The penalty awarded to Hearts on Sunday was a very poor decision, but such things happen more and more these days. Just like poor offside decisions such as the one which allowed Celtic's goal.

A Celtic player hit a post TWICE when it was easier to score and if he'd done his job properly, this thread would not exist and neither would the upcoming Edinburgh derby final.

Feck, you are still confusing Orangeism and Freemasonry. I doubt if there are enough Orangemen in influential enough positions to cause the effects you claim, even if they wanted to.

dont lie up all night worrying about bias ,masons and the bogeyman
heres neil getting his own back on the nasty non sellic men
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gHeRaAy3cWQ&feature=related

Please read the posts in full ie regarding his employers.

JamDav...I accept that.

Do you honestly not get the point that Collum's bosses using the 16% stat will not favour Celtic ? That is all I am saying. If the make up of the country was different my argument would still be the same ie use the stats. Collum and any other employee cannot make decision after decision as if they are not answerable to their employers. Please tell me you get that ?

He has come in for stick due to mistakes he has made in Celtic matches. It is often pointed out he is a Catholic etc etc.....so what. He made honest mistakes including having eyes at the back of his head. My point is he like any other employee is answerable to his employers. At my place of work I am aware I simply cannot say and do what I want as I have to adhere to certain rules laid down by my employers, some of which I do not agree with bit I need the job so you conform to the prescribed way of working or end up unemployed or at least involved in some dispute. I promise to leave it at that.

Ah OK Pollensa I think I see your point - Collum has been told by the SFA to cheat Celtic out of games due them being a Catholic side.

Willie Collum the former religious education teacher in a catholic school goes along with this without a second thought.

Fairly poor argument from you Pollensa.

I thought how much you were going on about it it was better than that to be honest

ffs grow up,its football we or discussing not cartoons.

Ah OK Pollensa I think I see your point - Collum has been told by the SFA to cheat Celtic out of games due them being a Catholic side.
Willie Collum the former religious education teacher in a catholic school goes along with this without a second thought.
Fairly poor argument from you Pollensa.
I thought how much you were going on about it it was better than that to be honest


It's not the way it happens JamDav at least not where your token micks are concerned. As Pollensa says, read the posts in full regarding his employers.


Is there anyone out there who truly believes Willie Collum would now be one of our "top referees" if his eyes in the back of his head penalty award had happened at the other end? He would've found himself refereeing meaningless games, possibly in the lower divisions, quicker than you could say "why was Andy Davis's Tynecatle hallucination rewarded with a cup final spot?".


Would you agree the RUC were a biased organisation during the troubles? There is well documented cases of them passing on information to loyalist paramilitary groups which led to murder. There were some Catholics in the RUC despite the fact they risked retribution from republican groups. There were even Jewish kapos in death camps. Did that make the nazis unbiased?

Feck

I am having difficulty seeing how your ref theory works out in practice m8?

Are they being told beforehand by certain (dark forces) that any contentious decisions should go against the tic?

If so would you have an inkling who the SFA members are that are responsible for this?

Or

Is there an unwritten law (as you may have suggested earlier) where it is known (amongst the whistlers) that any ref that does not toe the proposed party line will be sent to the lower leagues?

Do you know of any examples where this has happened to a ref?

And as for you Andy Davis chat. If you think that Hearts fans who were at Tynecastle that day thought "oh darn it, we got cheated out of that game but lets not make a fuss about it the next time we play Celtic it will all be made up for" you are an even bigger idiot than I previously thought.

Neil Lennon simply isnt good enough , THATS HIS PROBLEM

As in any job or walk off life , a good manager will take defeat on the chin , learn from it and go away and improve his team to try ensure it doesnt happen again .

A poor manager will deflect and blame everyone and everything but himself and not see the true reasons for defeat or not be man enough to admit it

Niel Lennon has created a situation at parkhead where his team cannot win a big match , the team take the park knowing if they do lose it will not be thier fault , it will be the refs as it has been in almost every game
And thats not good for any player

Gordon strachan and M o niell seen the team and themselves to blame for defeat and went back and worked on the faults together , thats what made theses men respected winners

Maggot what has he won , a title with only one runner

Tell me a big match he has won .

Has the cheek to put himself up with true greats like big jock , strachan , big billy , M O Niell , thats not his call to invite himself to that table ffs

Wins one tainted title and tells the world he will lift the champions league , that is a big clue to the delusional danger facing celtic right now

Champions league ffs

Well said mate , dark days long gone

well almost gone

DARK DAYS GONE ...

son whos lifting the league cup,its definetly not rangers so who is it.whos the best team in scotland the champions id say.do you say different

Feck
I am having difficulty seeing how your ref theory works out in practice m8?
Are they being told beforehand by certain (dark forces) that any contentious decisions should go against the tic?
If so would you have an inkling who the SFA members are that are responsible for this?
Or Is there an unwritten law (as you may have suggested earlier) where it is known (amongst the whistlers) that any ref that does not toe the proposed party line will be sent to the lower leagues?
Do you know of any examples where this has happened to a ref?

mac, I don't think the SFA as a whole meet to discuss keeping those micky b's down but there will be a faction within it who will. Steve Conroy & Eddie Smith (he of the Nakamura free kick against St Mirren) disappeared off the face of the earth for a long time.


Your arguement is terrible Feck. You are unable to prove something so you try and put the burden on to those questioning you to prove bias by asking them why something which has no evidence of existing wouldn't exist.

Dude, I put forward a perfectly logical reason as to why it exists. I can understand your frustration at being unable to answer the question "Why would there not be a bias?" as your failure to do so exposes your true motives.


WTF are you rambling on about?
Jews,Nazis,RUC,catholics,republicans,loyalists etc
You are part of the west of Scotland problem.
You are a bigot,living in the past.
The rest of Scotland are trying to discuss football here.

It's my hope that one day football will be all there will be to discuss but while people like yourself continue to deny the truth because it exposes your own hate that day will not come. Perhaps if you recognised that there is an element within Scotland who live only in the past and that the SFA is riddled with said saddos you'd start to understand things better. This July they'll be banging their drums down my street and singing how they'd love to be up to their knees in my blood yet you believe there's no possible way they'd make a dodgy decision in their team's favour. Get a grip (no pun intended) of yourself man.

Why would there not be a bias?

It's not surprising no one can answer this question because they are so full of hate that they know deep down, given the chance,  they'd be part of the problem themselves.

hello, they already set a precedent for that with Celtic but, had Rangers been under threat of administration at the time of the EUFA cup final they'd probably have went the extra length. There's little doubt they've thrown subtlety out the window since the very existence of their club came under threat.

ALWAYS CHEATED ,NEVER DEFEATED-THE CELTIC WAY