lots of losing days but the losing days should neve be of the proprtion we have sometimes seen.

Main problem for Koo IMO is that there isn't proper discipline on the staking system.

Koo, I want you to suceed so what I would suggest is the following:

You need to set staking limits per certain odds backs and lays. This is REGARDLESS OF HOW BIG AN EDGE OR BIG A CERT A BACK OR A LAY IS.

(I haven'r read the whole thread but I've observed you backiing 5K on a 1.01 and 7K on a 1.24 shot, both of which sadly lost)

I accept that overall you are in profit and therefore you are getting a decent edge on most of your bets but the staking is all wrong assuming that your overall goal is to increase you total profits over time. I saw you give a figure of a 300K target in a year, well that's less than 1000 per day so my assumption of 1500 per day is based on that.

IMO you should never risk more than 1000 on any given race. Even 1000 is proabably too high but I am assuming that you are very skillful and are getting an edge the majority of the time.

Maybe in your mind you should have say 3 risk figures. e.g 300, 600 and 1000 and on every bet quickly decide which of these three levels of risk is appropriate.

The 1000 max risk per race is based on that even if you risk the maximum 1000 on every race on a given day (lets assume 16 races) and you lose the full 1000 on 12 races but win on the other 4 races with an average win of 500 win per race then you have lost 10000. The points are that given your skill levels losing 12 out of 16 times will be a very rare occurence and even when it does happen you have still only lost what currently you are capable of losing in just one or two races.

By adopting a sensible and risk averse staking system two things are guaranteed to happen.

1. Your flow of profits will be far, far smoother with less wild swings and probably not many swings at all.

2. Your running P & L will accurately reflect the true edge that you are getting when backing/laying. (Currently you are gaining an edge but its impossible to tell how much of your running P & L is down to an edge you are gaining and how much of it is just good/bad luck)

I wish you well with your comeback and hope that you can look at your own strategy more objectively and with more of a long term steady accumulation of profits view.
By:
Gunslinger
When: 27 Mar 08 15:56
I should add to my last post that even by adopting an ultra disciplined staking sytem you find that you only average a 500 profit per day then that is still 180K profit in a year which is still a great figure to achieve.

With all due respect, perhaps you are trying to be too much of a big shot too early in your career.

Lets assume that you adopt the max 1000 per race staking limit and after a year it has produced 500 per day profit equalling 180K, well then in year two you can increase to 1500 per race max risk so by the end of year two meaning you have 450K total profit by the end of year 2.

This IMO is how to make half a million pounds. The way you are doing things now might still make half a milllion but also has a chance of busting you one or more times and of causing you a lot of psychological damage.
By:
The Sports Trader
When: 27 Mar 08 17:23
Very sensible advice Gunslinger and I wish you well Koo
By:
Koo...
When: 27 Mar 08 17:42
I've quickly read it all gunslinger, but gonna play the bumper before replying.
The day hasnt got much better , thats all i can say. However ive still got some ammunition left for wolves tonight as i need to try and win a kitty ion order to be able to play tomorrow.
By:
Gunslinger
When: 27 Mar 08 18:42
Add the 50K that you have already made and 500 per day profit in a year's time from now = 230K.

I've made plenty of errors in staking, risk control etc myself so I'm speaking from experience.

It may also be the case that you need to not enjoy your betting in order for it to be consistently profitable. It seems like you get too much of a buzz out of it and this in my experience breeds complacency and causes perspective to be lost.
By:
Koo...
When: 27 Mar 08 18:45
Right peeps, the worst day here since i started. But a good example of what was hampering me make money on here before.
The main problem i have is that i lose too much ona bad day compared to what i make on a decent day. To lose 20k is too much i feel. Therefore im putting in measures to limit any future losses to a maximum of 5k right now
Basically gonna start everyday with 5k and not be able to deposit to my account until the next day.

Todays losses were on 2 reasons.

First loss bad judgement in laying the 2/7 fav too big IR both price and stake.

Second loss - Unlucky. Got average of 1/4 for nearly over 6k so a good bet when it only had to jump a hurdle. But thasts the game at times.

Later losses - head was all over the place in all probability. Hence why ive lost 5k on the day without the big 2.

But as im always trying to improve, i've put the new measures in straight away to limut any losses to 5k.
I'll review the 5k limit when night racing starts though.


Horse Racing: -GBP19,198.66 Total P&L: -GBP19,198.66

Horse Racing Showing 1 - 20 of 26 markets
Market Start time Settled date Profit/loss ()
Horse Racing / Thurl 27th Mar : 2m INHF 27-Mar-08 17:45 27-Mar-08 17:52 -2,930.08
Horse Racing / Ayr 27th Mar : 2m NHF 27-Mar-08 17:20 27-Mar-08 17:37 1,013.27
Horse Racing / Thurl 27th Mar : 2m2f Hcap Chs 27-Mar-08 17:15 27-Mar-08 17:23 130.75
Horse Racing / Ling 27th Mar : 1m2f Hcap 27-Mar-08 17:10 27-Mar-08 17:14 558.91
Horse Racing / Extr 27th Mar : 2m1f Hcap Hrd 27-Mar-08 17:00 27-Mar-08 17:07 -105.04
Horse Racing / Ayr 27th Mar : 2m Hcap Chs 27-Mar-08 16:50 27-Mar-08 17:01 -64.14
Horse Racing / Thurl 27th Mar : 2m6f Beg Chs 27-Mar-08 16:45 27-Mar-08 16:53 270.93
Horse Racing / Ling 27th Mar : 7f Hcap 27-Mar-08 16:40 27-Mar-08 16:47 598.16
Horse Racing / Extr 27th Mar : 2m3f Hunt Chs 27-Mar-08 16:25 27-Mar-08 16:34 -768.22
Horse Racing / Ayr 27th Mar : 2m Hcap Hrd 27-Mar-08 16:15 27-Mar-08 16:27 106.88
Horse Racing / Thurl 27th Mar : 2m2f Beg Chs 27-Mar-08 16:10 27-Mar-08 16:20 239.75
Horse Racing / Ling 27th Mar : 5f Hcap 27-Mar-08 16:05 27-Mar-08 16:10 195.58
Horse Racing / Extr 27th Mar : 2m3f Nov Chs 27-Mar-08 15:55 27-Mar-08 16:01 -2,028.64
Horse Racing / Ayr 27th Mar : 2m Nov Hrd 27-Mar-08 15:45 27-Mar-08 15:55 48.95
Horse Racing / Thurl 27th Mar : 2m6f Hcap Hrd 27-Mar-08 15:40 27-Mar-08 15:48 346.95
Horse Racing / Ling 27th Mar : 6f Mdn Stks 27-Mar-08 15:35 27-Mar-08 15:40 -68.13
Horse Racing / Extr 27th Mar : 2m7f Hcap Chs 27-Mar-08 15:20 27-Mar-08 15:29 3.87
Horse Racing / Thurl 27th Mar : 2m4f Mdn Hrd 27-Mar-08 15:05 27-Mar-08 15:25 -117.70
Horse Racing / Ayr 27th Mar : 2m4f Beg Chs 27-Mar-08 15:10 27-Mar-08 15:24 -2,386.49
Horse Racing / Ling 27th Mar : 6f Sell Stks 27-Mar-08 15:00 27-Mar-08 15:05 648.77

Horse Racing: -GBP19,198.66 Total P&L: -GBP19,198.66

Horse Racing Showing 21 - 26 of 26 markets
Market Start time Settled date Profit/loss ()
Horse Racing / Extr 27th Mar : 2m3f Hcap Hrd 27-Mar-08 14:50 27-Mar-08 14:58 -6,748.82
Horse Racing / Ayr 27th Mar : 2m4f Nov Hrd 27-Mar-08 14:40 27-Mar-08 14:52 -7,084.38
Horse Racing / Thurl 27th Mar : 2m Mdn Hrd 27-Mar-08 14:35 27-Mar-08 14:41 505.84
Horse Racing / Ling 27th Mar : 1m2f Claim Stks 27-Mar-08 14:30 27-Mar-08 14:34 -216.65
Horse Racing / Extr 27th Mar : 2m3f Nov Hrd 27-Mar-08 14:20 27-Mar-08 14:29 -1,945.81
Horse Racing / Ayr 27th Mar : 2m5f Hcap Chs 27-Mar-08 14:10 27-Mar-08 14:24 596.83
Pages: 1 2 of 2 Pages



Total p/l since 7th March = Horse Racing: GBP45,403.59 | Soccer: GBP0.00 Total P&L: GBP45,403.59


I'll re read your thoughts gunslinger and reply fotrhwith.
By:
Proud to be a Northener
When: 27 Mar 08 19:00
I have to work all year to net 19k

Good luck koo.
By:
im allin
When: 27 Mar 08 19:11
Koo, Gunslinger is correct you have an edge on the market but with an erratic and crazy staking system you will never get the full benefit from your edge. You need to limit how much you are prepared to lose on any particular race. Winning big and losing big is not utilising your edge on the market and unless you have a bank of 400k dropping 20k in a day is too high. Good luck the thread is a good read.
By:
Gunslinger
When: 27 Mar 08 19:24
IMO the main battle you need to win is to wholly accept that it might take 12 months or even 24 months of discilplined hard graft using 90% skill and 10% luck to get back to near the 200k level that you had not so long ago.

The thought of such a long "sentence" (as in jail sentence to be endured) in order to get back to where you once were money wise is probably an unpleasant one but in order to ultimately be victorious and contented I feel its something you will have to deal with.

So if you can accept a 2 year "sentence" then during the two years you can also improve other aspects of your life so that in two years time you have improved lots of different areas and not just your bank balance.
By:
Koo...
When: 27 Mar 08 19:46
Gunslinger - im afriad i cant take up your 2 year sentence offer. Its not that i wouldnt be happy with 200k in 2 years, its more i think im capablke of getting more if i can find the right conditions for me to operate more consistentl;y

Im quite happy that i overstake at times, i find the only thing that does me harm is the big losing days.

I accept that i need to have better staking but i think by going to a smaller starting bank that i cant do much harm.
Overstaking for me is like the time i had 50k on Chelsea or laid Kingsgate Native to lose 40k. Also laid Beef Or Salmon to lose 80k in last years Gold CUp. Also had 80k on a 1/12 shot at Ripon last year.

Some of them bets have some have lost. But i do realise that the stakes are too high. Hence how ive tried to combat things.


Sorry its a short answer as my lift is here for snooker.

Adious and good luck people
By:
johnt
When: 27 Mar 08 19:49
Gunslinger giving very good advice IMO.

Good Luck Koo, Gunslinger and all apart from Billy. :-).
By:
TELL DEL
When: 27 Mar 08 19:57
been keeping up-to-date with this thread from the start.........still gobsmacked by it !
Your a clever operator Koo, but a 'flawed genius' as Gunslinger puts it, and some sound advice by him.

Good luck, and I'll keep reading, very interesting stuff.
By:
marksman
When: 27 Mar 08 19:57
Koo, can't you see that you are doing exactly what Dave Nevison said that people will do with this strategy. (Setting yourself a maximum amount that you can lose, then losing it.)
By:
Koo's worst nightmare
When: 27 Mar 08 19:58
koo, do not mention that 2yo in my presence ever agian.

Thank You.
By:
dan hardcore
When: 27 Mar 08 22:01
45 grand in 3 weeks - can't be that flawed!
By:
MR.CANADA
When: 27 Mar 08 22:03
Holy cow! Koo your bank is 400k thats about 1 MILLION in part of the world......Koo how do you have such a large bank??? winnings from the past I reckon?? also Koo I think if you try to average $1000.00 a day you would come out much better on your wallet body and mind....365k a year is not bad....remember mate money is nice but not at the cost of health which seems to be happening to you...but chin up and good luck ..
By:
Great White
When: 27 Mar 08 22:19
u mean chins up
By:
Koo...
When: 27 Mar 08 22:49
Marksman - to be honest and frank about it. Im not that bothered about how Dave Nevison operates.
Everyone is different, and probabably i wouldnt be seen walking round leafy backing 3 and 4 in a race to make a small profit. Staking apart theres plenty who would scoff at ducthing like that.

I do take in board what others say, but its hard for people to know how i operate to also understand at times how i stake.

By its very nature IR is a very dynamic beats. odds can change from 1.1 to 5 in a blink of an eye without a horse fallen or anything. So if im set up to lose say 1k on a race. What happens if im laying at 1.1 and have my stake ready to lose a grand at the price. I need 10k at 1.1 ready.

But something happens and now im set ready with 10k to lay. If you still feel its a lay at 2.2 then you gotta risk 12k to get anythi9ng laid. If you hesitate and its chances are dimishing all the time its 12.0 and you get nothing from it.

However if looks a 5 shot and you lay the 2.2 for 10k and then somehting happens and it wins. Then you done 12k in cold blood.

You had planned only 1k loss but the odds changed quick....... you cant alter stake and price together.......its a very fickle beast.

Hence i dont think being regemented to one staking is good. A defined set of boundarys i feel is a better approach. Ive been doing this for nearly 4 years now and havent cracked it yet. Built up from nothing to where i am, now. I have the belief that i'll al;ways win unless i totally go silly with staking. hence the controls now i have in place have been tightened still.
So hopefully now my biggest loss will be 5k in anyone sitting.

If i was betting pre race be very easy to have defined staking plans. But i think IR then presents more problems.

Right need some tea and tonioght its a takeway i think :D
By:
Koo...
When: 27 Mar 08 22:52
Horse Racing: -GBP19,881.54 Total P&L: -GBP19,881.54

Horse Racing Showing 1 - 20 of 29 markets
Market Start time Settled date Profit/loss ()
Horse Racing / Wolv 27th Mar : 1m1f Claim Stks 27-Mar-08 19:20 27-Mar-08 19:23 255.20
Horse Racing / Wolv 27th Mar : To Be Placed 27-Mar-08 18:50 27-Mar-08 18:53 4.90
Horse Racing / Wolv 27th Mar : 6f Hcap 27-Mar-08 18:50 27-Mar-08 18:53 -942.98


Overall after wolves = Horse Racing: GBP44,720.71 | Soccer: GBP0.00 Total P&L: GBP44,720.71
By:
Great White
When: 27 Mar 08 23:07
koo, where 5k limit, thort it went from 1k-10
By:
Koo...
When: 27 Mar 08 23:10
You obviously arent a big player sharky :p
By:
Gunslinger
When: 27 Mar 08 23:13
Koo,

I take on board your point about IR odds being very dynamic although this doesn't prevent you from at least applying fixed staking principles when backing in running.

But regarding laying in running............

Your explanation infers that you are laying "at market" in running? i.e. You decide the horse won't win and lay a certain stake at a potentially wide range of odds. I can't believe that you are laying "at market" because surely the value of the odds that you are laying at are crucial excepting instances where a horse is either already out, a totally unrecoverable distance behind or just a user error by the backer.

Therefore, if you are laying for value then it follows that you must have some idea of the level that you will get matched at and can therefore approximate your laying stake. e.g. If it looks like you'll be laying between 6.0 and 11.0 then laying 100 is a safe amount. You are right that sometimes you'll get matched at 2.0 and then wish that you had layed 1000 instead of 100 but equally you are right that you could also get matched at 12.0 and lose 11K if the selection wins.

Surely, there is some API betting software available that you can pre-set so that whatever selection you click on to lay it lays for a pre set liability amount. If you use such software then you will occasionally clean up by laying an enourmous amount such as 6000 @ 1.17 when you were happy just laying 500 @ 2.0

I'm not really sure yet whether deep down you don't really want to set or stick to a staking plan or whether you would like to but don't think its feasible?

An analogy might be: Do you really want to give up smoking (over staking/chasing) or are you just not smoking indoors but creeping out for a crafy one in the garage every so often?
By:
billy
When: 27 Mar 08 23:13
An excellent reply to marksman et al, koo. In truth, only you know

If I had your set up it would be stationed in the W.C
By:
Gunslinger
When: 27 Mar 08 23:19
A further thought Koo.

With the amounts of money you are betting in, even if API in running lay liability software doesn't yet exist then I'm sure that one or more of the API developers would be able to design it for you.

(I'm farly confident it does already exist, maybe ask the forum on a separate thread if anyone uses such software)

If you used it you would make no less money IMO when laying, save some big losses, and occasionally make more than you do now.

The exception might be smaller wins when backing but then over staking IS over staking whether its a back or a lay IMO.

Hope it all goes well tomorrow and you have a smooth flow of profits.

Regards

Gunslinger
By:
Great White
When: 27 Mar 08 23:20
Koo... 27 Mar 23:10
You obviously arent a big player sharky :p
----------------------------------------------------------------------------

not as big as u, i....... maybe if i do 200 large over 3 month they'll do it for me ;)
By:
Koo...
When: 27 Mar 08 23:21
I use some API that do exactly that Gunslinger......... i lay for payout rather than liabilty as well. As its alot better.

As you dfont want to lay at 1.03 before a fence to lose 1k as thats 33k stake which only gets taken if it jumps and isnt taken if it falls. a better amount is about 966 to lose 33. ( payout is 966+33=1k)

The thing is at the moment its user mistakes thats letting me down. And im not 100% i can kurb that too much without kurbing the instincts that help create the money in the first place.

From when i started doing this 4 years ago. ive always know it was the massive losing days that have knackered my overall p/l. I might play with bravado within those boundaries but with numerous banks in waiting i dont see the problem in playing hard with a 10k bank, now a 5k one. Its getting into a routiune so i dont expose too much of the daily bank in one bet, but its a hard routine or mindset to get into.
By:
Koo...
When: 27 Mar 08 23:23
maybe if you'd won 300k the 3 months before the loss they'd have let you have a master sub account though sillek hunt :p

then you can have whatever limits you want to really once i think about it
By:
Great White
When: 27 Mar 08 23:27
oooohhh touchy touchy fsc
By:
Gunslinger
When: 27 Mar 08 23:28
Okay, I understand the complexities of what you are doing and I supposeyou are saying that its an art as well as being a science and that there is a certain amount of volatility of profit and loss that is not down to desired risk control but to other odd factors.

The art side I guess is things such as controlling emotions, temperament and maybe even small things like having adequate rest breaks, doing a wee when you really need one etc.

I feel that eventually you will reach an optimum level of performane whereby the big losses are what I'd call genuine "slippage" (wrong clicks by you/extreme bad luck/computer or Betfair web site failure) and you don't have big losses by blatantly ignoring the parameters which you have set for yourself.
By:
Great White
When: 27 Mar 08 23:35
all jokin aside, apart from say setting up 1k limit on 5 accounts, wots advantage of having master/sub account for 1 person ? i was offered this a cpl year ago wen sumwon was gonna share my office,
i.e they use the sub account, then we both benefit commission wise. But wots the value in diff
accounts for 1 person,
By:
Koo...
When: 27 Mar 08 23:36
ok sharky i'll just use the sc abbrev so im not as touchy or the wink ;)

but you need a master sub account and a trustworthy friend for the limit thing to work. then you can limit to any amount over any anytime period. Is that ok fella without being touchy :p ;)



its sort of like that gunslinger - also you gotta remember sometimes when i overstake i enjoy the benefits of it and its probably only swings and roundabouts over time they probably even out with the times its bites my ass.
Ive had a few bets ive won on only as the leader as fallen as much as ive lost todays. My best ever win only won imo as the leader fell with 3 to jump.

Ive got someone else now in control of my daily staking, so i should now be more consistent in terms of i cant go off the rails and lose 20k like toady. Got 5k in the account now and the instrucvtions are now to deposit or withdraw every monring so the starting bank is on 5k

takes one factor out of my hands and leaves me to just bet IR. Though i do need to stakes a bit lower so im not left doing nowt half the afternoon after blowing a full 5k tank
Page 14 of 170  •  Previous | 1 | ... | 12 | 13 | 14 | 15 | 16 | ... | 170 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com