Forums

We want to share an important update with our Betfair Community users.

Over the coming months, the Betfair Community platform will be winding down. The final active day for the platform will be December 21st. From December 22nd, users will no longer be able to access the platform.

Your discussions, insights, engagement, and, most importantly, feedback have helped shape the platform and guided innovation. Your feedback continues to be important to us, and we will continue to listen via our dedicated feedback channels, as well as through product testing and innovations.

To share your feedback and experience, visit: https://support.betfair.com/app/home

There is currently 1 person viewing this thread.
These 69 comments are related to the topic:
Predict Newcastle's January signings

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
Page 2 of 2  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page
Replies: 69
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 20:35
Cabaye, Ba, Ben arfa, sissoko, winaldum all joined
Newcastle in similar circumstances, amongst others
By:
brentford
When: 10 Nov 21 20:38
you don't get release clauses typically that mean you have to sub their wages back in a top league though..and if they have that in place motivation must start to be a factor too..

I hope it works for Newcastle genuinely as it almost certainly will long term...not sure why they weren't bought up before.. I'm just looking at short term issues
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 20:42
They can write whatever contract they like.
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 20:44
You hope to sign players who are motivated

That's for dof and manager.


As tiger says its a 5 year plan ( possibly longer)
If they go down then get promoted...

But hope to avoid going down
By:
brentford
When: 10 Nov 21 20:45
That's the view is it that it'll just be money no object ?
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 20:46
What do man United have to offer over say Chelsea,
Liverpool or City?

Nothing, but folk want to give it a shot

They want to help put man utd back above those 3
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 20:47
Money is an object though, and they need to
buy well, sell well, and trade well.

Buying for future,... Look at chelsea
By:
brentford
When: 10 Nov 21 20:49
What do man United have to offer over say Chelsea,
Liverpool or City?


Nothing I'd imagine
think most probably looked at wages and CL football plus being courted by said club
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 20:52
Lots of them signed up with little hope
of champions league, or came through
from youth system, fantastic club loyalty.

Newcastle can't buy that, but can hope one day
to have built it.

Club has been a shambles from kids up for decades

That's got to massively improve
By:
brentford
When: 10 Nov 21 21:00
well City are the only ones who could really point at young player development with any pride..thought you meant players who had joined in general..
Utd especially has been a dreadful advert of in house development post the obvious class of '92
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 21:08
I did mean players they had signed, but you can't ignore
the man utd youth development which has been brilliant.
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 21:10
https://www.transfermarkt.co.uk/manchester-united/jugendarbeit/verein/985

..
By:
brentford
When: 10 Nov 21 21:10
name the world class players United have developed post the '92 brigade yhtl ?
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 21:19
Pogba, rashford, lingard, greenwood...

Must be more,...
By:
brentford
When: 10 Nov 21 21:21
well 3 of them aren't world class and the other was developed by Juve essentially because he wasn't playing first XI football with any regularity before regressing back at Utd..
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 21:22
Well if they ain't world class then you better define world
class, because they are clearly good enough to be champions
league players.
By:
brentford
When: 10 Nov 21 21:24
Brandon Williams played CL.. shall we include him ?
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 21:26
Is he good enough to be a champions league regular?

How high a bar are you trying to set?
By:
brentford
When: 10 Nov 21 21:26
feels a curious argument to me, United used to get the pick of young talent and invested in facilities to develop those talents...yet have very little top end stuff to point to that has come throught that system...
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 21:27
Newcastle fans would welcome lingard with open arms
same as they did willock, who clearly has potential
but wouldn't have made it under Bruce
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 21:29
It's exactly the point of the argument.

Newcastle have to work to get to that point
because they are not anywhere near it.

Buying in talent has to step up to that level,
as tiger says Rome wasn't built in a day
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 21:31
Not only do Newcastle need first team players, they need reserves
under 23s,u21s,and kids

It's a huge job
By:
brentford
When: 10 Nov 21 21:31
think we must be slightly offset in our debate yhtl tbh.
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 21:32
Nobody wanted to come for years, tales of bullying
and racism, and couldn't care less
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 21:33
It's the bigger picture Brentford, and the monets need
to do it all,... Plus what we already have, of course.
By:
brentford
When: 10 Nov 21 21:34
Well, genuinely I wish it all well and am pretty sure it has a positive outcome..
By:
----you-have-to-laugh---
When: 10 Nov 21 21:46
It's already positive, now we are another
club trying to get better.

Seriously it's a massive improvement on whats
been going on.
By:
Des Pond
When: 10 Nov 21 22:51
what's the betting they end up with a useless bunch of grand-standing, arm-waving dossers (a la alexis sanchez/pogba) who don't want to put in the work or take responsibility? And end up with almost as bad a team, with 50 times the wage bill?
By:
lurka
When: 10 Nov 21 23:18
Don't think Howe will be looking for a marquee type signing in Jan. Lower-key fast, energetic, younger players maybe some attacking full backs. He'll probably go for a number of players rather than a big name or two.
By:
sofaking
When: 11 Nov 21 02:19

Nov 10, 2021 -- 3:19PM, ----you-have-to-laugh--- wrote:


Pogba, rashford, lingard, greenwood...Must be more,...


World class?  Laughx1,000,000.

Page 2 of 2  •  Previous | 1 | 2 | Next
sort by:
Show
per page

Post your reply

Text Format: Table: Smilies:
Forum does not support HTML
Insert Photo
Cancel
‹ back to topics
www.betfair.com